Key Laboratory for Thermal Science and Power Engineering of the Ministry of Education, Department of Energy and Power Engineering, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China
haizhang@tsinghua.edu.cn
Show less
History+
Received
Accepted
Published
2019-10-11
2020-02-26
2021-03-15
Issue Date
Revised Date
2020-09-08
PDF
(921KB)
Abstract
An experimental study on the ignition of single coal particles at low oxygen concentrations (<21%) was conducted using a tube furnace. The surface temperature (Ts) and the center temperature (Tc) of the coal particles were obtained from the images taken by an infrared camera and thermocouples respectively. The ignition processes were recorded by a high-speed camera at different values and furnace temperatures Tw. Compared with literature experimental data obtained at a high value, the ignition delay time ti decreases more rapidly as increases at the low region. The responses of Ts and Tc to the variation of are different: Ts decreases while Tc remains nearly constant with increasing at a low value. In addition, ti is less sensitive to Tw while the ignition temperature Ti is more sensitive to Tw at a low value than in air. Observations of the position of flame front evolution illustrate that the ignition of a coal particle may change from a homogeneous mode to a heterogeneous or combined ignition mode as decreases. At a low value, buoyancy plays a more significant role in sweeping away the released volatiles during the ignition process.
Wantao YANG, Yang ZHANG, Lilin HU, Junfu LYU, Hai ZHANG.
An experimental study on ignition of single coal particles at low oxygen concentrations.
Front. Energy, 2021, 15(1): 38-45 DOI:10.1007/s11708-020-0692-1
Coal ignition at a low oxygen concentration (<21%) popularly exists in industrial applications. For example, in a coal-fired boiler, when the primary air flow carries coal particles into the furnace, it entrains the surrounding flue gas, making the ignition of most coal particles happen in an environment with <21% rather than in air ( = 21%) [1]. Similarly, in the moderate or intense low-oxygen dilution (MILD) combustion, which is regarded as a new clean coal technology due to its advantages in NOx reduction and flame stability [2], coal ignition occurs in low conditions due to the strongly dilution of the flue gas [3]. Besides, in a circulating fluidized bed (CFB) boiler with a good fuel flexibility, high concentration mm-sized particles mix with secondary air in the dense zone, causing a low condition for combustion and SO2 absorption [4]. Therefore, understanding the ignition of coal particles in low conditions is essential for the coal-fired burner and combustor design, CFB boiler operation, and pollutant removal.
The effect of oxygen concentration on coal ignition has been extensively studied before, but mostly under air or oxyfuel combustion conditions [5,6], and not much researches have been conducted at low values systematically. Two important parameters, i.e., the ignition delay time (ti) and ignition temperature (Ti) are often used to describe the ignition characteristics of a fuel [7–9]. It could be straightforward that Ti increases as decreases because of the decrease in the burning intensity. However, it is found that this hypothesis is not always true, namely, the variation of Ti with is still controversial. Du and Annamalai. [10] has found that when coal particles experience homogeneous ignition, Ti remains roughly constant and independent of . However, Liu et al. [11] and Zhou et al. [12] have experimentally found that Ti decreases with increasing . Moreover, Annamalai and Durbertaki [13] found that Ti also decreases with increasing in a homogeneous mode but it increases with increasing in a heterogeneous mode. However, in air or at a high value, the experiments consistently shows that Ti increases as decreases for single coal particles [14,15]. At the same time, most researches have discovered that ti decreases with increasing [14,16]. Illustrated by Ponzio et al. [17], ti is more sensitive to at a low value than at a high value.
In addition to the influences on Ti and ti, the change in value could also lead to the change in the ignition mode. On the one hand, a lower value could cause a weaker O2 diffusion onto the particle surface, making heterogeneous ignition more difficult to occur. On the other hand, a lower weakens the pyrolysis and volatile burning processes, making homogeneous ignition more difficult to occur as well [7]. Besides Tw and , the ignition mode can be different for different coal particle sizes (dp). The ignition modes for mm-sized coal particles at a low value and different Tw values remain unclear.
ti is often determined by using a set of continuous images or a temperature variation curve of the coal particle obtained during the ignition period [7,17]. For example, using three-color measurement, Gat et al. [18] have measured the temperature of a single coal particle in the range of 1500–2700 K heated by laser at three bands of 0.92, 1.1, and 1.2 mm. Fletcher [19] has measured the pyrolysis temperature of coal particles in a swirl burner higher than 850 K at 1.36 mm and 2.2 mm by using a two-color method. Zhu et al. [20] have used a monochromatic method to measure the Ti of a single coal particle heated by an electric heating furnace in the visible band. Ti is determined by the surface temperature (Ts) of coal particles at the moment when a visible flame appears. Actually, for single coal particles, the temperature gradient inside it cannot be neglected. Therefore, some researchers [14,15,20] have adopted thermocouples to measure the center temperature (Tc) of coal particles. Based on the two temperature measurements, Ti of single coal particles can be more accurately determined.
In this paper, an experimental system was establsihed to study the ignition of single mm-sized coal particles at low values by using a tube furnace. Both the surface and center temperatures of the coal particle were measured. Besides, the effect of Tw was assessed. The objectives of this study are to obtain the variation of ti and Ti with at low values, and to assess the possible changes of ignition mode of a single coal particle at low values.
2 Experimental approach
2.1 Experimental equipment and methods
The experimental system, similar to that used in Ref. [14], is schematically shown in Fig. 1. A high-speed CMOS camera was used to record the ignition and combustion process of the single coal particle. Meanwhile, the temperature variations at the center and the surface of the coal particle were detected by thermocouples and a SWIR camera respectively. A beam splitter divided the radiation from the coal particles into two parts, 90% of the visible light was reflected to the CMOS camera, and 80% of the infrared spectrum was transmitted to the SWIR camera.
A typical Chinese bituminous coal, Datong coal (DTC) was used and its proximate and ultimate analysis is given in Table 1. Hand-made spherical coal particles with a diameter of approximately 2 mm (dp=2mm) were used. The raw coals were crushed and sieved, and particles of approximately 2.0 mm in size were manually selected. Then the particles were drilled through a 0.25 mm hole and shaped into spherical. A vernier caliper was used to measure the particle size. When the error of two randomly selected particle sizes of the same particle is within 5%, it is considered that the spherical particles are qualified, otherwise, grinding would continue. To measure the temperature at the center of the coal particle, a fine bare-wired K type thermocouple (with a wire diameter of 0.125 mm and a joint diameter of 0.25 mm) was installed in the drilled hole, as illustrated in Fig. 2. The joint of the thermocouple was placed at the center of the coal particle. The hole was then sealed with high-temperature glue. The coal particle with thermocouple installed was supported by a ceramic probe with two tiny holes for the thermocouple wires. The probe was mounted to a linear motor, which could carry the probe into the furnace at a speed of 20 cm/s through a hole opened in the middle of furnace wall. The furnace was electrically heated and preheated to a preset temperature before the coal particle was inserted into. The size of the furnace was f 60 mm × 90 mm (length). More details about the experimental system could be referred to in Ref. [14].
Experiments were conducted at a series of oxygen concentrations ( = 10%, 15%, and 21%) and furnace temperatures (Tw = 923 K, 973 K, 1023 K, and 1073 K). At the beginning of each experiment, the furnace was filled with N2-O2 gas at a preset and Tw value. Though there was an 8 mm hole on the furnace to inject and retract the coal particle probe, there should be no leakage of external air into the furnace since the gas inside expanded only during ignition. When the furnace was filled with the hypoxic air at the lowest testing value ( = 10%), the excess air coefficient calculated was approximately 2.3. Therefore, oxygen was sufficient for burnout.
The ignition delay time (ti) was defined as the time interval from the moment when coal particle was sent into the furnace and the moment when ignition occurred, based on the color images recorded at 500 Hz. The ignition moment was referred to the time when a bright image showed up. The ti equaled to the summation of the residence time of the coal particle at the furnace center before ignition and the translation time in the furnace. In the experiment, the coal particle was inserted into the center of the furnace at 20 cm/s by a programmed linear stepper motor and the translation time in the furnace was about 0.2 s [14]. If a flame with a size larger than that of the coal particle was observed before the particle surface turned luminous red, the ignition was considered as homogeneous. On the opposite, the ignition was regarded as heterogeneous. If one or a few bright spots on the particle surface and at the same time a flame around the particle were observed, the ignition was regarded as combined ignition. Ti was defined as the Ts of coal particle right before the appearance of a visual flame, determined by the infrared images recorded by a SWIR camera at 50 Hz using the monochrome method.
To reduce the error in Ts measurement, relatively long wavelengths were selected to increase the measurable radiation energy. Given that drying and pyrolysis processes could produce a certain amount of vapor and CO2, which were highly absorptive in the wavelength range of 2.4–2.7 mm, the associated wavelength range was excluded. Based on the previous experiments [21], coal particles do not behave as a gray body in the wavelength range of 2–6 mm, due to the low and fluctuating emissivity. Therefore, the infrared spectrum selected to measure the radiant energy from the coal particle surface was in the range of 0.9–1.7 mm. According to the optical design in the experiment, the relationship between the radiation energy captured by the SWIR camera and the Ts of coal particles is [22]
where G(l,Ts) represents the grayscale, the radiation intensity; K(Ts) is a conversion coefficient of the optical system at Ts; g(l) and b(l) represent the spectral curves of photo-sensitive elements and beam splitter, respectively; and C1 is the first constant of Planck radiation while C2 is the second constant of Planck radiation. During the heating process, the coal particle was assumed as a gray body and its surface emissivity ε remained unchanged. In the calculation, ε was assumed to be 0.85, as used in Refs. [14,23]. Ts calibration was done using a blackbody furnace in the range of 600–950 K, with an interval of 25 K. The typical calibration images are demonstrated in Fig. 3.
Based on Eq. (1), the unqiue relationship between K(Ts) and Ts can be established using a black-body furnace calibration. The relationship was in an exponential form, similar to the one reported in Ref. [14]. Besides, the value of exp(C2/(lTs)) is much greater than 1, and thus, G(l,Ts) can be expressed as an exponential function of Ts regardless of l
When the coal particle was just placed at the center of the furnace, the radiation emitted by the coal particle was much weaker than that emitted from the furnace wall and reflected by the surface of the coal particle. The radiation energy received by the SWIR camera was mainly the background, which was subtracted to obtain the net radiation energy emitted by coal particles.
2.2 Error analysis
The total measurement error of the temperature at the coal particle center (Ti,c) by the thermocouples (denoted as sc) was introduced by three parts. One part of the error was due to the offset (DL) of the joint of thermocouples from the center of the particle, denoted as s1. The maximum offset was estimated at 10% of the particle diameter, i.e., 0.2 mm. According to the measurement data, the temperature difference (DT) between Ti,s and Ti,c was about 100 K. The radial temperature variation inside the particles could be linear as the intra-particle thermal conduction was considered. Calculated by Eq. (3), s1 was nearly 20 K, with a relative error of less than 5.0%.
The second part of the error was due to the accuracy of the thermocouple (s2). The thermocouple provided by the manufacturer was 0.75%, introducing a systematic error was nearly 6 K. The third part of the error could be induced by the high-temperature glue (s3). Both the thermal conductivity and amount of the high-temperature glue were much less than those for the coal particle. Thus, heat transfer caused by high-temperature glue in the ignition process was little. Namely, s3 could be be neglected [24]. Besides, some error could be introduced by temperature acquisition. Given the temperature acquisition frequency was 20 Hz and the variation of temperature was 100 K/s, this error was about ±0.1 K. Such a small error could be neglected in the measurement of Ti,c [25].
Therefore, calclauted by Eq. (4), sc was nearly 20 K.
The error of surface temperature measurement ss depended on the accuracy of the black-body calibration process, and the maximum value was estimated at ± 10 K. In our experiments, the error caused by the optical system was neglected [14].
3 Results and discussion
3.1 Ignition delay time at low O2 concentrations
Figure 4 depicts that the ignition delay time t* (ti/ti,air) decreases with under low conditions, which decreases obviously faster compared with the results obtained by Liu et al.[14] at a high value. Similarly, Ponzio et al. found that the decreasing rate at a low value is faster than the result obtained in this paper because they have adopted larger coal pellets with a diameter of 15 mm and a height of 35 mm in their experiments [17], which may strengthen the effect of O2 on ti at a low value. The reason for this is that becomes the dominant factor influencing ti at a low value for homogeneous ignition of cm-sized coal particles.
Figure 5 exhibits the variation of ti with Tw in air and low conditions. It can be seen that ti is less sensitive to Tw at a low value than in air, especially at a higher Tw. This can be explained by the ignition theory of the flammability limit criterion proposed by Zhang and his coworkers [26]. Based on the theory, ignition occurs only if the content of volatiles generated by pyrolysis reaches the flammability which is inversely proportional to Tw and , but the influence becomes weaker as increases.
3.2 Ignition temperature at low O2 concentrations
Shown in Fig. 6, in which T* is equal to the ratio of Ti to Ti,air, Ts decreases with increasing at a low value, which is consistent with that found by Zhou et al. [12]. As increases, more O2 diffuses onto the particle, which accelerates the pyrolysis reaction. Therefore, more volatile matter is released to reduce Ti. These phenomena can also be found in air and high atmosphere [11,14]. However, similar to the results found by Annamalai and Durbetaki [13], Ts is hardly influenced by when using center temperature (Tc). Given that the internal temperature gradient cannot be neglected for large coal particles, Tc can better reflect the ignition of coal particle. At a low value, barely influences the heating rate of coal particles and thus it plays little role in Tc.
Figure 7 shows that Ti decreases with Tw, but the decrease at a low value and air is different. Ti is more sensitive to Tw at = 10%, which is consistent with the result reported by Zhou et al. [27]. At a low value, the flammability limit for coal ignition is high since the volatile content released is low. Therefore, Ti is more sensitive to Tw under a low condition than in air. When Tw increases, the devolatilization rate accelerates. Even at a low value, the surrounding volatile content is high enough to reach the flammability limit. Therefore, the difference in Ti is not significant. In air, the flammability limit can be met at different Tw values. Therefore, the decreasing rate of Ti is nearly constant.
3.3 Ignition modes at low O2 concentrations
The transient combustion processes of a single coal particle at two low values and three Tw values are displayed in Fig. 8. It can be seen at the ignition that there is a large amount of soot surrounding the coal particles. It can be also seen that the burning intensity of the flame after ignition varies non-monotonically with Tw at the same value. For example, when = 10%, the brightness of the flame at Tw = 1023 K is between that at Tw = 973 K and that at Tw = 1073 K. When Tw is low (e.g., at 973 K), the evaporation of tar, which is regarded as the precursor of the volatile matter, into combustible gases is slow, and O2 intends to diffuse onto the particle surface. Ignition occurs at the surface with a bright flame and gas phase combustion finishes more quickly as the evoluted volatile matter is depleted. When Tw increases to a certain value (e.g., at 1023 K), more tar is converted into combustible gases. The out-diffusing gases impede O2 diffusion onto the surface of coal particles. However, the temperature is still not high enough to initiate the ignition while the volatile matter released could be swept by the buoyancy. Thus, a weaker instead of a stronger flame appears even at a high Tw value. As Tw further increases (e.g., to 1073 K), the coal particle changes into homogeneous ignition because more volatile is released. Both the concentration of combustible gases and temperature meet the flammability limits in the near space surrounding the coal particles.
To better reflect the evolution of flame during ignition, a dimensionless standoff distance r* is introduced, which is defined as the ratio of the distance of flame front standing away from particle center (x) to particle radius (rp). Shown in Fig. 9, r* decreases with the increasing , especially for homogeneous ignition at a high Tw value, because a high value accelerates O2 diffusion onto the particle surface. This could be attributed to the fact that a higher Tw promotes the pyrolysis of coal particles to produce more volatiles, but the volatiles inhibit the diffusion of oxygen to the surface of coal particles.
According to the flame standoff position, it can be inferred that heterogeneous ignition may occur at 973 K and a value of 15%. Figure 10 illustrates the ignition modes for single coal particles of 2 mm at different values. Four regions including unburned, heterogeneous, homogeneous and combined ones are divided. For large sizes, coal particles tend to ignite homogeneously. However, at a low and Tw value, heterogeneous ignition may occur because the volatile matter released could be swept away by buoyancy. At a higher Tw and a low value, combined ignition occurs. The reason for this is that more volatiles accumulate around coal particles with insufficient , leading to a vigorous flame with larger flame standoff but shorter duration, especially obvious at 973 K and a value of 10%. As Tw further increases, the balance between Tw and is broken, and ignition intends to be homogeneous again. The critical Tw between homogeneous ignition and heterogeneous ignition decreases with .
4 Conclusions
Experiments on ignition of single coal particle at low values were conducted at different Tw values. The combustion process was recorded by a high-speed camera while Ts and Tc were obtained by an infrared camera and thermocouples, respectively. It is found that the ignition delay time (ti) decreases more rapidly as increases at a low value than at a high value. The surface temperature (Ts) for coal particles decreases with while the center temperature (Tc) remains constant with at a low value. ti is less sensitive but Ti is more sensitive to Tw at a low value than in air. The flame front locates further away from coal particles at a high Tw value but approaches to particle surface at a high value. Observations of the position of flame front evolution illustrate that the ignition of a coal particle may change from a homogeneous mode to a heterogeneous or a combined ignition mode as decreases. At a low value, buoyancy plays a more significant role in sweeping away the released volatiles during the ignition process.
Lille S, Blasiak W, Jewartowski M. Experimental study of the fuel jet combustion in high temperature and low oxygen content exhaust gases. Energy, 2005, 30(2–4): 373–384
[2]
Stadler H, Ristic D, Förster M, Schuster A, Kneer R, Scheffknecht G. NOx-emissions from flameless coal combustion in air, Ar/O2 and CO2/O2. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute, 2009, 32(2): 3131–3138
[3]
Li P, Wang F, Tu Y, Mei Z, Zhang J, Zheng Y, Liu H, Liu Z, Mi J, Zheng C. Moderate or intense low-oxygen dilution oxy-combustion characteristics of light oil and pulverized coal in a pilot-scale furnace. Energy & Fuels, 2014, 28(2): 1524–1535
[4]
Yue G, Cai R, Lu J, Zhang H. From a CFB reactor to a CFB boiler–the review of R&D progress of CFB coal combustion technology in China. Powder Technology, 2017, 316(1): 18–28
[5]
Essenhigh R H, Misra M K, Shaw D W. Ignition of coal particles: a review. Combustion and Flame, 1989, 77(1): 3–30
[6]
Buhre B J, Elliott L K, Sheng C D, Gupta R P, Wall T F. Oxy-fuel combustion technology for coal-fired power generation. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science, 2005, 31(4): 283–307
[7]
Qiao Y, Zhang L, Binner E, Xu M, Li C Z. An investigation of the causes of the difference in coal particle ignition temperature between combustion in air and in O/CO. Fuel, 2010, 89(11): 3381–3387
[8]
Shaddix C R, Molina A. Particle imaging of ignition and devolatilization of pulverized coal during oxy-fuel combustion. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute, 2009, 32(2): 2091–2098
[9]
Farazi S, Attili A, Kang S, Pitsch H. Numerical study of coal particle ignition in air and oxy-atmosphere. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute, 2019, 37(3): 2867–2874
[10]
Du X, Annamalai K. The transient ignition of isolated coal particle. Combustion and Flame, 1994, 97(3–4): 339–354
[11]
Liu Y, Wang C, Che D. Ignition and kinetics analysis of coal combustion in low oxygen concentration. Energy Sources. Part A, Recovery, Utilization, and Environmental Effects, 2012, 34(9): 810–819
[12]
Zhou K, Lin Q, Hu H, Hu H, Song L. The ignition characteristics and combustion processes of the single coal slime particle under different hot-coflow conditions in N2/O2 atmosphere. Energy, 2017, 136: 173–184
[13]
Annamalai K, Durbetaki P. A theory on transition of ignition phase of coal particles. Combustion and Flame, 1977, 29(2): 193–208
[14]
Liu B, Zhang Z, Zhang H, Zhang D. Volatile release and ignition behaviors of single coal particles at different oxygen concentrations under microgravity. Microgravity Science and Technology, 2016, 28(2): 101–108
[15]
Liu B, Zhang Z, Zhang H, Yang H, Zhang D. An experimental investigation on the effect of convection on the ignition behaviour of single coal particles under various O2 concentrations. Fuel, 2014, 116: 77–83
[16]
Goshayeshi B, Sutherland J C. A comparison of various models in predicting ignition delay in single-particle coal combustion. Combustion and Flame, 2014, 161(7): 1900–1910
[17]
Ponzio A, Senthoorselvan S, Yang W, Blasiak W, Eriksson O. Ignition of single coal particles in high-temperature oxidizers with various oxygen concentrations. Fuel, 2008, 87(6): 974–987
[18]
Gat N, Cohen L M, Witte A. Three-color pyrometer for burning particle temperature measurement. In: JANNAF Combust Meeting, Monterrey,1983
[19]
Fletcher T H. Time-resolved temperature measurements of individual coal particles during devolatilization. Combustion Science and Technology, 1989, 63(1): 89–105
[20]
Zhu M, Zhang H, Tang G, Liu Q, Lu J, Yue G, Wang S, Wan S. Ignition of single coal particle in a hot furnace under normal and micro-gravity condition. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute, 2009, 32(2): 2029–2035
[21]
Bhattacharya S P, Wall T F. Development of emittance of coal particles during devolatilisation and burnoff. Fuel, 1999, 78(5): 511–519
[22]
Fu T, Tan P, Pang C, Zhao H, Shen Y. Fast fiber-optic multi-wavelength pyrometer. Review of Scientific Instruments, 2011, 82(6): 064902
[23]
Tichenor D A, Mitchell R E, Hencken K R, Niksa S. Simultaneous in situ measurement of the size, temperature and velocity of particles in a combustion environment. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute, 1985, 20(1): 1213–1221
[24]
Jiang X, Wang C, Bi H, Jiang C, Liu Y, Song Z, Lin Q. Experimental investigation on combustion and gas emission of scrap tire pellet under various concentrations of CO2/O2 mixtures. Combustion Science & Technology, Online (Bergheim)
[25]
Bu C, Leckner B, Chen X, Pallarès D, Liu D, Gómez-Barea A. Devolatilization of a single fuel particle in a fluidized bed under oxy-combustion conditions. Part A: Experimental results. Combustion and Flame, 2015, 162(3): 797–808
[26]
Zhang M, Yu J, Xu X. A new flame sheet model to reflect the influence of the oxidation of CO on the combustion of a carbon particle. Combustion and Flame, 2005, 143(3): 150–158
[27]
Zhou K, Lin Q, Hu H, Shan F, Fu W, Zhang P, Wang X, Wang C. Ignition and combustion behaviors of single coal slime particles in CO2/O2 atmosphere. Combustion and Flame, 2018, 194: 250–263
RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS
Higher Education Press
AI Summary 中Eng×
Note: Please be aware that the following content is generated by artificial intelligence. This website is not responsible for any consequences arising from the use of this content.