Integrated remediation approaches for selected pharmaceutical and personal care products in urban soils for a sustainable future

Abstract

The presence of trace contaminants, such as pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs), in various environmental media (soil, sediments, groundwater, and surface water), is a growing concern. This is a serious issue due to a lack of understanding about the potential consequences of their occurrence, fate, and eco-toxicological impacts. Numerous studies have been carried out to determine their effect on animals and humans. This is critical for removing them from the soil and wastewater. Because of their low concentrations (ppm or ppb) and complex structure, these pollutants are difficult to completely remove in wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). Moreover, PPCPs are not efficiently removed by WWTPs; therefore, novel techniques for improved performance are required. Several technologies, including bioremediation, have been developed to remove these compounds from polluted soil and water. This article discussed the various PPCPs found in soil and wastewater, as well as available removal technologies, with a focus on integrated remediation approaches. Furthermore, we discuss the sources of PPCPs, their toxicity and risks to humans and ecosystems, the UN's goals for sustainable development, and PPCP elimination strategies.

Keywords

Micro-pollutants / Pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) / Sources of PPCPs / Toxicity and risks of PPCPs

References

[1] Al-Farsi RS, Ahmed M, Al-Busaidi A, Choudri B. Translocation of pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) into plant tissues: a review. Emerg Contaminants, 2017, 3(4): 132-137

[2] Al-Mashaqbeh O, Alsafadi D, Dalahmeh S, Bartelt-Hunt S, Snow D. Removal of selected pharmaceuticals and personal care products in wastewater treatment plant in Jordan. Water, 2019, 11(10): 2004

[3] Al-Odaini NA, Zakaria MP, Yaziz MI, Surif S. Multi-residue analytical method for human pharmaceuticals and synthetic hormones in river water and sewage effluents by solid-phase extraction and liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry. J Chromatogr A, 2010, 1217(44): 6791-6806

[4] Alonso E, Santos A, Solis G, Riesco P. On the feasibility of urban wastewater tertiary treatment by membranes: a comparative assessment. Desalination, 2001, 141(1): 39-51

[5] Alvarino T, Suarez S, Lema J, Omil F. Understanding the removal mechanisms of PPCPs and the influence of main technological parameters in anaerobic UASB and aerobic CAS reactors. J Hazard Mater, 2014, 278: 506-513

[6] Arikan OA, Rice C, Codling E. Occurrence of antibiotics and hormones in a major agricultural watershed. Desalination, 2008, 226(1–3): 121-133

[7] Brix R, Postigo C, González S, Villagrasa M, Navarro A, Kuster M, de Alda MJL, Barceló D. Analysis and occurrence of alkylphenolic compounds and estrogens in a European river basin and an evaluation of their importance as priority pollutants. Anal Bioanal Chem, 2010, 396(3): 1301-1309

[8] Careghini A, Mastorgio AF, Saponaro S, Sezenna E. Bisphenol A, nonylphenols, benzophenones, and benzotriazoles in soils, groundwater, surface water, sediments, and food: a review. Environ Sci Pollut Res, 2015, 22(8): 5711-5741

[9] Chen F, Ying G-G, Kong L-X, Wang L, Zhao J-L, Zhou L-J, Zhang L-J. Distribution and accumulation of endocrine-disrupting chemicals and pharmaceuticals in wastewater irrigated soils in Hebei. China Environ Pollut, 2011, 159(6): 1490-1498

[10] Chen Z-F, Ying G-G, Ma Y-B, Lai H-J, Chen F, Pan C-G. Occurrence and dissipation of three azole biocides climbazole, clotrimazole and miconazole in biosolid-amended soils. Sci Total Environ, 2013, 452: 377-383

[11] Chen X, Vollertsen J, Nielsen JL, Dall AG, Bester K. Degradation of PPCPs in activated sludge from different WWTPs in Denmark. Ecotoxicology, 2015, 24(10): 2073-2080

[12] Chopra S, Kumar D. Pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) as emerging environmental pollutants: toxicity and risk assessment. Adv Anim Biotechnol Appl, 2018

[13] Christian T, Schneider RJ, Färber HA, Skutlarek D, Meyer MT, Goldbach HE. Determination of antibiotic residues in manure, soil, and surface waters. Acta Hydrochim Hydrobiol, 2003, 31(1): 36-44

[14] Clara M, Strenn B, Gans O, Martinez E, Kreuzinger N, Kroiss H. Removal of selected pharmaceuticals, fragrances and endocrine disrupting compounds in a membrane bioreactor and conventional wastewater treatment plants. Water Res, 2005, 39(19): 4797-4807

[15] De Gusseme B, Vanhaecke L, Verstraete W, Boon N. Degradation of acetaminophen by Delftia tsuruhatensis and Pseudomonas aeruginosa in a membrane bioreactor. Water Res, 2011, 45(4): 1829-1837

[16] Duedahl-Olesen L, Cederberg T, Pedersen KH, Højgård A. Synthetic musk fragrances in trout from Danish fish farms and human milk. Chemosphere, 2005, 61(3): 422-4231

[17] Evgenidou EN, Konstantinou IK, Lambropoulou DA. Occurrence and removal of transformation products of PPCPs and illicit drugs in wastewaters: a review. Sci Total Environ, 2015, 505: 905-926

[18] Farré M, Pérez S, Kantiani L, Barceló D. Fate and toxicity of emerging pollutants, their metabolites and transformation products in the aquatic environment. TrAC-Trends Anal Chem, 2008, 27(11): 991-1007

[19] Fent K, Weston AA, Caminada D. Ecotoxicology of human pharmaceuticals. Aquat Toxicol, 2006, 76(2): 122-159

[20] Ferguson PJ, Bernot MJ, Doll JC, Lauer TE. Detection of pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) in near-shore habitats of southern Lake Michigan. Sci Total Environ, 2013, 458: 187-196

[21] Fram MS, Belitz K. Occurrence and concentrations of pharmaceutical compounds in groundwater used for public drinking-water supply in California. Sci Total Environ, 2011, 409(18): 3409-3417

[22] Fu Q, Malchi T, Carter LJ, Li H, Gan J, Chefetz B. Pharmaceutical and personal care products: from wastewater treatment into agro-food systems. ACS Publ, 2019, 53: 14083-14090

[23] Garcia-Becerra FY, Ortiz I. Biodegradation of emerging organic micropollutants in nonconventional biological wastewater treatment: a critical review. Environ Eng Sci, 2018, 35(10): 1012-1036

[24] Gibson R, Durán-Álvarez JC, Estrada KL, Chávez A, Cisneros BJ. Accumulation and leaching potential of some pharmaceuticals and potential endocrine disruptors in soils irrigated with wastewater in the Tula Valley. Mexico Chemosphere, 2010, 81(11): 1437-1445

[25] Giri R, Ozaki H, Ota S, Takanami R, Taniguchi S. Degradation of common pharmaceuticals and personal care products in mixed solutions by advanced oxidation techniques. Int J Environ Sci Technol, 2010, 7(2): 251-260

[26] Hata T, Kawai S, Okamura H, Nishida T. Removal of diclofenac and mefenamic acid by the white rot fungus Phanerochaete sordida YK-624 and identification of their metabolites after fungal transformation. Biodegradation, 2010, 21(5): 681-689

[27] Heberer T. Occurrence, fate, and removal of pharmaceutical residues in the aquatic environment: a review of recent research data. Toxicol Lett, 2002, 131(1–2): 5-17

[28] Hena S, Gutierrez L, Croué J-P. Removal of pharmaceutical and personal care products (PPCPs) from wastewater using microalgae: a review. J Hazard Mater, 2020

[29] Herath G. Challenges in achieving the sustainable development goals (SDGs) of the UN in ASIA: can the environmental goals be realized. Int Conf Manag Sci Eng Manag, 2018

[30] Hu X, Zhou Q, Luo Y. Occurrence and source analysis of typical veterinary antibiotics in manure, soil, vegetables and groundwater from organic vegetable bases, northern China. Environ Pollut, 2010, 158(9): 2992-2998

[31] Huber MM, Canonica S, Park G-Y, Von Gunten U. Oxidation of pharmaceuticals during ozonation and advanced oxidation processes. Environ Sci Technol, 2003, 37(5): 1016-1024

[32] Hutter H-P, Wallner P, Moshammer H, Hartl W, Sattelberger R, Lorbeer G, Kundi M. Synthetic musks in blood of healthy young adults: relationship to cosmetics use. Sci Total Environ, 2009, 407(17): 4821-4825

[33] Jianlong W, Xiangchun Q, Libo W, Yi Q, Hegemann W. Bioaugmentation as a tool to enhance the removal of refractory compound in coke plant wastewater. Process Biochem, 2002, 38(5): 777-781

[34] Kasprzyk-Hordern B, Dinsdale RM, Guwy AJ. The removal of pharmaceuticals, personal care products, endocrine disruptors and illicit drugs during wastewater treatment and its impact on the quality of receiving waters. Water Res, 2009, 43(2): 363-380

[35] Kato K, Inoue T, Ietsugu H, Koba T, Sasaki H, Miyaji N, Kitagawa K, Sharma PK, Nagasawa T. Performance of six multi-stage hybrid wetland systems for treating high-content wastewater in the cold climate of Hokkaido, Japan. Ecol Eng, 2013, 51: 256-263

[36] Khunjar W, Mackintosh S, Skotnicka-Pitak J, Baik S, Aga D, Love N. Elucidating the relative roles of ammonia oxidizing and heterotrophic bacteria during the biotransformation of 17α-ethinylestradiol and trimethoprim. Environ Sci Technol, 2011, 45(8): 3605-3612

[37] Kim SD, Cho J, Kim IS, Vanderford BJ, Snyder SA. Occurrence and removal of pharmaceuticals and endocrine disruptors in South Korean surface, drinking, and waste waters. Water Res, 2007, 41(5): 1013-1021

[38] Kinney CA, Furlong ET, Zaugg SD, Burkhardt MR, Werner SL, Cahill JD, Bossio JP, Benotti MJ. Survey of organic wastewater contaminants in biosolids destined for land application. Environ Sci Technol, 2006, 40(23): 7207-7215

[39] Kinney CA, Furlong ET, Kolpin DW, Burkhardt MR, Zaugg SD, Werner SL Bioaccumulation of pharmaceuticals and other anthropogenic waste indicators in earthworms from agricultural soil amended with biosolid or swine manure. Environ Sci Technol, 2008, 42(6): 1863-1870

[40] Kolpin DW, Skopec M, Meyer MT, Furlong ET, Zaugg SD. Urban contribution of pharmaceuticals and other organic wastewater contaminants to streams during differing flow conditions. Sci Total Environ, 2004, 328(1–3): 119-130

[41] Kuroda K, Kobayashi J. Pharmaceuticals, personal care products, and artificial sweeteners in Asian groundwater: a review. Contam Drink Wastewater Sour, 2021

[42] Li X, Ying G-G, Su H-C, Yang X-B, Wang L. Simultaneous determination and assessment of 4-nonylphenol, bisphenol A and triclosan in tap water, bottled water and baby bottles. Environ Int, 2010, 36(6): 557-562

[43] Li X, Ying G-G, Zhao J-L, Chen Z-F, Lai H-J, Su H-C. 4-Nonylphenol, bisphenol-A and triclosan levels in human urine of children and students in China, and the effects of drinking these bottled materials on the levels. Environ Int, 2013, 52: 81-86

[44] Li J, Zhou Q, Campos LC. Removal of selected emerging PPCP compounds using greater duckweed (Spirodela polyrhiza) based lab-scale free water constructed wetland. Water Res, 2017, 126: 252-261

[45] Lignell S, Darnerud PO, Aune M, Cnattingius S, Hajslova J, Setkova L Temporal trends of synthetic musk compounds in mother′ s milk and associations with personal use of perfumed products. Environ Sci Technol, 2008, 42(17): 6743-6748

[46] Lin K, Gan J. Sorption and degradation of wastewater-associated non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and antibiotics in soils. Chemosphere, 2011, 83(3): 240-246

[47] Liu J-L, Wong M-H. Pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs): a review on environmental contamination in China. Environ Int, 2013, 59: 208-224

[48] Liu L, Liu Y-h, Wang Z, Liu C-x, Huang X, Zhu G-f. Behavior of tetracycline and sulfamethazine with corresponding resistance genes from swine wastewater in pilot-scale constructed wetlands. J Hazard Mater, 2014, 278: 304-310

[49] Liu X, Liang C, Liu X, Zhao F, Han C. Occurrence and human health risk assessment of pharmaceuticals and personal care products in real agricultural systems with long-term reclaimed wastewater irrigation in Beijing. China Ecotoxicol Environ Saf, 2020, 190: 110022

[50] López-Serna R, Petrović M, Barceló D. Occurrence and distribution of multi-class pharmaceuticals and their active metabolites and transformation products in the Ebro River basin (NE Spain). Sci Total Environ, 2012, 440: 280-289

[51] Lu Y, Yuan T, Wang W, Kannan K. Concentrations and assessment of exposure to siloxanes and synthetic musks in personal care products from China. Environ Pollut, 2011, 159(12): 3522-3528

[52] Lu Y, Yuan T, Yun SH, Wang W, Kannan K. Occurrence of synthetic musks in indoor dust from China and implications for human exposure. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol, 2011, 60(1): 182-189

[53] Managaki S, Murata A, Takada H, Tuyen BC, Chiem NH. Distribution of macrolides, sulfonamides, and trimethoprim in tropical waters: ubiquitous occurrence of veterinary antibiotics in the Mekong Delta. Environ Sci Technol, 2007, 41(23): 8004-8010

[54] Meyer MF, Powers SM, Hampton SE. An evidence synthesis of pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) in the environment: imbalances among compounds, sewage treatment techniques, and ecosystem types. Environ Sci Technol, 2019, 53(22): 12961-12973

[55] Nakada N, Kiri K, Shinohara H, Harada A, Kuroda K, Takizawa S, Takada H. Evaluation of pharmaceuticals and personal care products as water-soluble molecular markers of sewage. Environ Sci Technol, 2008, 42(17): 6347-6353

[56] Plósz BG, Langford KH, Thomas KV. An activated sludge modeling framework for xenobiotic trace chemicals (ASM-X): assessment of diclofenac and carbamazepine. Biotechnol Bioeng, 2012, 109(11): 2757-2769

[57] Pollice A, Lopez A, Laera G, Rubino P, Lonigro A. Tertiary filtered municipal wastewater as alternative water source in agriculture: a field investigation in Southern Italy. Sci Total Environ, 2004, 324(1–3): 201-210

[58] Popa C, Favier L, Dinica R, Semrany S, Djelal H, Amrane A Potential of newly isolated wild Streptomyces strains as agents for the biodegradation of a recalcitrant pharmaceutical, carbamazepine. Environ Technol, 2014, 35(24): 3082-3091

[59] Ramaswamy BR, Shanmugam G, Velu G, Rengarajan B, Larsson DJ. GC–MS analysis and ecotoxicological risk assessment of triclosan, carbamazepine and parabens in Indian rivers. J Hazard Mater, 2011, 186(2–3): 1586-1593

[60] Ray SS, Gusain R, Kumar N. Carbon nanomaterial-based adsorbents for water purification: fundamentals and applications., 2020

[61] Reiner J, Berset J, Kannan K. Mass flow of polycyclic musks in two wastewater treatment plants. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol, 2007, 52(4): 451-457

[62] Reiner JL, Wong CM, Arcaro KF, Kannan K. Synthetic musk fragrances in human milk from the United States. Environ Sci Technol, 2007, 41(11): 3815-3820

[63] Reis PJ, Reis AC, Ricken B, Kolvenbach BA, Manaia CM, Corvini PF Biodegradation of sulfamethoxazole and other sulfonamides by Achromobacter denitrificans PR1. J Hazard Mater, 2014, 280: 741-749

[64] Rekhate CV, Srivastava JK. Recent advances in ozone-based advanced oxidation processes for treatment of wastewater: a review. Chem Eng J Adv, 2020, 3: 100031

[65] Richmond EK, Grace MR, Kelly JJ, Reisinger AJ, Rosi EJ, Walters DM Pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) are ecological disrupting compounds (EcoDC). Elementa Sci Anthropocene, 2017

[66] Rodrigo-Comino J, López-Vicente M, Kumar V, Rodríguez-Seijo A, Valkó O, Rojas C Soil science challenges in a new era: a transdisciplinary overview of relevant topics. Air Soil Water Res, 2020, 13: 1178622120977491

[67] Santosa I, Grossmana MJ, Sartorattob A, Ponezib AN, Durranta LR. Degradation of the recalcitrant pharmaceuticals carbamazepine and 17α-ethinylestradiol by ligninolytic fungi. Chem Eng, 2012, 27: 169-174

[68] Simon M, Kumar A, Garg A. Biological treatment of pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) before discharging to environment. Fate Transp Subsurf Pollut, 2021

[69] Snyder SA, Adham S, Redding AM, Cannon FS, DeCarolis J, Oppenheimer J Role of membranes and activated carbon in the removal of endocrine disruptors and pharmaceuticals. Desalination, 2007, 202(1–3): 156-181

[70] Staples C, Friederich U, Hall T, Klečka G, Mihaich E, Ortego L, Caspers N, Hentges S. Estimating potential risks to terrestrial invertebrates and plants exposed to bisphenol A in soil amended with activated sludge biosolids. Environ Toxicol Chem, 2010, 29(2): 467-475

[71] Stumpf M, Ternes TA, Wilken R-D, Rodrigues SV, Baumann W. Polar drug residues in sewage and natural waters in the state of Rio de Janeiro. Brazil Sci Total Environ, 1999, 225(1–2): 135-141

[72] Styszko K, Proctor K, Castrignanò E, Kasprzyk-Hordern B. Occurrence of pharmaceutical residues, personal care products, lifestyle chemicals, illicit drugs and metabolites in wastewater and receiving surface waters of Krakow agglomeration in South Poland. Sci Total Environ, 2021, 768: 144360

[73] Suarez S, Dodd MC, Omil F, von Gunten U. Kinetics of triclosan oxidation by aqueous ozone and consequent loss of antibacterial activity: relevance to municipal wastewater ozonation. Water Res, 2007, 41(12): 2481-2490

[74] Suárez S, Carballa M, Omil F, Lema JM. How are pharmaceutical and personal care products (PPCPs) removed from urban wastewaters?. Rev Environ Sci Bio/technol, 2008, 7(2): 125-138

[75] Tamtam F, Mercier F, Le Bot B, Eurin J, Dinh QT, Clément M, Chevreuil M. Occurrence and fate of antibiotics in the Seine River in various hydrological conditions. Sci Total Environ, 2008, 393(1): 84-95

[76] Teijon G, Candela L, Tamoh K, Molina-Díaz A, Fernández-Alba A. Occurrence of emerging contaminants, priority substances (2008/105/CE) and heavy metals in treated wastewater and groundwater at Depurbaix facility (Barcelona, Spain). Sci Total Environ, 2010, 408(17): 3584-3595

[77] Ternes TA, Meisenheimer M, McDowell D, Sacher F, Brauch H-J, Haist-Gulde B Removal of pharmaceuticals during drinking water treatment. Environ Sci Technol, 2002, 36(17): 3855-3863

[78] Ternes TA, Stüber J, Herrmann N, McDowell D, Ried A, Kampmann M Ozonation: a tool for removal of pharmaceuticals, contrast media and musk fragrances from wastewater?. Water Res, 2003, 37(8): 1976-1982

[79] Touraud E, Roig B, Sumpter JP, Coetsier C. Drug residues and endocrine disruptors in drinking water: risk for humans?. Int J Hyg Environ Health, 2011, 214(6): 437-441

[80] United Nations (2015) Resolution adopted by the General Assembly on 25 September 2015, Transforming our world: the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (A/RES/70/1 Archived 28 November 2020 at the Wayback Machine).

[81] U.S. EPA (US Environmental Protection Agency) (2013) Effluent guidelines-pharmaceutical manufacturing point source category-permit guidance document

[82] Vieno NM, Härkki H, Tuhkanen T, Kronberg L. Occurrence of pharmaceuticals in river water and their elimination in a pilot-scale drinking water treatment plant. Environ Sci Technol, 2007, 41(14): 5077-5084

[83] Vikelsøe J, Thomsen M, Carlsen L. Phthalates and nonylphenols in profiles of differently dressed soils. Sci Total Environ, 2002, 296(1–3): 105-116

[84] Wang Q-J, Mo C-H, Li Y-W, Gao P, Tai Y-P, Zhang Y, Li Ruan Z, Xu J-W. Determination of four fluoroquinolone antibiotics in tap water in Guangzhou and Macao. Environ Pollut, 2010, 158(7): 2350-2358

[85] Wang L, Liao C, Liu F, Wu Q, Guo Y, Moon H-B, Nakata H, Kannan K. Occurrence and human exposure of p-hydroxybenzoic acid esters (parabens), bisphenol A diglycidyl ether (BADGE), and their hydrolysis products in indoor dust from the United States and three East Asian countries. Environ Sci Technol, 2012, 46(21): 11584-11593

[86] Wang Y, Wang X, Li M, Dong J, Sun C, Chen G. Removal of pharmaceutical and personal care products (PPCPs) from municipal waste water with integrated membrane systems, MBR-RO/NF. Int J Environ Res Public Health, 2018, 15(2): 269

[87] Wiegel S, Aulinger A, Brockmeyer R, Harms H, Löffler J, Reincke H, Schmidt R, Stachel B, von Tümpling W, Wanke A. Pharmaceuticals in the river Elbe and its tributaries. Chemosphere, 2004, 57(2): 107-126

[88] Xu J, Wu L, Chen W, Chang AC. Simultaneous determination of pharmaceuticals, endocrine disrupting compounds and hormone in soils by gas chromatography–mass spectrometry. J Chromatogr A, 2008, 1202(2): 189-195

[89] Xu J, Chen W, Wu L, Green R, Chang AC. Leachability of some emerging contaminants in reclaimed municipal wastewater-irrigated turf grass fields. Environ Toxicol Chem Int J, 2009, 28(9): 1842-1850

[90] Xu J, Wu L, Chen W, Chang AC. Leaching potential of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs in soils. Environ Toxicol Chem Int J, 2010, 29(4): 800-807

[91] Yin J, Wang H, Zhang J, Zhou N, Gao F, Wu Y, Xiang J, Shao B. The occurrence of synthetic musks in human breast milk in Sichuan, China. Chemosphere, 2012, 87(9): 1018-1023

[92] Zhang YY, He C, Sharma VK, Li XZ, Tian SH, Xiong Y. A new reactor coupling heterogeneous Fenton-like catalytic oxidation with membrane separation for degradation of organic pollutants. J Chem Technol Biotechnol, 2011, 86(12): 1488-1494

[93] Zhang L, Hu J, Zhu R, Zhou Q, Chen J. Degradation of paracetamol by pure bacterial cultures and their microbial consortium. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 2013, 97(8): 3687-3698