An estimated Time of Arrival (ETA) model for achieving Just-in-Time (JIT) modular construction delivery in high-density cities

Abstract

Modular construction (MC) is a sound strategy to alleviate global issues such as housing crisis, labor shortage, and stagnant productivity. Project managers are aspired to achieve a Just-in-Time (JIT) delivery of their MC logistics. However, the efforts often fall short without the presence of a dedicated Estimated Time of Arrival (ETA) model. This study aims to bridge this gap by developing a MC-oriented ETA model. It does so by first identifying critical factors influencing ETA accuracy in general logistics and then developing an ETA model prototype, which is then calibrated using simulations and data collected from the Internet of Things (IoTs) applied in real-life MC projects in Hong Kong, China. Validated through a cross-border MC project in China’s Greater Bay Area, the MC-oriented ETA model achieved 90.6% prediction accuracy (±10 min), reduced transportation delays by 37.5%, and slashed daily planning time from 46.75 to 18.75 min. It is expected that the ETA model can be used in predictive planning of MC logistics delivery in the future. Ultimately, it can lead to the development of smart logistics planning and control systems to expedite MC housing delivery and alleviate urban congestion in high-density cities, offering valuable insights for policymakers, construction stakeholders, and supply chain managers.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

modular construction / estimated time of arrival model / high-density cities / just-in-time delivery / logistics planning

References

[1] Abdi A, Amrit C, (2024). Enhancing vessel arrival time prediction: A fusion-based deep learning approach. Expert Systems with Applications, 252( 2): 123988

[2] Al-Naim R, Lytkin Y, (2021). Review and comparison of prediction algorithms for the estimated time of arrival using geospatial transportation data. Procedia Computer Science, 193( 1): 13–21

[3] AnH YChoiW SChoiS G (2022). Data preprocessing method for ANN-based travel time estimation using insufficient GPS data. In 2022 13th International Conference on Information and Communication Technology Convergence (ICTC). IEEE1917–1922

[4] Arbabkhah H, Sedaghat A, Jafari Kang M, Hamidi M, (2024). Automatic identification system-based prediction of tanker and cargo estimated time of arrival in narrow waterways. Journal of Marine Science and Engineering, 12( 2): 12020215

[5] Ballis A, Dimitriou L, (2010). Issues on railway wagon asset management using advanced information systems. Transportation Research Part C, Emerging Technologies, 18( 5): 807–820

[6] Balster A, Hansen O, Friedrich H, Ludwig A, (2020). An ETA prediction model for intermodal transport networks based on machine learning. Business & Information Systems Engineering, 62( 5): 403–416

[7] Barros V H, Costa T S, Oliveira A C, Lorena L A, (2011). Model and heuristic for berth allocation in tidal bulk ports with stock level constraints. Computers & Industrial Engineering, 60( 4): 606–613

[8] Basturk O, Cetek C, (2021). Prediction of aircraft estimated time of arrival using machine learning methods. Aeronautical Journal, 125( 1289): 1245–1259

[9] Belfadel A, Hörl S, Tapia R J, Politaki D, Kureshi I, Tavasszy L, Puchinger J, (2023). A conceptual digital twin framework for city logistics. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems, 103( 1): 101989

[10] BodunovOSchmidtFMartinABritoAFetzerC (2018). Real-time Destination and ETA Prediction for Maritime Traffic. Proceedings of the 12th ACM International Conference on Distributed and Event-Based Systems. ACM Digital Library, 198–201

[11] Chen K, Chu G, Yang X, Shi Y, Lei K, Deng M, (2022). HSETA: A heterogeneous and sparse data learning hybrid framework for estimating time of arrival. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems, 23( 11): 21873–21884

[12] Chondrodima E, Georgiou H, Pelekis N, Theodoridis Y, (2022). Particle swarm optimization and RBF neural networks for public transport arrival time prediction using GTFS data. International Journal of Information Management Data Insights, 2( 2): 100086

[13] Chung E H, Shalaby A, (2007). Expected time of arrival model for school bus transit using real-time global positioning system-based automatic vehicle location data. Journal of Intelligent Transport Systems, 11( 4): 157–167

[14] Construction Industry Council [CIC] (2018). About modular integrated construction. Hong Kong: Construction Industry Council. Available from the website of cic.hk

[15] Construction Industry Council [CIC] (2020). Reference Material on Logistics and Transport for Modular Integrated Construction Projects. . Available from the website of cic.hk

[16] Dalmau R, Trzmiel A, Kirby S, (2025). Combining machine learning models to improve estimated time of arrival predictions. European Journal of Transport and Infrastructure Research, 25( 1): 45–66

[17] Di Martino S, Rossi S, (2016). An architecture for a mobility recommender system in smart cities. Procedia Computer Science, 98( 4): 425–430

[18] Du W, Li Y, Zhang G, Wang C, Zhu B, Qiao J, (2022). Ship weather routing optimization based on improved fractional order particle swarm optimization. Ocean Engineering, 248( 1): 110680

[19] Halili R, Yousaf F Z, Slamnik-Krijestorac N, Yilma G M, Liebsch M, Berkvens R, Weyn M, (2023). Self-correcting algorithm for estimated time of arrival of emergency responders on the highway. IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, 72( 1): 340–356

[20] Hsu P Y, Angeloudis P, Aurisicchio M, (2018). Optimal logistics planning for modular construction using two-stage stochastic programming. Automation in Construction, 94: 47–61

[21] Kaparias I, Bell M G, Belzner H, (2008). A new measure of travel time reliability for in-vehicle navigation systems. Journal of Intelligent Transport Systems, 12( 4): 202–211

[22] Kim B, Kim T W, (2017). Weather routing for offshore transportation using genetic algorithm. Applied Ocean Research, 63( 2): 262–275

[23] Kwak D, Liu R, Kim D, Nath B, Iftode L, (2016). Seeing is believing: Sharing real-time visual traffic information via vehicular clouds. IEEE Access: Practical Innovations, Open Solutions, 4( 2): 3617–3631

[24] Lee D, Lee S, (2021). Digital twin for supply chain coordination in modular construction. Applied Sciences (Basel, Switzerland), 11( 13): 5909

[25] Li M, Feng Y, Wu X, (2024). AttentionTTE: a deep learning model for estimated time of arrival. Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence, 7( 2): 1258086

[26] Lin S, Xu Y, Zhao S, Wang Y, Xu J, (2023). TransETA: transformer networks for estimated time of arrival with local congestion representation. Applied Intelligence, 53( 24): 30384–30399

[27] Lindell M K, Prater C S, (2007). A hurricane evacuation management decision support system (EMDSS). Natural Hazards, 40( 3): 627–634

[28] Lin Y, Yang X, Zou N, Jia L, (2013). Real-time bus arrival time prediction: Case study for Jinan, China. Journal of Transportation Engineering, 139( 11): 1133–1140

[29] Lu W, Wu L, Xu J, Lou J, (2022). Construction E-inspection 2.0 in the COVID-19 pandemic era: A blockchain-based technical solution. Journal of Management Engineering, 38( 4): 04022032

[30] Lu W, Wu L, Zhao R, Li X, Xue F, (2021). Blockchain technology for governmental supervision of construction work: Learning from digital currency electronic payment systems. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 147( 10): 04021122

[31] Nguyen V L, Hwang R H, Lin P C, (2022). Controllable path planning and traffic scheduling for emergency services in the internet of vehicles. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems, 23( 8): 12399–12413

[32] Observatory of Economic Complexity (OEC) (2021). Prefabricated buildings. Available at the website of oec.world

[33] Pang B, Low K H, Duong V N, (2024). Chance-constrained UAM traffic flow optimization with fast disruption recovery under uncertain waypoint occupancy time. Transportation Research Part C, Emerging Technologies, 161( 2): 104547

[34] Rehman S U, Kim I, Choi J, (2023). Data-driven integration framework for four-dimensional building information modeling simulation in modular construction: A case study approach. Journal of Computational Design and Engineering, 10( 6): 2288–2311

[35] Rogel N, Raphaeli D, Bialer O, (2021). Time of arrival and angle of arrival estimation algorithm in dense multipath. IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing, 69( 1): 5907–5919

[36] Seo C, Noh Y, Abebe M, Kang Y J, Park S, Kwon C, (2023). Ship collision avoidance route planning using CRI-based A* algorithm. International Journal of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering, 15( 1): 100551

[37] Sheikholeslami A, Ilati R, (2018). A sample average approximation approach to the berth allocation problem with uncertain tides. Engineering Optimization, 50( 10): 1772–1788

[38] Sun Y, Fu K, Wang Z, Zhou D, Wu K, Ye J, Zhang C, (2022). CoDriver ETA: Combine driver information in estimated time of arrival by driving style learning auxiliary task. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems, 23( 5): 4037–4048

[39] Wang H, Yi W, Zhen L, Chan A P, (2024). Cost-optimized transport planning for prefabricated modules with the implementation of the just-in-time strategy. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 150( 8): 04024093

[40] Wang Z, Gao G, Liu X, Lyu W, (2019). verification and analysis of traffic evaluation indicators in urban transportation system planning based on multi-source data—A case study of Qingdao city, China. IEEE Access: Practical Innovations, Open Solutions, 7( 1): 110103–110115

[41] Wang Z, Liang M, Delahaye D, (2018). A hybrid machine learning model for short-term estimated time of arrival prediction in terminal manoeuvring area. Transportation Research Part C, Emerging Technologies, 95( 1): 280–294

[42] Weiss P, (2021). The Global Positioning System (GPS): Creating satellite beacons in space, engineers transformed daily life on earth. Engineering, 7( 3): 290–303

[43] Wiegmans B, Menger I, Behdani B, Van Arem B, (2018). Communication between deep sea container terminals and hinterland stakeholders: information needs and the relevance of information exchange. Maritime Economics & Logistics, 20( 4): 531–548

[44] Wu L, Li X, Zhao R, Lu W, Xu J, Xue F, (2022a). A blockchain-based model with an incentive mechanism for cross-border logistics supervision and data sharing in modular construction. Journal of Cleaner Production, 375: 133460

[45] Wu L, Lu W, Chen C, (2024). Compliance checking for cross-border construction logistics clearance using blockchain smart contracts and oracles. International Journal of Logistics, 27( 12): 2778–2812

[46] Wu L, Lu W, Zhao R, Xu J, Li X, Xue F, (2022b). Using blockchain to improve information sharing accuracy in the onsite assembly of modular construction. Journal of Management Engineering, 38( 3): 04022014

[47] Wuni I Y, Shen G Q, (2020). Barriers to the adoption of modular integrated construction: Systematic review and meta-analysis, integrated conceptual framework, and strategies. Journal of Cleaner Production, 249( 2): 119347

[48] Yan R, Chu Z, Wu L, Wang S, (2024). Predicting vessel service time: A data-driven approach. Advanced Engineering Informatics, 62( 2): 102718

[49] YangY (2020). Multi-perspective approaches for enhancing offsite logistics of modular construction in high-rise high-density cities. (Ph.D. Thesis). University of Hong Kong

[50] Yang Y, Pan M, Pan W, Zhang Z, (2021). Sources of uncertainties in offsite logistics of modular construction for high-rise building projects. Journal of Management Engineering, 37( 3): 04021011

[51] Ye Y, Zhu Y, Markos C, Yu J J Q, (2022). CatETA: A categorical approximate approach for estimating time of arrival. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems, 23( 12): 24389–24400

[52] Zhang J, Liu J, Hu R, Zhu H, (2018b). Online four dimensional trajectory prediction method based on aircraft intent updating. Aerospace Science and Technology, 77( 1): 774–787

[53] Zhang R, Liu W, Jia Y, Jiang G, Xing J, Jiang H, Liu J, (2018a). WiFi sensing-based real-time bus tracking and arrival time prediction in urban environments. IEEE Sensors Journal, 18( 11): 4746–4760

[54] Zou G, Lai Z, Ma C, Tu M, Fan J, Li Y, (2023). When will we arrive? A novel multi-task spatio-temporal attention network based on individual preference for estimating travel time. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems, 24( 10): 11438–11452

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s). This article is published with open access at link.springer.com and journal.hep.com.cn