Carbon-based materials: adsorptive removal of antibiotics from water

Abstract

The contamination generated by multiple antibiotics represents a general concern given its impact at the environmental level, mainly affecting the planet’s soil and water and impacting the development of numerous species. Additionally, a new problem has been triggered in terms of the development of antibiotic-resistance genes in various pathogenic microorganisms generating concern for the health sector in terms of the efficiency of antibiotics in the future. These actual problems and concerns demand efforts and actions to remove or eliminate these contaminants. Multiple alternatives to reduce the impact of antibiotics in water have been carried out, such as advanced oxidation, reverse osmosis, and membrane filtration. However, adsorption techniques have presented more favorable and viable results in which carbon-based materials are an efficient tool to remediate the environment that can take advantage of other alternatives due to their characteristics. This review presents different carbon-based absorptive materials such as biochar, carbon nanotubes, activated carbon, and graphene to remove these contaminants, given their characteristics and favorable results. However, process integration, production, and modification continue to be challenging and require more research and experimentation.

Keywords

Antibiotic removal / water treatment / adsorption method / graphene / carbon nanotubes / activated carbon / biochar / bio-removal

References

[1] García J,Day JW.A review of emerging organic contaminants (EOCs), antibiotic resistant bacteria (ARB), and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in the environment: increasing removal with wetlands and reducing environmental impacts.Bioresour Technol2020;307:123228

[2] Bilal M,Rasheed T.Antibiotics traces in the aquatic environment: persistence and adverse environmental impact.Curr Opin Environ Sci Health2020;13:68-74

[3] Storto D,Kozusny-andreani DI.Seasonal dynamics of microbial contamination and antibiotic resistance in the water at the Tietê Ecological Park, Brazil.Water Air Soil Pollut2021;232

[4] Grenni P,Barra Caracciolo A.Ecological effects of antibiotics on natural ecosystems: a review.Microchem J2018;136:25-39

[5] Qaswar M,Jing H.Soil nutrients and heavy metal availability under long-term combined application of swine manure and synthetic fertilizers in acidic paddy soil.J Soils Sediments2020;20:2093-106.5

[6] Bilal M,Barceló D.Biocatalytic degradation/redefining “removal” fate of pharmaceutically active compounds and antibiotics in the aquatic environment.Sci Total Environ2019;691:1190-211

[7] Bilal M,Adeel M,Awad YA.Robust strategies to eliminate endocrine disruptive estrogens in water resources.Environ Pollut2022;306:119373.7

[8] González-González RB,Parra-Saldívar R,Bilal M.Decontamination of emerging pharmaceutical pollutants using carbon-dots as robust materials.J Hazard Mater2022;423:127145.8

[9] Chaturvedi P,Giri BS.Prevalence and hazardous impact of pharmaceutical and personal care products and antibiotics in environment: a review on emerging contaminants.Environ Res2021;194:110664

[10] Zuo R,Zhang Q.Sulfonamide antibiotics in groundwater and their migration in the vadose zone: a case in a drinking water resource.Ecol Eng2021;162:106175

[11] Szekeres E,Baricz A.Investigating antibiotics, antibiotic resistance genes, and microbial contaminants in groundwater in relation to the proximity of urban areas.Environ Pollut2018;236:734-44

[12] PubChem. Available from: https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ [Last accessed on 9 Feb 2023]

[13] Drugs.com. Available from: https://www.drugs.com/ [Last accessed on 9 Feb 2023]

[14] DrugBank Online. Available from: https://go.drugbank.com/ [Last accessed on 9 Feb 2023]

[15] Zhang X,Ngo HH,Li N.Performance evaluation of powdered activated carbon for removing 28 types of antibiotics from water.J Environ Manage2016;172:193-200

[16] Aguilar-pérez K,Ruiz-pulido G.Nano-sorbent materials for pharmaceutical-based wastewater effluents - an overview.Case Stud Chem Environ Eng2020;2:100028

[17] Aguilar-Pérez KM,Ruiz-Pulido G,Parra-Saldivar R.Nanoadsorbents in focus for the remediation of environmentally-related contaminants with rising toxicity concerns.Sci Total Environ2021;779:146465

[18] Gopinath KP,Gnana Prakash D,Viswanathan S.Environmental applications of carbon-based materials: a review.Environ Chem Lett2021;19:557-82

[19] Araújo RG,Martinez-Ruiz M.Expanding the scope of nanobiocatalysis and nanosensing: applications of nanomaterial constructs.ACS Omega2022;7:32863-76

[20] Cruz-cruz A,Rivas-sanchez A.Recent advances in carbon dots based biocatalysts for degrading organic pollutants.Curr Pollution Rep2022;8:384-94.20

[21] González-González RB,Alsanie WF.Nanohybrid catalysts with porous structures for environmental remediation through photocatalytic degradation of emerging pollutants.Environ Res2022;214:113955

[22] González-González RB,Parra-Saldívar R.Bio-removal of emerging pollutants by advanced bioremediation techniques.Environ Res2022;214:113936

[23] Rivas-Sanchez A,Gallareta-Olivares G,Parra-Saldívar R.Carbon-based nanocomposite materials with multifunctional attributes for environmental remediation of emerging pollutants.Chemosphere2022;303:135054

[24] Rodríguez-hernández JA,López-pacheco IY.Environmental persistence, detection, and mitigation of endocrine disrupting contaminants in wastewater treatment plants - a review with a focus on tertiary treatment technologies.Environ Sci Adv2022;1:680-704

[25] Mashkoor F,Inamuddin .Carbon nanotube-based adsorbents for the removal of dyes from waters: a review.Environ Chem Lett2020;18:605-29

[26] Bhuyan MSA,Islam MM,Hossain SS.Synthesis of graphene.Int Nano Lett2016;6:65-83

[27] Papageorgiou DG,Young RJ.Mechanical properties of graphene and graphene-based nanocomposites.Prog Mater Sci2017;90:75-127

[28] Akinwande D,Bunch JS.A review on mechanics and mechanical properties of 2D materials - Graphene and beyond.Extreme Mech Lett2017;13:42-77

[29] Gupta N,Sharma SK.Carbon nanotubes: synthesis, properties and engineering applications.Carbon Lett2019;29:419-47

[30] Rahman G,Mehmood A.An overview of the recent progress in the synthesis and applications of carbon nanotubes.C J Carbon Res2019;5:3

[31] Kar KK.Handbook of nanocomposite supercapacitor materials II. Cham: Springer International Publishing; 2020.

[32] Cha JS,Jung S.Production and utilization of biochar: a review.J Ind Eng Chem2016;40:1-15

[33] Weber K.Properties of biochar.Fuel2018;217:240-61

[34] Leng L,Yang L.An overview on engineering the surface area and porosity of biochar.Sci Total Environ2021;763:144204

[35] Mansour F,Yahfoufi R,Ahmad MN.The use of activated carbon for the removal of pharmaceuticals from aqueous solutions: a review.Rev Environ Sci Biotechnol2018;17:109-45

[36] Lesaoana M,Mtunzi F,Ejidike P.Influence of inorganic acid modification on Cr(VI) adsorption performance and the physicochemical properties of activated carbon.S Afr J Chem Eng2019;28:8-18

[37] Ji L,Xu Z,Zhu D.Graphene nanosheets and graphite oxide as promising adsorbents for removal of organic contaminants from aqueous solution.J Environ Qual2013;42:191-8

[38] Li MF,Zeng GM,Liu SB.Graphene and graphene-based nanocomposites used for antibiotics removal in water treatment: a review.Chemosphere2019;226:360-80

[39] Moradi SE. Highly efficient removal of amoxicillin from water by magnetic graphene oxide adsorbent. Available from: http://chemicalbulletin.upt.ro/admin/articole/72848art_3(41-48).pdf [Last accessed on 9 Feb 2023]

[40] Yusuf M,Zaidi SA,Khan MA.Applications of graphene and its derivatives as an adsorbent for heavy metal and dye removal: a systematic and comprehensive overview.RSC Adv2015;5:50392-420

[41] Jian M,Xia K.Challenge and opportunities of carbon nanotubes. Industrial applications of carbon nanotubes. Elsevier; 2017. pp. 433-76.

[42] Song W,Wang X.Experimental and theoretical evidence for competitive interactions of tetracycline and sulfamethazine with reduced graphene oxides.Environ Sci Nano2016;3:1318-26

[43] Zhang Y,Hu Y.Removal of tetracycline and oxytetracycline from water by magnetic [e-mail] Sci Pollut Res Int2017;24:2987-95

[44] Bai L,Zhang Y.Synthesis of water-dispersible graphene-modified magnetic polypyrrole nanocomposite and its ability to efficiently adsorb methylene blue from aqueous solution.Chem Eng J2015;279:757-66

[45] Yao N,Yu J.Insight into adsorption of combined antibiotic-heavy metal contaminants on graphene oxide in water.Sep Purif Technol2020;236:116278

[46] Rostamian R.A comprehensive adsorption study and modeling of antibiotics as a pharmaceutical waste by graphene oxide nanosheets.Ecotoxicol Environ Saf2018;147:117-23

[47] Gao Y,Zhang L.Adsorption and removal of tetracycline antibiotics from aqueous solution by graphene oxide.J Colloid Interf Sci2012;368:540-6

[48] Jia X,Wang Y,Hou X.Adsorption behavior and mechanism of sulfonamide antibiotics in aqueous solution on a novel MIL-101(Cr)@GO composite.J Chem Eng Data2019;64:1265-74.48

[49] Carrales-alvarado D,Leyva-ramos R,Villela-martínez D.Effect of surface area and physical-chemical properties of graphite and graphene-based materials on their adsorption capacity towards metronidazole and trimethoprim antibiotics in aqueous solution.Chem Eng J2020;402:126155

[50] Salihi E, Wang J, Kabacaoğlu G, Kırkulak S, Šiller L. Graphene oxide as a new generation adsorbent for the removal of antibiotics from waters.Sep Sci Technol2021;56:453-61

[51] Liu Y,Zhao X.Fabrication of three-dimensional porous β-cyclodextrin/chitosan functionalized graphene oxide hydrogel for methylene blue removal from aqueous solution.Colloids Surf A Physicochem Eng Asp2018;539:1-10

[52] Yao Q,Xiong Y,Sun Q.3D assembly based on 2D structure of cellulose nanofibril/graphene oxide hybrid aerogel for adsorptive removal of antibiotics in water.Sci Rep2017;7:45914

[53] Vithanage M,Herath I,Mohan D.Kinetics, thermodynamics and mechanistic studies of carbofuran removal using biochars from tea waste and rice husks.Chemosphere2016;150:781-9

[54] Zhang Y,Zhao L.Biochar-supported reduced graphene oxide composite for adsorption and coadsorption of atrazine and lead ions.Appl Surf Sci2018;427:147-55

[55] Zhang A,Xing J.Adsorption of potentially toxic elements in water by modified biochar: a review.J Environ Chem Eng2020;8:104196

[56] Wu L,Zhang S,Kuzyakov Y.MgO-modified biochar increases phosphate retention and rice yields in saline-alkaline soil.J Clean Prod2019;235:901-9

[57] Xu J,Wang Y.Distributing sulfidized nanoscale zerovalent iron onto phosphorus-functionalized biochar for enhanced removal of antibiotic florfenicol.Chem Eng J2019;359:713-22

[58] Liu S,Liu YG.Facile synthesis of Cu(II) impregnated biochar with enhanced adsorption activity for the removal of doxycycline hydrochloride from water.Sci Total Environ2017;592:546-53

[59] Gholami P,Khataee A,Bhatnagar A.Facile hydrothermal synthesis of novel Fe-Cu layered double hydroxide/biochar nanocomposite with enhanced sonocatalytic activity for degradation of cefazolin sodium.J Hazard Mater2020;381:120742

[60] Fu C,Xia M,Wang F.The single/co-adsorption characteristics and microscopic adsorption mechanism of biochar-montmorillonite composite adsorbent for pharmaceutical emerging organic contaminant atenolol and lead ions.Ecotoxicol Environ Saf2020;187:109763

[61] Ashiq A,Adassooriya N.Sorption process of municipal solid waste biochar-montmorillonite composite for ciprofloxacin removal in aqueous media.Chemosphere2019;236:124384

[62] Hu X,Long L.Characteristics and batch experiments of acid- and alkali-modified corncob biomass for nitrate removal from aqueous solution.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2018;25:19932-40

[63] Ma Y,Yang L.Iron/zinc and phosphoric acid modified sludge biochar as an efficient adsorbent for fluoroquinolones antibiotics removal.Ecotoxicol Environ Saf2020;196:110550

[64] Wang B,Fang J.Recent advances in engineered biochar productions and applications.Crit Rev Environ Sci Technol2017;47:2158-207

[65] Qin Y,Su Q.Enhanced removal of ammonium from water by ball-milled biochar.Environ Geochem Health2020;42:1579-87

[66] Huang J,Chen H.Ball milled biochar effectively removes sulfamethoxazole and sulfapyridine antibiotics from water and wastewater.Environ Pollut2020;258:113809

[67] Xiang W,Zhang X.Adsorption of tetracycline hydrochloride onto ball-milled biochar: governing factors and mechanisms.Chemosphere2020;255:127057

[68] Sabzehmeidani MM,Ghaedi M,Roy VAL.Carbon based materials: a review of adsorbents for inorganic and organic compounds.Mater Adv2021;2:598-627

[69] Nazal MK.An overview of carbon-based materials for the removal of pharmaceutical active compounds. In: Bartoli M, Frediani M, Rosi L, editors. Carbon-based material for environmental protection and remediation. IntechOpen; 2020.

[70] Yu F,Han S,Ma J.Adsorption removal of ciprofloxacin by multi-walled carbon nanotubes with different oxygen contents from aqueous solutions.Chem Eng J2016;285:588-95

[71] Mousavi SA.Antibiotics adsorption from aqueous solutions using carbon nanotubes: a systematic review.Toxin Reviews2020;39:87-98

[72] Azarpira H,Khaleghi O. Thermodynamic studies on the removal of metronidazole antibiotic by multi-walled carbon nanotubes. Available from: https://www.scholarsresearchlibrary.com/articles/thermodynamic-studies-on-the-removal-of-metronidazole-antibiotic-by-multiwalled-carbon-nanotubes.pdf [Last accessed on 9 Feb 2023]

[73] Shaban MAA,M-ridha MJ.Adsorption of meropenem antibiotics from aqueous solutions on multi-walled carbon nanotube.Int Rev Civ Eng2020;11:283-93

[74] Gaálová J,Soukup K.Modified single-walled carbon nanotube membranes for the elimination of antibiotics from water.Membranes2021;11:720

[75] Martins AC,Cazetta AL.Removal of tetracycline by NaOH-activated carbon produced from macadamia nut shells: Kinetic and equilibrium studies.Chem Eng J2015;260:291-9

[76] Marzbali MH,Abolghasemi H.Tetracycline adsorption by H3PO4-activated carbon produced from apricot nut shells: a batch study.Process Saf Environ Prot2016;102:700-9

[77] Acosta R,Martinez de Yuso A,Celzard A.Tetracycline adsorption onto activated carbons produced by KOH activation of tyre pyrolysis char.Chemosphere2016;149:168-76

[78] Ahmed MJ.Adsorption of quinolone, tetracycline, and penicillin antibiotics from aqueous solution using activated carbons.Environ Toxicol Pharmacol2017;50:1-10

[79] Balarak D,Shahbaksh S,Abdala A.Adsorptive removal of azithromycin antibiotic from aqueous solution by azolla filiculoides-based activated porous carbon.Nanomaterials2021;11:3281

[80] Al-musawi TJ,Khatibi AD.Effective adsorption of ciprofloxacin antibiotic using powdered activated carbon magnetized by iron(III) oxide magnetic nanoparticles.J Porous Mater2021;28:835-52

[81] Fu H,Wang J.Activated carbon adsorption of quinolone antibiotics in water: performance, mechanism, and modeling.J Environ Sci2017;56:145-52