Survey on security aspects of distributed software-defined networking controllers in an enterprise SD-WLAN

Abstract

Software-Defined Networking (SDN) improves network management by separating its control logic from the underlying hardware and integrating it into a logically centralized control unit, termed the SDN controller. SDN adaptation is essential for wireless networks because it offers enhanced and data-intensive services. The initial intent of the SDN design was to have a physically centralized controller. However, network experts have suggested logically centralized and physically distributed designs for SDN controllers, owing to issues such as a single point of failure and scalability. This study addressed the security, scalability, reliability, and consistency issues associated with the design of distributed SDN controllers. Moreover, the security issues of an enterprise related to multiple physically distributed controllers in a software-defined wireless local area network (SD-WLAN) were emphasized, and optimal solutions were suggested.

Keywords

Software-defined networking (SDN) SDN controller / Logically centralized SDN controller / Physically distributed SDN controller / Software-defined wireless local area network (SD-WLAN)

References

[1] R. Sahay, W. Meng, C.D. Jensen, The application of software defined networking on securing computer networks: a survey, J. Netw. Comput. Appl. 131 (2019) 89-108.

[2] K.K. Karmakar, V. Varadharajan, U. Tupakula, Mitigating attacks in software de-fined networks, Clust. Comput. 22 (2019) 1143-1157.

[3] M. Chen, Y. Qian, S. Mao, W. Tang, X. Yang, Software-defined mobile networks security, Mob. Netw. Appl. 21 (2016) 729-743.

[4] A.Y. Ding, J. Crowcroft, S. Tarkoma, H. Flinck, Software defined networking for security enhancement in wireless mobile networks, Comput. Netw. 66 (2014) 94-101.

[5] D.B. Rawat, S.R. Reddy, Software defined networking architecture, security and energy efficiency: a survey, IEEE Commun. Surv. Tutor. 19 (1) (2016) 325-346.

[6] M. Dabbagh, B. Hamdaoui, M. Guizani, A. Rayes, Software-defined networking security: pros and cons, IEEE Commun. Mag. 53 (6) (2015) 73-79.

[7] I. Alsmadi, D. Xu, Security of software defined networks: a survey, Comput. Secur. 53 (2015) 79-108.

[8] S.T. Ali, V. Sivaraman, A. Radford, S. Jha, A survey of securing networks using software defined networking, IEEE Trans. Reliab. 64 (3) (2015) 1086-1097.

[9] S. Scott-Hayward, S. Natarajan, S. Sezer, A survey of security in software defined networks, IEEE Commun. Surv. Tutor. 18 (1) (2015) 623-654.

[10] D. Kreutz, F.M. Ramos, P. Verissimo,Towards secure and dependable software-defined networks, in:Proceedings of the Second ACM SIGCOMM Workshop on Hot Topics in Software Defined Networking, 2013, pp. 55-60.

[11] Z. Shu, J. Wan, D. Li, J. Lin, A.V. Vasilakos, M. Imran, Security in software-defined networking: threats and countermeasures, Mob. Netw. Appl. 21 (2016) 764-776.

[12] B. Dezfouli, V. Esmaeelzadeh, J. Sheth, M. Radi, A review of software-defined WLANs: architectures and central control mechanisms, IEEE Commun. Surv. Tu-tor. 21 (1) (2018) 431-463.

[13] K.I. Qureshi, L. Wang, L. Sun, C. Zhu, L. Shu, A review on design and implementa-tion of software-defined WLANs, IEEE Syst. J. 14 (2) (2020) 2601-2614.

[14] M.-C. Chan, C. Chen, J.-X. Huang, T. Kuo, L.-H. Yen, C.-C. Tseng, Opennet: a sim-ulator for software-defined wireless local area network, in: 2014 IEEE Wireless Communications and Networking Conference, WCNC, IEEE, 2014, pp. 3332-3336.

[15] J. Feng, L. Zhao, C. Chen, Z. Ren, J. Du, User-oriented load balance in software-defined campus WLANs, in: 2016 IEEE 83rd Vehicular Technology Conference, VTC Spring, IEEE, 2016, pp. 1-5.

[16] J. Chen, B. Liu, H. Zhou, Q. Yu, L. Gui, X. Shen, Qos-driven efficient client asso-ciation in high-density software-defined WLAN, IEEE Trans. Veh. Technol. 66 (8)(2017) 7372-7383.

[17] D. Zhao, M. Zhu, M. Xu, Sdwlan: a flexible architecture of enterprise WLAN for client-unaware fast ap handoff, in: Fifth International Conference on Computing, Communications and Networking Technologies, ICCCNT, IEEE, 2014, pp. 1-6.

[18] S. Costanzo, L. Galluccio, G. Morabito, S. Palazzo, Software defined wireless net-works: unbridling SDNs, in: 2012 European Workshop on Software Defined Net-working, IEEE, 2012, pp. 1-6.

[19] L. Leonardi, M. Ashjaei, H. Fotouhi, L.L. Bello,A proposal towards software-defined management of heterogeneous virtualized industrial networks, in: 2019 IEEE 17th International Conference on Industrial Informatics, vol. 1, INDIN, IEEE, 2019, pp. 1741-1746.

[20] J. Schulz-Zander, C. Mayer, B. Ciobotaru, S. Schmid, A. Feldmann, Opensdwn: pro-grammatic control over home and enterprise WiFi,in: Proceedings of the 1st ACM SIGCOMM Symposium on Software Defined Networking Research, 2015, pp. 1-12.

[21] J. Vestin, P. Dely, A. Kassler, N. Bayer, H. Einsiedler, C. Peylo, Cloudmac: tor-wards software defined WLANs,in: Proceedings of the 18th Annual International Conference on Mobile Computing and Networking, 2012, pp. 393-396.

[22] L. Suresh, J. Schulz-Zander, R. Merz, A. Feldmann, T. Vazao,Towards pro-grammable enterprise WLANs with odin, in:Proceedings of the First Workshop on Hot Topics in Software Defined Networks, 2012, pp. 115-120.

[23] K. Yap, M. Kobayashi, R. Sherwood, T. Huang, M. Chan, N. Handigol, N. McKeown, Acm sigcomm comput, Commun. Rev. 40 (1) (2010) 125.

[24] D. Tu, Z. Zhao, H. Zhang, ISD-WiFi: an intelligent SDN based solution for enter-prise WLANs, in: 2016 8th International Conference on Wireless Communications & Signal Processing, WCSP, IEEE, 2016, pp. 1-6.

[25] K.V.K. Singh, M. Pandey, Software-defined mobility in IP based Wi-Fi networks: design proposal and future directions, in: 2016 IEEE International Conference on Advanced Networks and Telecommunications Systems, ANTS, IEEE, 2016, pp. 1-6.

[26] S. Mushhad, M. Gilani, T. Hong, W. Jin, G. Zhao, H.M. Heang, C. Xu,Mobility man-agement in IEEE 802.11 WLAN using SDN/NFV technologies, EURASIP J. Wirel. Commun. Netw. 2017 (2017) 1.

[27] A. Zubow, S. Zehl, A. Wolisz,Bigap—seamless handover in high performance enter-prise IEEE 802.11 networks, in: NOMS 2016-2016 IEEE/IFIP Network Operations and Management Symposium, IEEE, 2016, pp. 445-453.

[28] T. Lei, Z. Lu, X. Wen, X. Zhao, L. Wang Swan, An SDN based campus WLAN framework, in: 2014 4th International Conference on Wireless Communications, Vehicular Technology, Information Theory and Aerospace & Electronic Systems, VITAE, IEEE, 2014, pp. 1-5.

[29] O. Stiti, O. Braham, G. Pujolle, Virtual openflow-based SDN wi-fi access point, in: 2015 Global Information Infrastructure and Networking Symposium, GIIS, IEEE, 2015, pp. 1-3.

[30] D. Zhao, M. Zhu, M. Xu, Supporting “one big ap” illusion in enterprise WLAN: an SDN-based solution, in: 2014 Sixth International Conference on Wireless Commu-nications and Signal Processing, WCSP, IEEE, 2014, pp. 1-6.

[31] J. Saldana, R. Munilla, S. Eryigit, O. Topal, J. Ruiz-Mas, J. Fernández-Navajas, L. Sequeira, Unsticking the wi-fi client: smarter decisions using a software defined wireless solution, IEEE Access 6 (2018) 30917-30931.

[32] A. Patro, S. Banerjee, COAP: a software-defined approach for home WLAN manage-ment through an open API,in: Proceedings of the 9th ACM Workshop on Mobility in the Evolving Internet Architecture, 2014, pp. 31-36.

[33] X. Sang, Q. Wu, H. Li,Client-network collaborative load balancing mechanism for WLAN based on SDN and 802.11 u, in: 2017 13th International Wireless Commu-nications and Mobile Computing Conference, IWCMC, IEEE, 2017, pp. 506-511.

[34] H. Moura, G.V. Bessa, M.A. Vieira, D.F. Macedo, Ethanol: software defined net-working for 802.11 wireless networks, in: 2015 IFIP/IEEE International Sympo-sium on Integrated Network Management (IM), IEEE, 2015, pp. 388-396.

[35] A.K. Nayak, A. Reimers, N. Feamster, R. Clark, Resonance: dynamic access control for enterprise networks,in: Proceedings of the 1st ACM Workshop on Research on Enterprise Networking, 2009, pp. 11-18.

[36] R.N. Murty, J. Padhye, A. Wolman, M. Welsh, An architecture for extensible wire-less LANs, in: HotNets, 2008, pp. 79-84.

[37] R. Murty, J. Padhye, A. Wolman, M. Welsh Dyson,An architecture for extensible wireless LANs, in:Usenix Annual Technical Conference, 2010.

[38] R. Murty, J. Padhye, R. Chandra, A. Wolman, B. Zill, Designing high performance enterprise wi-fi networks, in: NSDI, vol. 8, 2008, pp. 73-88.

[39] G. Bhanage, D. Vete, I. Seskar, D. Raychaudhuri,Splitap: leveraging wireless net-work virtualization for flexible sharing of WLANs, in: 2010 IEEE Global Telecom-munications Conference GLOBECOM 2010, IEEE, 2010, pp. 1-6.

[40] V. Shrivastava, N. Ahmed, S. Rayanchu, S. Banerjee, S. Keshav, K. Papagiannaki, A. Mishra, Centaur: realizing the full potential of centralized WLANs through a hybrid data path,in: Proceedings of the 15th Annual International Conference on Mobile Computing and Networking, 2009, pp. 297-308.

[41] M.S. Carmo, S. Jardim, T. de Souza, A.V. Neto, R. Aguiar, D. Corujo, Towards en-hanced connectivity through WLAN slicing, in: 2017 Wireless Telecommunications Symposium (WTS), IEEE, 2017, pp. 1-7.

[42] K. Nakauchi, Y. Shoji, N. Nishinaga, Airtime-based resource control in wireless LANs for wireless network virtualization, in: 2012 Fourth International Conference on Ubiquitous and Future Networks, ICUFN, IEEE, 2012, pp. 166-169.

[43] S. Senapathi, X. Foukas, M.K. Marina, Vali-an SDN-based management framework for public wireless LANs: poster,in: Proceedings of the 22nd Annual International Conference on Mobile Computing and Networking, 2016, pp. 443-444.

[44] L. Deek, E. Garcia-Villegas, E. Belding, S.-J. Lee, K. Almeroth,Joint rate and channel width adaptation for 802.11 mimo wireless networks, in: 2013 IEEE Inter-national Conference on Sensing, Communications and Networking, SECON, IEEE, 2013, pp. 167-175.

[45] Y. Li, C. Liao, Y. Wang, C. Wang, Energy-efficient optimal relay selection in co-operative cellular networks based on double auction, IEEE Trans. Wirel. Commun. 14 (8) (2015) 4093-4104.

[46] Y. Li, Y. Liang, Q. Liu, H. Wang, Resources allocation in multicell d2d communica-tions for Internet of things, IEEE Int. Things J. 5(5) (2018) 4100-4108.

[47] T. Nagai, H. Shigeno, A framework of ap aggregation using virtualization for high density WLANs, in: 2011 Third International Conference on Intelligent Networking and Collaborative Systems, IEEE, 2011, pp. 350-355.

[48] I.T. Haque, N. Abu-Ghazaleh, Wireless software defined networking: a survey and taxonomy, IEEE Commun. Surv. Tutor. 18 (4) (2016) 2713-2737.

[49] N. McKeown, T. Anderson, H. Balakrishnan, G. Parulkar, L. Peterson, J. Rexford, S. Shenker, J. Turner, Openflow: enabling innovation in campus networks, ACM SIGCOMM Comput. Commun. Rev. 38 (2) (2008) 69-74.

[50] H. Kim, N. Feamster, Improving network management with software defined net-working, IEEE Commun. Mag. 51 (2) (2013) 114-119.

[51] M. Casado, M.J. Freedman, J. Pettit, J. Luo, N. McKeown, S. Shenker, Ethane: taking control of the enterprise, ACM SIGCOMM Comput. Commun. Rev. 37 (4)(2007) 1-12.

[52] T. Hu, Z. Guo, P. Yi, T. Baker, J. Lan, Multi-controller based software-defined net-working: a survey, IEEE Access 6 (2018) 15980-15996.

[53] B. Heller, R. Sherwood, N. McKeown, The controller placement problem, ACM SIGCOMM Comput. Commun. Rev. 42 (4) (2012) 473-478.

[54] H.K. Rath, V. Revoori, S.M. Nadaf, A. Simha,Optimal controller placement in soft-ware defined networks (SDN) using a non-zero-sum game, in: Proceeding of IEEE International Symposium on a World of Wireless, Mobile and Multimedia Networks 2014, IEEE, 2014, pp. 1-6.

[55] A. Ksentini, M. Bagaa, T. Taleb, I. Balasingham, On using bargaining game for optimal placement of SDN controllers, in: 2016 Ieee International Conference on Communications, ICC, IEEE, 2016, pp. 1-6.

[56] C.-C. Tseng, L.-H. Yen, H.-H. Chang, K.-C. Hsu,Topology-aided cross-layer fast handoff designs for ieee 802.11/mobile ip environments, IEEE Commun. Mag. 43 (12) (2005) 156-163.

[57] M. Caria, A. Jukan, M. Hoffmann, Sdn partitioning: a centralized control plane for distributed routing protocols, IEEE Trans. Netw. Serv. Manag. 13 (3) (2016) 381-393.

[58] Y. Zhang, L. Cui, W. Wang, Y. Zhang, A survey on software defined networking with multiple controllers, J. Netw. Comput. Appl. 103 (2018) 101-118.

[59] B.P.R. Killi, S.V. Rao, Optimal model for failure foresight capacitated controller placement in software-defined networks, IEEE Commun. Lett. 20 (6) (2016) 1108-1111.

[60] K.-S. Kong, W. Lee, Y.-H. Han, M.-K. Shin, Handover latency analysis of a network-based localized mobility management protocol, in: 2008 IEEE International Con-ference on Communications, IEEE, 2008, pp. 5838-5843.

[61] A. Sallahi, M. St-Hilaire, Expansion model for the controller placement problem in software defined networks, IEEE Commun. Lett. 21 (2) (2016) 274-277.

[62] Y. Fu, J. Bi, Z. Chen, K. Gao, B. Zhang, G. Chen, J. Wu, A hybrid hierarchical control plane for flow-based large-scale software-defined networks, IEEE Trans. Netw. Serv. Manag. 12 (2) (2015) 117-131.

[63] P. Xiao, N. Liu, Y. Li, Y. Lu, X.-j. Tang, H.-w. Wang, M.-x. Li, A traffic classification method with spectral clustering in SDN, in: 2016 17th International Conference on Parallel and Distributed Computing, Applications and Technologies, PDCAT, IEEE, 2016, pp. 391-394.

[64] Y. Hu, W. Wang, X. Gong, X. Que, S. Cheng, On reliability-optimized controller placement for software-defined networks, China Commun. 11 (2) (2014) 38-54.

[65] N. Beheshti, Y. Zhang, Fast failover for control traffic in software-defined net-works, in: 2012 IEEE Global Communications Conference, GLOBECOM, IEEE, 2012, pp. 2665-2670.

[66] Y. Zhang, N. Beheshti, M. Tatipamula,On resilience of split-architecture networks, in: 2011 IEEE Global Telecommunications Conference-GLOBECOM 2011, IEEE, 2011, pp. 1-6.

[67] S. Song, H. Park, B.-Y. Choi, T. Choi, H. Zhu, Control path management framework for enhancing software-defined network (SDN) reliability, IEEE Trans. Netw. Serv. Manag. 14 (2) (2017) 302-316.

[68] Y. Jimenez, C. Cervelló-Pastor, A.J. Garcia, On the controller placement for design-ing a distributed SDN control layer, in: 2014 IFIP Networking Conference, IEEE, 2014, pp. 1-9.

[69] F.J. Ros, P.M. Ruiz,Five nines of southbound reliability in software-defined net-works, in:Proceedings of the Third Workshop on Hot Topics in Software Defined Networking, 2014, pp. 31-36.

[70] L.F. Müller, R.R. Oliveira, M.C. Luizelli, L.P. Gaspary, M.P. Barcellos, Survivor: an enhanced controller placement strategy for improving SDN survivability, in: 2014 IEEE Global Communications Conference, IEEE, 2014, pp. 1909-1915.

[71] D. Dotan, R.Y. Pinter Hyperflow, An integrated visual query and dataflow language for end-user information analysis, in: 2005 IEEE Symposium on Visual Languages and Human-Centric Computing, VL/HCC’05, IEEE, 2005, pp. 27-34.

[72] B. Zhou, C. Wu, W. Gao, X. Hong, M. Jiang, S. Chen, Achieving consistence for cross-domain wan control in software-defined networks, China Commun. 12 (10)(2015) 136-146.

[73] S. Vinoski, Advanced message queuing protocol, IEEE Internet Comput. 10 (6)(2006) 87-89.

[74] W. Zhou, D. Jin, J. Croft, M. Caesar, P.B. Godfrey, Enforcing customizable consis-tency properties in software-defined networks, in: 12th {USENIX} Symposium on Networked Systems Design and Implementation ({NSDI} 15), 2015, pp. 73-85.

[75] Z. Guo, M. Su, Y. Xu, Z. Duan, L. Wang, S. Hui, H.J. Chao, Improving the perfor-mance of load balancing in software-defined networks through load variance-based synchronization, Comput. Netw. 68 (2014) 95-109.

[76] T. Koponen, M. Casado, N. Gude, J. Stribling, L. Poutievski, M. Zhu, R. Ra-manathan, Y. Iwata, H. Inoue, T. Hama, et al., Onix: a distributed control platform for large-scale production networks, in: OSDI, vol. 10, 2010, p. 6.

[77] A. Tootoonchian, Y. Ganjali Hyperflow,A distributed control plane for openflow, in:Proceedings of the 2010 Internet Network Management Conference on Research on Enterprise Networking, vol. 3, 2010, pp. 10-5555.

[78] Opendaylight, OpenDaylight: a community-led, industry-supported open source platform, https://www.opendaylight.org/ (n.d.).

[79] ONOS, Onos: open network operating system, https://onosproject.org/ (n.d.).

[80] F. Bannour, S. Souihi, A. Mellouk, Distributed SDN control: survey, taxonomy, and challenges, IEEE Commun. Surv. Tutor. 20 (1) (2017) 333-354.

[81] J. Xie, D. Guo, Z. Hu, T. Qu, P. Lv, Control plane of software defined networks: asurvey, Comput. Commun. 67 (2015) 1-10.

[82] F. Contributors, Floodlight openflow controller, https://github.com/floodlight/floodlight, 2020.

[83] S. Ryu, Framework community: Ryu SDN framework, Online, http://osrg.github.io/ryu.

[84] D. Erickson,The beacon openflow controller, in:Proceedings of the Second ACM SIGCOMM Workshop on Hot Topics in Software Defined Networking, 2013, pp. 13-18.

[85] Y.E. Oktian, S. Lee, H. Lee, J. Lam, Distributed SDN controller system: a survey on design choice, Comput. Netw. 121 (2017) 100-111.

[86] R. Shubbar, M. Alhisnawi, A. Abdulhassan, M. Ahamdi,A comprehensive survey on software-defined network controllers, next generation of Internet of things,in:Proceedings of ICNGIoT 2021, 2021, pp. 199-231.

[87] E. Coronado, S. Bayhan, A. Thomas, R. Riggio, Ai-empowered software-defined WLANs, IEEE Commun. Mag. 59 (3) (2021) 54-60.

[88] J. Vestin, A. Kassler, Qos enabled WiFi mac layer processing as an example of a nfv service, in: Proceedings of the 2015 1st IEEE Conference on Network Softwariza-tion, NetSoft, IEEE, 2015, pp. 1-9.

[89] K. Pelechrinis, M. Iliofotou, S.V. Krishnamurthy, Denial of service attacks in wire-less networks: the case of jammers, IEEE Commun. Surv. Tutor. 13 (2) (2010) 245-257.

[90] E. Bayraktaroglu, C. King, X. Liu, G. Noubir, R. Rajaraman, B. Thapa,Performance of ieee 802.11 under jamming, Mob. Netw. Appl. 18 (5) (2013) 678-696.

[91] K. Pelechrinis, I. Broustis, S.V. Krishnamurthy, C. Gkantsidis, Ares: an anti-jamming reinforcement system for 802.11 networks,in: Proceedings of the 5th Interna-tional Conference on Emerging Networking Experiments and Technologies, 2009, pp. 181-192.

[92] D. Giustiniano, D. Malone, D.J. Leith, K. Papagiannaki,Measuring transmission opportunities in 802.11 links, IEEE/ACM Trans. Netw. 18 (5) (2010) 1516-1529.

[93] K. Sui, S. Sun, Y. Azzabi, X. Zhang, Y. Zhao, J. Wang, Z. Li, D. Pei, Understanding the impact of ap density on WiFi performance through real-world deployment, in: 2016 IEEE International Symposium on Local and Metropolitan Area Networks, LANMAN, IEEE, 2016, pp. 1-6.

[94] K.-C. Ting, F.-C. Kuo, B.-J. Hwang, H. Wang, C.-C. Tseng,A power-saving and robust point coordination function for the transmission of VoIP over 802.11, in: International Symposium on Parallel and Distributed Processing with Applications, IEEE, 2010, pp. 283-289.

[95] Z. Zeng, Y. Gao, P. Kumar, Sofa: a sleep-optimal fair-attention scheduler for the power-saving mode of WLANs, in: 2011 31st International Conference on Dis-tributed Computing Systems, IEEE, 2011, pp. 87-98.

[96] F. Afghah, B. Cambou, M. Abedini, S. Zeadally, A ReRAM physically unclonable function (ReRAM PUF)-based approach to enhance authentication security in soft-ware defined wireless networks, Int. J. Wirel. Inf. Netw. 25 (2018) 117-129.

[97] P. Porras, S. Shin, V. Yegneswaran, M. Fong, M. Tyson, G. Gu,A security enforce-ment kernel for openflow networks, in:Proceedings of the First Workshop on Hot Topics in Software Defined Networks, 2012, pp. 121-126.

[98] S. Hong, L. Xu, H. Wang, G. Gu, Poisoning network visibility in software-defined networks: new attacks and countermeasures, in: Ndss, vol. 15, 2015, pp. 8-11.

[99] A. Gudipati, D. Perry, L.E. Li, S. Katti, Softran: software defined radio access net-work,in: Proceedings of the Second ACM SIGCOMM Workshop on Hot Topics in Software Defined Networking, 2013, pp. 25-30.

[100] Q. Yan, F.R. Yu, Q. Gong, J. Li, Software-defined networking (SDN) and distributed denial of service (DDoS) attacks in cloud computing environments: a survey, some research issues, and challenges, IEEE Commun. Surv. Tutor. 18 (1) (2015) 602-622.

[101] M. Dhawan, R. Poddar, K. Mahajan, V. Mann, Sphinx: detecting security attacks in software-defined networks, in: Ndss, vol. 15, 2015, pp. 8-11.

[102] S. Shin, G. Gu, Attacking software-defined networks: a first feasibility study,in: Proceedings of the Second ACM SIGCOMM Workshop on Hot Topics in Software Defined Networking, 2013, pp. 165-166.

[103] H.T.N. Tri, K. Kim, Assessing the impact of resource attack in software defined network, in: 2015 International Conference on Information Networking, ICOIN, IEEE, 2015, pp. 420-425.

[104] J. Leng, Y. Zhou, J. Zhang, C. Hu, An inference attack model for flow table capacity and usage: exploiting the vulnerability of flow table overflow in software-defined network, arXiv preprint, arXiv :1504.03095.

[105] D. Montero, M. Yannuzzi, A. Shaw, L. Jacquin, A. Pastor, R. Serral-Gracia, A. Lioy, F. Risso, C. Basile, R. Sassu, et al., Virtualized security at the network edge: auser-centric approach, IEEE Commun. Mag. 53 (4) (2015) 176-186.

[106] I. Ahmad, S. Namal, M. Ylianttila, A. Gurtov, Security in software defined networks: a survey, IEEE Commun. Surv. Tutor. 17 (4) (2015) 2317-2346.

[107] D. He, S. Chan, M. Guizani, Securing software defined wireless networks, IEEE Commun. Mag. 54 (1) (2016) 20-25.

[108] M. Ali, S.U. Khan, A.V. Vasilakos, Security in cloud computing: opportunities and challenges, Inf. Sci. 305 (2015) 357-383.

[109] W. Etaiwi, M. Biltawi, S. Almajali,Securing distributed SDN controllers against dos attacks, in:2017 International Conference on New Trends in Computing Sciences (ICTCS), 2017, pp. 203-206.

[110] Z. Zhao, B. Wu, Scalable SDN architecture with distributed placement of controllers for WAN, Concurr. Comput.: Pract. Exp. 29 (16) (2017) e4030.