A comparative analysis of small extracellular vesicle (sEV) micro-RNA (miRNA) isolation and sequencing procedures in blood plasma samples

Abstract

Aims: Analysis of miRNA (18-23nt) encapsulated in small extracellular vesicles (sEVs) (diameter ~30-200 nm) is critical in understanding the diagnostic and therapeutic value of sEV miRNA. However, various sEV enrichment techniques yield different quantities and qualities of sEV miRNA. Here, we compare the efficacy of three sEV isolation techniques in four combinations for miRNA next-generation sequencing.

Methods: Blood plasma from four Holstein-Friesian dairy cows (Bos taurus) (n = 4) with similar genetic traits and physical characteristics were pooled to isolate sEV. Ultracentrifugation (UC) (100,000 × g, 2 h at 4 °C), size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) and ultrafiltration (UF) were used to design four groups of sEV isolations (UC+SEC, SEC+UC, SEC+UF and UC+SEC+UF). sEV miRNAs were isolated using a combination of TRIzol, Chloroform and miRNeasy mini kit (n = 4/each), later sequenced utilizing Novaseq S1 platform (single-end 100 bp sequencing).

Results: All four sEV methods yielded > 1,700 miRNAs and sEV miRNAs demonstrated a clear separation from control blood plasma circulating miRNA (PCA analysis). MiR-381-3p, miR-23-3p, and miR-18b-3p are among the 25 miRNAs unique to sEV, indicating potential sEV-specific miRNA markers. Further, those 25 miRNAs mostly regulate immune-related functions, indicating the value of sEV miRNA cargo in immunology.

Conclusion: The four sEV miRNA isolation methods employed in this study are valid techniques. The choice of method depends on the research question and study design. If purity is of concern, the UC+SEC method resulted in the best particles/µg protein ratio, which is often used as an indication of sample purity. These results could eventually establish sEV miRNAs as effective diagnostic and therapeutic tools of immunology.

Keywords

Small extracellular vesicles / exosomes / miRNA / size exclusion chromatography / ultracentrifugation / ultrafiltration / next-generation sequencing / immune function

References

[1] Min L,Chen L.Evaluation of circulating small extracellular vesicles derived miRNAs as biomarkers of early colon cancer: a comparison with plasma total miRNAs.J Extracell Vesicles2019;8:1643670 PMCID:PMC6691764

[2] Rajkumar AP,Lange J.Next-generation RNA-sequencing of serum small extracellular vesicles discovers potential diagnostic biomarkers for dementia with lewy bodies.Am J Geriatr Psychiatry2021;29:573-84

[3] Jiang YF,Geng N.Evaluation of circulating small extracellular vesicle-derived miRNAs as diagnostic biomarkers for differentiating between different pathological types of early lung cancer.Sci Rep2022;12:17201 PMCID:PMC9561663

[4] Buschmann D,Hermann S.Evaluation of serum extracellular vesicle isolation methods for profiling miRNAs by next-generation sequencing.J Extracell Vesicles2018;7:1481321 PMCID:PMC5990937

[5] Grunt M,Stevic I,Schwarzenbach H.A novel assay for exosomal and cell-free miRNA isolation and quantification.RNA Biol2020;17:425-40 PMCID:PMC7237161

[6] Jiawei S,Kewei T.Magnetic bead-based adsorption strategy for exosome isolation.Front Bioeng Biotechnol2022;10:942077 PMCID:PMC9424818

[7] Ku A,Yang M.A urinary extracellular vesicle microRNA biomarker discovery pipeline; from automated extracellular vesicle enrichment by acoustic trapping to microRNA sequencing.PLoS One2019;14:e0217507 PMCID:PMC6541292

[8] Chen H,Inaba M,Suehiro J.Characterization of extra-cellular vesicle dielectrophoresis and estimation of its electric properties.Sensors2022;22:3279 PMCID:PMC9101962

[9] Havers M,Lenshof A.Advancement and obstacles in microfluidics-based isolation of extracellular vesicles.Anal Bioanal Chem2023;415:1265-85 PMCID:PMC9928917

[10] Chen J,Zhang T.Review on strategies and technologies for exosome isolation and purification.Front Bioeng Biotechnol2021;9:811971 PMCID:PMC8766409

[11] Northrop-Albrecht EJ,Huang BQ,Lucien F.Assessment of extracellular vesicle isolation methods from human stool supernatant.J Extracell Vesicles2022;11:e12208 PMCID:PMC8980777

[12] Mol EA,Doevendans PA,Vader P.Higher functionality of extracellular vesicles isolated using size-exclusion chromatography compared to ultracentrifugation.Nanomedicine2017;13:2061-5

[13] Gámez-Valero A,Carreras-Planella L,Beyer K.Size-exclusion chromatography-based isolation minimally alters extracellular vesicles' characteristics compared to precipitating agents.Sci Rep2016;6:33641 PMCID:PMC5027519

[14] An M,Zhu J.Comparison of an optimized ultracentrifugation method versus size-exclusion chromatography for isolation of exosomes from human serum.J Proteome Res2018;17:3599-605 PMCID:PMC6292670

[15] Allelein S,Lopes ALH.Potential and challenges of specifically isolating extracellular vesicles from heterogeneous populations.Sci Rep2021;11:11585 PMCID:PMC8172572

[16] Nordin JZ,Vader P.Ultrafiltration with size-exclusion liquid chromatography for high yield isolation of extracellular vesicles preserving intact biophysical and functional properties.Nanomedicine2015;11:879-83

[17] Shu S,Allen CL.Purity and yield of melanoma exosomes are dependent on isolation method.J Extracell Vesicles2020;9:1692401 PMCID:PMC6882439

[18] Gheinani AH,Baumgartner U.Improved isolation strategies to increase the yield and purity of human urinary exosomes for biomarker discovery.Sci Rep2018;8:3945 PMCID:PMC5834546

[19] Oeyen E,Baggerman G.Ultrafiltration and size exclusion chromatography combined with asymmetrical-flow field-flow fractionation for the isolation and characterisation of extracellular vesicles from urine.J Extracell Vesicles2018;7:1490143 PMCID:PMC6032024

[20] Koh YQ,Vaswani K,Mitchell MD.Exosome enrichment by ultracentrifugation and size exclusion chromatography.Front Biosci2018;23:865-74

[21] Turner NP,Kwan Cheung KA.A comparison of blood plasma small extracellular vesicle enrichment strategies for proteomic analysis.Proteomes2022;10:19 PMCID:PMC9229025

[22] Drees EEE,Groenewegen NJ.Extracellular vesicle miRNA predict FDG-PET status in patients with classical Hodgkin Lymphoma.J Extracell Vesicles2021;10:e12121 PMCID:PMC8282992

[23] Sundar IK,Rahman I.Small RNA-sequence analysis of plasma-derived extracellular vesicle miRNAs in smokers and patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease as circulating biomarkers.J Extracell Vesicles2019;8:1684816 PMCID:PMC6848892

[24] Muñoz ER,Wilson BE.Effects of purposeful soccer heading on circulating small extracellular vesicle concentration and cargo.J Sport Health Sci2021;10:122-30 PMCID:PMC7987560

[25] Flemming JP,Haque MW.miRNA- and cytokine-associated extracellular vesicles mediate squamous cell carcinomas.J Extracell Vesicles2020;9:1790159 PMCID:PMC7480578

[26] Meier S,Eketone K. Calf and heifer development and the onset of puberty in dairy cows with divergent genetic merit for fertility. Available from: https://www.nzsap.org/proceedings/calf-and-heifer-development-and-onset-puberty-dairy-cows-divergent-genetic-merit [Last accessed on 28 Feb 2024]

[27] Australian code for the care and use of animals for scientific purposes. Available from: https://www.nhmrc.gov.au/about-us/publications/australian-code-care-and-use-animals-scientific-purposes [Last accessed on 28 Feb 2024]

[28] Percie du Sert N,Alam S.Reporting animal research: Explanation and elaboration for the ARRIVE guidelines 2.0.PLoS Biol2020;18:e3000411 PMCID:PMC7360025

[29] Crookenden MA,Peiris H.Short communication: Proteins from circulating exosomes represent metabolic state in transition dairy cows.J Dairy Sci2016;99:7661-8

[30] Turner N,Peiris H.Proteomic profiling of plasma-derived small extracellular vesicles: a novel tool for understanding the systemic effects of tick burden in cattle.J Anim Sci2022;100:skac015 PMCID:PMC8867580

[31] Fan Y,Arora SK,Kimmins S.miRNet - dissecting miRNA-target interactions and functional associations through network-based visual analysis.Nucleic Acids Res2016;44:W135-41 PMCID:PMC4987881

[32] Agarwal V,Nam JW.Predicting effective microRNA target sites in mammalian mRNAs.Elife2015;4:e05005 PMCID:PMC4532895

[33] Dweep H,Sticht C. miRWalk database for miRNA-target interactions. In: Alvarez ML, Nourbakhsh M, editors. RNA Mapping. New York: Springer; 2014. pp. 289-305.

[34] Herrnreiter CJ,Luck ME,Choudhry MA.Integrated analysis of dysregulated microRNA and mRNA expression in intestinal epithelial cells following ethanol intoxication and burn injury.Sci Rep2021;11:20213 PMCID:PMC8510995

[35] Li D,Gong B.Identification of translational microRNA biomarker candidates for ketoconazole-induced liver injury using next-generation sequencing.Toxicol Sci2021;179:31-43 PMCID:PMC7855383

[36] Thomas PD,Muruganujan A,Albou LP.PANTHER: Making genome-scale phylogenetics accessible to all.Protein Sci2022;31:8-22 PMCID:PMC8740835

[37] Wickham H. ggplot2: Elegant graphics for data analysis. Springer New York, NY; 2016. pp. VIII, 213.

[38] Wang L,Yu M.Serum exosomal miR-377-3p and miR-381-3p as diagnostic biomarkers in colorectal cancer.Future Oncol2022;18:793-805

[39] Shojaei S,Ghanbarian H,Salehi M.Delivery of miR-381-3p mimic by mesenchymal stem cell-derived exosomes inhibits triple negative breast cancer aggressiveness; an in vitro study.Stem Cell Rev Rep2021;17:1027-38

[40] Liu Y,Bao S,Liu W.Bone marrow mesenchymal stem cell-derived exosomal microRNA-381-3p alleviates vascular calcification in chronic kidney disease by targeting NFAT5.Cell Death Dis2022;13:278 PMCID:PMC8964813

[41] Bourgeois BL,Molina PE.Differential expression of adipocyte and myotube extracellular vesicle miRNA cargo in chronic binge alcohol-administered SIV-infected male macaques.Alcohol2023;108:1-9 PMCID:PMC10033305

[42] Otahal A,Kramer K.Functional repertoire of EV-associated miRNA profiles after lipoprotein depletion via ultracentrifugation and size exclusion chromatography from autologous blood products.Sci Rep2021;11:5823 PMCID:PMC7955123

[43] Di K,Gu X.Highly efficient and automated isolation technology for extracellular vesicles microRNA.Front Bioeng Biotechnol2022;10:948757 PMCID:PMC9399425

[44] Veerman RE,Czarnewski P.Molecular evaluation of five different isolation methods for extracellular vesicles reveals different clinical applicability and subcellular origin.J Extracell Vesicles2021;10:e12128 PMCID:PMC8298890

[45] Saludas L,Ruiz-Villalba A.Isolation methods of large and small extracellular vesicles derived from cardiovascular progenitors: A comparative study.Eur J Pharm Biopharm2022;170:187-96

[46] Bai SY,Ren Y.HDAC8-inhibitor PCI-34051-induced exosomes inhibit human bronchial smooth muscle cell proliferation via miR-381-3p mediated TGFB3.Pulm Pharmacol Ther2021;71:102096

[47] Sun L,Zhang G.Identification of circulating exosomal miR-101 and miR-125b panel act as a potential biomarker for hepatocellular carcinoma.Int J Genomics2021;2021:1326463 PMCID:PMC8723878

[48] Zhou C,He X,Xue D.Functional implication of exosomal miR-217 and miR-23b-3p in the progression of prostate cancer.Onco Targets Ther2020;13:11595-606 PMCID:PMC7670263

[49] Qu P,Chi J.Circulating exosomal miR-144-3p from crohn's disease patients inhibits human umbilical vein endothelial cell function by targeting FN1.Dis Markers2022;2022:8219557 PMCID:PMC9184168

[50] Chen P,Yu Q.Serum exosomal microRNA-144-3p: a promising biomarker for monitoring Crohn's disease.Gastroenterol Rep2022;10:goab056 PMCID:PMC8973006

[51] Yan Z,Zheng Y.Cancer-associated fibroblast-derived exosomal miR-18b promotes breast cancer invasion and metastasis by regulating TCEAL7.Cell Death Dis2021;12:1120 PMCID:PMC8636636

[52] Huang Q,Tan T,Bao Y.Human umbilical cord mesenchymal stem cells-derived exosomal microRNA-18b-3p inhibits the occurrence of preeclampsia by targeting LEP.Nanoscale Res Lett2021;16:27 PMCID:PMC7876216

[53] Lu Z,Li X.Exosome-derived miRNAs as potential biomarkers for prostate bone metastasis.Int J Gen Med2022;15:5369-83 PMCID:PMC9167626

[54] O'Brien K,Ughetto S,Breakefield XO.RNA delivery by extracellular vesicles in mammalian cells and its applications.Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol2020;21:585-606 PMCID:PMC7249041

[55] Mittelbrunn M,Villarroya-Beltri C.Unidirectional transfer of microRNA-loaded exosomes from T cells to antigen-presenting cells.Nat Commun2011;2:282 PMCID:PMC3104548

[56] Zhang X,Ma L.Essential roles of exosome and circRNA_101093 on ferroptosis desensitization in lung adenocarcinoma.Cancer Commun2022;42:287-313 PMCID:PMC9017758

[57] Yang J,Chen X,Yang G.Exosome Mediated Delivery of miR-124 Promotes Neurogenesis after Ischemia.Mol Ther Nucleic Acids2017;7:278-87 PMCID:PMC5415550

[58] Kang L,Jin Y,Lin X.Exosomal miR-205-5p derived from periodontal ligament stem cells attenuates the inflammation of chronic periodontitis via targeting XBP1.Immun Inflamm Dis2023;11:e743 PMCID:PMC9761342

[59] Yang H,Fan L.lncRNA LINC00960 promotes apoptosis by sponging ubiquitin ligase Nrdp1-targeting miR-183-5p.Acta Biochim Biophys Sin2023;55:91-102 PMCID:PMC10157604

[60] Tang MR,Guo S,Li HH.Prognostic significance of in situ and plasma levels of transforming growth factor β1, -2 and -3 in cutaneous melanoma.Mol Med Rep2015;11:4508-12

[61] Yue Y,Hsiao YW,Zhao K.Association between transforming growth factors-β and matrix metalloproteinases in the aqueous humor and plasma in myopic patients.J Fr Ophtalmol2022;45:1177-83

[62] Karimi N,Jang SC.Detailed analysis of the plasma extracellular vesicle proteome after separation from lipoproteins.Cell Mol Life Sci2018;75:2873-86 PMCID:PMC6021463

[63] Johnsen KB,Andresen TL.What is the blood concentration of extracellular vesicles? Implications for the use of extracellular vesicles as blood-borne biomarkers of cancer.Biochim Biophys Acta Rev Cancer2019;1871:109-16

[64] Vergauwen G,Pinheiro C.Robust sequential biophysical fractionation of blood plasma to study variations in the biomolecular landscape of systemically circulating extracellular vesicles across clinical conditions.J Extracell Vesicles2021;10:e12122 PMCID:PMC8363909

[65] Karimi N,Dias T,Lässer C.Tetraspanins distinguish separate extracellular vesicle subpopulations in human serum and plasma - contributions of platelet extracellular vesicles in plasma samples.J Extracell Vesicles2022;11:e12213 PMCID:PMC9077141

[66] Mladenović D,Kittel Á,Buzás EI.Acidification of blood plasma facilitates the separation and analysis of extracellular vesicles.J Thromb Haemost2023;21:1032-42

[67] Arroyo JD,Kroh EM.Argonaute2 complexes carry a population of circulating microRNAs independent of vesicles in human plasma.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A2011;108:5003-8 PMCID:PMC3064324

[68] Abeysinghe AAPH. Replication data for sEV miRNA isolation method comparison. Available from: https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/DNXWVG [Last accessed on 28 Feb 2024]