Assessment of the reproducibility of bacterial membrane vesicle isolation and characterization

Abstract

Aim: This study aimed to evaluate the reproducibility of the isolation and characterization of feces-derived bacterial membrane vesicles.

Methods: Human fecal samples (n = 12) stored at -80 °C were thawed, sampled, and then refrozen. From these samples, bacterial membrane vesicles were isolated through ultrafiltration, ultracentrifugation and size exclusion chromatography. Vesicle-associated DNA was characterized by marker [16 ribosomal DNA (rDNA)] sequencing to determine composition. The same fecal samples were thawed again after > 6 months of storage at -80 °C to repeat this procedure. Compositions and other vesicle characteristics were compared to investigate effects of storage and freeze/thawing on sample stability. In addition, for four of the fecal aliquots, the bacteria were subjected to marker gene sequencing alongside their derived membrane vesicles.

Results: No significant differences were observed in the pre- and post freeze/thawing composition of feces-derived bacterial membrane vesicles [permutational multivariate analysis of variance (PERMANOVA) P = 0.356] or bacteria (PERMANOVA P = 0.721) as determined by 16S rDNA sequencing. Additionally, no significant differences were observed in vesicle size, concentration, and associated protein or DNA content. These results indicate that, long-term storage of feces at -80 °C and an additional freeze/thawing cycle does not induce compositional or qualitative changes to vesicle repertoires.

Conclusion: These reproducibility findings hold great relevance for research on (gut)bacteria derived membrane vesicles. Our results indicate that fecal samples can be stably preserved at -80 °C for bacterial and vesicle isolations as their characteristics remain stable over time.

Keywords

Bacterial membrane vesicles / bacteria / vesicles / microbiome / microbiota / 16S rDNA sequencing / reproducibility

References

[1] Jovel J,Kao D,Wine E.The human gut microbiome in health and disease. Metagenomics. Elsevier; 2018. pp. 197-213.

[2] Heintz-Buschart A.Human gut microbiome: function matters.Trends Microbiol2018;26:563-74

[3] Amabebe E,Agbalalah T.Microbial dysbiosis-induced obesity: role of gut microbiota in homoeostasis of energy metabolism.Br J Nutr2020;123:1127-37

[4] Stadlbauer V,Komarova I.Dysbiosis, gut barrier dysfunction and inflammation in dementia: a pilot study.BMC Geriatr2020;20:248 PMCID:PMC7372911

[5] Rogers GB,Young RL,Licinio J.From gut dysbiosis to altered brain function and mental illness: mechanisms and pathways.Mol Psychiatry2016;21:738-48 PMCID:PMC4879184

[6] Tamboli CP,Desreumaux P.Dysbiosis in inflammatory bowel disease.Gut2004;53:1-4 PMCID:PMC1774115

[7] John GK.The gut microbiome and obesity.Curr Oncol Rep2016;18:45

[8] Verbunt J.Probiotic membrane vesicles: emerging tools for disease treatment.Microbiome Res Rep2025;4:25 PMCID:PMC12367458

[9] Bielka W,Pawlik A.The role of the gut microbiota in the pathogenesis of diabetes.Int J Mol Sci2022;23:480 PMCID:PMC8745411

[10] Toyofuku M,Kaparakis-Liaskos M.Composition and functions of bacterial membrane vesicles.Nat Rev Microbiol2023;21:415-30

[11] Doré E.Bacterial extracellular vesicles and their interplay with the immune system.Pharmacol Ther2023;247:108443

[12] Bitto NJ,Pidot S.Bacterial membrane vesicles transport their DNA cargo into host cells.Sci Rep2017;7:7072 PMCID:PMC5539193

[13] Gao Q,Nurxat N.Dynamic profiling of lipoteichoic acid (LTA) and/or lipopolysaccharide (LPS) positive extracellular vesicles in plasma as diagnostic and prognostic biomarkers for bacterial infection.Adv Sci2025;Epub ahead of print:

[14] Díaz-Garrido N,Baldomà L.Microbiota-derived extracellular vesicles in interkingdom communication in the gut.J Extracell Vesicles2021;10:e12161 PMCID:PMC8568775

[15] Kameli N,Lpez-Iglesias C,Stassen FRM.Characterization of feces-derived bacterial membrane vesicles and the impact of their origin on the inflammatory response.Front Cell Infect Microbiol2021;11:667987 PMCID:PMC8139245

[16] Théry C,Aikawa E.Minimal information for studies of extracellular vesicles 2018 (MISEV2018): a position statement of the International Society for Extracellular Vesicles and update of the MISEV2014 guidelines.J Extracell Vesicles2018;7:1535750 PMCID:PMC6322352

[17] Barriga MF, Randolph JWJ, Glassman SI. Not all is lost: resilience of microbiome samples to freezer failures and long-term storage.mSphere2025;10:e0060324 PMCID:PMC11774026

[18] Rius-sansalvador B,Khannous-lleiffe O.Stability of oral and fecal microbiome at room temperature: impact on diversity.Front Microbiomes2025;4:1334775

[19] Caporaso JG,Walters WA.Ultra-high-throughput microbial community analysis on the Illumina HiSeq and MiSeq platforms.ISME J2012;6:1621-4 PMCID:PMC3400413

[20] Peterson GL.A simplification of the protein assay method of Lowry et al. which is more generally applicable.Anal Biochem1977;83:346-56

[21] Barnett D,Penders J.microViz: an R package for microbiome data visualization and statistics.JOSS2021;6:3201

[22] Tap J,Pavan S.Effects of the long-term storage of human fecal microbiota samples collected in RNAlater.Sci Rep2019;9:601 PMCID:PMC6345939

[23] Kim JH,Im YJ.Long-term taxonomic and functional stability of the gut microbiome from human fecal samples.Sci Rep2023;13:114 PMCID:PMC9810722

[24] Cabrera P, Bokulich NA, Zimmermann P. Evaluating stool microbiome integrity after domestic freezer storage using whole-metagenome sequencing, genome assembly, and antimicrobial resistance gene analysis.Microbiol Spectr2025;13:e0227824 PMCID:PMC11878046

[25] Olson J,Durkee K.DNA stabilization is critical for maximizing performance of fecal DNA-based colorectal cancer tests.Diagn Mol Pathol2005;14:183-91

[26] Devan SS,Alshehade SA,Mamat N.Comparison of the techniques for isolating immunoassay-suitable proteins from heterogeneous fecal samples.Anal Biochem2025;698:115748

[27] Armand M.Lipases and lipolysis in the human digestive tract: where do we stand?.Curr Opin Clin Nutr Metab Care2007;10:156-64

[28] Bitto NJ,Johnston EL.Staphylococcus aureus membrane vesicles contain immunostimulatory DNA, RNA and peptidoglycan that activate innate immune receptors and induce autophagy.J Extracell Vesicles2021;10:e12080 PMCID:PMC8015888

[29] Kaparakis M,Carneiro L.Bacterial membrane vesicles deliver peptidoglycan to NOD1 in epithelial cells.Cell Microbiol2010;12:372-85

[30] Li J,Han Y.Unveiling a novel mechanism of enhanced secretion, cargo loading, and accelerated dynamics of bacterial extracellular vesicles following antibiotic exposure.J Extracell Vesicles2025;14:e70131 PMCID:PMC12287860

[31] Domingues S.Membrane vesicles and horizontal gene transfer in prokaryotes.Curr Opin Microbiol2017;38:16-21

[32] Zhou Z,Tu Y.Exploring naturally tailored bacterial outer membrane vesicles for selective bacteriostatic implant coatings.Adv Sci2024;11:e2405764 PMCID:PMC11497020

[33] Sandanusova M,Pechackova E.Growth phase matters: boosting immunity via Lacticasebacillus-derived membrane vesicles and their interactions with TLR2 pathways.J Extracell Biol2024;3:e169 PMCID:PMC11341917

[34] Burt M,Mais CN.Lipid A in outer membrane vesicles shields bacteria from polymyxins.J Extracell Vesicles2024;13:e12447 PMCID:PMC11103557

[35] Avila-Calderón ED,Aguilera-Arreola MG.Outer membrane vesicles of gram-negative bacteria: an outlook on biogenesis.Front Microbiol2021;12:557902 PMCID:PMC7969528