Analysis of squeezing-induced failure in a water tunnel and measure of rehabilitation: A case study of Tishreen tunnel, Syria

Abstract

Squeezing phenomena can lead to severe loads in deep tunnels, especially in the presence of a low ratio of surrounding rock strength to overburden pressure. For this reason, it is highly imperative to analyze and identify a suitable methodology to estimate the squeezing potential and select a proper support system of rock mass. This study aims to reveal the causes of failure of Tishreen tunnel in the west of Syria and develop remediation measures accordingly so as to bring the tunnel back into service. The tunnel in question was subjected to successive failures such as buckling and spalling of side walls, floor heave, and extremely large convergence reaching the failure state of the tunnel lining. In this study, an effective way was demonstrated to evaluate the squeezing potential of the tunnel lining and appropriate modeling of the long-term response of a tunnel excavated in weak rock. Specifically, the causes of failure of Tishreen tunnel were first evaluated by empirical approaches. Then, a numerical model was developed using a time-dependent constitutive model to investigate the time-dependent response of the tunnel lining. On this basis, this study proposed an effective reinforcement schemes including steel ribs, grout injection, ground anchors, and new lining of reinforced concrete. The results show that the Burger viscoplastic model simulates effectively the resulting deformation and creep behavior of squeezing ground. It is also observed that using a combined heavy support system can provide efficient control over squeezing deformation and maintain the serviceability of the tunnel under study.

Keywords

Burger–creep viscoplastic model / floor heave / grout injection / squeezing potential / steel ribs / tunnel support

References

[1] Abdolyousefi MM, Nikkhah M, Zare S. Assessment of time dependent behaviour of rocks on concrete lining in a large cross section tunnel. Geomech Eng. 2022; 29(1): 41-51.

[2] Agan C. Prediction of squeezing potential of rock masses around the Suruç Water tunnel. Bull Eng Geol Environ. 2016; 75: 451-468.

[3] Aksoy CO, Ogul K, Topal I, Ozer SC, Ozacar V, Posluk E. Numerical modeling of non-deformable support in swelling and squeezing rock. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci. 2012; 52: 61-70.

[4] Arora k, Gutierrez M, Hedayat A, Xia C. Tunnels in squeezing clay-rich rocks. Undergr Space. 2021; 6: 432-445.

[5] Asghar R, Lohrasb F, Mohammad D. Squeezing rock conditions at phyllite-slate zone in Golab water conveyance tunnel, Iran: a case study. J Central South Univ. 2017; 24: 2475-2485.

[6] Azizi F, Koopialipoor M, Khoshrou H. Estimation of rock mass squeezing potential in tunnel route (case study: Kerman Water Conveyance Tunnel). Geotech Geol Eng. 2018; 37: 1671-1685.

[7] Barla G, Bonini M, Debernardi D. Time Dependent Deformations in Squeezing Tunnels. International Association for Computer Methods and Advances in Geomechanics (IACMAG); 2008.

[8] Barla G, Bonini M, Debernardi D. Time dependent deformations in squeezing tunnels. Int J Geoeng Case Histories. 2010; 2(1): 40-65.

[9] Barla G, Borgna S. Tunneling in squeezing ground condition. Proc ROOKSITE-99. 1999; 1: 97-108.

[10] Barton N. Some new Q-value correlations to assist in site characterisation and tunnel design. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci. 2002; 39(2): 185-216.

[11] Barton N, Lien R, Lunde J. Engineering classification of rock masses for the design of tunnel support. Rock Mech. 1974; 6(4): 189-236.

[12] Basnet CB. Evaluation on the Squeezing Phenomenon at the Headrace Tunnel of Chameliya Hydroelectric Project, Nepal. Engineering thesis. Norwegian University of Science and Technology; 2013.

[13] Bian K, Liu J, Liu Z, et al. Mechanisms of large deformation in soft rock tunnels: a case study of Huangjiazhai Tunnel. Bull Eng Geol Environ. 2019; 78: 431-444.

[14] Bieniawski ZT. Engineering Rock Mass Classifications. Wiley; 1989.

[15] Bo Y, Huang X, Pan Y, et al. Robust model for tunnel squeezing using Bayesian optimized classifiers with partially missing database. Undergr Space. 2023; 10: 91-117.

[16] Chern JC, Yu CW, Kao HC. Tunneling in squeezing ground. In: International Conference on Case Histories in Geotechnical Engineering. University of Missouri-Rolla; 1998:13. https://scholarsmine.mst.edu/icchge/4icchge/4icchge-session06/13

[17] Dalgıç S. Tunneling in squeezing rock, the Bolu tunnel, Anatolian Motorway, Turkey. Eng Geol. 2002; 67: 73-96.

[18] Do DP, Vu MN, Tran NT, Armand G. Closed‑form solution and reliability analysis of deep tunnel supported by a concrete liner and a covered compressible layer within the viscoelastic burger rock. Rock Mech Rock Eng. 2021; 54: 2311-2334.

[19] Do NA, Dias D, Oreste P, Djeran-Maigre I. Three-dimensional numerical simulation for mechanized tunnelling in soft ground: the influence of the joint pattern. Acta Geotech. 2014; 9(4): 673-694.

[20] Dwivedi RD, Singh M, Viladkar MN, Goel RK. Estimation of support pressure during tunnelling through squeezing grounds. Eng Geol. 2014; 168: 9-22.

[21] Fraldi M, Guarracino F. Analytical solutions for collapse mechanisms in tunnels with arbitrary cross sections. Int J Solids Struct. 2010; 47: 216-223.

[22] De La Fuente M. Tunneling Under Squeezing Conditions: Effect of the Excavation Method. PhD thesis. Université Paris-Est; 2018.

[23] De La Fuente M, Sulem J, Taherzadeh R, Subrin D. Tunneling in squeezing ground: effect of the excavation method. Rock Mech Rock Eng. 2020; 53: 601-623.

[24] Gao S, Chen J, Zuo C, Wang W, Sun Y. Structure optimization for the support system in soft rock tunnel based on numerical analysis and field monitoring. Geotech Geol Eng. 2016; 34: 1089-1099.

[25] Goel RK, Jethwa JL, Paithankar AG. Indian experiences with Q and RMR systems. Tunnel Undergr Space Technol. 1995; 10(1): 97-109.

[26] Hoek E. Support for very weak rock associated with faults and shear zones. In: International Symposium on Rock Support and Reinforcement Practice in Mining, Kalgoorlie, Australia, 14-19 March 1999. 1999.

[27] Hoek E. Big tunnels in bad rock 2000 Terzaghi lecture. ASCE J Geotech GeoenvironEng. 2000; 127(9): 726-740.

[28] Hoek E, Brown ET. Practical estimates of rock mass strength. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci. 1997; 34(8): 1165-1186.

[29] Hoek E, Guevara R. Overcoming squeezing in the Yacambú-Quibor tunnel, Venezuela. Rock Mech Rock Eng. 2009; 42(2): 389-418.

[30] Hoek E, Marinos P. Predicting tunnel squeezing problems in weak heterogeneous rock masses. Tunnels Tunnel Int. 2000; 32(11): 45-51.

[31] Iasiello C, Guerra Torralbo JC, Torrero Fernández C. Large deformations in deep tunnels excavated in weak rocks: study on Y-Basque high-speed railway tunnels in northern Spain. Undergr Space. 2021; 6: 636-649.

[32] Jethwa JL, Singh B, Singh BH. Estimation of ultimate rock pressure for tunnel linings under squeezing rock conditions—a new approach. In: Brown ET, Hudson JA, eds. Design and Performance of Underground Excavations: ISRM Symposium, Cambridge. Vol 1. 1984: 231-238.

[33] Kabwe E, Karakus M, Chanda EK. Isotropic damage constitutive model for time-dependent behaviour of tunnels in squeezing ground. Comput Geotech. 2020; 127:103738.

[34] Kitagawa T, Kumeta T, Ichizyo T, Soga S, Sato M, Yasukawa M. Application of convergence confinement analysis to the study of preceding displacement of a squeezing rock tunnel. Rock Mech Rock Eng. 1991; 24: 31-51.

[35] Liu B, Song Y, Chu Z. Time-dependent safety of lining structures of circular tunnels in weak rock strata. Int J Min Sci Technol. 2022; 32(2): 323-334.

[36] Oke J, Vlachopoulos N, Diederichs M. Improvement to the convergence confinement method: inclusion of support installation proximity and stiffness. Rock Mech Rock Eng. 2018; 51: 1495-1519.

[37] Panda MK, Mohanty S, Pingua BMP, Mishra AK. Engineering geological and geotechnical investigations along the head race tunnel in Teesta Stage-III hydroelectric project, India. Eng Geol. 2014; 181: 297-308.

[38] Paraskevopoulou C, Diederichs M. Analysis of time-dependent deformation in tunnels using the convergence-confinement method. Tunnel Undergr Space Technol. 2018; 71: 62-80.

[39] Qiu W, Wang G, Gong L, Shen Z, Li C, Dang J. Research and application of resistance-limiting and energy-dissipating support in large deformation tunnel. Chin J Rock Mech. 2018; 37: 1785-1795.

[40] Sakai K, Schubert W. Study on ductile support system by means of convergence confinement method. In: Fifth ISRM Young Scholars' Symposium on Rock Mechanics and International Symposium on Rock Engineering for Innovative Future. Japanese Society for Rock Mechanics; 2019.

[41] Singh B, Jethwa JL, Dube AK, Singh B. Correlation between observed support pressure and rock mass quality. Tunnel Undergr Space Technol. 1992; 7(1): 59-74.

[42] Sun J, Pan XM. Research on large squeezing deformation and its nonlinear rheological mechanical characteristics of tunnel with weak surrounding rocks. Chin J Rock Mech Rock Eng. 2012; 31(10): 1957-1968.

[43] Sun Y, Feng X, Yang L. Predicting tunnel squeezing using multiclass support vector machines. Adv Civil Eng. 2018; 2018: 1-12.

[44] Taghizadeh H, Zare S, Mazraehli M. Analysis of rock load for tunnel lining design. Geotech Geol Eng. 2020; 38: 2989-3005.

[45] User's manual of FLAC3D, creep material models. Version 3. Itasca Consulting Group Inc.; 2005.

[46] Wang X, Iura T, Jiang Y, Wang Z, Liu R. Deformation and mechanical characteristics of in squeezing ground: a case study of the west section of the Tawarazaka Tunnel in Japan. Tunnel Undergr Space Technol. 2021; 109:103697.

[47] Wang X, Lai J, Garnes RS, Luo Y. Support system for tunnelling in squeezing ground of Qingling-Daba mountainous area: a case study from soft rock tunnels. Adv Civil Eng. 2019; 2019:8682535.

[48] Wu G, Chen W, Dai Y, Yang J, Tan X, Tian H. Application of a type of strain block FBG sensor for strain measurements of squeezing rock in a deep-buried tunnel. Meas Sci Technol. 2017; 28(11):115001.

[49] Wu K, Shao Z, Qin S, Li B. Determination of deformation mechanism and countermeasures in silty clay tunnel. J Perform Constr Facil. 2020; 34(1):04019095.

[50] Xu C, Xia C, Du S. Simplified solution for viscoelastic–plastic interaction between tunnel support and surrounding rock based on MC and GZZ strength criteria. Comput Geotech. 2021; 139:104393.

[51] Yang Z, Wang Z, Zhang L, Zhou R, Xing N. Back-analysis of viscoelastic displacements in a soft rock road tunnel. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci. 2001; 38(3): 331-341.

[52] Zaheri M, Ranjbarnia M, Zareifard MR. A theoretical solution to investigate long-term behavior of pressurized tunnels in severe squeezing conditions. Comput Geotech. 2023; 159:105499.

[53] Zhang J, Li D, Wang Y. Predicting tunnel squeezing using a hybrid classifier ensemble with incomplete data. Bull Eng Geol Environ. 2020; 79: 3245-3256.

[54] Zhang ZX, Liu C, Huang X. Numerical analysis of volume loss caused by tunnel face instability in soft soils. Environ Earth Sci. 2017; 76:5630.

[55] Zheng X, Wu K, Shao Z, Yuan B, Zhao N. Tunnel squeezing deformation control and the use of yielding elements in shotcrete linings: a review. Materials. 2022; 15(1):391.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2024 The Author(s). Deep Underground Science and Engineering published by John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd on behalf of China University of Mining and Technology.