Is soil carbon sequestration overestimated in carbon footprint accounting?

References

[1] Crippa M,Guizzardi D,Tubiello FN.Food systems are responsible for a third of global anthropogenic GHG emissions.Nat Food2021;2:198-209

[2] Jones MW,Gasser T.National contributions to climate change due to historical emissions of carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide since 1850.Sci Data2023;10:155 PMCID:PMC10060593

[3] Hong C,Xu M.Interactions among food systems, climate change, and air pollution: a review.Engineering2025;44:215-33

[4] Paustian K,Ogle S,Robertson GP.Climate-smart soils.Nature2016;532:49-57

[5] Sanderman J,Fiske GJ.Soil carbon debt of 12,000 years of human land use.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A2017;114:9575-80 PMCID:PMC5594668

[6] Rumpel C,Chenu C.The 4p1000 initiative: opportunities, limitations and challenges for implementing soil organic carbon sequestration as a sustainable development strategy.Ambio2020;49:350-60 PMCID:PMC6889108

[7] Moinet GYK,van Vuuren DP.Carbon for soils, not soils for carbon.Glob Chang Biol2023;29:2384-98

[8] Smith P,Angers D.How to measure, report and verify soil carbon change to realize the potential of soil carbon sequestration for atmospheric greenhouse gas removal.Glob Chang Biol2020;26:219-41 PMCID:PMC6973036

[9] Powlson DS,Goulding KWT.Soil carbon sequestration to mitigate climate change: a critical re‐examination to identify the true and the false.Eur J Soil Sci2011;62:42-55

[10] Paul C,Dönmez C.Carbon farming: are soil carbon certificates a suitable tool for climate change mitigation?.J Environ Manage2023;330:117142

[11] Paustian K,Baldock J.Quantifying carbon for agricultural soil management: from the current status toward a global soil information system.Carbon Manag2019;10:567-87

[12] Don A,Leifeld J.Carbon sequestration in soils and climate change mitigation-definitions and pitfalls.Glob Chang Biol2024;30:e16983

[13] Dupla X,Deluz C.Are soil carbon credits empty promises? Shortcomings of current soil carbon quantification methodologies and improvement avenues.Soil Use Manag2024;40:e13092

[14] Cotrufo MF,Horton AJ.Formation of soil organic matter via biochemical and physical pathways of litter mass loss.Nature Geosci2015;8:776-9

[15] Lal R.Carbon sequestration in soil.CABI Reviews2008;3:1-20

[16] Lal R.Soil carbon sequestration impacts on global climate change and food security.Science2004;304:1623-7

[17] Nair R,Sharma S.Carbon sequestration in soils-a review.Agri Rev2015;36:81

[18] Six J,Paul EA.Stabilization mechanisms of soil organic matter: Implications for C-saturation of soils.Plant Soil2002;241:155-76.

[19] Ghimirey V,Acharya N.Understanding soil carbon sequestration: mechanistic insights, management approaches, and future challenges.Discov Soil2025;2:133

[20] Stewart CE,Conant RT,Six J.Soil carbon saturation: concept, evidence and evaluation.Biogeochemistry2007;86:19-31

[21] Ogle SM,Paustian K.Agricultural management impacts on soil organic carbon storage under moist and dry climatic conditions of temperate and tropical regions.Biogeochemistry2005;72:87-121

[22] Davidson EA.Changes in soil carbon inventories following cultivation of previously untilled soils.Biogeochemistry1993;20:161-93

[23] Minasny B,Mcbratney AB.Soil carbon 4 per mille.Geoderma2017;292:59-86

[24] Six J,Paustian K.Soil macroaggregate turnover and microaggregate formation: a mechanism for C sequestration under no-tillage agriculture.Soil Biol Biochem2000;32:2099-103

[25] Farooqi ZUR,Qadeer A.Role of carbon cycle in soil productivity and carbon fluxes under changing climate. In Frontiers in plant-soil interaction: molecular insights into plant adaptation; Elsevier, 2021; pp 29-48.

[26] Kopittke PM,Carrillo Y.Ensuring planetary survival: the centrality of organic carbon in balancing the multifunctional nature of soils.Crit Rev Environ Sci Technol2022;52:4308-24

[27] Lal R.Soil organic matter and feeding the future: environmental and agronomic impacts, 1th ed.; CRC Press, 2021

[28] Kögel-knabner I.Dynamics, Chemistry, and Preservation of Organic Matter in Soils. In Treatise on Geochemistry, 2th ed.; Vol. 12; Elsevier, 2014; pp 157-215.

[29] Smith P,Beerling DJ.Land-management options for greenhouse gas removal and their impacts on ecosystem services and the sustainable development goals.Annu Rev Environ Resour2019;44:255-86.

[30] García-oliva F.Assessment and measurement issues related to soil carbon sequestration in land-use, land-use change, and forestry (LULUCF) projects under the kyoto protocol.Clim Change2004;65:347-64

[31] Georgiou K,Vindušková O.Global stocks and capacity of mineral-associated soil organic carbon.Nat Commun2022;13:3797 PMCID:PMC9249731

[32] Sommer R.Dynamics and climate change mitigation potential of soil organic carbon sequestration.J Environ Manage2014;144:83-7

[33] Nazir MJ,Nazir MM.Harnessing soil carbon sequestration to address climate change challenges in agriculture.Soil Tillage Res2024;237:105959

[34] West TO.Soil organic carbon sequestration rates by tillage and crop rotation: a global data analysis.Soil Sci Soc Am J2002;66:1930-46

[35] Balesdent J,Balabane M.Relationship of soil organic matter dynamics to physical protection and tillage.Soil Tillage Res2000;53:215-30

[36] Guo X,Jian S.Drought amplifies warming-induced soil carbon loss in a decade-long experiment.Nat Clim Chang2026;16:485-93

[37] García-palacios P,Dacal M.Evidence for large microbial-mediated losses of soil carbon under anthropogenic warming.Nat Rev Earth Environ2021;2:507-17

[38] Thamo T.Challenges in developing effective policy for soil carbon sequestration: perspectives on additionality, leakage, and permanence.Clim Policy2016;16:973-92

[39] He Q,Wang B.Identifying effective agricultural management practices for climate change adaptation and mitigation: a win-win strategy in South-Eastern Australia.Agric Syst2022;203:103527

[40] Powlson DS,Jat ML.Limited potential of no-till agriculture for climate change mitigation.Nat Clim Chang2014;4:678-83

[41] Vuichard N,Viovy N.Simulating the net ecosystem CO₂ exchange and its components over winter wheat cultivation sites across a large climate gradient in Europe using the ORCHIDEE-STICS generic model.Agric Ecosyst Environ2016;226:1-17

[42] Schiettecatte L,Chotte J.Assessment of soil integration in nationally determined contributions and guidance for quantifying ex-ante soil organic carbon stock changes in national policies using IPCC default methodologies.CATENA2025;252:108805

[43] IPCC. 2019 Refinement to the 2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories. 2019. https://www.ipcc.ch/report/2019-refinement-to-the-2006-ipcc-guidelines-for-national-greenhouse-gas-inventories/ (accessed 2026-07-09).

[44] Caparrós A.Conflicts between biodiversity and carbon sequestration programs: economic and legal implications.Ecol Econ2003;46:143-57

[45] Batalla I,Mogensen L,Pinto M.Carbon footprint of milk from sheep farming systems in Northern Spain including soil carbon sequestration in grasslands.J Clean Prod2015;104:121-9

[46] Millard P,Simmons A. FAO. Measuring and modelling soil carbon stocks and stock changes in livestock production systems: guidelines for assessment; Version 1 - Advanced copy. Preprint posted online 2019. https://literatur.thuenen.de/digbib_extern/dn060726.pdf (accessed 2026-07-09).

[47] Wendt JW.An equivalent soil mass procedure for monitoring soil organic carbon in multiple soil layers.Eur J Soil Sci2013;64:58-65

[48] Vanguelova EI,De Vos B.Sources of errors and uncertainties in the assessment of forest soil carbon stocks at different scales-review and recommendations.Environ Monit Assess2016;188:630

[49] FAO. Soil organic carbon (SOC) MRV sourcebook for agricultural landscapes. 2021. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/948041625049766862/pdf/Soil-Organic-Carbon-MRV-Sourcebook-for-Agricultural-Landscapes.pdf (accessed 2026-07-09).

[50] Luo Y,Allison SD.Toward more realistic projections of soil carbon dynamics by Earth system models.Global Biogeochem Cycles2016;30:40-56

[51] Angelopoulou T,Balafoutis A,Bochtis D.Remote sensing techniques for soil organic carbon estimation: a review.Remote Sens2019;11:676

[52] Phelan L,Ziv G.The role of information in shaping the emerging agricultural soil carbon market.J Rural Stud2025;120:103861

[53] Vanderheyden L,Van den Broeck G.What monitoring, reporting & verification (MRV) systems can reduce costs and enhance scalability of carbon farming?.J Environ Manage2026;401:128885

[54] Thorsøe MH,Criscuoli I.Carbon farming: the foundation for carbon farming schemes - lessons learned from 160 European schemes.Land Use Policy2025;158:107747