From hinterland granary fort to frontier mountain fortress: Initiation, construction, and expansion of the Diaoyucheng Fortress, Hechuan, China, in the wars during 1125-1279

Abstract

The Southern Song planned and constructed the Diaoyucheng Fortress at Hezhou of the Sichuan Theatre, during the 13th century. This fortress became famous for its 36-year resistance against the Mongols and the death of Möngke Khan in 1259. Based on historical documents and data from re-analysis of archaeological report and field survey, this study explores its initiation, construction and transition, to build a coherent narrative for its transformation from a hinterland transport hub during the Song-Jin War (1125-1234) to a frontier stronghold during the Song-Mongol War (1235-1279), which experiences the establishment of Zhuanban Granary in the 1130s, the construction of Xinyuguan Fort in the 1160s-1170s, the transformation into a refuge in 1240, and the expansion into the Diaoyucheng Fortress in 1243-1279. By combining spatial analysis with military history, this study discusses how the peninsular site, the “dustpan” form, and the fort cluster were formed under the influence of military strategies in different war periods and the topography in Sichuan. With the comparisons with the fortifications across Eurasia around the same period, this study illustrates this fortress epitomizes the development of knowledge system for fortification design in ancient China, especially the river defense fortress taking advantage of topography and navy.

Keywords

The Diaoyucheng Fortress / Logistical system / River defense system / Mountain fortress / “Dustpan” form / Paradigm

References

[1] Barfield, T.J. , 1989. The Perilous Frontier: Nomadic Empires and China, 221 BC to AD 1757. Blackwell, London.

[2] Cao, W. , 1999. Ancient Chinese Map, Warring States Period to Yuan Dynasty. Cultural Relics Press, Beijing plate 83. (in Chinese).

[3] Chang, S.D. , 1977. The morphology of walled capitals. In: Skinner, G.W. (Ed.), The City in Late Imperial China. Stanford University Press, Redwood City, pp. 75-100.

[4] Chen, F. , 1999. The evolution and changes of grain transport in the tang and song dynasties. Res. Chin. Econ. Hist. (3), 85-95 (in Chinese).

[5] Cheng, L. , 2006. Study on the Food Supply Geography in Northwest War Area of Northern Song Dynasty. Social Sciences Academic Press, Beijing (in Chinese).

[6] Cho, D.W. , 2012. Namhansanseong, Mountain Fortress city (Republic of Korea). In: Parrinello, S., Bertocci, S., Pancani, G. (Eds.), Between East and West, Transposition of Cultural Systems and Military Technology of Fortified Landscape. Edifiredizioni Firenze, Firenze, pp. 115-118.

[7] CMRICRA and ADBSM , 2021. Collection of Reports on Archaeological Survey and Excavation of the Diaoyucheng Fortress Site. China Science Publishing & Media Ltd. (CSPM), Beijing (in Chinese).

[8] Conwell, D. , 2008. Connecting a City to the Sea: the History of the Athenian Long Walls. Brill, Leiden.

[9] Cotterill, J. , 1993. Saxon raiding and the role of the late roman coastal forts of Britain. Britannia 24, 227- 239.

[10] Editorial Committee of Hechuan County Sichuan Province , 1995. The County Records of Hechuan. People’s Publishing House of Sichuan, Chengdu (in Chinese).

[11] Ellenblum, R. , 2007. Crusader Castles and Modern Histories. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

[12] Fan, C. , 1998. Passing through hancchu county on the Jialing River [1175]. In: Fu, X. (Ed.), Complete Poetry Works of Song Dynasty, vol. 41. Peking University, Beijing, 25746 (in Chinese).

[13] Fang, H. , 1944. Looking back at the present for the Diaoyucheng fortress. The Eastern Miscellany 13, 49-54 (in Chinese).

[14] Fu, X. , 2004. Ten Essays on Ancient Chinese Architecture. Fuda University Press, Shanghai (in Chinese).

[15] Guo, D. , 2003. History of Ancient Chinese Architecture, Volume 3, Sung, Liao, Jin and Western Xia. China Architecture Publishing & Media Co. Ltd., Beijing (in Chinese).

[16] Guo, H. , 1985. The system of Zicheng (inner city) in the history of ancient Chinese cities - a study. The toho gakuho. J. Orient. Stud. 57, 665-683 (in Chinese).

[17] Hansen, V. , 2014. Changing Gods in Medieval China. Princeton University Press, Princeton, pp. 1127-1276.

[18] He, Y. , 2012. Study of Administrative Operation System of Sichuan and Shanxi in the South Song Dynasty. Shanghai Classics Publishing House, Shanghai (in Chinese).

[19] Hua, Y. , 2005. Suggestion of Cuiwei Northern Expedition [1208]. Huangshan Publishing House, Hefei (in Chinese).

[20] Huang, C. , 2016. The structure and functions of the defense system on the Yangtze River in the southern song dynasty. Journal of Hebei University (Philosophy and Social Science) 41 (5), 10-17 (in Chinese).

[21] Huang, W. , Feng, J. , 2023. From temples to mountain cities: the planning and construction of the yunding city in jintang, Chengdu, during the song-mongol war. City Planning Review (published online) (in Chinese).

[22] Huang, B. , 2020. Guazhou city construction during southern song dynasty. China Local Records (05) 67-77+126 (in Chinese).

[23] ICOFORT , 2021. The Icomos Guidelines on Gortifications and Military Heritage (GA 2021 6-1).

[24] Jia, T. , 2012. The Origins of Ancient Chinese City Wall Regulations [Unpublished Doctoral Thesis]. Southeast University (in Chinese).

[25] K’uan-Chung, H. , Wright, D. , 2000. Mountain fortress defence: the experience of the southern song and korea in resisting the Mongol invasions. In: Van de Ven, H. (Ed.), Warfare in Chinese History. Brill, Leiden, pp. 222-251.

[26] Ladefoged, T.N. , Pearson, R. , 2000. Fortified castles on okinawa island during the Gusuku reriod, AD 1200-1600. Antiquity 74 (284), 404- 412.

[27] Le, J. , 2019. Construction Method and Characteristics of Goguryeo Forts in the Basin of Han River. Military History, vol. 113, pp. 201-232.

[28] Li, K. , 2006. Record of the Feixilou [1171]. In: Zeng, Z., Liu, L. (Eds.), Chinese Collection of Prose Literature from the Song Dynasty (960-1279), vol. 242. Shanghai Lexicographical Publishing House, Shanghai, p. 296 (in Chinese).

[29] Li, T. , 1966. The History of the Song-Mongolia War. Shihuo Publish House, Taiwan (in Chinese).

[30] Li, T. , 1979. Extended Continuation to Comprehensive Mirror in Aid of Governance [1183]. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing (in Chinese).

[31] Li, X. , 1985. Miscellaneous Records of Historical Documents from Jianyan Period [1216]. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing (in Chinese).

[32] Li, X. , 2013. Summary of Annual Events from Jianyan Period [1167-1240]. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing (in Chinese).

[33] Li, X. , 2023. River defense and fleet building: the song navy in the wars against the Jin and Mongol forces. J. Chin. Mil. Hist. 12 (1), 24- 39.

[34] Liu, H. , 2009. Analysis and comparison of two military heritages in China and The Netherlands. South Architecture (4), 84-88 (in Chinese).

[35] Liu, W.G. , 2015. The making of a fiscal state in song China, 960-1279. Econ. Hist. Rev. 68 (1), 48- 78.

[36] Liu, F. , Tian, J. , 1979. Gazetteer of Hezhou, Wanli Period, volume 1 [1579]. Bureau of Culture and Education, Publicity Department of the Hechuan County, pp. 14-19 (in Chinese).

[37] Liu, W. , Wang, J. , Ruan, J. , Zhao, X. , 2018. Defensive space analysis of Chinese ancient cities in the north-south confrontation area: a case study in cities of Jing-xiang area. City Planning Review (04) 65-74 (in Chinese).

[38] May, T. , 2013. The Mongol Conquests in World History. Reaktion Books, London.

[39] Pollak, M. , 2010. Cities at War in Early Modern Europe. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

[40] Pow, S. , 2019. Hungary’s castle defense strategy in the aftermath of the Mongol invasion (1241-1242). Fortifications, Defence Systems, Structures and Features in the Past 13, 239- 250.

[41] Raphael, K. , 2010. Muslim Fortresses in the Levant: between Crusaders and Mongols. Routledge, Oxfordshire.

[42] Ren, F. , 2000. Dianjiangzhi, segment [1224]. In: Jie, J., Yao, G., Zhen, C. (Eds.), Yongle Encyclopedia [1408], vol. 15948. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing, pp. 22-23 (in Chinese).

[43] Shi, J. , 1999. On army provisions in sichuan and shaanxi during the reign of emperor gao zong in the southern song dynasty (Social Sciences Edition, (02 Journal of Southwest University 135-139 (in Chinese).

[44] Song, L. , 1976. History of Yuan [1370]. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing (in Chinese).

[45] Su, P. , 2008. The Military History of the Southern Song Dynasty. Shanghai Classics Publishing House, Shanghai (in Chinese).

[46] Sun, H. , Xi, J. , 2017. Summary on military engineering heritag. Study on Natural and Cultural Heritage (5), 1-6 (in Chinese).

[47] Tackett, N. , 2017. The Origins of the Chinese Nation: Song China and the Forging of an East Asian World Order. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

[48] Thomas, C.G. Conant, C. , 2009. Citadel to City-State: the Transformation of Greece, 1200-700 BCE. Indiana University Press, Bloomington.

[49] Tong, R. , 2020. The nature of fanjiayan site in hechuan Diaoyu city-protection and interpretation based on ArchaeoIogical research of Diaoyu city site. Study on Natural and Cultural Heritage 5 (1), 68-80 (in Chinese).

[50] Tuo, T. , 1985. History of Song Dynasty [1345]. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing (in Chinese).

[51] Wang, S. , Huo, Q. , Wang, K. , Sun, Y. , Ju, F. , He, H. , 2011. Brief excavation report of the granary site of the song and yuan dynasties at shuangjing road in Zhenjiang, jiangsu. South. Cult. (5), 7, 71+130-132. (in Chinese).

[52] Wang, X. , 1992. The Record of Scenic Spots across the Country [1227]. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing (in Chinese).

[53] Wang, Z. , 2006. Memorial about the land survey measure in Tongchuanfulu province [1156]. In: Zeng, Z., Liu, L. (Eds.), Chinese Collection of Prose Literature from the Song Dynasty (960-1279), vol. 197. Shanghai Lexicographical Publishing House, Shanghai, p. 154 (in Chinese).

[54] Wei, L. , 2006. Record of the construction of the lianxi temple [1224]. In: Zeng, Z., Liu, L. (Eds.), Chinese Collection of Prose Literature from the Song Dynasty (960-1279), ume 310. Shanghai Lexicographical Publishing House, Shanghai, p. 369 (in Chinese).

[55] Willey, P. , 2005. Eagle’s Nest: Ismaili Castles in Iran and Syria. I.B.Tauris Publishers, London.

[56] Wu, Q. , 2006. The Art of Chinese Military Architecture. Hubei Education Press Co. Ltd, Wuhan (in Chinese).

[57] Xu, D. , 1935. Hu Qian Jing [1004]. Commercial Press, Hong Kong (in Chinese).

[58] Xu, S. , 1957. Draft for the Collected Statutes of Song Dynasty, Military Matters 23 [1810]. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing (in Chinese).

[59] Yang, F. , 2006. A letter to the theater military intendancy Yu Jie [1243]. In: Zeng, Z., Liu, L. (Eds.), Chinese Collection of Prose Literature from the Song Dynasty (960-1279), ume 325. Shanghai Lexicographical Publishing House, Shanghai, pp. 306-310 (in Chinese).

[60] Yang, F. , 2019. Study of the Public Granary System in Song Dynasty. Shanghai Classics Publishing House, Shanghai (in Chinese).

[61] Yang, N. , Li, H. , Qiu, Z. , 2021. Research on the layering deconstruction and protection of historic urban landscape of the ancient military towns in southwest China. Urban Development Studies 28 (10), 87-95 (in Chinese).

[62] Yao, C. , 1958. Yu Jie built mountain cities to defense Mongols in the song dynasty. Guolibianyiguan, Taibei Theses Collection for the History of Song Dynasty 1, 215-226 (in Chinese).

[63] Yao, C. , 1964. The research on the background of ms. Xiong Er and Wang Li and the survival of Hezhou in the Diaoyucheng fortress battle of the song- mongal war. Guolibianyiguan, Taibei Theses Collection for the History of Song Dynasty 2, 123-140 (in Chinese).

[64] Yao, S. , 2004. Career statue of the Li zhongxuangong [1290]. In: Li, X. (Ed.), A Complete Collection of the Prose Literature, vol. 9. Phoenix Publishing & Media, Inc., Nanjing, p. 484 (in Chinese).

[65] Yuan, S. , 1998. Passing through the Qu river ferry [1195]. In: Fu, X. (Ed.), Complete Poetry Works of Song Dynasty, vol. 48. Peking University, Beijing, 29884 (in Chinese).

[66] Zeng, R. , 2006. Expanding the northwest frontier: a study of the war against Xia in the middle and late northern song dynasty. Chung Hwa Book Co. (H.K.) Ltd. Hongkong. (in Chinese).

[67] Zhang, J. , 2006. Memorial of applying to build the zhuanban granary at Guazhou [1162]. In: Zeng, Z., Liu, L. (Eds.), Chinese Collection of Prose Literature from the Song Dynasty (960-1279), ume 188. Shanghai Lexicographical Publishing House, Shanghai, p. 15 (in Chinese).

[68] Zhou, Y. , 2012. The deeds of Li zengbo in huaihe river region. J. Xidian Univ. (6), 76-83 (in Chinese).

[69] Zhang, S. , 1992. Gazetteer of Hechuan County, vol. 31 [1922]. Bashu Publishing House, The Republic of China, p. 55 (in Chinese).

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2025 The Author(s). Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Higher Education Press and KeAi.

审图号：GS（2024）5226号