The use of traditional Chinese medicine diagnostic methods in heart failure - an evidence map

Abstract

Introduction Heart failure (HF) is a significant global health issue. There is an ongoing need for early detection and monitoring of its severity, which remains a critical and unmet requirement. Inspection diagnosis in traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) is a method of assessing the condition of the internal zang-fu organs by observing the body's external manifestations, offering a promising approach to this issue. In this study, we aimed to systematically evaluate the existing research on the correlation between TCM diagnostic inspection and HF, using an evidence map to uncover potential research directions in this domain. Methods A comprehensive literature search was conducted across several databases, including the China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), Wanfang Database, Chinese Scientific Journal Database (VIP), PubMed, and Web of Science. The search screened clinical studies, systematic reviews, guidelines, and clinical pathways relevant to diagnostic inspection and HF. The collected data were analyzed using graphical and textual representations to delineate the distribution and characteristics of the evidence. Results Overall, 33 studies, comprising 14 cross-sectional, 8 cohort, and 11 case-control studies, were included in the analysis. The clinical research output showed consistent growth between 1992 and 2024, with 70% of the investigations enrolling ≤300 participants. The primary focus of these studies was chronic HF (10 studies, 30.3%). Regarding diagnostic approaches, 26.47% used visual assessment and 61.76% used device-based methods. Inspection diagnosis played several roles in HF management, predominantly facilitating disease risk prediction (15 studies, 45.45%) and disease severity evaluation (14 studies, 42.42%). Conclusion Observational evidence from TCM inspection diagnoses, especially regarding retinal/fundus and tongue manifestations, indicates that it may be of possible prognostic use. However, this needs to be confirmed through high-quality prospective studies, which should also validate the auxiliary role of inspection diagnoses in preventing and treating HF.

Keywords

heart failure / inspection diagnosis / retinal / fundus / tongue / traditional Chinese medicine / evidence map

References

[1] GBD 2017 Disease and Injury Incidence and Prevalence Collaborators. Global, regional, and national incidence, prevalence, and years lived with disability for 354 diseases and injuries for 195 countries and territories, 1990-2017:a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017. Lancet. 2018; 392(10159):1789-1858.

[2] Savarese G, Becher PM, Lund LH, Seferovic P, Rosano GMC, Coats AJS. Global burden of heart failure):a comprehensive and updated review of epidemiology. Cardiovasc Res. 2023; 118(17):3272-3287.

[3] Hao G, Wang X, Chen Z, et al. Prevalence of heart failure and left ventricular dysfunction in China:the China Hypertension Survey, 2012-2015. Eur J Heart Fail. 2019; 21(11):1329-1337.

[4] Lawson CA, Zaccardi F, Squire I, et al. 20-year trends in cause-specific heart failure outcomes by sex, socioeconomic status, and place of diagnosis:a population-based study. Lancet Public Health. 2019; 4(8):e406-e420.

[5] McCoubrey A, Campbell RT. What is the future of diagnostics in heart failure? Br J Hosp Med (Lond). 2025; 86(2):1-6.

[6] Bozkurt B. Pre-heart failure:an important opportunity to prevent a deadly disease. JACC Heart Fail. 2023; 11(8 Pt1):1027-1031.

[7] Severino P, D’Amato A, Prosperi S, et al. Do the current guidelines for heart failure diagnosis and treatment fit with clinical complexity? J Clin Med. 2022; 11(3):857.

[8] Bozkurt B, Coats AJS, Tsutsui H, et al. Universal definition and classification of heart failure:a report of the Heart Failure Society of America, Heart Failure Association of the European Society of Cardiology, Japanese Heart Failure Society and Writing Committee of the Universal Definition of Heart Failure:Endorsed by the Canadian Heart Failure Society, Heart Failure Association of India, Cardiac Society of Australia and New Zealand, and Chinese Heart Failure Association. Eur J Heart Fail. 2021; 23(3):352-380.

[9] Liu G Y, Zhang D, Ma X. Clinical research progress of traditional Chinese medicine in the intervention of chronic heart failure. Chin J Heart Fail Cardiomyopathy. 2021; 5(4):270-274.

[10] The Standardization Project Group for “Clinical Application Guidelines for Dominant Diseases Treated with Chinese Patent Medicines”. Clinical application guidelines of Chinese patent medicines for heart failure ( 2021). Chin J Integr Tradit West Med. 2022; 42(3):261-275.

[11] Chinese Medical Association, Chinese Medical Journals Publishing House, Chinese Society of General Practice, Editorial Board of Chinese Journal of General Practitioners of Chinese Medical Association, Expert Group of Guidelines for Primary Care of Cardiovascular Disease. Guideline for primary care of chronic heart failure (2019). Chin J Gen Pract. 2019; 18(10):936-947.

[12] Sun J. Construction of a multivariate observation system for cardiovascular diseases. Tradit Chin Med Res. 2014; 27(5):6-9.

[13] Zhang X, Qiu R, Li C, Shang H. Clinical research priority setting for traditional Chinese medicine. Chin J Evid Based Med. 2019; 19(3):373-376.

[14] Wells GA, Shea B, O'Connell D, et al. The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) for assessing the quality of nonrandomized studies in meta-analyses. The Ottawa Hospital Research Institute Web site. http://www.ohri.ca/programs/clinical_epidemiology/oxford.htm. Updated June 15, 2012. Accessed January 1, 2025.

[15] Zeng XT, Liu H, Chen X, et al. Series of meta-analysis part four:quality assessment tools for observational studies. Chin J Evid Based Cardiovasc Med. 2012; 4(4):297-299.

[16] Rostom A, Dubé C, Cranney A, et al. Celiac Disease. Evidence Report/Technology Assessment No. 104. (Prepared by the University of Ottawa Evidence-based Practice Center, under Contract No. 290-02-0021.) AHRQ Publication No. 04-E029-2. Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality; 2004.

[17] Cui X, Yang B, Zhao A. Correlation between fundus retinopathy, silencing information regulator 4 with ventricular remodeling and cardiac function in patients with chronic heart failure. China Med Herald. 2024; 21(17):9-12.

[18] Du JS, Yang C, Zhao M, Du JB. Observation on tongue coating in patients with chronic congestive heart failure. Tradit Chin Med Res. 1992; 5(3):37-38.

[19] Gopinath B, Wang SB, Liew G, et al. Retinal vascular geometry and the prevalence of atrial fibrillation and heart failure in a clinic-based sample. Heart Lung Circ. 2019; 28(11):1631-1637.

[20] Li DY. Correlation between lingual ecchymosis density and sublingual vein diameter with cardiac function classification in patients with chronic heart failure. China Health Ind. 2012; 9(35):136.

[21] Phan K, Mitchell P, Liew G, et al. Association between retinal arteriolar and venule calibre with prevalent heart failure:a cross-sectional study. Plos One. 2015; 10(12):e0144850.

[22] Rui XT. Skin changes in patients with chronic heart failure. J Pract Diagn Ther. 2003; 17(6):494.

[23] Tian XM, Liu QQ, Kou LJ, Liang JP. Exploration of the evolutionary regularity of tongue manifestations in patients with acute heart failure. J Emerg Tradit Chin Med. 2010; 19(9):1525-1526.

[24] Wang R, Li Y, Sun L, Wang B. Relationship between sublingual collaterals changes and blood components content in patients with chronic heart failure. Chin J Integr Med Cardio Cerebrovasc Dis. 2018; 16(7):833-840.

[25] Wang X, Xiao Y, Ren C, et al. Correlation analysis between distribution features of tongue manifestations and some risk factors of the heart failure in dialysis patients. China Med Herald. 2018; 15(10):110-113.

[26] Wei J, Huang X, Zhao H, et al. Correlation between four diagnosis methods of traditional Chinese medicine and quality of life of patients with chronic heart failure. World Chin Med. 2018; 13(3):746-750.

[27] Xu XG, Zhang L, Xu BL, et al. Correlation between distribution features of syndrome types and tongue manifestations and cardiac functional grading in patients with chronic heart failure. J Beijing Univ Tradit Chin Med. 2012; 35(5):312-316.

[28] Xu SQ. Observation on tongue images and exploration of mechanism in 60 patients with heart failure with normal ejection fraction. Asia Pac Tradit Med. 2017; 13(8):112-114.

[29] Zhang L, Li X, He J. Clinical study on correlation between characteristics of tongue manifestation and NYHA cardiac function classification in patients with chronic heart failure. New Chin Med. 2023; 55(16):75-80.

[30] Zhao M, Liu P, Yuan L, et al. Association and cluster analysis of syndrome, symptom, tongue, pulse, and moss in 215 patients with heart failure. Chin J Integr Med Cardio Cerebrovasc Dis. 2021; 19(9):1464-1468.

[31] Liu X, Huang X, Zhang L, Deng B. Correlation between physical characteristic appearance of auricular point surface and chronic heart failure. Acta Chin Med. 2021; 36(2):410-413.

[32] Zhang L, Li X, He J. Expression and significance of NFAT3 in tongue coating fluid of congestive heart failure with qi deficiency and blood stasis syndrome. Liaoning J Tradit Chin Med. 2024; 51(6):10-13.

[33] Huang Y, Zeng W, Gan Q, et al. Analysis of diagnostic value of hemodynamics and sublingual microcirculation in patients with sepsis complicated with acute heart failure. Chin J Front Med Sci Electron Ed. 2020; 12(9):56-60.

[34] Abdin A, Abdin AD, Merone G, et al. Cardio-ocular syndrome):retinal microvascular changes in acutely decompensated heart failure. Eur J Heart Fail. 2024; 26(11):2421-2430.

[35] Jung S, Kolwelter J, Bosch A, et al. Hypertrophic remodelling of retinal arterioles in patients with congestive heart failure. ESC Heart Fail. 2021; 8(3):1892-1900.

[36] Khalilipur E, Mahdizad Z, Molazadeh N, et al. Microvascular and structural analysis of the retina and choroid in heart failure patients with reduced ejection fraction. Sci Rep. 2023; 13(1):5467.

[37] Sadowski J, Targonski R, Cyganski P, et al. Remodeling of retinal arterioles and carotid arteries in heart failure development-a preliminary study. J Clin Med. 2022; 11(13):3721.

[38] Nägele MP, Barthelmes J, Ludovici V, et al. Retinal microvascular dysfunction in heart failure. Eur Heart J. 2018; 39(1):47-56.

[39] Weerts J, Raafs AG, Sandhoefner B, et al. Retinal vascular changes in heart failure with preserved ejection fraction using optical coherence tomography angiography. J Clin Med. 2024; 13(7):1892.

[40] Topaloglu C, Bekmez S. Retinal vascular density change in patients with heart failure. Photodiagnosis Photodyn Ther. 2023; 42:103621.

[41] Kanar HS, Penbe A, Kanar BG. Subfoveal choroidal thickness and retinal nerve fiber layer alterations in chronic heart failure patients. Arq Bras Oftalmol. 2021; 84(5):467-473.

[42] Barthelmes J, Nägele MP, Cantatore S, et al. Retinal microvascular dysfunction in patients with coronary artery disease with and without heart failure):a continuum? Eur J Heart Fail. 2019; 21(8):988-997.

[43] Chandra A, Seidelmann SB, Claggett BL, et al. The association of retinal vessel calibres with heart failure and long-term alterations in cardiac structure and function):the Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities (ARIC) Study. Eur J Heart Fail. 2019; 21(10):1207-1215.

[44] Guo S, Yin S, Song W, et al. Retinal microvascular abnormalities predict clinical outcomes in patients with heart failure. Diagnostics. 2022; 12(9):2078.

[45] Kaya Ö, Kaya H. Stasis dermatitis:a skin manifestation of poor prognosis in patients with heart failure. Hippokratia. 2022; 26(1):13-18.

[46] Matsuoka S, Kaneko H, Okada A, et al. Association of retinal atherosclerosis assessed using Keith-Wagener-Barker system with incident heart failure and other atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease:analysis of 319 501 individuals from the general population. Atherosclerosis. 2022; 348:68-74.

[47] Rim TH, Oh J, Kang SM, Kim SS. Association between retinal vein occlusion and risk of heart failure:a 12-year nationwide cohort study. Int J Cardiol. 2016; 217:122-127.

[48] Wong TY, Rosamond W, Chang PP, et al. Retinopathy and risk of congestive heart failure. JAMA. 2005; 293(1):63-69.

[49] Chen Y, Yin M, Fan L, et al. Mirror-like tongue is an important predictor of acute heart failure:a cohort study of acute heart failure in Chinese patients. J Tradit Chin Med. 2023; 43(6):1243-1251.

[50] Wang BH, Sun LJ, Yu ZQ. Analysis of tongue manifestations in the treatment of congestive heart failure by enriching yin, warming yang, activating blood circulation and promoting urination. Tianjin J Tradit Chin Med. 1998; 15(1):17-18.

[51] Feng J, Zhang Y, Zhang J. Epidemiology and burden of heart failure in Asia. JACC Asia. 2024; 4(4):249-264.

[52] Yoo SGK, Lam CSP, Sweitzer NK.“Asian” heart failure. Circulation. 2024; 150(3):177-179.

[53] Klein R, Myers CE, Knudtson MD, et al. Relationship of blood pressure and other factors to serial retinal arteriolar diameter measurements over time:the beaver dam eye study. Arch Ophthalmol. 2012; 130(8):1019-1027.

[54] Myers CE, Klein R, Knudtson MD, et al. Determinants of retinal venular diameter:the Beaver Dam Eye Study. Ophthalmology. 2012; 119(12):2563-2571.

[55] Gopinath B, Chiha J, Plant AJ, et al. Associations between retinal microvascular structure and the severity and extent of coronary artery disease. Atherosclerosis. 2014; 236(1):25-30.

[56] Seidelmann SB, Claggett B, Bravo PE, et al. Retinal vessel calibers in predicting long-term cardiovascular outcomes:the atherosclerosis risk in communities study. Circulation. 2016; 134(18):1328-1338.

[57] De Backer D, Creteur J, Dubois MJ, Sakr Y, Vincent JL. Microvascular alterations in patients with acute severe heart failure and cardiogenic shock. Am Heart J. 2004; 147(1):91-99.

[58] Wijntjens GW, Fengler K, Fuernau G, et al. Prognostic implications of microcirculatory perfusion versus macrocirculatory perfusion in cardiogenic shock:a CULPRIT-SHOCK substudy. Eur Heart J Acute Cardiovasc Care. 2020; 9(2):108-119.

[59] Peng H, Yu W, Chen S, Zhang H. Development and application of a heart failure-specific information platform. Chin J Med Sci Res Manag. 2023; 36(3):225-230.

[60] Whiting PF, Rutjes AWS, Westwood ME, et al. QUADAS-2:a revised tool for the quality assessment of diagnostic accuracy studies. Ann Intern Med. 2011; 155(8):529-536.

[61] Guyatt G, Oxman AD, Akl EA, et al. GRADE guidelines:1. Introduction-GRADE evidence profiles and summary of findings tables. J Clin Epidemiol. 2011; 64(4):383-394.