Influence of avoided biomass decay on a life cycle assessment of oil palm residues-based ethanol

Abstract

Lignocellulosic (bio)ethanol from oil palm agricultural residue was investigated regarding feedstock availability and environmental impacts while accounting for avoided biomass decay. A life cycle assessment (LCA) was carried out at both pilot- and large-scale plants, from oil palm empty fruit bunch (EFB) collection until ethanol production and use. The primary data were gathered from a pilot plant at Research Center for Chemistry BRIN, Indonesia. Producing bioethanol at a large scale required 59.8% of available feedstock within a 200 km radius, with the need for chemical fertilizer to substitute EFB-based fertilizer to replenish soil nutrients. Global warming potential impacts, evaluated using CML IA Baseline 2016, indicating 8.06 and − 0.14 kg CO₂eq/kg would be generated at pilot- and large-scale plants, respectively. Considering the use of ethanol from large scale plant by car, the GWP impact for bioethanol, gasoline, and E5 (blending of 5% ethanol and 95% gasoline) is − 3.07, 84.07 and 81.23 g CO₂eq/MJ, respectively. The negative value of such an impact at the large scale indicated that bioethanol would lead to 1.42% and 3.38% reduction of GWP at production phase and E5 use phase, respectively. Some options were investigated to improve the GWP impact and energy profit ratio at the plant level, covering main impact contributors such as energy sources, enzymes, and chemical materials. The consideration of avoided decay may lead to further potential implication for E5 policy, which can contribute to achieving 7.46% of the national GHGs reduction target in the transportation sector. Further research would be recommended, at larger scales, to identify various biomass decay emission profiles as well as spatialized biomass availability while ensuring to maintain soil quality.

Keywords

Oil palm biomass residue / Life cycle assessment / Lignocellulosic ethanol / Pilot scale / Large scale / Avoided decay

References

[1] Alamsyah Z, Napitupulu D, Hamid E, Yanita M, Fauzia G. Factors affecting the FFB price of independent smallholder oil palm farmers in Jambi Province. IOP Conf Ser Earth Environ Sci, 2021

[2] Ani FN. Utilization of bioresources as fuels and energy generation. Electr Renew Energy Syst, 2015

[3] APROBI (2023) Pemerintah Keluarkan Aturan Standar BBM Nabati. https://www.aprobi.or.id/pemerintah-keluarkan-aturan-standar-bbm-nabati/. Accessed 16 Aug 2023

[4] Argon Laboratory (2021) Polyethylene glycol dataset in GREET v1.3.0.13991

[5] Balan V (2014) Current challenges in commercially producing biofuels from lignocellulosic biomass. ISRN Biotechnol 2014

[6] Bird N, Cherubini F, Jungmeier G (2013) Using a life cycle assessment approach to estimate the net greenhouse gas emissions of bioenergy

[7] Boschma S, Kwant IKW (2013) Valorization of palm oil ( mill ) residues. Identifying and solving the challenges. NL Agency 38

[8] BP (2022) Statistical review of world energy. 2022. Available at:

[9] Buchspies B, Kaltschmitt M, Junginger M. Straw utilization for biofuel production: a consequential assessment of greenhouse gas emissions from bioethanol and biomethane provision with a focus on the time dependency of emissions. GCB Bioenergy, 2020, 12: 789-805

[10] Caldeira-Pires A, Benoist A, da Luz SM, Silverio VC, Silveira CM, Machado FS. Implications of removing straw from soil for bioenergy: an LCA of ethanol production using total sugarcane biomass. J Clean Prod, 2018, 181: 249-259

[11] Cannella D, Jørgensen H. Do new cellulolytic enzyme preparations affect the industrial strategies for high solids lignocellulosic ethanol production?. Biotechnol Bioeng, 2014, 111: 59-68

[12] Carriquiry MA, Du X, Timilsina GR. Second generation biofuels: economics and policies. Energy Policy, 2011, 39: 4222-4234

[13] Carusedjp (2021) If you buy a Canter (canter truck), what is the best mileage?

[14] Cherubini F, Bird ND, Cowie A, Jungmeier G, Schlamadinger B, Woess-Gallasch S. Energy- and greenhouse gas-based LCA of biofuel and bioenergy systems: key issues, ranges and recommendations. Resour Conserv Recycl, 2009, 53: 434-447

[15] Chiew YL, Shimada S. Current state and environmental impact assessment for utilizing oil palm empty fruit bunches for fuel, fiber and fertilizer—a case study of Malaysia. Biomass Bioenerg, 2013, 51: 109-124

[16] Contadini JF (2002) Life cycle assessment of fuel cell vehicles—dealing with uncertainties. University of California

[17] de Azevedo A, Fornasier F, da Silva Szarblewski M, de Souza Schneider RDC, Hoeltz M, de Souza D. Life cycle assessment of bioethanol production from cattle manure. J Clean Prod, 2017, 162: 1021-1030

[18] Delikonstantis E, Igos E, Augustinus M, Benetto E, Stefanidis GD. Life cycle assessment of plasma-assisted ethylene production from rich-in-methane gas streams. Sustain Energy Fuels, 2020, 4: 1351-1362

[19] Demirbaş A, Demirbaş AH. Estimating the calorific values of lignocellulosic fuels. Energy Explor Exploit, 2004, 22: 135-143

[20] Devi A, Singh A, Bajar S, Pant D, Din ZU. Ethanol from lignocellulosic biomass: an in-depth analysis of pre-treatment methods, fermentation approaches and detoxification processes. J Environ Chem Eng, 2021, 9

[21] Do TX, Lim YI, Jang S, Chung HJ. Hierarchical economic potential approach for techno-economic evaluation of bioethanol production from palm empty fruit bunches. Bioresour Technol, 2015, 189: 224-235

[22] Dumfort S, Kirchmair C, Floerl K, Larch C, Rupprich M (2018) Storage as the weak link of the biomass supply chain. In: Africa-EU renewable energy research and innovation symposium. pp 117–125

[23] Ecochain (2023) Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA)—How is it different from LCA? https://ecochain.com/blog/environmental-impact-assessment-eia-how-is-it-different-from-lca/

[24] Ecoinvent Database version 8.3.0, Sodium Hydroxide in 50% solution state, market, global, and Potassium Hydroxide, market, global,

[25] Ecoinvent (2016) Petrol, Low Sulfur, RoW—Datasets in SimaPro Faculty

[26] Erivianto D, Dani A, Gunawan H. Pengolahan Biomassa Tandan Kosong Kelapa Sawit Sebagai Bahan Bakar Pembangkit Listrik Tenaga Uap. J Indones Sos Teknol, 2022, 3: 162-171

[27] European Parliament, Council of the European Union DIRECTIVE 2009/30/EC OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL of 23 April 2009 amending Directive 98/70/EC as regards the specification of petrol, diesel and gas-oil and introducing a mechanism to monitor and reduce greenhouse gas emissions and amend. Off J Eur Union, 2009, 88: 88-113

[28] Forster P, Ramaswamy V, Artaxo P, Berntsen T, Betts R, Fahey DW, Haywood J, Lean J, Lowe DC, Myhre G, Nganga J, Prinn R, Raga G, And MS, Dorland R Van (2007) Changes in atmospheric constituents and in radiative forcing. In: Climate change 2007: the physical science basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change

[29] Fujita H, Nakano K, Chaisomphob T, Hambali E. Greenhouse gas emission of electricity generation and field abandonment scenarios using empty fruit bunches at a palm oil Mill, Surat Thani Province, Thailand. J Jpn Inst Energy, 2019, 98: 119-123

[30] Gandam PK, Chinta ML, Pabbathi NPP, Baadhe RR, Sharma M, Thakur VK, Sharma GD, Ranjitha J, Gupta VK. Second-generation bioethanol production from corncob—a comprehensive review on pretreatment and bioconversion strategies, including techno-economic and lifecycle perspective. Ind Crops Prod, 2022

[31] Giuntoli J, Agostini A, Caserini S, Lugato E, Baxter D, Marelli L. Climate change impacts of power generation from residual biomass. Biomass Bioenerg, 2016, 89: 146-158

[32] IPCC (2006) Chapter 2: Stationary Combustion in 2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories. IPCC, Geneva, Switzerland

[33] González-García S, Moreira MT, Feijoo G, Murphy RJ. Comparative life cycle assessment of ethanol production from fast-growing wood crops (black locust, eucalyptus and poplar). Biomass Bioenerg, 2012, 39: 378-388

[34] Hergoualc’h K, Akiyama H, Bernoux M, Chirinda N, del Prado A, Kasimir Å, MacDonald JD, Ogle SM, Regina K, Weerden TJ van der, Liang C, Noble A (2019) Chapter 11: N₂O emissions from managed soils, and CO2 emissions from lime and urea application. In: 2019 Refinement to the 2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories. IPCC

[35] Hidayati S, Zuidar AS, Satyajaya W, Murhadi M, Retnowati D. Isolation and characterization of formacell Lignins from oil empty fruits bunches. IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng, 2018

[36] Hidayati S, Satyajaya W, Fudholi A. Lignin isolation from black liquor from oil palm empty fruit bunch using acid. J Mater Res Technol, 2020, 9: 11382-11391

[37] Hindustan Times (2021) The importance of the PM’s ethanol push

[38] IEA (2020) Sustainable Recovery: Fuels

[39] Indian Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas (2022) India has achieved the target of 10 percent ethanol blending, 5 months ahead of schedule

[40] Indonesian Ministry of Agriculture (2022) Statistical of National Leading Estate Crops Commodity 2021–2023

[41] Indonesian Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (2022) Konsumsi Pertalite Capai 23 Juta KL, Paling Banyak Digunakan Masyarakat

[42] Indonesian Ministry of Environment (2018) Kontribusi Penurunan Emisi GRK Nasional, Menuju NDC 2030

[43] International Organization for Standardization (2006) ISO 14040:2006 Environmental management—life cycle assessment—principles and framework

[44] IPCC Climate change 2014: synthesis report. Contribution of Working Groups I, II and III to the fifth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change, 2014 Geneva IPCC 151

[45] Gómez DR, Watterson JD, Americanohia BB, Ha C, Marland G, Matsika E, Namayanga LN, Osman-Elasha B, Saka JK, Treanton K (2006) IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories: Chapter 2 Stationary Combustion. IPCC, IPCC: Geneva, Switzerland

[46] Jeon H, Kang KE, Jeong JS, Gong G, Choi JW, Abimanyu H, Ahn BS, Suh DJ, Choi GW. Production of anhydrous ethanol using oil palm empty fruit bunch in a pilot plant. Biomass Bioenerg, 2014, 67: 99-107

[47] Jeswani HK, Chilvers A, Azapagic A. Environmental sustainability of biofuels: a review: Environmental sustainability of biofuels. Proc R Soc A Math Phys Eng Sci, 2020

[48] Kiuchi T, Yoshida M, Kato Y. Energy saving bioethanol distillation process with self-heat recuperation technology. J Jpn Pet Inst, 2015, 58: 135-140

[49] Kosugi A, Yamashita M (2022) Rebuilding Malaysia’s Palm Oil Industry Sustainable with “Innovative Biomass”

[50] Kouisni L, Holt-Hindle P, Maki K, Paleologou M. The lignoforce system: a new process for the production of high-quality lignin from black liquor. J. Sci. Technol. for. Prod. Process, 2012, 2: 6-10

[51] Lee ZY, Liew PY, Woon KS, Tan LS, Tamunaidu P, Klemeš JJ. Life-cycle environmental and cost analysis of palm biomass-based bio-ethanol production in Malaysia. Chem Eng Trans, 2021, 89: 85-90

[52] Lineback N, Dellinger T, Shienvold LF, Witcher B, Reynolds A, Brown LE. Industrial greenhouse gas emissions: Does CO₂ from combustion of biomass residue for energy really matter?. Clim Res, 1999, 13: 221-229

[53] Liu G, Bao J. Evaluation of electricity generation from lignin residue and biogas in cellulosic ethanol production. Bioresour Technol, 2017, 243: 1232-1236

[54] Lubis MAR, Dewi AR, Risanto L, Zaini LH, Hermiati E. Isolation and characterization of lignin from alkaline pretreatment black liquor of oil palm empty fruit bunch and sugarcane bagasse. Proc Asean Cosat, 2014, 2014: 483-491

[55] Lya A, Udiantoro AH. Karakteristik serat tandan kosong kelapa sawit (tkks) dengan perlakuan perebusan dan pengukusan. Ziraa’ah, 2016, 41: 97-102

[56] Mann M, Spath P. A life cycle assessment of biomass cofiring in a coal-fired power plant. Clean Prod Process, 2001, 3: 81-91

[57] Matemilola S, Salami HA (2021) Environmental assessment. In: Encyclopedia of Sustainable Management. Springer, pp 1–4

[58] Matsushima J. Why is the energy balance ratio view important?—Reexamination of the definition and significance of EPR. Nucl Instrum Methods Phys Res, 1996, 3: 42-47

[59] Ministry of Transportation (2023) Penurunan Emisi Gas Rumah Kaca (GRK) pada Transportasi Perkotaan melalui Upaya Penyeimbangan Karbon

[60] Muryanto TE, Hendarsyah H, Abimanyu H. Reuse black liquor of alkali pretreatment in bioethanol production. Energy Procedia, 2015, 68: 236-243

[61] Nogueira GP, Capaz RS, Franco TT, Dias MOS, Cavaliero CKN. Enzymes as an environmental bottleneck in cellulosic ethanol production: Does on-site production solve it?. J Clean Prod, 2022

[62] Nugroho R, Hanafi J, Shobatake K, Chun YY, Tahara K, Purwanto WW. Life cycle inventories and life cycle assessment for an electricity grid network: case study of the Jamali grid, Indonesia. Int J Life Cycle Assess, 2022, 27: 1081-1091

[63] Olisa YP, Island W, State B, Kotingo KW, Island W, State B. Utilization of palm empty fruit bunch (pefb) as solid fuel for steam boiler. Eur J Eng Technol, 2014, 2: 1-7

[64] Pacheco R, Silva C. Global warming potential of biomass-to-ethanol: review and sensitivity analysis through a case study. Energies, 2019

[65] Pehme S, Veromann E, Hamelin L. Environmental performance of manure co-digestion with natural and cultivated grass—a consequential life cycle assessment. J Clean Prod, 2017, 162: 1135-1143

[66] Prudhomme R, O’Donoghue C, Ryan M, Styles D. Defining national biogenic methane targets: Implications for national food production & climate neutrality objectives. J Environ Manag, 2021

[67] Raham D. Study of mineral nutrient losses from oil palm empty fruit bunches during temporary storage. J Oil Palm Res, 2004, 16: 11-21

[68] Raj T, Chandrasekhar K, Naresh Kumar A, Rajesh Banu J, Yoon JJ, Kant Bhatia S, Yang YH, Varjani S, Kim SH. Recent advances in commercial biorefineries for lignocellulosic ethanol production: current status, challenges and future perspectives. Bioresour Technol, 2022

[69] Rentizelas AA. Biomass storage. Biomass Supply Chain Bioenergy Biorefining, 2016

[70] Reuters (2023) Indonesia’s Pertamina launches sales of gasoline with 5% ethanol mix

[71] Ro JW, Zhang Y, Kendall A. Developing guidelines for waste designation of biofuel feedstocks in carbon footprints and life cycle assessment. Sustain Prod Consum, 2023, 37: 320-330

[72] Setiawan VN (2022) Bioetanol Bisa Jadi Bahan Bakar, Kapan RI Mau Ngembangin?

[73] Sharma B, Larroche C, Dussap CG. Comprehensive assessment of 2G bioethanol production. Bioresour Technol, 2020

[74] Shukla PR, Skea J, Slade R, Fradera R, Pathak M, Khourdajie A Al, Belkacemi M, Diemen R van, Hasija A, Lisboa G, Luz S, Malley J, McCollum D, Some S, Vyas P (2022) Mitigation of Climate Change—Climate Change 2022

[75] Singh A, Pant D, Korres NE, Nizami AS, Prasad S, Murphy JD. Key issues in life cycle assessment of ethanol production from lignocellulosic biomass: challenges and perspectives. Bioresour Technol, 2010, 101: 5003-5012

[76] Soleymani Angili T, Grzesik K, Rödl A, Kaltschmitt M. Life cycle assessment of bioethanol production: a review of feedstock, technology and methodology. Energies, 2021

[77] Soni SK, Batra N, Bansal N, Soni R. Bioconversion of sugarcane bagasse into second generation bioethanol after enzymatic hydrolysis with in-house produced cellulases from Aspergillus sp. S4B2F. BioResources, 2010, 5: 741-757

[78] Sonnichsen N (2022) Global biodiesel production 2021 by country. In: Stat. 2022

[79] Sreekumar A, Shastri Y, Wadekar P, Patil M, Lali A. Life cycle assessment of ethanol production in a rice-straw-based biorefinery in India. Clean Technol Environ Policy, 2020, 22: 409-422

[80] Sudiyani Y, Styarini D, Triwahyuni E, Sudiyarmanto SKC, Aristiawan Y, Abimanyu H, Han MH. Utilization of biomass waste empty fruit bunch fiber of palm oil for bioethanol production using pilot—scale unit. Energy Procedia, 2013, 32: 31-38

[81] Sulaiman F, Abdullah N, Aliasak Z. Solar drying system for drying empty fruit bunches. J Phys Sci, 2013, 24: 75-93

[82] Sung CTB (2016) Availability, use, and removal of oil palm biomass in Indonesia

[83] Tellnes LGF, Ganne-Chedeville C, Dias A, Dolezal F, Hill C, Escamilla EZ. Comparative assessment for biogenic carbon accounting methods in carbon footprint of products: a review study for construction materials based on forest products. Iforest, 2017, 10: 815-823

[84] The Engineering Toolbox (2003) Fuels—higher and lower calorific values

[85] Triwahyuni E, Suaidah S, Sugiwati S, Muryanto M, Abimanyu H. Lactic acid production from oil palm empty fruit bunch using lactobacillus delbrueckii. AIP Conf Proc, 2023

[86] UNFCC (2022) Enhanced nationally determined contribution: Republic of Indonesia

[87] UNFCCC/CCNUCC (2014) III. E Avoidance of methane production from biomass decay through controlled combustion

[88] US Department of Agriculture (2022) Biofuels Annual Report: Indonesia

[89] USLCI (2013) Novozyme Cellulase Dataset in SimaPro Faculty

[90] Usman F (2019) Ethanol Dilemma. In: Pertamina. https://www.pertamina.com/id/news-room/market-insight/ethanol-dilemma. Accessed 3 Apr 2022

[91] Vaskan P, Pachón ER, Gnansounou E. Techno-economic and life-cycle assessments of biorefineries based on palm empty fruit bunches in Brazil. J Clean Prod, 2018, 172: 3655-3668

[92] Villegas JM, Avila H. Quick-scan estimating model of higher heating value of oil palm empty fruit bunches based on ash from proximate analysis data. Ing e Investig, 2014, 34: 33-38

[93] Wibawa DS, Nasution MA, Noguchi R, Ahamed T, Demura M, Watanabe MM. Microalgae oil production: a downstream approach to energy requirements for the minamisoma pilot plant. Energies, 2018

[94] Wihersaari M. Evaluation of greenhouse gas emission risks from storage of wood residue. Biomass Bioenerg, 2005, 28: 444-453

[95] Wiloso EI, Heijungs R, De Snoo GR. LCA of second generation bioethanol: a review and some issues to be resolved for good LCA practice. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 2012, 16: 5295-5308

[96] Wiloso EI, Bessou C, Heijungs R. Methodological issues in comparative life cycle assessment: treatment options for empty fruit bunches in a palm oil system. Int J Life Cycle Assess, 2015, 20: 204-216

[97] Woolf D, Amonette JE, Street-Perrott FA, Lehmann J, Joseph S. Sustainable biochar to mitigate global climate change: supplementary information. Nat Commun, 2010, 1: 56

[98] Zhou Y, Searle S, Anup S (2021) Techno-economic analysis of cellulosic ethanol in India using agricultural residues. ICCT-White Pap 1–18