Research on the reuse path of the Third Front construction stock space in China based on value assessment

Abstract

The Third Front construction played a crucial role in China’s socialist development, resulting in an excess of stock space after four decades of evolution. This study focuses on 113 Third Front plants and mines in western Hubei to explore their contemporary reuse potential. Through field research and statistical analysis, the study examines the layout and conditions of these sites, utilizing the concept of “smart shrinkage” to assess their reuse value. Tools like the minimum cumulative resistance (MCR) model, network analysis, and cluster analysis are employed to develop a reuse value assessment model. The study finds that The Third Front construction plants and mines were concentrated in the transition zone from the plains to the mountains, and idleness and inefficiency became a common problem. These sites exhibit a unique “non-urban, non-rural” layout and possess heritage, asset, and ecological values. The study identifies various reuse strategies, including heritage preservation, property rights transformation, and ecological restoration through rewilding. These measures aim to revitalize the Third Front construction plants and mines, offering theoretical and methodological support for their sustainable development and potential recognition as world cultural heritage.

Keywords

Third front construction / Stock space / Value assessment / Case study / Reuse path

References

[1] Adhya, A. , 2017. Shrinking Cities and First Suburbs. Springer International Publishing, Cham.

[2] Ahmad, M. , Akram, W. , Ikram, M. , Shah, A.A. , Rehman, A. , Chandio, A.A. , Jabeen, G. , 2021. Estimating dynamic interactive linkages among urban agglomeration, economic performance, carbon emissions, and health expenditures across developmental disparities. Sustain. Prod. Consum. 26, 239- 255.

[3] Almasieh, K. , Mohammadi, A. , Alvandi, R. , 2022. Identifying core habitats and corridors of a near threatened carnivore, striped hyaena (Hyaena hyaena) in southwestern Iran. Sci. Rep. 12, 3425.

[4] An, Y. , Liu, S. , Sun, Y. , Shi, F. , Beazley, R. , 2021. Construction and optimization of an ecological network based on morphological spatial pattern analysis and circuit theory. Landsc. Ecol. 36, 2059- 2076.

[5] Ashrafi, B. , Kloos, M. , Neugebauer, C. , 2020. Heritage Impact Assessment, beyond an Assessment Tool: a comparative analysis of urban development impact on visual integrity in four UNESCO World Heritage Properties. J. Cult. Herit. 47, 199- 207.

[6] Batunova, E. , Gunko, M. , 2018. Urban shrinkage: an unspoken challenge of spatial planning in Russian small and medium-sized cities. Eur. Plann. Stud. 26, 1580- 1597.

[7] Boschma, R. , 2022. Global value chains from an evolutionary economic geography perspective: a research agenda. Area Development and Policy 7, 123- 146.

[8] Boussaa, D. , Madandola, M. , 2024. Cultural heritage tourism and urban regeneration: the case of Fez Medina in Morocco. Frontiers of Architectural Research.

[9] Castells-Quintana, D. , Wenban-Smith, H. , 2020. Population dynamics, urbanisation without growth, and the rise of megacities. J. Dev. Stud. 56, 1663- 1682.

[10] Chen, D. , 2003. Third Front Construction: Western Development in the Period of Preparation for War. Party School of the Communist of CP.C Press.

[11] Cho, M. , Shin, S. , 2014. Conservation or economization? Industrial heritage conservation in Incheon, Korea. Habitat Int. 41, 69- 76.

[12] Choe, H. , Lee, D.H. , Seo, I.W. , Kim, H.D. , 2013. Patent citation network analysis for the domain of organic photovoltaic cells: country, institution, and technology field. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 26, 492- 505.

[13] Del, M.S.T.T. , Sedghpour, B.S. , Tabrizi, S.K. , 2020. The semantic conservation of architectural heritage: the missing values. Heritage Science 8, 70.

[14] Fan, J. , Zou, B. , 2021. Industrialization from scratch: the “Construction of Third Front” and local economic development in China’s hinterland. J. Dev. Econ. 152, 102698.

[15] Feng, S. , Chang, J. , 2017. Abandoned mine land ecological restoration: an opportunity to improve urban green instructure. Chinese Landscape Architecture 33, 24- 28.

[16] Freeman, L.C. , 1978. Centrality in social networks conceptual clarification. Soc. Network. 1, 215- 239.

[17] Gao, S. , 2015. A review of researches on shrinking cities. Urban Planning Forum 44-49.

[18] Gao, Y. , Xue, C.Q.L. , Tan, G. , Chen, Y. , 2022. From South China to the global south: tropical architecture in China during the cold war. J. Archit. 27, 979- 1011.

[19] Giustolisi, O. , Ridolfi, L. , Simone, A. , 2020. Embedding the intrinsic relevance of vertices in network analysis: the case of centrality metrics. Sci. Rep. 10, 3297.

[20] Hattori, K. , Kaido, K. , Matsuyuki, M. , 2017. The development of urban shrinkage discourse and policy response in Japan. Cities 69, 124- 132.

[21] He, L. , Lo, K. , Zhang, P. , 2020. Population shrinkage in resource-dependent cities in China: processes, patterns and drivers. Chin. Geogr. Sci. 30, 1- 15.

[22] Huang, L. , Li, B. , Sun, Y. , 2013. Planning and development of third-front cities at critical point of paradigm shift. Journal of Urban Planning 97-103.

[23] Kim, G. , Newman, G. , Jiang, B. , 2020. Urban regeneration: community engagement process for vacant land in declining cities. Cities 102, 102730.

[24] Kui, G. , Qi, C. , 2022. Study on the evolution of world citrus trade pattern based on social network analysis. World Agric. 18-30.

[25] Kunc, J. , Navrátil, J. , Tonev, P. , Frantál, B. , Klusácek, P. , Martinat, S. , Havlíček, M. , Černík, J. , 2014. Perception of urban renewal: reflexions and coherences of socio-spatial patterns (Brno, Czech Republic). Geogr. Tech. 9, 66- 77.

[26] Li, H. , 2008. Socialism, planned economy and the modemism utopia: a retrospection on the soviet union’s architecture and urban planning in the first half of twentieth century. Urban Planning Forum.

[27] Li, Y. , Guo, J. , Zhao, L. , Chen, Y. , Wang, C. , Wang, C. , Li, J. , 2021a. Spatial evolution path of Gulangyu Island historical international community: from the perspective of actor-network theory. Heritage Science 9, 151.

[28] Li, Y.Y. , Zhang, Y. , Jiang, Z. , Guo, C. , Zhao, M. , Yang, Z.G. , Guo, M.Y. , Wu, B.Y. , Chen, Q.L. , 2021b. Integrating morphological spatial pattern analysis and the minimal cumulative resistance model to optimize urban ecological networks: a case study in Shenzhen City, China. Ecological Processes 10, 63.

[29] Li, Q. , Jin, X. , Zhang, X. , Han, B. , Li, H. , Zhou, Y. , 2023. Comparison and evaluation of the ecological network construction method based on principles of landscape ecology. Acta Ecol. Sin. 43, 1461- 1473.

[30] Liu, F. , 2013. The Study on the Industrial Heritage Corridor of Sanxian Construction Based on Value Assessment-Taking Shipping Industry of Chongqing along Yangzi River as an Example. Chongqing University.

[31] Liu, X. , Yuan, L. , Tan, G. , 2023. Identification and hierarchy of traditional village characteristics based on concentrated contiguous development-taking 206 traditional villages in hubei province as an example. Land 12, 471.

[32] Long, Y. , Wu, K. , 2016. Several emerging issues of China’s urbanization: spatial expansion, population shrinkage, low-density human activities and city boundary delimitation. Urban Planning Forum 72-77.

[33] Lu, J. , 2019. Study on the Preservation and Utilisation of Contemporary Industrial Heritage. Fudan University Press, Shanghai.

[34] Lüthi, L. , 2008. The vietnam war and China’s third-line defense planning before the cultural revolution, 1964-1966. J. Cold War Stud. 10, 26- 51.

[35] Meyskens, C. , 2015. Third Front railroads and industrial modernity in late maoist China. Twentieth-Century China 40, 238- 260.

[36] Meyskens, C.F. , 2020. Mao’s Third Front: the Militarization of Cold War China. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

[37] Mustonen, T. , Scherer, A. , Kelleher, J. , 2022. We belong to the land: review of two northern rewilding sites as a vehicle for equity in conservation. Humanit Soc Sci Commun 9, 1- 9.

[38] Mykhnenko, V. , Turok, I. , 2007. Cities in Transition: East European Urban Trajectories 1960-2005.

[39] Naughton, B. , 1988. The third Front: defence industrialization in the Chinese interior. China Q. 115, 351- 386.

[40] Pallagst, K. , 2009. Shrinking cities in the United States of America: three cases, three planning stories. The Future of Shrinking Cities 81-88.

[41] Pinho, P. , Oliveira, V. , 2009. Different approaches in the study of urban form. Journal of Urbanism: International Research on Placemaking and Urban Sustainability 2, 103- 125.

[42] Popper, D.E. , Popper, F. , 2002. Small can be beautiful. Planning 68, 20- 23.

[43] Qian, Y. , 2009. Hubei in Contemporary China (Above and below). Contemporary China Press.

[44] Rojecki, A. , 2002. Modernism, state sovereignty and dissent: media and the new post-coldwar movements. Crit. Stud.Media Commun.

[45] Ruiz, R. , Javier Rodriguez, F. , Coronado, J.M. , 2014. Identification and assessment of engineered road heritage: a methodological approach. J. Cult. Herit. 15, 36- 43.

[46] Sahlean, T.C. , Papeș, M. , Strugariu, A. , Gherghel, I. , 2020. Ecological corridors for the amphibians and reptiles in the Natura 2000 sites of Romania. Sci. Rep. 10, 19464.

[47] Santos, B. , Gonçalves, J. , Almeida, P.G. , Martins-Nepomuceno, A.M.T. , 2023. GIS-based inventory for safeguarding and promoting Portuguese glazed tiles cultural heritage. Heritage Science 11, 133.

[48] Saranya, T. , Saravanan, S. , 2020. Groundwater potential zone mapping using analytical hierarchy process (AHP) and GIS for Kancheepuram District, Tamilnadu, India. Model. Earth Syst. Environ. 6, 1105- 1122.

[49] Saura, S. , Pascual-Hortal, L. , 2007. A new habitat availability index to integrate connectivity in landscape conservation planning: comparison with existing indices and application to a case study. Landsc. Urban Plann. 83, 91- 103.

[50] Scott, J.W. , Kühn, M. , 2012. Urban change and urban development strategies in central east Europe: a selective assessment of events since 1989. Eur. Plann. Stud. 20, 1093- 1109.

[51] Tan, G. , Gao, Y. , Xu, L. , 2019. Research on the Third Front Construction Heritage Based on Industrial Archaeology.

[52] The World Bank , 2009. World Development Report: Reshaping Economic Geography. World Bank, Washington, D.C.

[53] Venovcevs, A. , 2021. Living with socialism: toward an archaeology of a post-soviet industrial town. Extr. Ind. Soc. 8, 100835.

[54] Wang, L. , 2009. A study on cultural heritage corridor construction of the ancient tea and horse road in yunnan-tibet. Guizhou Ethnic Studies 29, 61- 65.

[55] Wang, T. , Li, H. , Huang, Y. , 2021. The complex ecological network’s resilience of the Wuhan metropolitan area. Ecol. Indicat. 130, 108101.

[56] Xu, K. , 2003. Review and inspiration of hubei’s third line construction. Hubei Social Sciences 23-24.

[57] Xu, B. , 2018. A Study of Shrinking Cities Worldwide. Social Sciences Academic Press, Beijing.

[58] Xu, Y. Chen, D. , 2021. Small Three-Line Construction Research Series :Three-Line Construction Researchers in Their Own Words. Shanghai University Press, Shanghai.

[59] Xu, Y. , Wang, Y.Y. , 2022. Everyday lives in China’s cold war military-industrial complex: voices from the Shanghai small third Front, 1964-1988. Palgrave Studies in Oral History. Springer, Cham.

[60] Xu, L. Gao, Y. Tan, G. , 2022. Urban Imprints: 70 Years of Construction Practice of Hubei Gongjian and its Impact on Localities. Huazhong University of Science and Technology Press, Wuhan.

[61] Yan, J. , 2023. The evaluation of the departmental resources and positions within the inter-departmental collaborative networks: a case study on the joint prevention and control mechanism in China. RMHP 16, 1023- 1031.

[62] Yang, T. , 2020. On the construction of national cultural heritage spatial system from the perspective of territorial spatial planning. Urban Planning Forum 81-87.

[63] Yao, C. , An, R. , Dou, C. , Liu, Y. , 2022. Research on construction and evaluation of forest land ecoodica network in three goraes reservoir area based on MSPA and MCR mode. Resour. Environ. Yangtze Basin 31, 1953- 1962.

[64] Yin, Y. , Liu, S. , Sun, Y. , Zhao, S. , An, Y. , Dong, S. , Coxixo, A. , 2019. Identifying multispecies dispersal corridor priorities based on circuit theory: a case study in Xishuangbanna, Southwest China. J. Geogr. Sci. 29, 1228- 1245.

[65] Zhang, R. , Zhang, L. , Zhong, Q. , Zhang, Q. , Ji, Y. , Song, P. , Wang, Q. , 2021. An optimized evaluation method of an urban ecological network: the case of the Minhang District of Shanghai. Urban For. Urban Green. 62, 127158.

[66] Zuo, Y. Zhu, X. Yang, L. , 2017. On regeneration opportunity and mode of "three line". Industrial Heritage in Western China: A Case Study of Datong in Qinghai. Science Press, Beijing.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2025 The Author(s). Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Higher Education Press and KeAi.

审图号：GS京（2025）0055号