Benefit-based cost allocation for residentially distributed photovoltaic systems in China: A cooperative game theory approach

Abstract

Distributed photovoltaic (PV) systems have constantly been the key to achieve a low-carbon economy in China. However, the development of Chinese distributed PV systems has failed to meet expectations because of their irrational profit and cost allocations. In this study, the methodology for calculating the levelized cost of energy (LCOE) for PV is thoroughly discussed to address this issue. A mixed-integer linear programming model is built to determine the optimal system operation strategy with a benefit analysis. An externality-corrected mathematical model based on Shapley value is established to allocate the cost of distributed PV systems in 15 Chinese cities between the government, utility grid and residents. Results show that (i) an inverse relationship exists between the LCOEs and solar radiation levels; (ii) the government and residents gain extra benefits from the utility grid through net metering policies, and the utility grid should be the highly subsidized participant; (iii) the percentage of cost assigned to the utility grid and government should increase with the expansion of battery bank to weaken the impact of demand response on increasing theoretical subsidies; and (iv) apart from the LCOE, the local residential electricity prices remarkably impact the subsidy calculation results.

Keywords

solar photovoltaic / cost allocation / cooperative game theory / Shapley value / mixed-integer linear programming / levelized cost of energy

References

[1] Branker K, Pathak M J M, Pearce J M (2011). A review of solar photovoltaic levelized cost of electricity. Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews, 15(9): 4470–4482

[2] Breyer C, Koskinen O, Blechinger P (2015). Profitable climate change mitigation: The case of greenhouse gas emission reduction benefits enabled by solar photovoltaic systems. Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews, 49: 610–628

[3] Constantino G, Freitas M, Fidelis N, Pereira M (2018). Adoption of photovoltaic systems along a sure path: A Life-Cycle Assessment (LCA) study applied to the analysis of GHG emission impacts. Energies, 11(10): 2806

[4] Costa P M, Matos M A (2009). Avoided losses on LV networks as a result of microgeneration. Electric Power Systems Research, 79(4): 629–634

[5] Darling S B, You F, Veselka T, Velosa A (2011). Assumptions and the levelized cost of energy for photovoltaics. Energy & Environmental Science, 4(9): 3133–3139

[6] Fernandez E, Hossain M J, Nizami M S H (2018). Game-theoretic approach to demand-side energy management for a smart neighbourhood in Sydney incorporating renewable resources. Applied Energy, 232: 245–257

[7] Fthenakis V M, Kim H C (2011). Photovoltaics: Life-cycle analyses. Solar Energy, 85(8): 1609–1628

[8] Garnaut R (2011). The Garnaut Review 2011: Australia in the Global Response to Climate Change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

[9] Holland M, Berry J, Forster D, Watkiss P, Boyd R, Lee D, Schneider T, Scheiber C, Tort V, Dreicer M (1998). ExternE: Externalities of Energy—Vol. 7, Methodology 1998 update (EUR19083); Vol. 8, Global warming (EUR 18836); Vol. 9, Fuel cycles for emerging and end-use technologies, transport and waste (EUR 18887); Vol. 10, National implementation (EUR 18528). Luxembourg: Commission of the European Communities

[10] Hope C (2011). The social cost of CO₂ from the PAGE09 model. Economics Discussion Paper, 39

[11] Jing R, Wang M, Liang H, Wang X, Li N, Shah N, Zhao Y (2018). Multi-objective optimization of a neighborhood-level urban energy network: Considering game-theory inspired multi-benefit allocation constraints. Applied Energy, 231: 534–548

[12] Li Y, Yang W, He P, Chen C, Wang X (2019). Design and management of a distributed hybrid energy system through smart contract and blockchain. Applied Energy, 248: 390–405

[13] Lin B, Li J (2015). Analyzing cost of grid-connection of renewable energy development in China. Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews, 50: 1373–1382

[14] Lorestani A, Ardehali M M (2018). Optimization of autonomous combined heat and power system including PVT, WT, storages, and electric heat utilizing novel evolutionary particle swarm optimization algorithm. Renewable Energy, 119: 490–503

[15] Luo X, Liu J (2015). Economic analysis of residential distributed solar photovoltaic. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 2(2): 125–130

[16] Luo X, Liu J (2016). Cost allocation of residential distributed PV project based on cooperative game theory. International Journal of Earth Sciences and Engineering, 9: 2106–2112

[17] Luo X, Liu Y, Liu J, Liu X (2019). Optimal design and cost allocation of a distributed energy resource (DER) system with district energy networks: A case study of an isolated island in the South China Sea. Sustainable Cities and Society, 51: 101726

[18] Luo X, Liu Y, Liu J, Liu X (2020). Energy scheduling for a three-level integrated energy system based on energy hub models: A hierarchical Stackelberg game approach. Sustainable Cities and Society, 52: 101814

[19] Oliva H S, MacGill I, Passey R (2016). Assessing the short-term revenue impacts of residential PV systems on electricity customers, retailers and network service providers. Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews, 54: 1494–1505

[20] Parrado C, Girard A, Simon F, Fuentealba E (2016). 2050 LCOE (Levelized Cost of Energy) projection for a hybrid PV (photovoltaic)-CSP (concentrated solar power) plant in the Atacama Desert, Chile. Energy, 94: 422–430

[21] Peng J, Lu L, Yang H (2013). Review on life cycle assessment of energy payback and greenhouse gas emission of solar photovoltaic systems. Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews, 19: 255–274

[22] Ren H B, Zhou W S, Nakagami K, Gao W J, Wu Q (2010). Multi-objective optimization for the operation of distributed energy systems considering economic and environmental aspects. Applied Energy, 87(12): 3642–3651

[23] Rideout D, Wagner J E (1986). An analysis of the separable costs–remaining benefits method of joint cost allocation. Canadian Journal of Forest Research, 16(5): 880–884

[24] Roson R, Hubert F (2015). Bargaining power and value sharing in distribution networks: A cooperative game theory approach. Networks and Spatial Economics, 15(1): 71–87

[25] Said M, El-Shimy M, Abdelraheem M A (2015). Photovoltaics energy: Improved modeling and analysis of the levelized cost of energy and grid parity-Egypt case study. Sustainable Energy Technologies and Assessments, 9: 37–48

[26] Sauhats A, Zemite L, Petrichenko L, Moshkin I, Jasevics A (2018). Estimating the economic impacts of net metering schemes for residential PV systems with profiling of power demand, generation, and market prices. Energies, 11(11): 3222

[27] Shapley L S (1953). A value for n-person games. Contributions to the Theory of Games, 2(28): 307–317

[28] Su W, Huang A Q (2014). A game theoretic framework for a next-generation retail electricity market with high penetration of distributed residential electricity suppliers. Applied Energy, 119: 341–350

[29] Tang R, Wang S, Li H (2019). Game theory based interactive demand side management responding to dynamic pricing in price-based demand response of smart grids. Applied Energy, 250: 118–130

[30] Tol R S J (2005). The marginal damage costs of carbon dioxide emissions: An assessment of the uncertainties. Energy Policy, 33(16): 2064–2074

[31] Watkiss P, Downing T, Handley C, Butterfield R (2005). The impacts and costs of climate change. Final Report. European Commission DG Environment

[32] Wei F, Jing Z X, Wu P Z, Wu Q H (2017). A Stackelberg game approach for multiple energies trading in integrated energy systems. Applied Energy, 200: 315–329

[33] Zhao H Y, Yang R, Wang C H, Pabasara W M, Wijeratne U, Liu C Y, Xue X L, Abdeen N (2019). Effects of design parameters on rooftop photovoltaic economics in the urban environment: A case study in Melbourne, Australia. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 6(3): 352–367

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Higher Education Press