Use of fluoride varnish with functionalized tricalcium phosphate for prevention of early childhood caries: A randomised clinical trial

Abstract

The aim of this study is to compare the caries-preventive effect of 5% sodium fluoride (NaF) varnish with and without functionalized tricalcium phosphate (fTCP) on young children with untreated active caries. This 24-month, double-blind, parallel-designed, randomised controlled trial recruited 408 three-year-old children with untreated active carious lesion. Dental caries was diagnosed at the cavitation level according to WHO criteria, with carious lesions categorized as active if gentle probing revealed softness. A tooth surface was scored as sound in the absence of treated or untreated clinical dental caries. Recruited children were block-randomized into two intervention groups based on caries status (dmfs=1–3 or > 3). Group A received semi-annual application of a NaF varnish on all tooth surfaces. Group B received semi-annual application of a NaF varnish with fTCP on all tooth surfaces. Silver nitrate was applied on carious tooth surface before varnish application to promote caries arrest. Per protocol analysis was performed. At the 24-month evaluation, 356 children (87%) and 29,628 tooth surfaces (87%) were assessed. No significant difference was found in the attrition rate between groups (p = 0.30). At child level, no significant difference was found in the incidence rate of dental caries (86% vs. 82%, p = 0.38), the increment of mean dmft score (2.7 vs. 2.5, p = 0.50) and mean dmfs scores (4.8 vs. 4.3, p = 0.37) between groups. At tooth surface level, Group A had more sound tooth-surface becoming carious (865 vs. 742; 5.7% vs. 5.1%; p = 0.035). However, results of the generalized estimating equation model indicated treatment protocols were not significant related to the incidence of carious surfaces (p = 0.197) after adjusting clustering effect and confounding factors. When applied semi-annually to children with active caries, the 5% NaF varnish with fTCP and the conventional NaF varnish showed equivalent preventive efficacy in children with active caries.

Keywords

Caries / Children / Fluoride / Prevention / Clinical trial

References

[1] A. De Grauwe, J.K. Aps, L.C. Martens, Early Childhood Caries (ECC): what's in a name? Eur. J. Paediatr. Dent. 5 (2004) 62-70.

[2] S.E. Uribe, N. Innes, I. Maldupa, The global prevalence of early childhood caries: a systematic review with meta-analysis using the who diagnostic criteria, Int J. Paediatr. Dent. 31 (6) (2021) 817-830.

[3] H. Colak, C.T. Dülgergil, M. Dalli, M.M. Hamidi, Early childhood caries update: a review of causes, diagnoses, and treatments, J. Nat. Sci. Biol. Med. 4 (1) (2013) 29-38.

[4] S.G. Dashper, H.L. Mitchell, K.A. Lê Cao, L. Carpenter, M.G. Gussy, H. Calache, S.L. Gladman, D.M. Bulach, B. Hoffmann, D.V. Catmull, et al., Temporal development of the oral microbiome and prediction of early childhood caries, Sci. Rep. 9 (1) (2019) 19732.

[5] R.H. Selwitz, A.I. Ismail, N.B. Pitts, Dental caries, Lancet 369 (9555) (2007) 51-59.

[6] V.K. Kutsch, Dental caries: an updated medical model of risk assessment, J. Prosthet. Dent. 111 (4) (2014) 280-285.

[7] K.J. Chen, S.S. Gao, D. Duangthip, S.K.Y. Li, E.C.M. Lo, C.H. Chu, Dental caries status and its associated factors among 5-year-old hong kong children: a cross-sectional study, BMC Oral. Health 17 (1) (2017) 121.

[8] M. Goldberg, Deciduous tooth and dental caries, Ann. Pedia Child Health 5 (1) (2017) 1120.

[9] J.D.B. Featherstone, Y.O. Crystal, P. Alston, B.W. Chaffee, S. Doméjean, P. Rechmann, L. Zhan, F. Ramos-Gomez, A comparison of four caries risk assessment methods, Front Oral. Health 2 (2021) 656558.

[10] P. Corrêa-Faria, S. Paixão-Gonçalves, S.M. Paiva, I.A. Pordeus, Incidence of dental caries in primary dentition and risk factors: a longitudinal study, Braz. Oral. Res 30 (1) (2016).

[11] X.L. Gao, C.Y. Hsu, T. Loh, D. Koh, H.B. Hwamg, Y. Xu, Dental caries prevalence and distribution among preschoolers in singapore, Community Dent. Health 26 (1) (2009) 12-17.

[12] S.H. Wei, A.K. Holm, L.S. Tong, S.W. Yuen, Dental caries prevalence and related factors in 5-year-old children in hong kong, Pedia Dent. 15 (2) (1993) 116-119.

[13] K. Rošin-Grget, K. Peroš, I. Sutej, K. Bašić, The cariostatic mechanisms of fluoride, Acta Med Acad. 42 (2) (2013) 179-188.

[14] J.D. Featherstone, Prevention and reversal of dental caries: role of low level fluoride, Community Dent. Oral. Epidemiol. 27 (1) (1999) 31-40.

[15] V.C. Marinho, H.V. Worthington, T. Walsh, J.E. Clarkson, Fluoride varnishes for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents, Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 2013 (7) (2013) Cd002279.

[16] E.A. Abou Neel, A. Aljabo, A. Strange, S. Ibrahim, M. Coathup, A.M. Young, L. Bozec, V. Mudera, Demineralization-remineralization dynamics in teeth and bone, Int J. Nanomed. 11 (2016) 4743-4763.

[17] J. Chen, Y. Zhang, I.X. Yin, O.Y. Yu, A.K.Y. Chan, C.H. Chu, Preventing dental caries with calcium-based materials: a concise review, Inorganics 12 (9) (2024) 253.

[18] R. Karlinsey, A. Pfarrer, Fluoride plus functionalized β-tcp: a promising combination for robust remineralization, Adv. Dent. Res. 24 (2) (2012) 48-52.

[19] O. Salamara, A. Papadimitriou, D. Mortensen, S. Twetman, D. Koletsi, S. Gizani, Effect of fluoride varnish with functionalized tri-calcium phosphate on post-orthodontic white spot lesions: an investigator-blinded controlled trial, Quintessence Int. 51 (10) (2020).

[20] K. Chen, S. Gao, D. Duangthip, E. Lo, C. Chu, Randomized clinical trial on sodium fluoride with tricalcium phosphate, J. Dent. Res. 100 (1) (2021) 66-73.

[21] K.J. Chen, S.S. Gao, D. Duangthip, E.C.M. Lo, C.H. Chu, The caries-arresting effect of incorporating functionalized tricalcium phosphate into fluoride varnish applied following application of silver nitrate solution in preschool children: study protocol for a randomized, double-blind clinical trial, Trials 19 (1) (2018) 352.

[22] S. Cuschieri, The consort statement, Saudi J. Anaesth. 13 (1) (2019) S27-S30.

[23] B.H. Oliveira, M. Salazar, D.M. Carvalho, A. Falcão, K. Campos, P. Nadanovsky, Biannual fluoride varnish applications and caries incidence in preschoolers: a 24-month follow-up randomized placebo-controlled clinical trial, Caries Res. 48 (3) (2014) 228-236.

[24] World Health Organization, Oral health surveys: Basic methods, World Health Organization, 2013.

[25] K. Ekstrand, D. Zero, S. Martignon, N. Pitts, Lesion activity assessment. Detection, assessment, diagnosis and monitoring of caries, Karger Publishers, 2009, pp. 63-90.

[26] P.B. Shah, Intention-to-treat and per-protocol analysis, CMAJ 183 (6) (2011) 696.

[27] J. Zou, Q. Du, L. Ge, J. Wang, X. Wang, Y. Li, G. Song, W. Zhao, X. Chen, B. Jiang, et al., Expert consensus on early childhood caries management, Int J. Oral Sci. 14 (1) (2022) 35.

[28] O.Y. Yu, I.S. Zhao, M.L. Mei, E.C. Lo, C.H. Chu, Effect of silver nitrate and sodium fluoride with tri-calcium phosphate on streptococcus mutans and demineralised dentine, Int J. Mol. Sci. 19 (5) (2018).

[29] R.J. Wierichs, S. Stausberg, J. Lausch, H. Meyer-Lueckel, M. Esteves-Oliveira, Caries-preventive effect of naf, naf plus tcp, naf plus cpp-acp, and sdf varnishes on sound dentin and artificial dentin caries in vitro, Caries Res. 52 (3) (2018) 199-211.

[30] K.J. Toumba, S. Twetman, C. Splieth, C. Parnell, C. van Loveren, N. Lygidakis, Guidelines on the use of fluoride for caries prevention in children: an updated eapd policy document, Eur. Arch. Paediatr. Dent. 20 (6) (2019) 507-516.

[31] F.M. Zheng, I.G. Yan, I.G. Sun, D. Duangthip, E.C.M. Lo, C.H. Chu, Early childhood caries and dental public health programmes in hong kong, Int Dent. J. 74 (1) (2024) 35-41.

[32] Department of Health, Oral Health Survey 2021, Hong Kong SAR, 2024, p. 28.

[33] H.-J. Cho, H.-C. Lee, J.-Y. Lee, B.-H. Jin, Remineralization ability of fluoride varnish containing tricalcium phosphate by time, J. Korean Acad. Oral. Health 41 (1) (2017) 3-8.

[34] S. Aruna, B. Meenakshi, K. Rama, S. Valarmathi, Salivary levels of calcium and phosphorus in children with and without early childhood caries: a pilot study, SRM J. Res. Dent. Sci. 11 (2) (2020) 72-75.

[35] G.M. Whitford, Acute and chronic fluoride toxicity, J. Dent. Res 71 (5) (1992) 1249-1254.

[36] A. Borutta, M. Wagner, S. Kneist, Early childhood caries: A multi-factorial disease, Life 20 (2010) 22.

[37] A.A. Marghalani, E. Guinto, M. Phan, V. Dhar, N. Tinanoff, Effectiveness of xylitol in reducing dental caries in children, Pediatr. Dent. 39 (2) (2017) 103-110.

[38] R.C. Soares, S.V. da Rosa, S.T. Moysés, J.S. Rocha, P.V.C. Bettega, R.I. Werneck, S.J. Moysés, Methods for prevention of early childhood caries: overview of systematic reviews, Int J. Paediatr. Dent. 31 (3) (2021) 394-421.

[39] R. Ferro, A. Besostri, A. Olivieri, Caries prevalence and tooth surface distribution in a group of 5-year-old italian children, Eur. Arch. Paediatr. Dent. 10 (1) (2009) 33-37.

[40] D.M. O'Sullivan, N. Tinanoff, The association of early dental caries patterns with caries incidence in preschool children, J. Public Health Dent. 56 (2) (1996) 81-83.

[41] S. Tungare, A.G. Paranjpe, Statpearls, Early childhood caries, StatPearls Publishing, Treasure Island, 2025.

[42] FDI World Dental Federation, Chairside guide consensus on toothbrushing, FDI World Dental Federation, Switzerland, 2023.

[43] G.S. Doig, F. Simpson, Randomization and allocation concealment: a practical guide for researchers, J. Crit. Care 20 (2) (2005) 187-191 discussion 191-183.

[44] P. Kaul, B. Bose, R. Kumar, I. Ilahi, P.K. Garg, The strength of a randomized controlled trial lies in its design-randomization, Support. Care Cancer 30 (6) (2022) 4573-4575.

[45] J.R. Landis, G.G. Koch, The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data, Biometrics 33 (1) (1977) 159-174.

[46] S. He, D. Duangthip, C.H. Chu, E.C.M. Lo, Topical fluoride in preventing occlusal caries in children in a fluoridated area: a randomized clinical trial, J. Dent. Res (2025) 220345251355260.

[47] F.M. Zheng, I.G. Yan, D. Duangthip, E.C.M. Lo, S.S. Gao, C.H. Chu, Caries prevention using silver diamine fluoride: a 12-month clinical trial, Int Dent. J. 73 (5) (2023) 667-673.

[48] J. Gomez, Detection and diagnosis of the early caries lesion, BMC Oral. Health 15 (2015) Suppl 1(Suppl 1) S3.

[49] G. Tripepi, N.C. Chesnaye, F.W. Dekker, C. Zoccali, K.J. Jager, Intention to treat and per protocol analysis in clinical trials, Nephrology 25 (7) (2020) 513-517.

[50] E. Miller, W. Vann Jr., The use of fluoride varnish in children: a critical review with treatment recommendations, J. Clin. Pediatr. Dent. 32 (4) (2008) 259-264.

[51] V.C. Marinho, H.V. Worthington, T. Walsh, J.E. Clarkson, Fluoride varnishes for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents, Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 2013 (7) (2013) Cd002279.