Life cycle assessment of lead-free potassium sodium niobate versus lead zirconate titanate: Energy and environmental impacts

Abstract

Over the years, lead-based piezoelectric ceramics found extensive use in vital fields such as sensors and actuators. Despite their exceptional electromechanical properties, lead-containing materials pose severe environmental risks and foster a new era of lead-free piezoelectric materials after decades of research. However, recent comparative assessments of potassium sodium niobate (KNN) versus lead zirconate titanate (PZT) piezoelectric materials proposed that the environmental damage already presented before use due to raw material extraction and processing, invoking concerns on the true greenness of the lead-free alternatives. Nevertheless, many other factors deserve further consideration, for example, reference geometry and life cycle stage. Herein, the comprehensive life cycle assessment is undertaken on PZT and KNN-based ceramics with a unit volume of 0.001 m³ from cradle to gate. Results show that PZT exhibits higher negative impacts than KNN-based counterparts, attributed to lead extraction, processing, and associated environmental emissions. Across primary quantitative impact indicators from toxicity, environmental, and resource aspects, KNN-based ceramics impose fewer risks on the environment and human health, with the overall impact being only 28% of PZT ceramics. Still, more efficient methods are required for KNN-based ceramics to reduce the high energy consumption and emission during extraction and purification of raw material Nb₂O₅. This work not only offers critical insights for material development but also serves as a multifaceted reference for advanced fabrication technologies.

Keywords

environmental sustainability / lead zirconate titanate / life cycle assessment / potassium sodium niobate

References

[1] Nilius B. Pressing and squeezing with Piezos. EMBO Rep. 2010;11(12):902-903.

[2] M. R. P. Ltd. Piezoelectric Ceramics Market by Type (Barium Titanate, Potassium Niobate, SodiumTungstate, Lead Zirconate Titanate), End user (Consumer Electronics, Industry &Manufacturing, Automotive, Medical), and Region - Global Forecast to 2028. https://www.marketsandmarkets.com/Market-Reports/piezoelectric-ceramics-market-146130307.html. Accessd: September, 2023

[3] Guo Q, Li F, Xia F, et al. Piezoelectric ceramics with high piezoelectricity and broad temperature usage range. J Mater. 2021;7(4):683-692.

[4] (a) Rödel J, Webber KG, Dittmer R, Jo W, Kimura M, Damjanovic D. Transferring lead-free piezoelectric ceramics into application. J Eur Ceram Soc. 2015;35(6):1659-1681. b) Mercury compounds [except (organo) alkyls] (as Hg). https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/idlh/7439976.html. Accessd: December, 2023 (c) Katz SA, Salem H. The toxicology of chromium with respect to its chemical speciation: a review. J Appl Toxicol. 1993;13(3):217-224.

[5] Bell AJ, Deubzer O. Lead-free piezoelectrics—The environmental and regulatory issues. MRS Bull. 2018;43(8):581-587.

[6] Hong C-H, Kim H-P, Choi B-Y, et al. Lead-free piezoceramics – Where to move on? J Mater. 2016;2(1):1-24.

[7] Saito Y, Takao H, Tani T, et al. Lead-free piezoceramics. Nature. 2004;432(7013):84-87.

[8] (a) Li JF, Wang K, Zhu FY, Cheng LQ, Yao FZ. (K,Na) NbO3-based Lead-free piezoceramics: fundamental aspects, processing technologies, and remaining challenges. J Am Ceram Soc. 2013;96(12):3677-3696. b) Koruza J, Bell AJ, Frömling T, Webber KG, Wang K, Rödel J. Requirements for the transfer of lead-free piezoceramics into application. J Mater. 2018;4(1):13-26. c) Wu J, Xiao D, Zhu J. Potassium-sodium niobate Lead-free piezoelectric materials: past, present, and future of phase boundaries. Chem Rev. 2015;115(7):2559-2595. d) Liu YX, Qu W, Thong HC, et al. Isolated-oxygen-vacancy hardening in lead-free piezoelectrics. Adv Mater. 2022;34(29):2202558.

[9] (a) Shibata K, Wang R, Tou T, Koruza J. Applications of lead-free piezoelectric materials. MRS Bull. 2018;43(8):612-616. b) Kawada S, Hayashi H, Ishii H, et al. Potassium sodium Niobate-based lead-free piezoelectric multi-layer ceramics Co-fired with nickel electrodes. Materials. 2015;8(11):7423-7438.

[10] Research B. Lead-free piezoelectric ceramics: technologies and global opportunities. https://www.bccresearch.com/market-research/nanotechnology/lead-free-piezoelectric-ceramics-market-report.html. Accessd: October, 2023

[11] Rudnick SGRL. Treatise on Geochemistry. Vol 3. USA: Elsevier; 2003.

[12] Schulz KJ, Papp JF. Niobium and Tantalum: Indispensable Twins. Reston, VA, USA: U.S. Geological Survey; 2014.

[13] Miller GL. Tantalum and niobium. USA: Literary Licensing, LLC; 2013.

[14] Ibn-Mohammed T, Koh S, Reaney I, et al. Are lead-free piezoelectrics more environmentally friendly? MRS Commun. 2017;7(1):1-7.

[15] Osorio-Tejada JL, Ferlin F, Vaccaro L, Hessel V. The sustainability impact of Nobel prize chemistry: life cycle assessment of C–C cross-coupling reactions. Green Chem. 2023;25(23):9760-9778.

[16] Ibn-Mohammed T, Koh S, Reaney I, et al. Integrated hybrid life cycle assessment and supply chain environmental profile evaluations of lead-based (lead zirconate titanate) versus lead-free (potassium sodium niobate) piezoelectric ceramics. Energy Environ Sci. 2016;9(11):3495-3520.

[17] Ibn-Mohammed T, Reaney IM, Koh SCL, et al. Life cycle assessment and environmental profile evaluation of lead-free piezoelectrics in comparison with lead zirconate titanate. J Eur Ceram Soc. 2018;38(15):4922-4938.

[18] Rödel J, Frisch A, Damjanovic D. The scientists' responsibility in communicating the sustainability crisis. J Mater Sci. 2023;58(40):15577-15587.

[19] H. S. Co.Ltd. The production process of piezoelectric ceramics – Several ways of the upper electrode. https://www.he-shuai.com/the-production-process-of-piezoelectric-ceramics-several-ways-of-the-upper-electrode/. Accessd: September, 2023

[20] Wong J. Principles and applications of piezoceramics. https://www.bjultrasonic.com/piezoelectric-ceramic-technical. Accessd: October, 2023

[21] Li J-F. Lead-Free Piezoelectric Materials. China: John Wiley & Sons; 2020.

[22] Editorial. Nat Mater. 2023.

[23] Standard I. Environmental management, Vol. ISO 14044. 2006.

[24] Lu Y-Q, Li Y-X. A review on lead-free piezoelectric ceramics studies in China. J Adv Dielectr. 2011;1(3):269-288.

[25] Thong H-C, Zhao C, Zhou Z, et al. Technology transfer of lead-free (K, Na)NbO₃-based piezoelectric ceramics. Mater Today. 2019;29:37-48.

[26] (a) Erhart J. Bulk piezoelectric ceramic transformers. Adv Appl Ceram. 2013;112(2):91-96. b) Chure M-C, Wu L, Wu K-K, Tung C-C, Lin J-S, Ma W-C. Power generation characteristics of PZT piezoelectric ceramics using drop weight impact techniques: Effect of dimensional size. Ceram Int. 2014;40(1):341-345.

[27] (a) Bjørn A, Moltesen A, Laurent A, et al. Life cycle inventory analysis. In: Hauschild MZ, Rosenbaum RK, Olsen SI, eds. Life Cycle Assessment: Theory and Practice. Springer; 2018:117-165. b) Islam S, Ponnambalam S, Lam HL. Review on life cycle inventory: methods, examples and applications. J Clean Prod. 2016;136:266-278.

[28] (a) I. E. T. C. Ltd. Chinese reference life cycle database. http://www.ike-global.com. Accessd: September, 2023 (b) Liu X, Wang H, Chen J, et al. Method and basic model for development of Chinese reference life cycle database. Acta Scien Circum. 2010;30(10):2136-2144.

[29] Hu B. Domestic literature review and the latest overseas research progress of life cycle assessment. Sci Tech Prog Pol. 2013;30(8):155-160.

[30] (a) L. Tianjin Universal Piezo Co. Wuqing District People's Government, Tianjin, China. 2020. (b) Frischknecht R, Jungbluth N, Althaus H-J, et al. The ecoinvent database: overview and methodological framework. Int J Life Cycle Assess. 2005;10:3-9.

[31] Chiang S. Lawrence Berkeley Nat. Lab. 1981.

[32] Kwestroo W, Huizing A. The preparation of ultra pure lead oxide. J Inorg Nucl Chem. 1965;27(9):1951-1954.

[33] (a) Kenichi Nada KO, Kida M. Europe Patent WO2002062724A3. 2021. (b) Birol H, Damjanovic D, Setter N. Preparation and characterization of (K_0.5Na_0.5)NbO₃ ceramics. J Eur Ceram Soc. 2006;26(6):861-866.

[34] Linnen R, Trueman DL, Burt R. Tantalum and niobium. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd; 2014.

[35] L. Tsingfeng Technology Co. Nanhu District People's Government, Jiaxing, China. 2018.

[36] Hauschild MZ, Rosenbaum RK, Olsen SI. Life cycle assessment. Switzerland: Springer Nature; 2018.

[37] (a) Rödel J, Jo W, Seifert KT, Anton EM, Granzow T, Damjanovic D. Perspective on the development of lead-free piezoceramics. J Am Ceram Soc. 2009;92(6):1153-1177. b) Cross E. Lead-free at last. Nature. 2004;432(7013):24-25.

[38] Kamiya M, Sasai R, Itoh H, Ceram J. Recovery of lead in lead zirconate titanate ceramics by wet ball mill with acidic solution. Soc Jpn. 2003;111(1299):806-810.

[39] Ma C, Shu Y, Chen H. Preparation of high-purity lead oxide from spent lead paste by low temperature burning and hydrometallurgical processing with ammonium acetate solution. RSC Adv. 2016;6(25):21148-21155.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2024 2024 The Authors. EcoMat published by The Hong Kong Polytechnic University and John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd.