Comparison of extracellular vesicle isolation methods reveals method-dependent protein and miRNA profiles in saliva

Abstract

Aim: Salivary extracellular vesicles (EVs) are promising non-invasive biomarkers for disease diagnosis and monitoring, reflecting both systemic and local physiological states. However, the diversity of EV isolation protocols and the possibility that each method enriches distinct EV subpopulations remain major barriers to reproducibility and data comparability. This study aimed to evaluate the impact of different EV isolation methods on the yield, purity, and molecular composition of salivary EVs from healthy volunteers, thereby clarifying how these methods affect the potential use of salivary EVs as a non-invasive biomarker source for disease diagnosis and monitoring.

Methods: We conducted a comprehensive comparison of three EV isolation methods - ultracentrifugation (UC), polyethylene glycol (PEG)-based co-precipitation (Q), and immunoaffinity capture (M) - to evaluate their impact on EV yield, purity, and molecular composition. Salivary EVs from healthy volunteers were analyzed using proteomic and small RNA sequencing approaches.

Results: Principal component analysis revealed clear isolation method-dependent clustering, where M-derived EVs displayed the most distinct profile. The UC and Q methods yielded broader proteomic repertoires with higher total protein content, while M-isolated EVs exhibited greater purity and enrichment of trafficking- and lysosome-associated proteins. Among the 731 microRNAs (miRNAs) analyzed, 28 were consistently altered across methods and 65 uniquely enriched in M isolates. Reverse transcription quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR) confirmed the key directional trends. These 93 method-dependent miRNAs were predicted to target genes associated with synaptic structure and neurodegenerative pathways.

Conclusion: These findings show that EV isolation methodology profoundly influences the cargo composition of salivary EVs and suggest that M can isolate specific EV populations that may better meet diagnostic requirements.

Keywords

Salivary extracellular vesicles / EV isolation methods / miRNA profiling / proteomics / biomarker discovery

References

[1] van Niel G, D’Angelo G, Raposo G. Shedding light on the cell biology of extracellular vesicles.Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol2018;19:213-28

[2] van Niel G, Carter DRF, Clayton A, Lambert DW, Raposo G, Vader P. Challenges and directions in studying cell-cell communication by extracellular vesicles.Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol2022;23:369-82

[3] Buzas EI.The roles of extracellular vesicles in the immune system.Nat Rev Immunol2023;23:236-50 PMCID:PMC9361922

[4] Wang X,Bian C.M2 microglia-derived exosomes promote vascular remodeling in diabetic retinopathy.J Nanobiotechnology2024;22:56 PMCID:PMC10854107

[5] Zhang Y,Liu Y.Exosomes derived from human umbilical cord blood mesenchymal stem cells stimulate regenerative wound healing via transforming growth factor-β receptor inhibition.Stem Cell Res Ther2021;12:434 PMCID:PMC8336384

[6] Ye Z,Li G,Lei J.Tissue-derived extracellular vesicles in cancer progression: mechanisms, roles, and potential applications.Cancer Metastasis Rev2024;43:575-95

[7] Arvanitaki ES,Gkirtzimanaki K.Microglia-derived extracellular vesicles trigger age-related neurodegeneration upon DNA damage.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A2024;121:e2317402121 PMCID:PMC11047102

[8] Park C,Schneider R,Pitt D.CNS cell-derived exosome signatures as blood-based biomarkers of neurodegenerative diseases.Front Neurosci2024;18:1426700 PMCID:PMC11222337

[9] Kumar A,Deep G.Emergence of extracellular vesicles as “liquid biopsy” for neurological disorders: boom or bust.Pharmacol Rev2024;76:199-227 PMCID:PMC10877757

[10] Karimi N,Dias T,Lässer C.Tetraspanins distinguish separate extracellular vesicle subpopulations in human serum and plasma - contributions of platelet extracellular vesicles in plasma samples.J Extracell Vesicles2022;11:e12213 PMCID:PMC9077141

[11] Gudehithlu KP,Vernik J.In diabetic kidney disease urinary exosomes better represent kidney specific protein alterations than whole urine.Am J Nephrol2015;42:418-24

[12] Muraoka S,Yanamandra K,Gygi SP.Proteomic profiling of extracellular vesicles derived from cerebrospinal fluid of Alzheimer’s disease patients: a pilot study.Cells2020;9:1959 PMCID:PMC7565882

[13] Ogawa Y,Harazono A.Proteomic analysis of two types of exosomes in human whole saliva.Biol Pharm Bull2011;34:13-23

[14] Khijmatgar S,Rübsamen N.Salivary biomarkers for early detection of oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC) and head/neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC): a systematic review and network meta-analysis.Jpn Dent Sci Rev2024;60:32-9 PMCID:PMC10776379

[15] Jung JY,Kim HA.Salivary biomarkers in patients with Sjögren’s syndrome-a systematic review.Int J Mol Sci2021;22:12903 PMCID:PMC8657642

[16] Khijmatgar S,Rübsamen N.Salivary biomarkers for early detection of oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC) and head/neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC): a systematic review and network meta-analysis.Jpn Dent Sci Rev2024;60:32-9 PMCID:PMC10776379

[17] Ryu IS,Ro JY.The microRNA-485-3p concentration in salivary exosome-enriched extracellular vesicles is related to amyloid β deposition in the brain of patients with Alzheimer’s disease.Clin Biochem2023;118:110603

[18] De Bartolo MI,Mancinelli R.A systematic review of salivary biomarkers in Parkinson’s disease.Neural Regen Res2024;19:2613-25 PMCID:PMC11168506

[19] Rastogi S,Rai S.Fluorescence-tagged salivary small extracellular vesicles as a nanotool in early diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease.BMC Med2023;21:335 PMCID:PMC10478478

[20] Li K,Zhou Y.Salivary extracellular microRNAs for early detection and prognostication of esophageal cancer: a clinical study.Gastroenterology2023;165:932-45.e9

[21] Huang Z,Huang Y.Saliva - a new opportunity for fluid biopsy.Clin Chem Lab Med2023;61:4-32

[22] Sidhom K,Saleem A.A review of exosomal isolation methods: is size exclusion chromatography the best option?.Int J Mol Sci2020;21:6466 PMCID:PMC7556044

[23] Bobrie A,Krumeich S,Théry C.Diverse subpopulations of vesicles secreted by different intracellular mechanisms are present in exosome preparations obtained by differential ultracentrifugation.J Extracell Vesicles2012;1:18397 PMCID:PMC3760636

[24] García-Romero N,Rackov G.Polyethylene glycol improves current methods for circulating extracellular vesicle-derived DNA isolation.J Transl Med2019;17:75 PMCID:PMC6419425

[25] Lee H,Lee J,Rhee WJ.Isolation and characterization of urinary extracellular vesicles from healthy donors and patients with castration-resistant prostate cancer.Int J Mol Sci2022;23:7134 PMCID:PMC9266865

[26] Li M,Chen J.Deep dive on the proteome of salivary extracellular vesicles: comparison between ultracentrifugation and polymer-based precipitation isolation.Anal Bioanal Chem2021;413:365-75

[27] Mussack V,Pfaffl MW.Comparing small urinary extracellular vesicle purification methods with a view to RNA sequencing-Enabling robust and non-invasive biomarker research.Biomol Detect Quantif2019;17:100089 PMCID:PMC6554496

[28] Feng X,Zhang W.High-throughput capture and in situ protein analysis of extracellular vesicles by chemical probe-based array.Nat Protoc2025;20:1057-81

[29] Maricchiolo E,Osnato M.Plant vs mammal extracellular vesicles: new tools in therapeutic drug delivery.Curr Res Biotechnol2026;11:100352

[30] Gui Y,Zhang L,Hu X.Altered microRNA profiles in cerebrospinal fluid exosome in Parkinson disease and Alzheimer disease.Oncotarget2015;6:37043-53 PMCID:PMC4741914

[31] Hofmann L,Ezić J.Comparison of plasma- and saliva-derived exosomal miRNA profiles reveals diagnostic potential in head and neck cancer.Front Cell Dev Biol2022;10:971596 PMCID:PMC9441766

[32] Wang L.Circulating exosomal miRNA as diagnostic biomarkers of neurodegenerative diseases.Front Mol Neurosci2020;13:53 PMCID:PMC7174585

[33] Yáñez-Mó M,Andreu Z.Biological properties of extracellular vesicles and their physiological functions.J Extracell Vesicles2015;4:27066 PMCID:PMC4433489

[34] Kalluri R.The biology, function, and biomedical applications of exosomes.Science2020;367:eaau6977 PMCID:PMC7717626

[35] Serrano-Pertierra E,Rivas M.Characterization of plasma-derived extracellular vesicles isolated by different methods: a comparison study.Bioengineering2019;6:8 PMCID:PMC6466225

[36] Helwa I,Drewry MD.A comparative study of serum exosome isolation using differential ultracentrifugation and three commercial reagents.PLoS One2017;12:e0170628 PMCID:PMC5256994

[37] Llorens-Revull M,Quer J.Comparison of extracellular vesicle isolation methods for miRNA sequencing.Int J Mol Sci2023;24:12183 PMCID:PMC10418926

[38] Barreiro K,Leparc G.Comparison of urinary extracellular vesicle isolation methods for transcriptomic biomarker research in diabetic kidney disease.J Extracell Vesicles2020;10:e12038 PMCID:PMC7789228

[39] Dhondt B,Tulkens J.Unravelling the proteomic landscape of extracellular vesicles in prostate cancer by density-based fractionation of urine.J Extracell Vesicles2020;9:1736935 PMCID:PMC7144211

[40] Jackson KK,Marcus RK.Comparison of the capillary-channeled polymer (C-CP) fiber spin-down tip approach to traditional methods for the isolation of extracellular vesicles from human urine.Anal Bioanal Chem2022;414:3813-25

[41] Sjoqvist S,Hirozane Y.Analysis of cerebrospinal fluid extracellular vesicles by proximity extension assay: a comparative study of four isolation kits.Int J Mol Sci2020;21:9425 PMCID:PMC7763352

[42] Krušić Alić V,Biberić M.Extracellular vesicles from human cerebrospinal fluid are effectively separated by sepharose CL-6B-comparison of four gravity-flow size exclusion chromatography methods.Biomedicines2022;10:785 PMCID:PMC9032713

[43] Reseco L,Atienza M,Falcon-Perez JM.Characterization of extracellular vesicles from human saliva: effects of age and isolation techniques.Cells2024;13:95 PMCID:PMC10778510

[44] Itzel CG,Velia RA.Salivary extracellular vesicles separation: analysis of ultracentrifugation-based protocols.Oral Dis2025;31:879-89 PMCID:PMC12021316

[45] Boulestreau J,Ouedraogo A.Salivary extracellular vesicles isolation methods impact the robustness of downstream biomarkers detection.Sci Rep2024;14:31233 PMCID:PMC11682200

[46] Welsh JA, Goberdhan DCI, O’Driscoll L, et al.; MISEV Consortium. Minimal information for studies of extracellular vesicles (MISEV2023): from basic to advanced approaches. J Extracell Vesicles. 2024;13:e12404. PMCID:PMC10850029

[47] Yuana Y,Kuil ME.Cryo-electron microscopy of extracellular vesicles in fresh plasma.J Extracell Vesicles2013;2:21494 PMCID:PMC3895263

[48] Linares R,Gounou C,Brisson AR.High-speed centrifugation induces aggregation of extracellular vesicles.J Extracell Vesicles2015;4:29509 PMCID:PMC4689953

[49] Emelyanov A,Kamyshinsky R.Cryo-electron microscopy of extracellular vesicles from cerebrospinal fluid.PLoS One2020;15:e0227949 PMCID:PMC6991974

[50] Cox J.MaxQuant enables high peptide identification rates, individualized p.p.b.-range mass accuracies and proteome-wide protein quantification.Nat Biotechnol2008;26:1367-72

[51] Cox J,Michalski A,Olsen JV.Andromeda: a peptide search engine integrated into the MaxQuant environment.J Proteome Res2011;10:1794-805

[52] Tyanova S,Sinitcyn P.The Perseus computational platform for comprehensive analysis of (prote)omics data.Nat Methods2016;13:731-40

[53] Love MI,Anders S.Moderated estimation of fold change and dispersion for RNA-seq data with DESeq2.Genome Biol2014;15:550 PMCID:PMC4302049

[54] Edgar R,Lash AE.Gene expression omnibus: NCBI gene expression and hybridization array data repository.Nucleic Acids Res2002;30:207-10 PMCID:PMC99122

[55] Vallejo MC,Elliott EC.A proteomic meta-analysis refinement of plasma extracellular vesicles.Sci Data2023;10:837 PMCID:PMC10684639

[56] Takov K,Davidson SM.Comparison of small extracellular vesicles isolated from plasma by ultracentrifugation or size-exclusion chromatography: yield, purity and functional potential.J Extracell Vesicles2019;8:1560809 PMCID:PMC6327926

[57] Liu C,Palma C.Immunoaffinity-enriched salivary small extracellular vesicles in periodontitis.Extracell Vesicles Circ Nucl Acids2023;4:698-712 PMCID:PMC11648426

[58] Kowal J,Colombo M.Proteomic comparison defines novel markers to characterize heterogeneous populations of extracellular vesicle subtypes.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A2016;113:E968-77 PMCID:PMC4776515

[59] Kawano T,Shinchi H,Nomura T.Differentiation of large extracellular vesicles in oral fluid: Combined protocol of small force centrifugation and sedimentation pattern analysis.J Extracell Biol2024;3:e143 PMCID:PMC11080912

[60] Sandira MI,Yoshida T.Nanoscopic profiling of small extracellular vesicles via high-speed atomic force microscopy (HS-AFM) videography.J Extracell Vesicles2025;14:e270050 PMCID:PMC11943829

[61] O’Brien K,Ughetto S,Breakefield XO.RNA delivery by extracellular vesicles in mammalian cells and its applications.Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol2020;21:585-606 PMCID:PMC7249041

[62] Li F,Sun J.Characterization of human salivary extracellular RNA by next-generation sequencing.Clin Chem2018;64:1085-95 PMCID:PMC7759158

[63] Buschmann D,Hermann S.Evaluation of serum extracellular vesicle isolation methods for profiling miRNAs by next-generation sequencing.J Extracell Vesicles2018;7:1481321 PMCID:PMC5990937

[64] Mustapic M,Werner JK Jr.Plasma extracellular vesicles enriched for neuronal origin: a potential window into brain pathologic processes.Front Neurosci2017;11:278 PMCID:PMC5439289

[65] Coughlan C,Jacot JG.Specific binding of Alzheimer’s Aβ peptides to extracellular vesicles.Int J Mol Sci2024;25:3703 PMCID:PMC11011551

[66] Goetzl EJ,Kapogiannis D.Cargo proteins of plasma astrocyte-derived exosomes in Alzheimer’s disease.FASEB J2016;30:3853-9 PMCID:PMC5067254

[67] Goetzl EJ,Mustapic M.Altered levels of plasma neuron-derived exosomes and their cargo proteins characterize acute and chronic mild traumatic brain injury.FASEB J2019;33:5082-8 PMCID:PMC6436652

[68] Kazanopoulos N,Xu Y.Identification of salivary exosome-derived miRNAs as potential biomarkers of bone remodeling during orthodontic tooth movement.Int J Mol Sci2025;26:1228 PMCID:PMC11818790

[69] Malaguarnera M.Emerging role of extracellular vesicles as biomarkers in neurodegenerative diseases and their clinical and therapeutic potential in central nervous system pathologies.Int J Mol Sci2024;25:10068 PMCID:PMC11432603

[70] Stranska R,Wouters J.Comparison of membrane affinity-based method with size-exclusion chromatography for isolation of exosome-like vesicles from human plasma.J Transl Med2018;16:1 PMCID:PMC5761138

[71] Lobb RJ,Wen SW.Optimized exosome isolation protocol for cell culture supernatant and human plasma.J Extracell Vesicles2015;4:27031 PMCID:PMC4507751

[72] Gheinani AH,Baumgartner U.Improved isolation strategies to increase the yield and purity of human urinary exosomes for biomarker discovery.Sci Rep2018;8:3945 PMCID:PMC5834546

[73] Lozano-Ramos I,Oliveira-Tercero A.Size-exclusion chromatography-based enrichment of extracellular vesicles from urine samples.J Extracell Vesicles2015;4:27369 PMCID:PMC4449362

[74] Mladenović D,Peacock B,Zarovni N.Quantitative fluorescent nanoparticle tracking analysis and nano-flow cytometry enable advanced characterization of single extracellular vesicles.J Extracell Biol2025;4:e70031

[75] Fiandaca MS,Mapstone M.Identification of preclinical Alzheimer’s disease by a profile of pathogenic proteins in neurally derived blood exosomes: a case-control study.Alzheimers Dement2015;11:600-7.e1 PMCID:PMC4329112

[76] Gurgone A,Tangari MM.Clinical validation of α-synuclein in salivary extracellular vesicles as a biomarker for Parkinson’s disease: a longitudinal study.Eur J Neurol2026;33:e70508 PMCID:PMC12848592

[77] Cha DJ,Mustapic M.miR-212 and miR-132 are downregulated in neurally derived plasma exosomes of Alzheimer’s patients.Front Neurosci2019;13:1208 PMCID:PMC6902042