Introduction
Broiler breeds are intensively selected for higher growth rate, which results in higher body mass, excessive fat deposition, lameness, and higher mortality rate (
Buyse et al., 1987;
Govaerts et al., 2000;
Baghbanzadeh and Decuypere, 2008). Feed restriction (FR) in the early stage was beneficial for improving feed efficiency and decreasing feeding cost (
Lippens et al., 2000;
Mahmood et al., 2007). Animals can adjust physiological metabolism and acclimatize themselves to the deleterious stimulus, and therefore, the early adjustment would keep until the late stage of life. Metabolic programming is defined as a physiological process whereby the early adaptation to a nutritional stress, which permanently changes in physiology and the metabolism of organism, continues to be expressed even in the absence of the stress (
Zhan et al., 2007). Although early FR reduces growth performance, the compensatory growth in the refeeding period will be attained to accelerate organism growth to reach the weight of animals (
Tůmová et al., 2002;
Marek et al., 2006).
Growth of both birds and mammals depends on direct effects of T
4 and its active form T
3 and also on the interactions between thyroid hormones and GH-IGF-I-growth axis (
Scanes, 2009). Plasma T
3 is associated with protein synthesis and energy production and can increase the metabolism rate and the need of oxygen and heat production of broilers. Thyroid hormones play a crucial role in thermoregulation in avian species, and plasma T
3 levels are positively correlated with heat production. Previous research in poultry showed that FR may modify the plasma levels of T
3, T
4 and GH to modulate the energy metabolism and growth (
Mcmurtry et al., 1998;
Zhan et al., 2007).
Early-age feed or nutrient restriction (qualitative or quantitative) or light restriction to slow down the growth rate seems practically a viable method (
Baghbanzadeh and Decuypere, 2008). Diversification in response to FR is dependent on duration, intensity and timing of nutrient reduction (
Yu and Robinson, 1992;
Yang et al., 2009). In general, prolonged severe nutritional deficit at an early age results in permanent stunting of animals. With an increase in duration of undernutrition, chronic malnutrition represents a permanent stress for organs, and complete growth correction becomes more unlikely. The differences between restricted and AL feed chickens have been well documented; however, more effective FR programs have not been studied. We took orthogonal experiment to study the effects of FR programs on production performance, feed conversion ratio and meat quality to find the superior FR program for broiler chickens, to measure hormone levels and explore the FR mechanism of growth and metabolism of birds.
Materials and methods
Experimental animals and experiment design
The feeding experiment was taken at the Specimen Garden in Agricultural University of Hebei, China, from May 24th to July 5th, 2009. A total of 250 1-day-old Ross chicks, equally divided between males and females, were obtained from a local commercial hatchery and randomly assigned to 50 floorless portable metal pens. The 50 experiment units were divided into one feed ad libitum (AL) group and nine feed restriction (FR) experimental groups with 5 pens each group and 5 chickens in each pen. The body weight (BW) differences of chickens between groups had no statistical significance. Our experiment referred to three factors with three levels each, including age (5-, 7- and 10-day-old chickens), duration (for 7, 10 and 14 days) and intensity (70%, 80%, and 90%) (Table 1). The nine FR experimental groups were designed as L9(34) orthogonal experiment. The intensity of FR was the ratio of daily ration to the intake of the AL group chickens the day before. For example, 5-day-old T5D7I90 took 90 percent of the feed intake of AL at age of 4 days. Commercial Broiler Production Technology Regulation (GB/T 19664-2005) was used as a reference for all management conditions. Birds were fed with a corn-soybean meal basal diet formulated containing 22% crude protein, 13.4 MJ·kg-1 energy metabolism and all recommended vitamins and minerals. Feed was available freely for the AL broilers while FR broilers fed ad libitum merely before and after the feed restriction. Water was available freely for all the birds during the whole feeding period. After FR, all the birds were fed ad libitum up to 42 days old.
Measurements
Feed intake of all FR was recorded before FR, and that of AL was recorded daily from the age of 4 days to 22 days as a daily-ration criterion for the FR broilers. After feed restriction, feed intake of every group was recorded weekly. BW of broilers in each replicate was measured at the age of 24, 36 and 42 days. One 24-day-old and one 42-day-old broiler in each replicate were slaughtered by cutting the jugular veins and carotid arteries, while carcass weight and whole eviscerated weight were measured. Abdominal fat, leg muscle and breast muscle were excised and weighted, respectively. Blood samples were taken. T3, T4 and GH concentrations in plasma of group of T5D7I90, T5D14I70 and AL were measured with radioimmunoassay by Beijing North Institute of Biological Technology. The color of leg and breast muscle was measured within 24 h after slaughter with WSC-s colorimeter (Shanghai Precision & Scientific Instrument Co., LTD).
Carcass weight was the mass of a carcass without blood, feather, head and neck, and feet and paw. Whole eviscerated weight was the mass of a carcass excluding viscera (except kidney and lung) and gland (including thymus and bursa of Fabricius). RA, RL, RB and RM represent the ratio of weight of abdominal fat, leg muscle, breast muscle, and leg and breast muscle together to whole eviscerated weight, respectively. RC and RW represent the ratio of carcass weigh and whole eviscerated weight to BW, respectively.
Statistical analysis
One-way ANOVA was carried out by SPSS 16.0 to analyze the effects of FR on production performance of broilers. Difference between groups was analyzed by least significant difference (LSD). Data was presented as mean±SE. All statements of significance were based on testing at P<0.05.
Results
Production performance
BW, carcass weight and whole eviscerated weight are shown in Table 2. The results revealed that BW, carcass weight and whole eviscerated weight of T5D7I90 were all significantly the highest on day 24 and day 42, followed by those of AL, T10D7I80 and T7D10I90, while those of T5D14I70 were significantly the lowest. However, at the day of 36, BW of AL was the highest with that of T5D7I90 significantly higher than that of T5D14I70 (the lowest) and T7D14I80. Moreover, the whole eviscerated weight of T5D7I90 was significantly higher than that of T5D14I70, T7D7I70, T7D14I80, T10D7I80 and T10D10I70, while T5D14I70 had significantly lower whole eviscerated weight than that of any other group at the day of 24 (Table 2)
Table 3 shows the ratio of carcass and whole eviscerated. AL broilers had a higher ratio of carcass weight to body weight (RC) compared with FR broilers except T10D7I80 (the highest at 24th day) and T10D10I70 (the highest at 42nd day), and T5D14I70 and T7D7I70 were almost the lowest all along. RW of T5D14I70 was the lowest at the 24th and 42nd days. RW increased with days, while RC changed insignificantly from 24 day-old to 42 day-old, which showed that broilers presented their capability of meat production at age of later days. The whole eviscerated was the carcass excluding viscera (except kidney and lung) and gland including thymus and bursa of Fabricius. AL broilers had higher RW than all the FR broilers at the market age, which indicated that FR increased in the byproduct production of broilers. All the differences were not significant statistically.
RTable 3 shows the ratio of carcass and whole eviscerated. AL broilers had a higher ratio of carcass weight to body weight (RC) compared with FR broilers except T10D7I80 (the highest at 24th days) and T10D10I70 (the highest at 42nd day), and T5D14I70 and T7D7I70 were almost the lowest all along. RW of T5D14I70 was the lowest at the 24th day and 42nd day. RW increased with days, while RC changed insignificantly from 24 day-old to 42 day-old, which showed that broilers presented their capability of meat production at age of later days. The whole eviscerated was the carcass excluding viscera (except kidney and lung) and gland including thymus and bursa of Fabricius. AL broilers had higher RW than all the FR broilers at the market age, which indicated that FR increased in the byproduct production of broilers. All the differences were not significant statistically..
Meat production and meat color
The weights of leg muscle, breast muscle and abdominal fat are shown in Table 4. The leg muscle and breast muscle of T5D7I90 were the highest except the leg muscle at the 24th day, with little significant difference from that of AL broilers except leg muscle at the 42nd day. The weights of leg and breast muscle of T5D14I70 were the lowest and were significantly lower than that of AL at the 24th and 42nd days. The weight of abdominal fat of T5D14I70 was lower at the 24th day but higher at the 42nd day, and that of T5D7I90 was higher at the 24th and 42nd days than that of AL, without significant differences between groups.
Color values of leg muscle and breast muscle at the 42nd day are shown in Table 5. The leg muscle color of T10D10I70 was missed, while the other groups were all measured carefully. Muscle color had no significant difference between groups. L* and b* of leg muscle in FR were all lower than those of AL. T5D14I70 had the lowest a* value of leg muscle and FR except T5D7I90 and T10D14I90 all had lower a* values of leg muscle than AL. a* values of breast muscle in FR except T10D14I90 were all lower than in AL. T5D14I70 had the highest L* and b* values of breast muscle, while T5D7I90 had the lowest. Simultaneously, we found leg muscle had lower L* and b* values and higher a* value than breast muscle.
Feed conversion
Feed consumption and conversion are shown in Table 6. Daily feed intake (DFI) of FR during 1–23 days was all lower than that of AL, which showed that the feed intake of chickens was indeed restricted. The average daily gain (ADG) of FR during 1–23 days except T5D7I90 was all lower than that of AL, with T5D14I70 being the lowest. DFI of FR except group T5D14I70 and T7D7I70 were all higher, and ADG of FR groups except group T10D10I70 was all some lower, than the AL group during 24–35 days. DFI of FR groups was all lower, and ADG of FR groups (except group T5D10I80) were all higher than the AL group; and group T5D7I90 had the highest ADG during 36–42 days. It showed that the compensatory growth was mostly exhibited at later days of broilers. Feed conversion ratio (FCR) of FR was all lower than that of AL. Perhaps it was a random error too big that we did not find the statistical difference between groups about DFI and ADG.
Hormone level
T3, T4 and GH levels of T5D7I90, T5D14I70 and AL are shown in Table 7. Differences of T3, T4 and GH levels, as well as ratio of T4/T3 among the three groups, were not significant. However, T3 and GH of the two FR groups were both lower, with T4/T3 higher, than those of AL at 24th and 42nd days. T4 of the two FR groups were higher than that of AL at the 24th day. T3, T4 and T4/T3 all decreased, but GH increased at the 42nd day compared with that at the 24th day.
Discussion
The timing, duration and intensity of early feed restriction (FR) were studied with orthogonal experiment, a partial experiment. We found early FR to 90% from day 5 to day 11 had the highest BW, carcass weight, whole eviscerated weight, leg and breast muscle, while that early FR to 70% from day 5 to day 18 had the lowest, which was in line with previous findings. Camacho et al. (
2004) reported that quantitative FR at the 7th day had the optimized effects. Govaerts et al. (
2000) reported FR of chicks to 80% or 90% from day 4 to day 7 or day 4 to day 11 had no effects on BW of age of 42 days; however, the average BW of FR groups was higher than that of AL broilers. Tůmová et al. (
2002) found broilers feed-restricted from day 7 to day 11 by 6 g·d
-1 per chick or from day 7 to day 14 by 8 g·d
-1 per chick had higher BW at 56 days. Yang et al. (
2009) reported Ross chicks received protein or energy reduced feed during 8–14 days had higher BW at 42 days and higher feed conversion ratio during the feeding period. The present results explained those previous conflicted results that early FR for short time and low intensity induced a compensatory growth at later feeding period, but early FR for long time and high intensity stunted the growth and development of birds, and the dwarfing effect became progressively worse as the duration of severe FR increased. Young animals severely feed-restricted or affected by severe diseases often failed to express compensatory growth (
Hornick et al., 2000). Yu et al. (
1992) suggested that animals with stunted bone growth did not recover as well as animals which suffered from wasting of soft tissues. Dressing percentage of FR broilers decreased without statistical significance in the paper of Mahmood et al. (
2007), which was in agreement with the present result that FR broilers had lower RC and RW, which, however, did not reach the significant level. The more severe the FR, the lower the RC and RW are, just as T
5D
14I
70. FR increased the byproducts of broilers.
Zhan et al. (
2007) reported that FR increased fat deposition. Onbaşlar et al. (
2009) did not find that early FR had any effects on fat deposition. Mark et al. (2003) reported that FR of broiler breeds decreased the abdominal fat deposition and T
3 level in plasma. Birds have the ability to store large quantities of excess energy in liver and abdominal fat tissue. Variations in nutrient intake and status were communicated to the liver and other internal organs by alterations in levels of T
3 in the plasma, which responded acutely to dietary changes and then changed its fat metabolism (Mark et al., 2003). During fasting, circulating T
3 was depressed while T
4 increased (
Marek et al., 2006;
Sun et al., 2006;
Andrea et al., 2009), which was in line with the present result that there was a lower concentration of T
3 in FR broilers and a higher concentration T
4 in FR broilers at the 24th day, suggesting a lower metabolic rate during feed restriction. The energy and nutrients to support compensatory growth may come from the reduction of maintenance requirements during refeeding after a period of FR. In our study, all the nine FR programs increased fat deposition at the 42nd day, and T
5D
7I
90 increased the lean meat ratio of breast and leg muscle by 1.8%, while T
5D
14I
70 decreased the lean meat ratio of breast and leg muscle weight by 1.5%.
T
4 was deiodinated to T
3 that was the main metabolic stimulating hormone in the periphery (
Andrea et al., 2009). T
4/T
3 ratio was higher in FR broilers than that of AL broilers at the 24th day. It indicated that animals could cope with FR challenge by decreasing the transformation of T
4 to T
3 or increasing catabolism of T
3, and by decreasing the basal metabolism and thus allowing the organism to spare energy to deposit protein and fat. At the same time, FR broilers could keep the metabolism till the market age. T
5D
7I
90 had higher fat and meat deposition ratio compared with AL, while T
5D
14I
70 had higher fat deposition ratio and lower meat deposition ratio, despite its higher T
4/T
3 than that of AL, which shows that T
4 and T
3 may mainly modulate the fat metabolism and have no relation with the meat deposition of broilers.
The normal growth rate of broiler depends in part on concentration of circulating T
3 being maintained at a well-controlled physiological “set-point”, which is achieved through an inhibitory feedback loop between T
3 and GH. These may explain the present result that GH at the 42nd day was higher than that at the 24th day because T
3 of broilers at the 42nd day was all lower than that at the 24th day. One of the responses to GH administration is the suppression of voluntary feed intake, attributed to improvement in the efficiency of nutrient utilization and reduced need for ingested substrates (
Wang et al., 2000). GH is a major anabolic agent with effects on protein, fat and carbohydrate metabolism and has the ability of anti-lipogenic effect in chickens (
Scanes, 2009). These just explained the present result that GH increased at the 42nd day compared with that at the 24th day, which resulted in a decrease in DFI during 36–42 days compared with that during 24–35 days. These also turned out that GH of both T
5D
7I
90 and T
5D
14I
70 was lower than that of AL at the 42nd day, and resulted that DFI of FR broilers during 36–42 days was all higher than that of AL, and RA of FR broilers at the 42nd day was higher than that of AL broilers.
Bruggeman et al. (
1997) determined FR produced higher plasma concentration of GH, while in our study, GH of FR broilers decreased at the 24th and 42nd days compared with AL broilers. The unconformity may be due to the measurement of GH of broilers after FR, while Bruggeman et al. (
1997) measured GH of broilers during FR, or perhaps it was the variations of FR. In the report of Govaerts et al. (
2000), restricted broilers with the compensatory growth had lower GH; however, the broilers without the compensatory growth had higher GH. High circulating levels of GH allowed enhanced fat mobilization. In the present study, FR program T
5D
14I
70 did not have compensatory growth, while the program T
5D
7I
90 had compensatory growth. Both the two programs had lower GH and higher RA, which may show that GH has no relation with the growth rate but with the fat metabolism.
FR broilers had a higher growth capability of leg muscle and lower growth capability of breast muscle. Vasilatos et al. (
2000) reported that GH injection decreased the deposition of breast muscle and the leg muscle of broilers, which may be differences of sensitivity of muscle fiber types. Color is one of the main characteristics of meat quality, which is determined by myoglobin content that depends on the myofibril types in muscle. There are four myofibril types in muscle. Breast muscle consists mainly of Type IIB with lower myoglobin, and leg muscle consists mainly of Type I and Type IIA with higher myoglobin, which caused that the leg muscle had higher
a* and lower
L* values than the breast muscle. Yue et al. (2007) reported that FR broilers had higher myofibril of Type I and Type IIA in lateral gastrocnemius muscle at the 14th day, but lower I type myofibril at the 63rd day. Myofibril type transform followed the sequence of I to IIA to IIB with age. In the present experiment, we found that FR decreased the lightness (
L*) and yellowness (
b*) values of the leg muscle, indicating that the leg muscle in FR broilers had more myofibril of Type I and Type IIA, and FR delayed the myofibril type conversion and improved the leg muscle quality. It has not been completely elucidated the pathway mediating the effect of nutritional deficiency on myofibril type transformation, yet the reduced serum concentration of thyroid hormones was suggested to be involved in the mechanism. Hypothyroidism leads to preferential expression of slower fiber types, while hyperthyroidism enhances the content of fast fibers in rats (
Vadaszova et al., 2004). We detected that T
3 and T
4 both decreased in FR at the 24th and 42nd day.
Conclusion
In summary, early (5 days) feed restriction for low intensity (90%) and short duration (for 7 days) caused that FR broilers not only had compensatory growth at the 24th day with higher meat production performance at the 42nd day, but also exceeded the growth of AL broilers. And early (5 days) feed restriction for high intensity (70%) and long duration (for 14 days) caused that broilers were stunned, with breast muscle instead of leg muscle restricted in growth. While the other FR programs also showed the ability of compensatory growth partially inhibited. The feed restriction could improve the leg muscle color and increase the production of broiler byproducts. Lower T3 and GH concentration and higher T4/T3 ratio in plasma had feed conversion rate and fat deposition increase in FR broilers, which has no relation with the meat production and growth rate.
Higher Education Press and Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg