Changes in species composition and diversity in the restoration process of sub-alpine dark brown coniferous forests in western Sichuan Province, China

Abstract

By adopting the concept of space as a substitute for time, we analyzed the dynamics of species composition and diversity of different restoration sequences (20, 30, 40, 50 years) in two secondary forest types in western Sichuan Province, distributed in a northerly or northwesterly direction. The analysis was based on the results of measurements of 50 plots located at elevations between 3100–3600 m. The forests originated from natural regeneration in combination with reforestation of spruce when the old-growth bamboo-dark brown coniferous forests and moss-dark brown coniferous old growth forests were harvested. Similar old-growth dark brown coniferous forests at ages ranging between 160 and 200 years were selected as the reference forests for comparisons. We recorded 167 species of vascular plants from 44 families and 117 genera. There was no significant difference in terms of the number of species among secondary forests. But the importance values of dominant species varied during the restoration processes. The dominant species in the secondary forests is Betula albo-sinensis, while Abies faxoniana is the dominant species in old-growth dark brown coniferous forests. Species richness increased significantly with restoration processes. It increased quickly in secondary forests during the period from 30 to 40 years, but decreased significantly in the old-growth dark brown coniferous forests. The species richness among growth forms decreased in the following order: herb layer > shrub layer > tree layer. The maximum value of the evenness index occurred in secondary forests at age 40 and remained relatively stable in the bamboo-birch forests, but the evenness index tended to decrease in moss-birch forests and slightly increased in the old-growth moss-dark brown coniferous forests. There was a statistically significant difference in the evenness index between the tree and shrub layers as well as between the tree layer and the herb layer, but there was no significant difference between the shrub layer and the herb layer. The value of the Shannon index increased over restoration time. In bamboo-birch forests, the maximum value of the Shannon index was 3.80, recorded at age 50. In moss-birch forests, the maximal value was 3.65, reached in this forest at age 30. The value of the Shannon index of old-growth dark brown coniferous forests was recorded between younger secondary and older secondary forests. The value of the dominance index of communities varied. At the first stage of restoration, it increased, and at the end it was decreased. The dominance index of the tree layer had a similar trend as that of the community dominance index, but was more variable. The minimum value of the dominance index of the tree layer in the moss-birch forests reached 20 years earlier than that of the bamboo-birch forests. There was a significant difference among restoration sequences in the ? diversity indices except for the dominance index. No significant differences between the two secondary forest types were detected. Over age, the value of the Bray-Curtis index between secondary forest and old-growth dark brown coniferous forest increased.

References

1. Bao W K Zhang Y L Wang Q Bai W Q Zheng D 2002 Plant diversity alonga time sequence (1–30 years) of artificial forest rehabilitationon subalpine cut land in the eastern Qinghai-Tibetan PlateauActa Phytoecol Sin26(3)330338 (in Chinese)
2. Gao X M Ma K P Huang J H Liu C R 1998 Studies on plant community diversity in Donglingshan Mountain, Beijing,China: XI. The β diversityof mountain meadow.Acta Ecol Sin18(1)2432 (in Chinese)
3. Grime J P 1997 Biodiversity and ecosystem function: the debate deepensScience277(5330)l2601261. doi:10.1126/science.277.5330.1260
4. Guariguata M R Chazdon R L Denslow J S Dupuy M J Anderson L 1997 Structure and floristicsof secondary and old-growth forest stands in lowland Costa RicaPlant Ecol132(1)107120. doi:10.1023/A:1009726421352
5. Hao Z Q Yu D Y Yang X M Ding Z H 2002a α diversity of communitiesand their variety along altitude gradient on northern slope of ChangbaiMountainChin J of Appl Ecol13(7)785789 (in Chinese)
6. Hao Z Q Guo S L Cao T 2002b Plant Diversity and Pattern in ChangbaishanMountainShenyangLiaoning Science and Technology Press (in Chinese)
7. He J S Chen W L 1997 A review ofgradient changes in species diversity of land plant communitiesActa Ecol Sin17(1)9199 (in Chinese)
8. Ishida H Hattori T Takeda Y 2005 Comparison of species composition andrichness between primary and secondary lucidophyllous forests in twoaltitudinal zones of Tsushima Island, JapanFor Ecol Manage213(1–3)273287. doi:10.1016/j.foreco.2005.03.046
9. Jiang Y X 1963a Community characteristic and classification principle ofalpine dark coniferous forest in Miyaluo, west SichuanActa Phytoecol Geobot Sin1(1)4250 (in Chinese)
10. Jiang Y X 1963b The primary study on habitat type of alpine forest in Miyaluoand Markang, west SichuanSci Silv Sin8(4)321335 (in Chinese)
11. Lin K M Yu X T Huang B L He Z Y 2001 Dynamical characteristics of undergrowth plant diversity in Chinesefir plantationsChin J Appl Environ Biol7(1)1319 (in Chinese)
12. Liu Q Wu Y He H 2001 Ecological problems of subalpine coniferousforest in the southwest ChinaWorld Sci-TechR&D23(2)6369 (in Chinese)
13. Ma K P Liu C R Liu Y M 1995 Community measurement method of bio-Diversity:II. measurement method of β diversity.Chin Biodivers3(1)3843 (in Chinese)
14. Peng S L 1996 The Dynamic of Forest Community in Low Subtropical ZoneBeijingSciencePress (in Chinese)
15. Ruiz-Jaen M C Aide T M 2005 Restorationsuccess: how is it being measured?Res Ecol13(3)569577. doi:10.1111/j.1526‐100X.2005.00072.x
16. Shi L X Wang J X Su Y M Hou G W 1988 Earlier_stages succession of vegetation on the clear-cut in Miyaluoforest district in western SichuanActaPhytoecol Geobot Sin12(4)306313 (in Chinese)
17. Shi S Y Yang J D Wang Z P Li X G 2002a Species diversity in the progression of ecological restoration ofartificial mixed forest after wind-damage in Jinyun Mountain, SichuanBiodiver Sci10(3)274279 (in Chinese)
18. Shi Z M Cheng R M Liu S R Jiang Y X Chen B J 2002b Study on species diversityof plant communities in BaotianmanSci SilvSin38(6)1723 (in Chinese)
19. Tilman D Downing J A 1994 Biodiversityand stability in grasslandNature367363365. doi:10.1038/367363a0
20. Vázquez G J A Givnish T J 1998 Altitudinalgradients in tropical forest composition, structure, and diversityin the Sierra de ManantlánJ Ecol869991020. doi:10.1046/j.1365‐2745.1998.00325.x
21. Wen Y G 1998 Restorative trend and rate of the species diversity ofrecovering process in degraded ecosystem of evergreen broad-leavedforestJ Guangxi Agric Univ17(2)93106 (in Chinese)
22. Wu Y Liu Q Qiao Y K Pan K W Zhao C M Chen Q H 2001 Species diversity changes in subalpine coniferous forestsof different restoration stages and their effects on soil propertiesActa Phytoecol Sin25(6)648655 (in Chinese)
23. Yan H P Tan X Sun X Y Geng Y Q Ren Y M Dong J L Wang T Z 2001 Studies onspecies divers of plantation community on Beijing XishanJ Beijing For Univ23(2)1619 (in Chinese)
24. Yang W Q Wang K Y Kellomaki S 2003 Relationships between biodiversity andprocesses of coniferous forest ecosystemWorld Sci-Tech R&D25(5)4755 (in Chinese)
25. Young T P 2000 Restoration ecology and conservation biologyBiol Conserv92(1)7383. doi:10.1016/S0006‐3207(99)00057‐9
26. Zerbe S Kreyer D 2006 Introductionto special section on “ecosystem restoration and biodiversity:how to assess and measure biological diversity?” Res Ecol14(1)103104. doi:10.1111/j.1526‐100X.2006.00110.x
27. Zhang J Y Zhao H L Zhang T H Zhao X Y 2004 Dynamics of species diversity of communities in restoration processesin Horqin sandy landActa Phytoecol Sin28(1)8692 (in Chinese)
28. Zhang Y D Zhao C M Liu S R 2005a The influence factors of sub-alpine forestrestoration in Miyaluo, West SichuanSciSilvae Sin41(4)189193 (in Chinese)
29. Zhang Y D Liu S R Ma J M Shi Z M Liu X L 2005b Woodland hydrologicaleffects of birch forests in sub-alpine region of western Sichuan,ChinaActa Ecol Sin25(11)29392946 (in Chinese)
30. Zhao C M Cheng Q H Qiao Y K Pan K W 2002 Dynamics of species diversity in the restoration process of artificialspruce conifer forest in the eastern edge of Qinghai-Tibet plateauActa Phytoecol Sin26(Suppl)2029 (in Chinese)