Polybrominated diphenyl ether (PBDE) removal from wastewater: a perspective on advancing microbial technologies

Abstract

Contaminants of emerging concern (CEC) continue to plague wastewater treatment facilities in their battle to recover water resources and circumvent environmental contamination. Of particular challenge are legacy pollutants - pollutants that are no longer in use but continue to enter wastewater treatment facilities due to their historic uses. Among these pollutants are polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs), a flame retardant used in many consumer products. PBDEs have been detected in waterways worldwide and were documented to impact juvenile Chinook salmon in the waterways of Puget Sound in Washington State, USA. This has both economic impacts in the region where salmon is a major commercial export, and societal implications where native tribes have deep cultural heritage connections with salmon. PBDEs are primarily removed from wastewater by sorption to wastewater sludge. However, this process can result in long-term impacts when PBDEs re-emerge in landfill leachates after sorptive material disposal. In this perspective, we explore what is currently understood about engineered solutions for the removal of PBDEs from wastewater, and we present an approach for the permanent destruction of PBDEs, which combines anaerobic bioprocesses for initial debromination, followed by aerobic treatments for the final degradation of the PBDEs. Through this perspective, we hope to inspire global research efforts to develop sustainable biological treatment solutions for CEC destruction during wastewater treatment.

Keywords

Emerging contaminants / anaerobic debromination / brominated flame retardants / fish / biochar sorption

References

[1] Abbasi G,Soehl A,Diamond ML.Stocks and flows of PBDEs in products from use to waste in the U.S. and Canada from 1970 to 2020.Environ Sci Technol2015;49:1521-8

[2] Arkoosh MR,Dietrich J.Disease susceptibility of salmon exposed to polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs).Aquat Toxicol2010;98:51-9

[3] Arkoosh MR,Strickland SA.Dietary exposure to a binary mixture of polybrominated diphenyl ethers alters innate immunity and disease susceptibility in juvenile Chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha).Ecotoxicol Environ Saf2018;163:96-103

[4] Akortia E,Lupankwa M.A review of sources, levels, and toxicity of polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) and their transformation and transport in various environmental compartments.Environ Rev2016;24:253-73

[5] Arkoosh MR,Strickland SA,Krupkin AB.Alteration of thyroid hormone concentrations in juvenile Chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) exposed to polybrominated diphenyl ethers, BDE-47 and BDE-99.Chemosphere2017;171:1-8

[6] Kim T,Kwon S.Bromination effect of polybrominated diphenyl ethers on the graphyne surface on enhanced adsorption characteristics using density functional theory study.AIP Adv2020;10:075117

[7] Carey AJ,Fisk RJ,Ylitalo G. Location and source of PBDE exposure in juvenile Chinook salmon along their out-migrant pathway through the Snohomish River, WA. 2019. https://wdfw.wa.gov/publications/02241. (accessed on 2025-03-17)

[8] Kim M.Treatment techniques for removal of polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) from real wastewater: Limitations, challenges, and future research directions.J Water Process Eng2024;63:105463

[9] James CA,Faber M.The screening and prioritization of contaminants of emerging concern in the marine environment based on multiple biological response measures.Sci Total Environ2023;886:163712

[10] Xu G,Zhao S.Insights into the occurrence, fate, and impacts of halogenated flame retardants in municipal wastewater treatment plants.Environ Sci Technol2021;55:4205-26

[11] Sun Y,Pawlowicz R,Stevens SW.Distribution, sources and dispersion of polybrominated diphenyl ethers in the water column of the Strait of Georgia, British Columbia, Canada.Sci Total Environ2023;873:162174

[12] Zhang Y,Song J.Environmental characteristics of polybrominated diphenyl ethers in marine system, with emphasis on marine organisms and sediments.Biomed Res Int2016;2016:1317232 PMCID:PMC5143782

[13] Lee HK,Jeong Y.Polybrominated diphenyl ethers in thirteen shark species from offshore and coastal waters of Korea.Mar Pollut Bull2015;95:374-9

[14] Mongillo TM,Noren DP.Predicted polybrominated diphenyl ether (PBDE) and polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) accumulation in southern resident killer whales.Mar Ecol Prog Ser2012;453:263-77

[15] Morales P,Muñoz-Arnanz J,Jiménez B.Evaluation of PCDD/Fs, PCBs and PBDEs in two penguin species from Antarctica.Chemosphere2022;286:131871

[16] Kim UJ,Lee IS,Oh JE.Investigation of bioaccumulation and biotransformation of polybrominated diphenyl ethers, hydroxylated and methoxylated derivatives in varying trophic level freshwater fishes.Chemosphere2015;137:108-14

[17] West JE,Ylitalo GM.Time trends of persistent organic pollutants in benthic and pelagic indicator fishes from Puget Sound, Washington, USA.Arch Environ Contam Toxicol2017;73:207-29 PMCID:PMC5539278

[18] Rayne S,Ross PS,Barrett-Lennard LG.PBDEs, PBBs, and PCNs in three communities of free-ranging killer whales (Orcinus orca) from the northeastern Pacific Ocean.Environ Sci Technol2004;38:4293-9

[19] Ikonomou MG,Hickman ZL.Spatio-temporal and species-specific variation in PBDE levels/patterns in British Columbia’s coastal waters.Environ Pollut2006;140:355-63

[20] Td, MacRae JD. Polybrominated diphenyl ethers in fish and wastewater samples from an area of the Penobscot River in central Maine.Chemosphere2006;62:1153-60

[21] O’Neill SM,Harding LB,Ylitalo GM.Chemical tracers guide identification of the location and source of persistent organic pollutants in juvenile Chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha), migrating seaward through an estuary with multiple contaminant inputs.Sci Total Environ2020;712:135516

[22] Wong, S. Chemicals of emerging concern in pretreated industrial wastewater in northwestern Washington State: screening study results, 2021. https://apps.ecology.wa.gov/publications/documents/2203013.pdf. (accessed on 2025-03-17)

[23] Xu H,An Q.Aerobic degradation characteristics of decabromodiphenyl ether through rhodococcus ruber TAW-CT127 and its preliminary genome analysis.Microorganisms2022;10:1441 PMCID:PMC9319644

[24] Paliya S,Bhisikar D,Kumar S.Polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) in Indian wastewater treatment plant: occurrence, mass flow and removal.Chemosphere2022;303:135055

[25] Shen J,Droste R.Variability of release rate of flame retardants in wastewater treatment plants.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2018;25:34740-52 PMCID:PMC6245005

[26] Chang R,Weng C,Liao C.Fast Removal of polybrominated diphenyl ethers from aqueous solutions by using low-cost adsorbents.Sustainability2017;9:102

[27] Duan FA,Ismail S,Cui Z.Hydroxypropyl-β-cyclodextrin improves the removal of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons by aerobic granular sludge.Environ Technol2022;43:3262-8

[28] Mohamed BA,Montoya-Bautista CV.Circular economy in wastewater treatment plants: treatment of contaminants of emerging concerns (CECs) in effluent using sludge-based activated carbon.J Clean Prod2023;389:136095

[29] Hu D,Fan L,Jia R.Aerobic degradation characteristics and mechanism of decabromodiphenyl ether (BDE-209) using complex bacteria communities.Int J Environ Res Public Health2022;19:17012 PMCID:PMC9778866

[30] Gu C,Jin Z.Congener-specificity, dioxygenation dependency and association with enzyme binding for biodegradation of polybrominated diphenyl ethers by typical aerobic bacteria: Experimental and theoretical studies.Chemosphere2023;314:137697

[31] Ni SQ,Zheng Z.Interaction of polybrominated diphenyl ethers and aerobic granular sludge: biosorption and microbial degradation.Biomed Res Int2014;2014:274620 PMCID:PMC4058842

[32] He J,Alvarez-Cohen L.Microbial reductive debromination of polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs).Environ Sci Technol2006;40:4429-34

[33] Zhao S,He Y.Microbial debromination of polybrominated diphenyl ethers by dehalococcoides-containing enrichment culture.Front Microbiol2021;12:806795 PMCID:PMC8891982

[34] Zhao S,Cao L,He J.Identification of reductive dehalogenases that mediate complete debromination of penta- and tetrabrominated diphenyl ethers in Dehalococcoides spp.Appl Environ Microbiol2021;87:e0060221 PMCID:PMC8357287

[35] Xu G,He J.Underexplored organohalide-respiring bacteria in sewage sludge debrominating polybrominated diphenyl ethers. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2024.

[36] Yu Y,Huang W,Lu G.Cellular changes of microbial consortium GY1 during decabromodiphenyl ether (BDE-209) biodegradation and identification of strains responsible for BDE-209 degradation in GY1.Chemosphere2020;249:126205

[37] Zhou Q,Ahmad HA.Production of more toxic hexa-brominated diphenyl ether from rapid biotransformation of decabromodiphenyl ether in anaerobic granular sludge.Int Biodeterior Biodegrad2018;134:7-15

[38] Wang S,Wang B.Characterization of the molecular degradation mechanism of diphenyl ethers by Cupriavidus sp. WS.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2015;22:16914-26

[39] Robrock KR,Alvarez-Cohen L.Pathways for the anaerobic microbial debromination of polybrominated diphenyl ethers.Environ Sci Technol2008;42:2845-52

[40] Kent J.Treatment of 17α-ethinylestradiol, 4-nonylphenol, and carbamazepine in wastewater using an aerobic granular sludge sequencing batch reactor.Sci Total Environ2019;652:1270-8

[41] Kryst K.Aerobic phenol biodegradation in an inverse fluidized-bed biofilm reactor.Ind Eng Chem Res2001;40:5436-9

[42] Lendenmann U,Smets BF.Simultaneous biodegradation of 2,4-dinitrotoluene and 2,6-dinitrotoluene in an aerobic fluidized-bed biofilm reactor.Environ Sci Technol1998;32:82-7

[43] Swain AK,Jena HM.Industrial wastewater treatment by Aerobic Inverse Fluidized Bed Biofilm Reactors (AIFBBRs): a review.J Water Process Eng2018;23:61-74

[44] Cui L,Yang Y.Influence of biochar on microbial activities of heavy metals contaminated paddy fields.BioRes2013;8:5536-48

[45] Chen Y,Li Y.Influence of biochar on heavy metals and microbial community during composting of river sediment with agricultural wastes.Bioresour Technol2017;243:347-55

[46] Pommier T,Bettarel Y.Off-site impacts of agricultural composting: role of terrestrially derived organic matter in structuring aquatic microbial communities and their metabolic potential.FEMS Microbiol Ecol2014;90:622-32

[47] Kambo HS.A comparative review of biochar and hydrochar in terms of production, physico-chemical properties and applications.Renew Sustain Energy Rev2015;45:359-78

[48] Xiang W,Chen J.Biochar technology in wastewater treatment: a critical review.Chemosphere2020;252:126539

[49] Colantoni A,Lord R.Characterization of biochars produced from pyrolysis of pelletized agricultural residues.Renew Sustain Energy Rev2016;64:187-94

[50] Xiong X,Tsang DC.Value-added chemicals from food supply chain wastes: state-of-the-art review and future prospects.Chem Eng J2019;375:121983

[51] Ming J,Yoza BA.Bioreactor performance using biochar and its effect on aerobic granulation.Bioresour Technol2020;300:122620

[52] El Shahawy A,El-Shatoury S.Using phragmites australis biochar bio-augmented with actinomycetes for enhancing UASB reactor performance: a field study.J Water Process Eng2024;68:106461

[53] Chakraborty I,Dubey BK.Waste-derived biochar: applications and future perspective in microbial fuel cells.Bioresour Technol2020;312:123587

[54] Lin S,Lamichhane KM,Kirs M.Anaerobic-aerobic biofilm-based digestion of chemical contaminants of emerging concern (CEC) and pathogen indicator organisms in synthetic wastewater.Bioresour Technol2020;299:122554

[55] Chan YJ,Law CL.A review on anaerobic–aerobic treatment of industrial and municipal wastewater.Chem Eng J2009;155:1-18

[56] Qiu M,Deng D.Effects of electron donors on anaerobic microbial debromination of polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs).Biodegradation2012;23:351-61

[57] Lust MJ,Strand SE,Stensel HD.Biodegradation kinetics of 17α-ethinylestradiol in activated sludge treatment processes.Environ Eng Sci2015;32:637-46

[58] Zhou NA,Andaker GL,Gough HL.Kinetics modeling predicts bioaugmentation with Sphingomonad cultures as a viable technology for enhanced pharmaceutical and personal care products removal during wastewater treatment.Bioresour Technol2014;166:158-67

[59] Zhou NA,Andaker GL,Ferguson JF.Cultivation and characterization of bacterial isolates capable of degrading pharmaceutical and personal care products for improved removal in activated sludge wastewater treatment.Biodegradation2013;24:813-27

[60] Ziels RM,Gough HL,Stensel HD.Influence of bioselector processes on 17α-ethinylestradiol biodegradation in activated sludge wastewater treatment systems.Environ Sci Technol2014;48:6160-7

[61] Shao Y,Sun C,Wang Q.Visible-light-induced degradation of polybrominated diphenyl ethers with AgI–TiO₂.RSC Adv2017;7:39089-95

[62] Wang R,Wei Y.Photocatalytic debromination of polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) on metal doped TiO₂ nanocomposites: mechanisms and pathways.Environ Int2019;127:5-12

[63] Lei M,Guo S,Ding Y.A one-pot consecutive photocatalytic reduction and oxidation system for complete debromination of tetrabromodiphenyl ether.Chem Eng J2018;345:586-93