Retention of medical graduates from rural compulsory services program in primary care: An eight-year follow-up study based on four colleges

Abstract

Background: The training of Compulsory Services Program (CSP) graduates is an important initiative to alleviate the shortage of medical human resources in rural areas. As of October 2023，three batches of CSP graduates have completed their required service obligations. However，there is still a lack of systematic research and definitive conclusions regarding their career development and whether they will continue to serve in rural areas after fulfilling their service commitments.

Objective: Based on eight years of panel data from a cohort of CSP graduates，this study aims to analyze their early career development characteristics and identify key factors influencing their retention in primary healthcare settings. The findings are intended to provide policy recommendations for the training and management of CSP graduates in China.

Methods: Since 2010，a dynamic follow-up cohort has been established，involving CSP graduates from Qinghai University，Guangxi Medical University，Jiujiang University，and Gannan Medical University. This study utilized data from 2 041 graduates from the 2015-2019 cohorts，collected through annual online surveys conducted over eight years. The surveys tracked their career development，including professional title promotion，administrative role acquisition，average monthly income，and the proportion of performance-based pay. Descriptive analysis was used to summarize the characteristics of career development，while Logistic regression models were employed to explore factors influencing retention in primary healthcare settings after the contractual period.

Results: Among the 2 041 CSP graduates included，1 068（52.3%）were male and 973（47.7%）were female. By the eighth year after graduation，92.0%（69/75）of graduates had obtained the title of attending physician，and 24.0%（18/75）held administrative positions. The average monthly income was 5 573.4 yuan，with performance-based pay accounting for 45.7% of the total. As of December 2023，with 232 graduates remaining in their positions after contract completion，resulting in a 37.5% retention rate in primary healthcare settings. Among the 386 graduates who left primary healthcare settings，136（35.2%）transitioned to hospitals above the county level，representing the largest proportion，followed by 107（27.7%）moving to county-level hospitals，and 29.0（7.5%）pursuing graduate studies. Multivariate Logistic regression analysis revealed that contract placement in home county/city（OR=2.74，95%CI=1.57-4.78，P=0.001）and holding administrative positions（OR=2.02，95%CI=1.14-3.59，P=0.016）were significant facilitators of retention in primary healthcare settings post-contract completion among CSP graduates. Conversely，passing the national medical licensing exam within two years of graduation（OR=0.37，95%CI=0.15-0.94，P=0.036）emerged as a barrier to retention.

Conclusion: CSP graduates show rapid career progression，with over half choosing to remain in county-level or lower primary healthcare settings after fulfilling their contracts. This strengthens human resource capacity and improves care quality in primary healthcare settings. Notably，CSP graduates who obtained physician qualification within two years post-graduation exhibited significantly higher occupational mobility in primary healthcare settings.

Keywords

Students / Health occupations / General practitioners / Medical graduates / Retention / Career development / Order-directed

Not applicable

Authors' contributions: Conceptualization, Z.H. and L.X.; Methodology, L.M. and L.X.; Data curation, Z.H., T.H., T.Y., H.L. and L.R.; Formal analysis, L.M. and L.X.; Funding acquisition, not applicable; Project administration, not applicable; Resources, not applicable; Supervision, L.M., T.H. and L.X.; Validation, L.M., T.H. and L.X.; Writing—original draft, Z.H.; Writing—review and editing, L.M., T.H. and L.X. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Ethical approval and consent to participate

The study received approval from Biomedical Ethics Committee of Peking University(IRB-00001052-15027).

Consent for publication

Not applicable.

Availability of data and materials

Not applicable.

Declaration of competing interest

All authors declare that there are no competing interests.

Funding

The China Medical Board (CMB) financed The Cohort Study of Medical Graduates with Compulsory Services in Rural Areas Studies, but did not participate in the study's design, collection or analysis of data, interpretation of results, or drafting of the report.

Acknowledgements

The authors express their gratitude to Qinghai University, Jiujiang University, Gannan Medical University, and Guangxi Medical University for their assistance in forming the cohorts.

Authors' other information

Not applicable.

References

[1] Russell D, Mathew S, Fitts M, et al. Interventions for health workforce retention in rural and remote areas: a systematic review. Hum Resour Health. 2021; 19(1):103.

[2] Marchand C, Peckham S. Addressing the crisis of GP recruitment and retention: a systematic review. Br J Gen Pract. 2017; 67(657):e227-e237.

[3] World Health Organization. Retention of the health workforce in rural and remote areas: a systematic review [Internet]. 2020 [cited 2024 Oct 28]. Available from: https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240013865.

[4] Notice on issuing the implementation plan for free training of rural order-oriented medical students [Internet]. (Chinese). National Development and Reform Commission, Ministry of Health, Ministry of Education, Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security of the People’s Republic of China. Ministry of Education of the PRC; 2010 Jun 2 [cited 2024 Nov 7]. Available from: http://www.moe.gov.cn/jyb_xxgk/moe_1777/moe_1779/201012/t20101216_112693.html.

[5] Opinions on further improving the free training program for rural order-oriented medical students [Internet]. (Chinese). Ministry of Education, National Development and Reform Commission, National Health and Family Planning Commission, Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security, National Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Ministry of Education of the PRC; 2015 May 19 [cited 2024 Nov 14]. Available from: http://www.moe.gov.cn/srcsite/A08/moe_740/s7955/201505/t20150520_189494.html.

[6] Cheng XR, Zhang XT, Wang JY, et al. Employment and contract performance of medical graduates from compulsory rural service directed free training program: a five-year follow-up analysis based on the graduates from four medical schools. (Chinese). Chin Gen Pract. 2022; 25(22):2713-2719.

[7] Kong Y, Zuo YL, Liu JH, et al. Performance and retention intention rates of order-oriented medical students in China: a meta-analysis. (Chinese). Chin Gen Pract. 2024; 27(28):3485-3494.

[8] Hu GM, Yuan Y, Feng ZQ, et al. Training status and reflection on rural order-oriented medical students. (Chinese). Chin J Grad Med Educ. 2024; 8(9):712-715.

[9] Jiang HS, Lei ZQ, Zhou YJ, et al. Survey on the demand for standardized residency training bases by general medical students in rural areas of Guangxi. (Chinese). Chin J Grad Med Educ. 2021; 5(4):364-366 384. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.2096-4293.2021.04.019.

[10] Li MY, Zuo YL, Zhang FB, et al. Impact of standardized residency training on the passing rate of the physician qualification examination among orderoriented medical students. (Chinese). Chin Gen Pract. 2022; 25(22):2706-2713. doi: 10.12114/j.issn.1007-9572.2022.0228.

[11] Tang HQ, Zheng HX, Zhang BS, et al. Career development of targeted admission medical students: a seven-year follow-up analysis based on four medical colleges. (Chinese). Chin J Health Policy. 2024; 17(1):43-50. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1674-2982.2024.01.006.

[12] Wang ZY, Hu D, Zhang BS, et al. Analysis on the targeted admission medical graduates and their work preference in rural areas: a three-year survey conducted in four medical schools. (Chinese). Chin J Health Policy. 2020; 13(11):57-62. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1674-2982.2020.11.009.

[13] Li M, Wang Z, Zhang B, et al. Job performance of medical graduates with compulsory services in underserved rural areas in China: a cohort study. Int J Health Policy Manag. 2022; 11(11):2600-2609.

[14] National Bureau of Statistics of China. China statistical yearbook —2023 [Internet]. (Chinese). 2023 [cited 2024 Nov 14]. Available from: https://www.stats.gov.cn/sj/ndsj/2023/indexch.htm.

[15] Zhang X, Zhao Y, Huang LC, et al. Study on the working status and influencing factors of the first group of targeted admission medical graduates in rural areas of three cities in Guangxi. (Chinese). Chin J Health Policy. 2022; 15(7):74-80.

[16] Matsumoto M, Takeuchi K, Tanaka J, et al. Follow-up study of the regional quota system of Japanese medical schools and prefecture scholarship programmes: a study protocol. BMJ Open. 2016; 6(4):e011165.

[17] Huang SS. Analysis of the willingness and influencing factors of rural order-oriented general practitioners in Hainan Province to stay after fulfilling their contract obligations [dissertation]. (Chinese). Hainan: Hainan Medical University; 2022.

[18] Van Essen C, Steffes BC, Thelander K, et al. Increasing and retaining African surgeons working in rural hospitals: an analysis of PAACS surgeons with twenty-year program follow-up. World J Surg. 2019; 43(1):75-86.

[19] Walton E. The meaning of community in diverse neighborhoods: stratification of influence and mental health. Health Place. 2018; 50:6-15.

[20] Chen H, Zhu Z, Chang J, et al. The effects of social integration and hometown identity on the life satisfaction of Chinese rural migrants: the mediating and moderating effects of a sense of belonging in the host city. Health Qual Life Outcomes. 2020; 18(1): 171.

[21] Feng NN, Cui LJ. The relation between restorative experience and place attachment: the role of environment preference and length of residence. (Chinese). J Psychol Sci. 2017; 40(5):1215-1221.

[22] Goel S, Angeli F, Singla N, et al. Measuring the reasons that discourage medical students from working in rural areas: development and validation of a new instrument. Medicine (Baltimore). 2018; 97(2):e9448.

[23] Wu QX, Cui S. Carp leaping over the dragon gate: the counterattack path of rural students in university —an empirical study based on the tracking survey of capital college students’ development. (Chinese). J East China Norm Univ (Educ Sci). 2019; 37(1): 124.

[24] McClelland DC, Atkinson JW, Clark RA, et al. The achievement motive. East Norwalk (CT): Appleton-Century-Crofts; 1953:384.

[25] Luo X, He Q, Li HB, et al. Study on career satisfaction and related factors of “5 + 3 ” directional general practitioners in Guizhou Province. (Chinese). Soft Sci Health. 2022; 36(7):92-96.

[26] Tang ZH, Shi WX, Zheng C, et al. General practitioners’ willingness to work in township health centers and the influencing factors. (Chinese). Chin Rural Health Serv Adm. 2024; 44(8):544-549.

[27] Wang JH, Li JG, Wang XC, et al. China national medical licensing examination: development in the past 16 years and prospect for the future. (Chinese). Med Educ Manag. 2015; 1(1):84-89.

[28] Zhang DH, Wang Y, Huang ZH. Comparison of medical licensing examination system between China and United States. (Chinese). Med Soc. 2016(6):31-34.

[29] Liu XY, Jia ZL, Liu M, et al. Design, implementation and future development of the policy of compulsory rural service directed medical students free training program. (Chinese). Chin Gen Pract. 2022; 25(22):2691-2697.

[30] Zhang BS, Hu D, Xia XL, et al. Development of compulsory rural service directed medical student free training project at home and abroad. (Chinese). Chin Gen Pract. 2022; 25(22):2698-2705.

[31] Zhang BS, Wang ZY, Hu D, et al. Income of order-oriented medical graduates and general clinical graduates: a longitudinal comparative study. (Chinese). Chin Gen Pract. 2023; 26(25):3133-3139.

[32] Li M, Wang Z, Zhang B, et al. Sample attrition analysis in a prospective cohort study of medical graduates in China. BMC Med Res Methodol. 2022; 22(1):14.