In-between spaces for today’s city: Historical review for identifying their beneficial characteristics

Abstract

Experts question why cities, which are supposedly built for citizens, fail to address their social needs. Everyday life is challenging in our cities, especially because public spaces have generally been arranged and designed by considering the physical environment and without consideration for how these spaces should facilitate human interactions. This paper identifies “in-between spaces” as key scenarios for addressing this issue. These spaces offer the opportunity to feel comfortable and safe, foster a sense of community, and facilitate connections.

Little has been written about these spaces and, particularly, their characteristics. Therefore, the objective of this study is to provide a more in-depth understanding of in-between spaces by examining literature on such spaces throughout city history.

The results underscore the threshold character as the primary feature of in-between spaces and define various types of in-between spaces depending on their position within the gradient between public and private domains. The analysis also identified recurring characteristics, such as presence of reproductive labor, vegetation, or amenities, tendency to be programmed or unprogrammed within interior or exterior spaces and establishes relationships between these characteristics. Furthermore, the results suggest that the values promoted by these spaces and their recurring features can offer solutions to regenerate cities.

Keywords

In-between space / Evolution / Community space / Social / Characterization

References

[1] Abdelmalek, A. , 2006. The courtyard houses of southern Algeria. In: Edwards, B., Sibley, M., Hakmi, M., Peter, L. (Eds.), Courtyard Housing. Past, Present & Future. Taylor & Francis, Abingdon, pp. 54-66.

[2] Alegre, L. , Armesto, A. , Brosa, V. , Gascón, E. , Martí, C. , Pastor, J.R. , Roig, J. , Sanmartí, J. , Torres, R. , 1991. Las formas de residencia en la ciudad moderna. Servicio de Publicaciones de la. UPC, Barcelona.

[3] Alexander, C. , 1977. A Pattern Language. Towns, Buildings, Construction. Oxford University Press, New York.

[4] Anderson, J. , Ruggeri, K. , Steemers, K. , Huppert, F. , 2016. Lively social space, well-being activity, and urban design: findings from a low-cost community-led public space intervention. Environ. Behav. 49, 685- 716.

[5] Blaser, W. , 1985. Atrium: five thousand years of open courtyard. Wepf & Co. AG, Basel.

[6] Breutz, P.L. , 1956. Stone kraal settlements in South Africa. Afr. Stud. 15, 157- 175.

[7] Buber, M. , 2018. ¿Qué es el hombre? Fondo de cultura económica, Mexico D.F (Original title “Das Problem des Menschen”, 1942).

[8] Can, I. , 2012. Between Space and Social Interaction: A Case Study of Three Neighbourhoods in Izmir. University of Nottingham.

[9] Carmona, M. , 2019. Place value: place quality and its impact on health, social, economic and environmental outcomes. J. Urban Des. 24, 1- 48.

[10] Carmona, M. , 2014. The place-shaping continuum: a theory of urban design process. J. Urban Des. 19 (1), 2- 36.

[11] Carmona, M. , Wunderlich, F.M. , 2012. Capital Spaces. The Multiple Complex Public Spaces of a Global City. Routledge, Abingdon.

[12] Carricas Torres, M. , 2021. LA VIDA URBANA EN EL UMBRAL. Configuración y perspectivas del urbanismo desde el prisma historiográfico de los espacios intermedios (1800 -1972). Universidad de Navarra.

[13] Cerdà, I. , 1867. Teoría general de la urbanización, y aplicación de sus principios y doctrinas a la reforma y ensanche de Barcelona: Volumen 1. Imprenta española, Madrid.

[14] Chermayeff, S. , Alexander, C. , 1963. Community and privacy. Toward a New Architecture of Humanism. Doubleday, New York.

[15] Chueca Goitia, F. , 1968. Breve Historia del Urbanismo, first ed. Alianza, Madrid.

[16] Colafranceschi, E. , Pallottino, E. , Porretta, P. , 2020. Tulou: the rammed earth dwellings of Fujian (China). Functional, typological and constructive features. International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences - ISPRS Archives 937-944.

[17] Col-lectiu Punt 6 , 2019. Urbanismo feminista. Por una transformación radical de los espacios de la vida. Virus Editorial, Barcelona.

[18] del Val Valdivieso, M.I. , 2010. Usos del agua en las ciudades castellanas del siglo XV. Cuadernos del CEMYR 18, 145- 166.

[19] del Val Valdivieso, M.I. , 2008. Los espacios del trabajo femenino en la Castilla del siglo XV. Studia Historica. Historia Medieval 26, 63- 90.

[20] Delgado, M. , 2011. El espacio público como ideología. Los libros de la. Catarata, Madrid.

[21] Delgado, M. , 1999. El animal público: hacia una antropología de los espacios urbanos.

[22] Félix, L. , Organista, M. , 2024. Understanding the neighborhoods’ in-between spaces on spatial perception, social interaction, and security. Frontiers of Architectural Research 13, 21- 36.

[23] Fernández-Llebrez, J. , 2013. La dimensión humana de la arquitectura de Aldo van Eyck. Escrita y Construida: Reconocimiento de sus ideas y Estudio de su iglesia en La Haya. Universidad Politécnica de, Valencia.

[24] Frago Clols, L. , Martínez-Rigol, S. , 2016. Las Utopías Urbanas Del Siglo XIX, Herencias Y Carencias: La Carencia Social Frente La Herencia Técnica. In: XIV Coloquio Internacional de Geocrítica Las Utopías y La Construcción de La Sociedad Del Futuro, pp. 1-13. Barcelona.

[25] Gehl, J. , 2010. Cities for People. Island Press, Washington, DC.

[26] Gehl, J. , 2006. La humanización del espacio urbanos, fifth ed. Editorial Reverté, Barcelona (Original title “Life between buildings” 2003).

[27] Gil Guinea, L. , 2016. Lugares intermedios : la “filosofía del umbral” en la arquitectura del Team 10. Universida Politécnica de Madrid.

[28] Gillespie, S. , Le Vasseur, M.T. , Michael, Y.L. , 2017. Neighbourhood amenities and depressive symptoms in urban-dwelling older adults - centre for urban design and mental health. Journal of Urban Design and Mental Health 2.

[29] Goffmann, E. , 1979. Relaciones en público. Microestudios del orden público. Alianza, Madrid (Original title “Relations in Public. Microstudies of the Public Order” 1971).

[30] González Capitel, A. , 2005. La arquitectura del patio. Gustavo Gili, Barcelona.

[31] Gravagnuolo, B. , 1998. Historia del Urbanismo en Europa 1750-1960. Akal, Madrid.

[32] Hajer, M.A. , Reijndorp, A. , 2001. In: Search of New Public Domain: Analysis and Strategy. NAI, Rotterdam (Original title “La obra progettazione urbana in Europa” 1991).

[33] Hales, S.J. , 2003. The Roman House and Social Identity. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

[34] Harvey, D. , 2013. Ciudades rebeldes: del derecho de la ciudad a la revolución urbana. Akal, Madrid. (Original title “Rebel Cities. From the Right to the City to the Urban Revolution” 2012).

[35] Illescas de la Morena, A. , 1997. La lección del patio argelino. DPA: Documents de Projectes d’Arquitectura 13, 12- 15.

[36] Iñigo, J. , Mace, A. , 2018. The suburban perimeter blocks of Madrid 10 years on: how residents’ level of satisfaction relates to urban design qualities. Plann. Perspect. 34, 999- 1021.

[37] Jacobs, J. , 2011. In: Muerte y Vida de las Grandes Ciudades, 2. Capitan Swing Libros, Madrid (Original title “The Death and Life of Great American Cities” 1961).

[38] Jenkins, I. , 1998. La vida cotidiana en Grecia y Roma. Akal, Madrid. (Original title “Greek and Roman life” 1986).

[39] Juárez Chicote, A. , Rodríguez Ramírez, F. , 2014. El espacio intermedio y los orígenes del TEAM X. Proyecto, Progreso. Arquitectura 11, 52- 63.

[40] Kapstein, G. , 1988. Espacios Intermedios. Respuesta Arquitectónica al Medio Ambiente, II región. Editorial Universidad del Norte. Santiago de Chile.

[41] Katayama, K. , 2011. Spatial order and typology of Hakka dwellings. In: International Workshop on Rammed Earth Materials and Sustainable Structures & Hakka Tulou Forum 2011, p. 9.

[42] Krier, L. , 2013. La arquitectura de la comunidad. La modernidad tradicional y la ecología del urbanismo. Editorial Reverté, Barcelona (Original title “The architecture of community” 2009).

[43] Krier, L. , Nicolin, P. , Villa, A. , Culot, M. , Grumbach, A. , 1978. Declaratión de Palerme. In: Declaration de Bruxelles. Archives d’Architecture Moderne, Bruxelles, pp. 15-16.

[44] Lawrence, R.J. , 1993. Public, collective and private space: a study of urban housing in Switzerland. In: Kent, S. (Ed.), Domestic Architecture and the Use of Space. An Interdisciplinary Cross-Cultural Study. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, p. 193.

[45] Lawrence, R.J. , 1989. Translating anthropological concepts into architectural practice. In: Low, S.M., Chambers, E. (Eds.), Housing, Culture and Design. A Comparative Perspective. University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, pp. 89-114.

[46] Lawrence, R.J. , 1987. Housing, Dwellings and Homes: Design Theory, Research and Practice, first ed. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester.

[47] Lawrence, R.J. , 1984. Transition spaces and dwelling design. Source: J. Architect. Plann. Res. 1, 261- 271.

[48] Le, Corbusier, Sert, J.M. , 1933. Athens Charter.

[49] Lefebvre, H. , 2017. El derecho a la ciudad (Original title “Le droit à la ville” 1968).

[50] Levy, D. , Liguori, C. , 2016. The neoliberal urbanization in São Paulo, Brazil: the case of agusta park. In: 17th International Planning History Society Proceedings, pp. 197-210.

[51] López de Lucio, R. , 2012. Vivienda colectiva, espacio público y ciudad: evolución y crisis en el diseño de tejidos residenciales 1860-2010. Nobuko, Buenos Aires.

[52] López de Lucio, R. , Hernández Aja, A. , 1995. Los nuevos ensanches de Madrid: la morfología residencial de la periferia reciente, 1985-1993. Gerencia Municipal de Urbanismo del Ayuntamiento de Madrid, Madrid.

[53] Loukaitou-Sideris, A. , 1996. Cracks in the city: addressing the constraints and potentials of urban design. J. Urban Des. 1, 91- 103.

[54] Maas, J. , Verheij, R.A. , Groenewegen, P.P. , de Vries, S. , Spreeuwenberg, P. , 2006. Green space, urbanity, and health: how strong is the relation? J. Epidemiol. Community Health 60, 587 LP- 592, 1978.

[55] Manzano Martínez, E.F. , 2017. La transformación de la manzana como tipo morfologista. Madrid ensanche de Vallecas 2000-2010. Universidad Camilo José Cela.

[56] Marín Durán, Á. , 2015. Espacio Colectivo y Vivienda. Aportaciones a la vida comunitaria en los edificios residenciales del siglo XX. Universidade da Coruña.

[57] Martienssen, R.D. , 1980. La idea del espacio en la arquitectura griega. Nueva Visión, Buenos Aires (Original title “The idea of space in greek architecture” 1956).

[58] Merino, M. , 2022. The street, the place where the life is. A Rudofskian thought about the mediterranean influence on the city, the street and the society. In: AMPS Proceedings Series 30. Cultures, Communities and Design. AMPS, Calgary.

[59] Moley, C. , 2006. Les abords du chez-soi en quête d’espaces intermédiaires. Edition de la Villette, Paris.

[60] Moley, C. , 2005. «Espace intermédiaire»: généalogie d’un discours. In: La Société Des Voisins. Partager Un Habitat Collectif. Edition de la MSH, Paris, pp. 37-47.

[61] Moneo, R. , 1978. On typology. Oppositions 13, 23- 45.

[62] Montaner, J.M. , 2015. La arquitectura de la vivienda colectiva. Editorial Reverté, Barcelona.

[63] Montaner, J.M. , 1993. Después del movimiento moderno: arquitectura de la segunda mitad del siglo XX. Gustavo Gili, Barcelona.

[64] Moya, L. , 2009. Espacios de transición. Ciudad Territ. - Estud. Territ. 41, 559- 570.

[65] Mumford, L. , 2018. La cultura de las ciudades, first ed. Pepitas de calabaza, Logroño (Original title “The culture of cities” 1938).

[66] Mumford, L. , 2012. La ciudad en la historia. Pepitas de calabaza, Logroño (Original title “The city in history” 1961).

[67] Muxí Martínez, Z. , 2018. Mujeres, Casas y Ciudades: Más allá del umbral, first ed. DPR-BARCELONA, Barcelona.

[68] Ortega Andrade, F. , 1995. La construcción romana (II). Rev. Edificacion 19, 55- 76.

[69] Palomino, A. , 2019. El otro Coderch: Bloc de Pescadors de la Barceloneta. Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya.

[70] Pérusson, E. , 1843. Union et bonheur pour tous, ou Le Phalanstère mis à la portée de tout le monde: exposé succinct de la doctrine de l’harmonie universelle et de l’association agricole domestique de Charles Fourier. Avec un plan du Phalanstère. Imprimerie de J. Duchsne.

[71] Porotto, A. , 2021. Vienna’s Höfe. How housing builds the collective. In: Lewis, P., Holm, L., Costa Santos, S. (Eds.), Architecture and Collective Life. Routledge, London, pp. 170-181.

[72] Presa-Torres, F.J. , Flores-Soto, J.A. , 2022. El espacio intermedio en los pueblos del Instituto Nacional de Colonización. Ciudad Territ. - Estud. Territ. 54, 57- 76.

[73] Romero, J. , Brandis, D. , Melo, C. , 2015. EL GIRO NEOLIBERAL DE LAS POLÍTICAS PARA LA CIUDAD EN ESPAÑA. BALANCE A PARTIR DE LOS EJEMPLOS DE MADRID Y VALENCIA. Boletín de la Asociación de Geógrafos Españoles 69, 369- 386.

[74] Rudofsky, B. , 2020. Arquitectura sin arquitectos : Una breve introducción a la arquitectura sin pedigrí. Pepitas de calabaza, Logroño (Original title “Architecture without architects. A short introduction to Non-pedegreed architecture” 1964).

[75] Sainz Gutiérrez, V. , 2006. El proyecto urbano en España Genesis y desarrollo de un urbanismo de los arquitectos. Junta de Andalucia y Universidad de Sevilla, Sevilla.

[76] Santos-Garcia, A. , Aseguinolaza Braga, I. , Cenicacelaya Marijuan, J. , 2021. “El patio” de manzana en Euskadi. Desarrollos urbanos de la segunda mitad del siglo XX. In: Llop Torné, C.J., Cervera Alonso de Medina, M., Peremiquel Lluch, F. (Eds.), Actas IV Congreso ISUF-H. ISUF-H, Barcelona, pp. 220-253.

[77] Schoenauer, N. Seeman, S. , 1962. The Court-Garden House. McGill University Press, Montreal.

[78] Secci, C. , Thibault, E. , 2005. Espace intermédiaire. Formation de cette notion chez les architectes. In: La Société Des Voisins. Partager Un Habitat Collectif. Edition de la MSH, Paris, pp. 23-35.

[79] Sendra, P. , Sennett, R. , 2021. Diseñar el desorden. Experimentos y disrupciones en la ciudad. Alianza, Madrid (Original title “Designing disorder. Experiments and Disruptions in the City” 2020).

[80] Sennett, R. , 2019. Construir y habitar: Ética para la ciudad. Anagrama, Barcelona (Original title “Building and Dwelling Ethics for the city” 2018).

[81] Shahlaei, A. , Mohajeri, M. , 2015. In-between space, dialectic of inside and outside in Architecture. International Journal of Architecture and Urban Development 5, 73- 80.

[82] Sibley, M. , 2006. The courtyard houses of north African medinas, past, present and future. In: Edwards, B., Sibley, M., Hakmi, M., Peter, L. (Eds.), Courtyard Housing. Past, Present & Future. Taylor & Francis, Abingdon, pp. 67-85.

[83] Simmel, G. , 1998. Puerta y Puente. In: Mas, S. (Ed.), El Individuo y La Libertad. Ensayo de Crítica de La Cultura. Península, Barcelona, p. 284 (Original title “Brücke und Tür” 1957).

[84] Smithson, A. , 1966. Manual del Team 10. Nueva Visión, Buenos Aires (Originally published in “Architectural Design” 1962).

[85] Smithson, A. , Smithson, P. , 2017. The Space between. Walther Konig Verlag, Cologne.

[86] Smithson, A. , Smithson, P. , 1974. The Spaces between. Oppositions 4.

[87] Thompson, S. , Corkery, L. , Judd, B. , 2007. The role of community gardens in sustaining healthy communities. In: State of Australian Cities Conference. State of Australian Cities Conference 2007 Proceedings, Sidney, pp. 161-171.

[88] Van Der Merwe, R.H. , Pikirayi, I. , 2019. South African archaeological society identifying zulu military (amakhanda) settlements in the archaeological record. S. Afr. Archaeol. Bull. 74, 91- 100.

[89] Van Eyck, A. , 2008. Writings. SUN, Amsterdam.

[90] Van Eyck, A. , 1966. El umbral. In: Smithson, A. (Ed.), Manual Del Team 10. Nueva Visión, Buenos Aires, pp. 43-46.

[91] Vidal, T. , Berroeta, H. , Masso, A. , Di, Valera, S. , Peró, M. , 2013. Apego al lugar, identidad de lugar, sentido de comunidad y participacioín en un contexto de renovacioín urbana. Estud. Psicol. 34, 275- 286.

[92] Wang, S. , Sen, Li, S.Y. , Liao, S.J. , 2012. The genes of Tulou: a study on the preservation and sustainable development of Tulou. Sustainability 4, 3377- 3386.

[93] WHO Regional Office for Europe , 2016. Urban Green Spaces and Health. Copenhagen.

[94] Worpole, K. , Knox, K. , 2007. The Social Value of Public Spaces.

[95] Zhang, D. , 2020. Courtyard houses around the world: a crosscultural analysis and contemporary relevance. In: Nia, H.A. (Ed.), New Approaches in Contemporary Architecture and Urbanism. Cinius Yayinlari. Istanbul.

[96] Zhang, D. , 2016. Juer hutong new courtyard housing in Beijing a review from the residents’ perspective. International Journal of Architectural Research 10, 166- 191.

[97] Zhang, D. , 2015. Classical courtyard houses of Beijing: architecture as cultural artifact. Journal of Space and Communication 1, 47- 68.

[98] Zhang, D. , 2013. Courtyard Housing and Cultural Sustainability: Theory, Practice, and Product. Routledge, London.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2025 The Author(s). Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Higher Education Press and KeAi.