Feta-type cheese developed from camel (Camelus dromedarius) milk: physicochemical properties and sensory acceptability

Abstract

Aim: The study aimed to develop feta-type cheese from camel milk and evaluate its physicochemical properties and sensory acceptability. Methods: Milk samples were obtained from dromedary camels (Camelus dromedarius) kept at the Tsabong Ecotourism Camel Park in Botswana. Feta-type cheese was developed using WhiteDaily 41 culture, which contains mesophilic and thermophilic lactic acid bacteria, and camel chymosin (CHY-MAX M1000). Standard procedures were used to assess physicochemical characteristics and sensory-based consumer acceptability. Cow-milk feta cheese produced using the same procedure served as the control. Mann–Whitney test was used to compare quality parameters of the camel- and cow-milk cheeses. Results: The results showed that producing feta-type cheese from camel milk was more difficult than from cow milk, and the yield from camel milk was slightly lower. Except for ash and fat content, no significant differences (p > 0.05) were found between the two cheese types. Cow-milk feta had significantly higher ash and fat levels (p<0.05) than camel-milk feta. Overall, camel-milk feta displayed physicochemical characteristics comparable to those of cow-milk feta. The sensory acceptability test revealed that aroma, texture, taste, and overall acceptability scores were significantly higher (p<0.05) for cow-milk feta than for camel-milk feta. However, colour did not differ significantly (p > 0.05) between the two cheeses. Conclusions: The findings show that making feta-type cheese from camel milk is possible, provided that manufacturing protocols are modified and processing parameters optimized. It is essential to improve the organoleptic properties of camel-milk feta cheese. Future research should consider the use of natural additives such as spices or condiments to improve flavour, aroma, texture, antioxidant and antimicrobial properties, and shelf life of the cheese.

Keywords

camel milk / consumer acceptability / feta-type cheese / physicochemical properties

References

[1] Gateway to dairy production and products: Dairy animals—Camels[Internet]. FDA; c2026 [cited 2026 Mar 3]. Available from: https://www.fao.org/dairy—production—products/dairy/camels/en

[2] Seifu E. Recent advances on camel milk: Nutritional and health benefits and processing implications—A review. AIMS Agric Food. 2022;7:777-804.

[3] Vikas M, Farah Z. Manufacture of cheese from camel milk. report on field studies in Kenya. Zurich: ETH; 1991.

[4] Haddadin MS, Gammoh SI, Robinson RK. Seasonal variations in the chemical composition of camel milk in Jordan. J Dairy Res. 2008;75:8-12.

[5] Kaskous S. Importance of camel milk for human health. Emirates J Food Agric. 2016;28:158-63.

[6] Wilson RT. Camels (The Tropical Agriculturalist). Macmillan Education; 1998.

[7] Fatma CH, Benmechernene Z. Isolation and identification of Leuconostoc mesenteroides producing bacteriocin isolated from Algerian raw camel milk. Afr J Microbiol Res. 2013;7:2961—9.

[8] Seifu E. Camel milk products: innovations, limitations and opportunities. Food Prod Process and Nutr. 2023;5:15.

[9] Al haj OA, Al Kanhal HA. Compositional, technological and nutritional aspects of dromedary camel milk. Int Dairy J. 2010;20:811—21.

[10] El—Agamy EI, Nawar M, Shamsia SM, Awad F, Haenlein GFW. Are camel milk proteins convenient to the nutrition of cow milk allergic children? Small Rum Res. 2009;82:1-6.

[11] Marete PK, Mariga AM, Huka G, Musalia L, Marete E, Mathara JM, et al. Camel milk products beyond yoghurt and fresh milk: challenges, processing and applications. J Food Sci Technol. 2024;61:220—9.

[12] Berhe T, Seifu E, Ipsen R, Kurtu MY, Hansen EB. Processing Challenges and Opportunities of Camel Dairy Products. Int J Food Sci.2017;2017:9061757.

[13] Jrad Z, Oussaeif O, El—Hatmi H. Recent Trends on Camel Milk Cheese Processing: Nutritional and Health Value. In: Abdou AM, editor. Recent Trends on Cheese as Functional Food with Great Nutritive and Health Benefits. London: IntechOpen; 2024.

[14] Mehaia MA. Fresh Soft White Cheese (Domiati—Type) from Camel Milk: Composition, Yield, and Sensory Evaluation. J Dairy Sci. 1993;76:2845-55.

[15] Khan H, Athar IH, Aslam M. Evaluation of cheese prepared by processing camel milk. Pak J Zool. 2004;36:323—6.

[16] Qadeer Z, Huma N, Sameen A, Iqbal T. Camel milk cheese: optimization of processing conditions. J Camelid Sci. 2015;8:18-25.

[17] Tsvakirai CZ. A review of the marketing approaches promoting the sale of milk from non—cattle dairy species. Discov Food. 2025;5:255.

[18] Vargas—Bello—Pérez E, Tajonar K, Foggi G, Mele M, Simitzis P, Mavrommatis A, et al. Consumer attitudes toward dairy products from sheep and goats: A cross—continental perspective. J Dairy Sci. 2022;105:8718—33.

[19] Wang S, Naumovski N, Ajlouni S, Ayyash M, Silva R, Balthazar CF, et al. Nonbovine milk and its products as sources of probiotics delivery: An overview of its viability, functionality and product quality characteristics. Int J Dairy Technol. 2023;76:482-511.

[20] Ruiz—Capillas C, Herrero AM, Pintado T, Delgado—Pando G. Sensory Analysis and Consumer Research in New Meat Products Development. Foods. 2021;10:429.

[21] Kgaudi K, Seifu E, Teketay D. Milk Production Potential and Major Browse Species Consumed by Dromedary Camels in Tshabong. Botswana Notes Rec. 2018;50:85-96.

[22] Bruntse A. Camel milk cheese: Recipes for North—east Africa[Internet]. [cited 2024 Dec 27]. Available from: https://infonet—biovision.org/sites/default/files/4314.camel_cheese_manual.pdf

[23] Kappeler SR, van den Brink HJ, Rahbek—Nielsen H, Farah Z, Puhan Z, Hansen EB, et al. Characterization of recombinant camel chymosin reveals superior properties for the coagulation of bovine and camel milk. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2006;342:647-54.

[24] Jensen JL, Mølgaard A, Poulsen JCN, Harboe MK, Simonsen JB, Lorentzen AM, et al. Camel and bovine chymosin: the relationship between their structures and cheese—making properties. Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr. 2013;69:901—13.

[25] Mehaia MA. Manufacture of Fresh Soft White Cheese (Domiati—Type) from Dromedary Camels’ Milk Using Ultrafiltration Process. J Food Technol. 2006;4:206-12.

[26] Bradley RL Jr, Arnold E Jr, Barbano DM, Semerad RG, Smith DE, Vines BK. Chemical and physical methods. In: Marshall RT, editor. Standard methods for the examination of dairy products. 16th ed. Washington, DC: American Public Health Association; 1992. pp. 433-531.

[27] International IDF Standard 20B:1993: Milk: Determination of Nitrogen Content: Inspection by Attributes. In: International Dairy Federation. IDF; 1990.

[28] AOAC. Official methods of analysis. 16th ed. Washington DC: Association of Official Analytical Chemists; 1995.

[29] Resurreccion AVA. Consumer Sensory Testing For Product Development. 1st ed. New York: Springer; 1998.

[30] Jeon SS, Lee SJ, Ganesan P, Kwak HS. Comparative study of flavor, texture, and sensory in cream cheese and cholesterol—removed cream cheese. Food Sci Biotechnol. 2012;21:159-65.

[31] R Core Team. An Introduction to R: Notes on R: A Programming Environment for Data Analysis and Graphics. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing; 2023.

[32] Mauropoulos AA, Arvanitoyannis IS. Implementation of hazard analysis critical control point to Feta and Manouri cheese production lines. Food Control. 1999;10:213—9.

[33] Özer B. CHEESE | Microflora of White—Brined Cheeses. In: Batt CA, Tortorello ML, editors. Encyclopedia of Food Microbiology (Second Edition). Oxford: Academic Press; 2014. pp. 402—8.

[34] Konuspayeva G, Faye B. Recent Advances in Camel Milk Processing. Animals (Basel). 2021;11:1045.

[35] Bornaz S, Sahli A, Attalah A, Attia H. Physicochemical characteristics and renneting properties of camels’ milk: A comparison with goats’, ewes’ and cows’ milks. Int J Dairy Technol. 2009;62:505—13.

[36] Mbye M, Ayyash M, Abu—Jdayil B, Kamal—Eldin A. The Texture of Camel Milk Cheese: Effects of Milk Composition, Coagulants, and Processing Conditions. Front Nutr. 2022;9:868320.

[37] Baig D, Sabikhi L, Khetra Y, Kumar D. Effect of casein to fat ratio of camel milk on solids losses in cheese whey and their recovery in camel milk cheese. J Dairy Sci. 2022;124:105185.

[38] Mohamed H, Johansson M, Lundh Å, Nagy P, Kamal—Eldin A. Short communication: Caseins and α—lactalbumin content of camel milk (Camelus dromedarius) determined by capillary electrophoresis . J Dairy Sci. 2020;103:11094—9.

[39] Athar IH, Masud T, Amanat A. Manufacturing of indigenous cheese using starter culture and direct acidification process. Pak J Sci Ind Res. 1989;32:355-7.

[40] Benkerroum N, Dehhaoui M, EL Fayq A, Tlaiha R. The effect of concentration of chymosin on the yield and sensory properties of camel cheese and on its microbiological quality. Int J Dairy Technol. 2011;64:232—9.

[41] Konuspayeva G, Camier B, Aleilawi N, Al—Shumeimyri M, Al—Hammad K, Algruin K, et al. Manufacture of dry— and brine—salted soft camel cheeses for the camel dairy industry. Int J Dairy Technol. 2016;70:92-101.

[42] Rangel—Ortega SdC, Campos—Múzquiz LG, Charles—Rodríguez AV, Palomo—Ligas L, Solanilla—Duque JF, Flores—Gallegos AC, et al. Dietary Factors and Production Season Effect on the Properties of Goat Cheese. Dairy. 2024;5:346-59.

[43] Hailu Y, Hansen EB, Seifu E, Eshetu M, Petersen MA, Lametsch R, et al. Rheological and sensory properties and aroma compounds formed during ripening of soft brined cheese made from camel milk. Int Dairy J. 2018;81:122—30.

[44] Bouazizi A, Ben Touati T, Guesmi C, Attia H, Felfoul I. Physicochemical, sensory and coagulation properties of dromedary and cows’ skim milk white brined cheeses. Int Dairy J. 2021;117:105006.

[45] Arain MA, Salman HM, Ali M, Khaskheli GB, Barham GS, Marghazani IB, et al. A Review on Camel Milk Composition, Techno—Functional Properties and Processing Constraints. Food Sci Anim Resour. 2024;44:739-57.