Recent advances in transition metal electrocatalysts for effective nitrogen reduction reaction under ambient conditions

Abstract

As one of the world’s largest chemical products, ammonia (NH₃) plays a vital role in the industry, agricultural production, and national defense. In modern industry, NH₃ is produced primarily through the high-temperature highpressure Haber-Bosch process, which consumes large amounts of energy and releases large amounts of greenhouse gases. Electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) under ambient conditions has been widely considered among many nitrogen fixation methods, which can be produced using renewable energy. However, the main challenge is to achieve both high NH₃ yield and Faraday efficiency, which is attributed to the strong N ≡ N bond and serious hydrogen evolution reaction. Based on the key problems, this review discussed the transition metal (TM) catalysts, including alloys, TM oxides, TM sulfides, TM carbides, and strategies for tuning the electronic structure, regulating the morphology, and bimetallic synergistic effect on improving the NRR performance. Moreover, this review also summarized the NH₃ detection methods and the reliable control experimental parameters in the NRR process to obtain accurate experimental results. Finally, the challenges and future directions of TM catalysts for NRR are considered, emphasizing the available opportunities by following the giving principles.

Keywords

NH ₃ detection methods / nitrogen reduction reaction / transition metal electrocatalysts

References

[1] ShipmanMA, SymesMD. Recent progress towards the electrosynthesis of ammonia from sustainable resources. Catal Today. 2017;286(15):57-68.

[2] ZhuD, ZhangL, RutherRE, Hamers RJ. Photo-illuminated diamond as a solid-state source of solvated electrons in water for nitrogen reduction. Nat Mater. 2013;12(9):836-841.

[3] RouxY, DubocC, GennariM. Molecular catalysts for N₂ reduction: state of the art, mechanism, and challenges. ChemPhysChem. 2017;18(19):2606-2617.

[4] SuryantoBHR, KangCSM, WangD, et al. Rational electrodeelectrolyte design for efficient ammonia electrosynthesis under ambient conditions. ACS Energy Lett. 2018;3(6):1219-1224.

[5] GuoC, RanJ, VasileffA, Qiao S-Z. Rational design of electrocatalysts and photo(electro)catalysts for nitrogen reduction to ammonia (NH₃) under ambient conditions. Energy Environ Sci. 2018;11(1):45-56.

[6] SongP, WangH, KangL, Ran B, SongH, WangR. Electrochemical nitrogen reduction to ammonia at ambient conditions on nitrogen and phosphorus co-doped porous carbon. Chem Commun. 2019;55(5):687-690.

[7] NiuL, WangD, XuK, et al. Tuning the performance of nitrogen reduction reaction by balancing the reactivity of N₂ and the desorption of NH₃. Nano Res. 2021;14(11):4093-4099.

[8] GuoX, DuH, QuF, LiJ. Recent progress in electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction. J Mater Chem A. 2019;7(8):3531-3543.

[9] GiddeyS, BadwalSPS, MunningsC, Dolan M. Ammonia as a renewable energy transportation media. ACS Sustainable Chem Eng. 2017;5(11):10231-10239.

[10] WangS, Ichihara F, PangH, ChenH, YeJ. Nitrogen fixation reaction derived from nanostructured catalytic materials. Adv Funct Mater. 2018;28(50):1803309.

[11] NiuL, AnL, WangX, Sun Z. Effect on electrochemical reduction of nitrogen to ammonia under ambient conditions: challenges and opportunities for chemical fuels. J Energy Chem. 2021;61:304-318.

[12] QinB, LiY, ZhangQ, Yang G, LiangH, PengF. Understanding of nitrogen fixation electro catalyzed by molybdenum-iron carbide through the experiment and theory. Nano Energy. 2020;68:104374.

[13] LiangJ, LiZ, ZhangL, et al. Advances in ammonia electrosynthesis from ambient nitrate/nitrite reduction. Chem. 2023;9(7):1768-1827.

[14] LiuQ, LinY, GuS, et al. Enhanced N₂-to-NH₃ conversion efficiency on Cu₃P nanoribbon electrocatalyst. Nano Res. 2022;15(8):7134-7138.

[15] LiuQ, XuT, LuoY, et al. Recent advances in strategies for highly selective electrocatalytic N₂ reduction toward ambient NH₃ synthesis. Curr Opin Electrochem. 2021;29:100766.

[16] MushtaqMA, KumarA, LiuW, et al. A metal coordination number determined catalytic performance in manganese borides for ambient electrolysis of nitrogen to ammonia. Adv Mater. 2024:36(21):2313086.

[17] FosterSL, Bakovic SIP, DudaRD, et al. Catalysts for nitrogen reduction to ammonia. Nat Catal. 2018;1(7):490-500.

[18] MontoyaJH, TsaiC, VojvodicA, Nrskov JK. The challenge of electrochemical ammonia synthesis: a new perspective on the role of nitrogen scaling relations. ChemSusChem. 2015;8(13):2180-2186.

[19] HoffmanBM, Lukoyanov D, YangZ-Y, DeanDR, Seefeldt LC. Mechanism of nitrogen fixation by nitrogenase: the next stage. Chem Rev. 2014;114(8):4041-4062.

[20] KeableSM, Zadvornyy OA, JohnsonLE, et al. Structural characterization of the P¹⁺ intermediate state of the P-cluster of nitrogenase. J Biol Chem. 2018;293(25):9629-9635.

[21] ZhaoJ, ChenZ. Single Mo atom supported on defective boron nitride monolayer as an efficient electrocatalyst for nitrogen fixation: a computational study. J Am Chem Soc. 2017;139(36):12480-12487.

[22] LiuC, LiQ, WuC, et al. Single-boron catalysts for nitrogen reduction reaction. J Am Chem Soc. 2019;141(7):2884-2888.

[23] LiX-F, LiQ-K, ChengJ, et al. Conversion of dinitrogen to ammonia by FeN₃-embedded graphene. J Am Chem Soc. 2016;138(28):8706-8709.

[24] MiltonRD, Abdellaoui S, KhadkaN, et al. Nitrogenase bioelectrocatalysis: heterogeneous ammonia and hydrogen production by MoFe protein. Energy Environ Sci. 2016;9(8):2550-2554.

[25] MouT, LongJ, FrauenheimT, Xiao J. Advances in electrochemical ammonia synthesis beyond the use of nitrogen gas as a source. Chempluschem. 2021;86(8):1211-1224.

[26] GaoW, XieK, XieJ, et al. Alloying of Cu with Ru enabling the relay catalysis for reduction of nitrate to ammonia. Adv Mater. 2023;35(19):2202952.

[27] WangL, XiaM, WangH, et al. Greening ammonia toward the solar ammonia refinery. Joule. 2018;2(6):1055-1074.

[28] LiuY, ChenS, XieQ, YuH. Efficient electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide to acetate on nitrogen-doped nanodiamond. J Am Chem Soc. 2015;137(36):11631-11636.

[29] MengF, ZhongH, BaoD, YanJ, ZhangX. In situ coupling of strung Co₄N and intertwined N-C fibers toward free-standing bifunctional cathode for robust, efficient, and flexible Zn-air batteries. J Am Chem Soc. 2016;138(32):10226-10231.

[30] ZhongH, WangJ, MengF, Zhang X. In situ activating ubiquitous rust towards low-cost, efficient, free-standing, and recoverable oxygen evolution electrodes. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2016;55(34):9937-9941.

[31] ZhongX, YuanE, YangF, et al. Optimizing oxygen vacancies through grain boundary engineering to enhance electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2023;120(40):e2306673120.

[32] BanerjeeA, YuhasBD, MarguliesEA, et al. Photochemical nitrogen conversion to ammonia in ambient conditions with FeMoS-chalcogels. J Am Chem Soc. 2015;137(5):2030-2034.

[33] ChenX, ZhangX, LiY-H. et al. Transition metal doping BiOBr nanosheets with oxygen vacancy and exposed {102} facets for visible light nitrogen fixation. Appl Catal B Environ. 2021;281:119516.

[34] ShiL, YinY, WangS, Sun H. Rational catalyst design for N₂ reduction under ambient conditions: strategies toward enhanced conversion efficiency. ACS Catal. 2020;10(12):6870-6899.

[35] LvX-W, WengC-C, YuanZ-Y. Ambient ammonia electrosynthesis: current status, challenges, and perspectives. ChemSusChem. 2020;13(12):3061-3078.

[36] SkúlasonE, Bligaard T, GudmundsdóttirS, et al. A theoretical evaluation of possible transition metal electrocatalysts for N₂ reduction. Phys Chem Chem Phys. 2012;14(3):1235-1245.

[37] ChengH, DingL-X, ChenG-F, Zhang L, XueJ, WangH. Molybdenum carbide nanodots enable efficient electrocatalytic nitrogen fixation under ambient conditions. Adv Mater. 2018;30(46):e1803694.

[38] ZhangX, WangJ, JinH, WangS, SongW. Bioinspired supramolecular lubricating hydrogel induced by shear force. J Am Chem Soc. 2018;140(9):3186-3189.

[39] FalconeM, Barluzzi L, AndrezJ, et al. The role of bridging ligands in dinitrogen reduction and functionalization by uranium multimetallic complexes. Nat Chem. 2019;11(2):154-160.

[40] PoolJA, Lobkovsky E, ChirikPJ. Hydrogenation and cleavage of dinitrogen to ammonia with a zirconium complex. Nature. 2004;427(6974):527-530.

[41] DengJ, Iñiguez JA, LiuC. Electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction at low temperature. Joule. 2018;2(5):846-856.

[42] van der HamCJM, KoperMTM, HetterscheidDGH. Challenges in reduction of dinitrogen by proton and electron transfer. Chem Soc Rev. 2014;43(15):5183-5191.

[43] OuyangL, LiangJ, LuoY, et al. Recent advances in electrocatalytic ammonia synthesis. Chin J Catal. 2023;50:6-44.

[44] ZhangH, WangH, CaoX, et al. Unveiling cutting-edge developments in electrocatalytic nitrate-to-ammonia conversion. Adv Mater. 2024;36(16):2312746.

[45] ZhengY, JiaoY, ZhuY, et al. Hydrogen evolution by a metal-free electrocatalyst. Nat Commun. 2014;5(1):3783.

[46] ZhangY, QiuW, MaY, et al. High-performance electrohydrogenation of N₂ to NH₃ catalyzed by multishelled hollow Cr₂O₃ microspheres under ambient conditions. ACS Catal. 2018;8(9):8540-8544.

[47] QinQ, ZhaoY, SchmalleggerM, et al. Enhanced electrocatalytic N₂ reduction via partial anion substitution in titanium oxide-carbon composites. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2019;58(37):13101-13106.

[48] LiC, MaD, MouS, et al. Porous LaFeO₃ nanofiber with oxygen vacancies as an efficient electrocatalyst for N₂ conversion to NH₃ under ambient conditions. J Energy Chem. 2020;50:402-408.

[49] XuT, MaD, LiC, et al. Ambient electrochemical NH₃ synthesis from N₂ and water enabled by ZrO₂ nanoparticles. Chem Commun. 2020;56(25):3673-3676.

[50] ZhuX, LiuZ, WangH, et al. Boosting electrocatalytic N₂ reduction to NH₃ on β-FeOOH by fluorine doping. Chem Commun. 2019;55(27):3987-3990.

[51] LiL, ChenG, ShaoZ, Huang H. Progress on smart integrated systems of seawater purification and electrolysis. Energy Environ Sci. 2023;16(11):4994-5002.

[52] LégaréM-A, Bélanger-ChabotG, DewhurstRD, et al. Nitrogen fixation and reduction at boron. Science. 2018;359(6378):896.

[53] DahchehF, MartinD, StephanDW, Bertrand G. Synthesis and reactivity of a CAAC-aminoborylene adduct: a hetero-allene or an organoboron isoelectronic with singlet carbenes. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2014;53(48):13159-13163.

[54] EdelK, KriegM, GroteD, Bettinger HF. Photoreactions of phenylborylene with dinitrogen and carbon monoxide. J Am Chem Soc. 2017;139(42):15151-15159.

[55] WuTT, FanWJ, ZhangY, Zhang FX. Electrochemical synthesis of ammonia: progress and challenges. Mater Today Phys. 2021;16:100310.

[56] KimC, SongJ-Y, ChoiC, et al. Atomic-scale homogeneous Ru-Cu alloy nanoparticles for highly efficient electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction. Adv Mater. 2022;34(40):2205270.

[57] PangY, SuC, JiaG, XuL, ShaoZ. Emerging two-dimensional nanomaterials for electrochemical nitrogen reduction. Chem Soc Rev. 2021;50(22):12744-12787.

[58] XiaX, LiB, LiuS, TangB. Recent advances and challenges in 2D metal-free electrocatalysts for N₂ fixation. Front Chem. 2020;8:437.

[59] RenY, YuC, TanX, et al. Strategies to activate inert nitrogen molecules for efficient ammonia electrosynthesis: current status, challenges, and perspectives. Energy Environ Sci. 2022;15(7):2776-2805.

[60] YangJ-H, PengM, ZhaiD-D, et al. Fixation of N₂ into valueadded organic chemicals. ACS Catal. 2022;12(5):2898-2906.

[61] CarroP, ChoiJ, MacFarlaneDR, SimonovAN, Doña-Rodríguez JM, AzofraLM. Competition between metalcatalysed electroreduction of dinitrogen, protons, and nitrogen oxides: a DFT perspective. Catal Sci Technol. 2022;12(9):2856-2864.

[62] BallB, DasP, SarkarP. Molybdenum atom-mediated salphen-based covalent organic framework as a promising electrocatalyst for the nitrogen reduction reaction: a firstprinciples study. J Phys Chem C. 2021;125(47):26061-26072.

[63] CuiX, TangC, ZhangQ. A review of electrocatalytic reduction of dinitrogen to ammonia under ambient conditions. Adv Energy Mater. 2018;8(22):1800369.

[64] KimM-C, NamH, ChoiJ, et al. Hydrogen bonding-mediated enhancement of bioinspired electrochemical nitrogen reduction on Cu_2-xS catalysts. ACS Catal. 2020;10(18):10316-10802.

[65] LvS-Y, HuangC-X, LiG, YangL-M. Electrocatalytic mechanism of N₂ reduction reaction by single-atom catalyst rectangular TM-TCNQ monolayers. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces. 2021;13(25):29641-29653.

[66] WangXX, Swihart MT, WuG. Achievements, challenges and perspectives on cathode catalysts in proton exchange membrane fuel cells for transportation. Nat Catal. 2019;2(7):578-589.

[67] XinY, LiS, QianY, et al. High-entropy alloys as a platform for catalysis: progress, challenges, and opportunities. ACS Catal. 2020;10(19):11280-11306.

[68] XinH, Vojvodic A, VossJ, NørskovJK, Abild-Pedersen F. Effects of d-band shape on the surface reactivity of transitionmetal alloys. Phys Rev B. 2014;89(11):115114.

[69] DingZ-B, WuF, WangY-C, Jiang H. Theoretical studies of the work functions of Pd-based bimetallic surfaces. J Chem Phys. 2015;142(21):214706.

[70] LongR, LiY, LiuY, et al. Isolation of Cu toms in Pd lattice: forming highly selective sites for photocatalytic conversion of CO₂ to CH₄. J Am Chem Soc. 2017;139(12):4486-4492.

[71] ZhangA, LiangY, ZhangH, Geng Z, ZengJ. Doping regulation in transition metal compounds for electrocatalysis. Chem Soc Rev. 2021;50(17):9817-9844.

[72] LiuZ, TeeSY, GuanG, Han M-Y. Atomically substitutional engineering of transition metal dichalcogenide layers for enhancing tailored properties and superior applications. Nano-Micro Lett. 2024;16(1):95.

[73] ZhouJ, ChenX, GuoM, HuW, HuangB, Yuan D. Enhanced catalytic activity of bimetallic ordered catalysts for nitrogen reduction reaction by perturbation of scaling relations. ACS Catal. 2023;13(4):2190-2201.

[74] ZhouHY, QuYB, FanYC, et al. Multi-site intermetallic Ni₃Mo effectively boosts selective ammonia synthesis. Appl Catal B Environ. 2023;339:123133.

[75] LeeY, KimSJ, KimYJ, et al. Oxidation-resistant titanium carbide MXene films. J Mater Chem A. 2020;8(2):573-581.

[76] NierengartenJ, HoukKN, DingK. Front cover: a journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step (Chem. Eur. J. 67/2020). Chem Eur J. 2020;26(67):15339.

[77] WangX, LuoM, LanJ, PengM, TanY. Nanoporous intermetallic Pd₃Bi for efficient electrochemical nitrogen reduction. Adv Mater. 2021;33(18):2007733.

[78] ZhangD, ZhaoH, WuX, et al. Multi-site electrocatalysts boost pH-universal nitrogen reduction by high-entropy alloys. Adv Funct Mater. 2021;31(9):2006939.

[79] GengZ, LiuY, KongX, et al. N₂ electrochemical reduction: achieving a record-high yield rate of 120.9 µg NH₃ mg_cat.^-1 h^-1 for N₂ electrochemical reduction over Ru single-atom catalysts (Adv. Mater. 40/2018). Adv Mater. 2018;30(40):1870301.

[80] WangXX, CullenDA, PanYT, et al. Nitrogen-coordinated single cobalt atom catalysts for oxygen reduction in proton exchange membrane fuel cells. Adv Mater. 2018;30(11):1706758.

[81] JiS, ChenY, ZhaoS, et al. Atomically dispersed ruthenium species inside metal-organic frameworks: combining the high activity of atomic sites and the molecular sieving effect of MOFs. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2019;58(13):4271-4275.

[82] ChuK, LiuY-p, LiY-b, Zhang H, TianY. Efficient electrocatalytic N₂ reduction on CoO quantum dots. J Mater Chem A. 2019;7(9):4389-4394.

[83] GuH, LiJ, NiuX, et al. Symmetry-breaking p-block antimony single atoms trigger N-bridged titanium sites for electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction with high efficiency. ACS Nano. 2023;17(21):21838-21849.

[84] LiS, ZhouY, LiK, et al. Electrosynthesis of ammonia with high selectivity and high rates via engineering of the solidelectrolyte interphase. Joule. 2022;6(9):2083-2101.

[85] LiuG, NiuL, MaZ, et al. Fe₂Mo₃O₈/XC-72 electrocatalyst for enhanced electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reaction under ambient conditions. Nano Res. 2022;15(7):5940-5945.

[86] XieM, DaiF, GuoH, et al. Improving electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction selectivity and yield by suppressing hydrogen evolution reaction via electronic metal-support interaction. Adv Energy Mater. 2023;13(21):2203032.

[87] SunY, HanY, ZhangX, et al. TiO_1.8 with lattice H for effective electrocatalytic nitrogen fixation. Appl Catal B Environ. 2022;319:121933.

[88] LiS-J, BaoD, ShiM-M. Wulan B-R, Yan J-M. Jiang Q. Amorphizing of Au nanoparticles by CeO_x-RGO hybrid support towards highly efficient electrocatalyst for N₂ reduction under ambient conditions. Adv Mater. 2017;29(33):1700001.

[89] YaoJ, ZhouY, YanJ-M. Jiang Q. Regulating Fe₂(MoO₄)₃ by Au nanoparticles for efficient N₂ electroreduction under ambient conditions. Adv Energy Mater. 2021;11(14):2003701.

[90] LiuZ, HuJ, GaoF, CaoH, ZhouQ, Wang X. Biodegradable and resilient poly (propylene carbonate) based foam from high pressure CO₂ foaming. Polym Degrad Stabil. 2019;165:12-19.

[91] WangX, LiM, ChangZ, Yang Y, WuY, LiuX. Co₃O₄@MWCNT nanocable as cathode with superior electrochemical performance for supercapacitors. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces. 2015;7(4):2280-2285.

[92] WenJ, ChangH, HuangT, et al. A simple synthesis of Co₃O₄@CNT to boost electrochemical nitrogen fixation. Electrochim Acta. 2021;367:137421.

[93] LiuY, LuoY, LiQ, WangJ, ChuK. Bimetallic MnMoO₄ with dual-active-centers for highly efficient electrochemical N₂ fixation. Chem Commun. 2020;56(70):10227-10230.

[94] ChuK, LiQ-Q, ChengY-H, Liu Y-P. Efficient electrocatalytic nitrogen fixation on FeMoO₄ nanorods. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces. 2020;12(10):11789-11796.

[95] AhmedMI, ChenS, RenW, ChenX, ZhaoC. Synergistic bimetallic CoFe₂O₄ clusters supported on graphene for ambient electrocatalytic reduction of nitrogen to ammonia. Chem Commun. 2019;55(81):12184-12187.

[96] QinM, LiX, GanG, et al. Boosting electrocatalytic nitrogen fixation with Co-N₃ site-decorated porous carbon. ACS Sustainable Chem Eng. 2020;8(35):13430-13439.

[97] WanY, ZhouH, ZhengM, et al. Oxidation state modulation of bismuth for efficient electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction to ammonia. Adv Funct Mater. 2021;31(30):2100300.

[98] FeiH, LiuR, WangJ, et al. Targeted modulation of competitive active sites toward nitrogen fixation via sulfur vacancy engineering over MoS₂. Adv Funct Mater. 2023;33(36):2302501.

[99] FeiH, LiuR, WangJ, et al. Unveiling the competitive behavior by the orientated regulation of S-vacancy over MoS₂ for highly effective N₂ fixation. Chem Eng J. 2023;476:146895.

[100] NiuL, LiuZ, LiuG, et al. Surface hydrophobic modification enhanced catalytic performance of electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction. Nano Res. 2022;15(5):3886-3893.

[101] ChenJ, KangY, ZhangW, et al. Lattice-confined single-atom Fe₁S_x on mesoporous TiO₂ for boosting ambient electrocatalytic N₂ reduction reaction. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2022;61(27):e202203022.

[102] HouY, Laursen AB, ZhangJ, et al. Layered nanojunctions for hydrogen-evolution catalysis. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2013;52(13):3621-3625.

[103] HuS, ChenX, LiQ, ZhaoY, MaoW. Effect of sulfur vacancies on the nitrogen photofixation performance of ternary metal sulfide photocatalysts. Catal Sci Technol. 2016;6(15):5884-5890.

[104] KyriakouV, Garagounis I, VasileiouE, VourrosA, Stoukides M. Progress in the electrochemical synthesis of ammonia. Catal Today. 2017;286:2-13.

[105] ZhangL, JiX, RenX, et al. Electrochemical ammonia synthesis via nitrogen reduction reaction on a MoS₂ catalyst: theoretical and experimental studies. Adv Mater. 2018;30(28):1800191.

[106] YeH, WangL, DengS, et al. Amorphous MoS₃ infiltrated with carbon nanotubes as an advanced anode material of sodium-ion batteries with large gravimetric, areal, and volumetric capacities. Adv Energy Mater. 2017;7(5):1601602.

[107] ChuK, NanH, LiQ, GuoY, TianY, Liu W. Amorphous MoS₃ enriched with sulfur vacancies for efficient electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction. J Energy Chem. 2021;53:132-138.

[108] ChuK, LiuY-p, ChengY-h, Li Q-q. Synergistic borondopants and boron-induced oxygen vacancies in MnO₂ nanosheets to promote electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction. J Mater Chem A. 2020;8(10):5200-5208.

[109] ChuK, WangJ, LiuY-p, Li Q-q, GuoY-l. Mo-doped SnS₂ with enriched S-vacancies for highly efficient electrocatalytic N₂ reduction: the critical role of the Mo-Sn-Sn trimer. J Mater Chem A. 2020;8(15):7117-7124.

[110] WangJ, NanH, TianY, Chu K. FeMo₃S₄ for efficient nitrogen reduction reaction. ACS Sustainable Chem Eng. 2020;8(20):7536-7750.

[111] CaoN, ChenZ, ZangK, et al. Doping strain induced bi-Ti³⁺ pairs for efficient N₂ activation and electrocatalytic fixation. Nat Commun. 2019;10:2877.

[112] WuT, ZhuX, XingZ, et al. Greatly improving electrochemical N₂ reduction over TiO₂ nanoparticles by iron doping. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2019;58(51):18449-18453.

[113] LiC, YuJ, YangL, et al. Spinel LiMn₂O₄ nanofiber: an efficient electrocatalyst for N₂ reduction to NH₃ under ambient conditions. Inorg Chem. 2019;58(15):9597-9601.

[114] YuJ, LiC, LiB, et al. A perovskite La₂Ti₂O₇ nanosheet as an efficient electrocatalyst for artificial N₂ fixation to NH₃ in acidic media. Chem Commun. 2019;55:6401-6404.

[115] WangZ, GongF, ZhangL, et al. Electrocatalytic hydrogenation of N₂ to NH₃ by MnO: experimental and theoretical investigations. Adv Sci. 2019;6(1):1801182.

[116] ChuK, LiuY-p, LiY-b, Guo Y-l, TianY, ZhangH. Multifunctional Mo-doping in MnO₂ nanoflowers toward efficient and robust electrocatalytic nitrogen fixation. Appl Catal B Environ. 2020;264:118525.

[117] ZhaoR, ChenY, XiangH, et al. Two-dimensional ordered double-transition metal carbides for the electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces. 2023;15(5):6797-6806.

[118] WeiH, JiangQ, AmpelliC, et al. Enhancing N₂ fixation activity by converting Ti₃C₂ MXenes nanosheets to nanoribbons. ChemSusChem. 2020;13(21):5614-5619.

[119] QiuW, XieX-Y, QiuJ, et al. High-performance artificial nitrogen fixation at ambient conditions using a metal-free electrocatalyst. Nat Commun. 2018;9(1):3485.

[120] MaY, YangT, ZouH, et al. Synergizing Mo single atoms and Mo₂C nanoparticles on CNTs synchronizes selectivity and activity of electrocatalytic N₂ reduction to ammonia. Adv Mater. 2020;32(33):2002177.

[121] XiaJ, YangS-Z, WangB, et al. Boosting electrosynthesis of ammonia on surface-engineered MXene Ti₃C₂. Nano Energy. 2020;72:104681.

[122] LiQ, QiuS, HeL, ZhangX, SunC. Impact of H-termination on the nitrogen reduction reaction of molybdenum carbide as an electrochemical catalyst. Phys Chem Chem Phys. 2018;20:23338-23343.

[123] RenX, ZhaoJ, WeiQ, et al. High-performance N₂-to-NH₃ conversion electrocatalyzed by Mo₂C nanorod. ACS Cent Sci. 2019;5(1):116-121.

[124] LiuX, JiaoY, ZhengY, Jaroniec M, QiaoS-Z. Building up a picture of the electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction activity of transition metal single-atom catalysts. J Am Chem Soc. 2019;141(24):9664-9672.

[125] SunT, XuL, WangD, Li Y. Metal organic frameworks derived single atom catalysts for electrocatalytic energy conversion. Nano Res. 2019;12(9):2067-2080.

[126] AndersenSZ, Čolić V, YangS, et al. A rigorous electrochemical ammonia synthesis protocol with quantitative isotope measurements. Nature. 2019;570(7762):504-508.

[127] WangQ, ZhengG, HaoS, et al. Au₁CO₁ alloy supported on graphene oxide with enhanced performance for ambient electrolysis of nitrogen to ammonia. ACS Sustainable Chem Eng. 2020;8(1):44-49.

[128] DengK, XuY, XueH, LiX, WangL, Wang H. Ambient nitrogen reduction to ammonia electrocatalyzed by bimetallic PdRu porous nanostructures. ACS Sustainable Chem Eng. 2019;7(2):2400-2405.

[129] BaiJ, HuangH, LiF-M. et al. Glycerol oxidation assisted electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction: ammonia and glyceraldehyde co-production on bimetallic RhCu ultrathin nanoflake nanoaggregates. J Mater Chem A. 2019;7(37):21149-21156.

[130] KumarRD, WangZ, LiC, et al. Trimetallic PdCuIr with longspined sea-urchin-like morphology for ambient electroreduction of nitrogen to ammonia. J Mater Chem A. 2019;7:3190-3196.

[131] FangZ, WuP, QianY, Yu G. Gel-derived amorphous bismuth-nickel alloy promotes electrocatalytic nitrogen fixation via optimizing nitrogen adsorption and activation. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2021;60(8):4275-4281.

[132] GuoY, ChengY, LiQ, ChuK. FeTe₂ as an earth-abundant metal telluride catalyst for electrocatalytic nitrogen fixation. J Energy Chem. 2021;56:259-263.

[133] GuoX, LiXY, LiYC, et al. Molecule template method for precise synthesis of Mo-based alloy clusters and electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction on partially reduced PtMo alloy oxide cluster. Nano Energy. 2020;78:105211.

[134] ArifM, KumarA, Asim MushtaqM, et al. Edge-hosted CoFeB active sites with graphene nanosheets for highly selective nitrogen reduction reaction towards ambient ammonia synthesis. Chem Eng J. 2023;473:145368.

[135] ShiMM, BaoD, WulanBR, et al. Au sub-nanoclusters on TiO₂ toward highly efficient and selective electrocatalyst for N₂ conversion to NH₃ at ambient conditions. Adv Mater. 2017;29(17):1606550.

[136] ZhangJ, JiY, WangP, Shao Q, LiY, HuangX. Adsorbing and activating N₂ on heterogeneous Au-Fe₃O₄ nanoparticles for N₂ fixation. Adv Funct Mater. 2020;30(4):1906579.

[137] XiangX, WangZ, ShiX, FanM, SunX. Ammonia synthesis from electrocatalytic N₂ reduction under ambient conditions by Fe₂O₃ nanorods. ChemCatChem. 2018;10(20):4530-4535.

[138] HanJ, JiX, RenX, et al. MoO₃ nanosheets for efficient electrocatalytic N₂ fixation to NH₃. J Mater Chem A. 2018;6(27):12974-12977.

[139] TanH, JiQ, WangC, et al. Asymmetrical π back-donation of hetero-dicationic Mo⁴⁺-Mo⁶⁺ pairs for enhanced electrochemical nitrogen reduction. Nano Res. 2022;15(4):3010-3016.

[140] WangH, ZhangC, LiuB, et al. Tuning surface potential polarization to enhance N₂ affinity for ammonia electrosynthesis. Adv Mater. 2024:2401032.

[141] ZhaoX, LanX, YuD, FuH, LiuZ, MuT. Deep eutecticsolvothermal synthesis of nanostructured Fe₃S₄ for electrochemical N₂ fixation under ambient conditions. Chem Commun. 2018;54(92):13010-13013.

[142] LiuY, HanM, XiongQ, et al. Dramatically enhanced ambient ammonia electrosynthesis performance by inoperando created Li-S interactions on MoS₂ electrocatalyst. Adv Energy Mater. 2019;9(14):1803935.

[143] GuoY, YaoZ, TimmerBJJ, et al. Boosting nitrogen reduction reaction by bio-inspired FeMoS containing hybrid electrocatalyst over a wide pH range. Nano Energy. 2019;62:282-288.

[144] LuoY, ShenP, LiX, GuoY, ChuK. Sulfur-deficient Bi₂S_3-x synergistically coupling Ti₃C₂T_x-MXene for boosting electrocatalytic N₂ reduction. Nano Res. 2022;15(5):3991-3999.

[145] MushtaqMA, KumarA, YasinG, et al. Multivalent sulfur vacancy-rich NiCo₂S₄@MnO₂ urchin-like heterostructures for ambient electrochemical N₂ reduction to NH₃. Small. 2024;2310431.

[146] ChengH, DingLX, ChenGF, Zhang L, XueJ, WangH. Nitrogen reduction reaction: molybdenum carbide nanodots enable efficient electrocatalytic nitrogen fixation under ambient conditions. Adv Mater. 2018;30(46):1803694.

[147] ZhangY, HuJ, ZhangC, et al. Bimetallic Mo-Co nanoparticles anchored on nitrogen-doped carbon for enhanced electrochemical nitrogen fixation. J Mater Chem A. 2020;8(18):9091-9098.

[148] GaoY, HanZ, HongS, et al. ZIF-67-derived cobalt/nitrogendoped carbon composites for efficient electrocatalytic N₂ reduction. ACS Appl Energy Mater. 2019;2(8):6071-6077.

[149] LiuY, ZhuX, ZhangQ, et al. Engineering Mo/Mo₂C/MoC hetero-interfaces for enhanced electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction. J Mater Chem A. 2020;8(18):8920-8926.

[150] FangY, XueY, LiY, et al. Graphdiyne interface engineering: highly active and selective ammonia synthesis. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2020;59(31):13021-13027.

[151] GreenleeLF, RennerJN, FosterSL. The use of controls for consistent and accurate measurements of electrocatalytic ammonia synthesis from dinitrogen. ACS Catal. 2018;8(9):7820-7827.

[152] ShanW, LiuF, HeH, ShiX, ZhangC. The remarkable improvement of a Ce-Ti based catalyst for NO_x abatement, prepared by a homogeneous precipitation method. ChemCatChem. 2011;3(8):1286-1289.

[153] QingG, Ghazfar R, JackowskiST, et al. Recent advances and challenges of electrocatalytic N₂ reduction to ammonia. Chem Rev. 2020;120(12):5437-5516.

[154] ZhouL, BoydCE. Comparison of Nessler, phenate, salicylate and ion selective electrode procedures for determination of total ammonia nitrogen in aquaculture. Aquaculture. 2016;450:187-193.

[155] DuanGY, RenY, TangY, et al. Improving the reliability and accuracy of ammonia quantification in electro-and photochemical synthesis. ChemSusChem. 2020;13(1):88-96.

[156] ZhaoY, ShiR, BianX, et al. Ammonia detection methods in photocatalytic and electrocatalytic experiments: how to improve the reliability of NH₃ production rates? Adv Sci. 2019;6(8):1802109.

[157] YangY, ZhangW, TanX, JiangK, ZhaiS, Li Z. Atomic-level reactive sites for electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction to ammonia under ambient conditions. Coord Chem Rev. 2023;489:215196.

[158] DuH-L, Gengenbach TR, HodgettsR, MacFarlaneDR, Simonov AN. Critical assessment of the electrocatalytic activity of vanadium and niobium nitrides toward dinitrogen reduction to ammonia. ACS Sustainable Chem Eng. 2019;(7):6839-6850.

[159] KibsgaardJ, Nørskov JK, ChorkendorffI. The difficulty of proving electrochemical ammonia synthesis. ACS Energy Lett. 2019;4(12):2986-2988.

[160] SunJ, ChenA, GuanJ, et al. Interpretable machine learningassisted high-throughput screening for understanding NRR electrocatalyst performance modulation between active center and C-N coordination. Energy Environ Mater. 2023;0:e12693.

[161] LiL, TangC, YaoD, ZhengY, QiaoS-Z. Electrochemical nitrogen reduction: identification and elimination of contamination in electrolyte. ACS Energy Lett. 2019;4(9):2111-2116.

[162] TangC, QiaoS-Z. How to explore ambient electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reliably and insightfully. Chem Soc Rev. 2019;48(12):3166-3180.

[163] ChenG-F, RenS, ZhangL, et al. Advances in electrocatalytic N₂ reduction-strategies to tackle the selectivity challenge. Small Methods. 2019;3(6):1800337.

[164] NielanderAC, McEnaney JM, SchwalbeJA, et al. A versatile method for ammonia detection in a range of relevant electrolytes via direct nuclear magnetic resonance techniques. ACS Catal. 2019;9(7):5797-5802.

[165] SuryantoBHR, DuH-L, WangD, Chen J, SimonovAN, MacFarlaneDR. Challenges and prospects in the catalysis of electroreduction of nitrogen to ammonia. Nat Catal. 2019;2(4):290-296.

[166] YaoY, ZhuS, WangH, Li H, ShaoM. A spectroscopic study on the nitrogen electrochemical reduction reaction on gold and platinum surfaces. J Am Chem Soc. 2018;140(4):1496-1501.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2024 The Authors. EcoEnergy published by John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd on behalf of China Chemical Safety Association.