Review of material flow analysis and its application under carbon neutralization target: a bibliometric perspective

Abstract

Material flow analysis (MFA) could provide methodological support for quantifying material carbon flow and carbon emissions in the pursuit of carbon neutrality. Despite the extensive publication of MFA studies in academic journals, significant challenges remain on MFA and its application in carbon emission (MFA-CE) research, including identifying emerging research trends. This paper reviews MFA and MFA-CE research based on bibliometric analysis of data from WOS (Web of Science) platform, spanning from 1991 to 2022. We find that over the last 32 years: (1) Both MFA and MFA-CE research share similar article characteristics, such as rapid and active fluctuations in trends, with high-output countries primarily being the USA, China, and others; (2) MFA and MFA-CE are multidisciplinary fields, showing the fastest growth in Environmental Studies and Economics research; (3) Highly cited papers mainly focus on global material flow, environmental impact, and recycling. Notably, high citation analysis shows that both MFA and MFA-CE research have garnered substantial attention since 2014; and (4) Combining MFA with other methods would help identify material flow, such as carbon material flow. Additionally, the future perspectives of MFA-CE research were summarized: increasing interdisciplinary cooperation; a growing emphasis on multi-scale research; and enhanced availability and application of data.

Keywords

Bibliometric analysis / material flow analysis / carbon emission

References

[1] Boehm S,Levin K. State of climate action 2022. Available from: https://climateanalytics.org/publications/2022/state-of-climate-action-2022 [Last accessed on 2 Aug 2024]

[2] Climate Action Tracker. CAT net zero target evaluations. 2022. Available from: https://climateactiontracker.org/global/cat-net-zero-target-evaluations [Last accessed on 2 Aug 2024]

[3] Igarashi Y,Matsuno Y.Dynamic material flow analysis for stainless steels in Japan-reductions potential of CO₂ emissions by promoting closed loop recycling of stainless steels.ISIJ Int2007;47:758-63

[4] Krausmann F,Haas W.From resource extraction to outflows of wastes and emissions: the socioeconomic metabolism of the global economy, 1900-2015.Glob Environ Chang2018;52:131-40 PMCID:PMC6333294

[5] Liu GX,Jia FR,Wang HM.Material flow and spatial data analysis of the petroleum use to carbon dioxide (CO₂) emissions in Northeast China.J Ind Ecol2019;23:823-37

[6] Li D,Zhong S,Li X.Spatial and temporal evolution patterns of material, energy and carbon emission nexus for power generation infrastructure in China.Resour Conserv Recycl2023;190:106775

[7] Bruckner M,Lutz C.Materials embodied in international trade - global material extraction and consumption between 1995 and 2005.Glob Environ Chang2012;22:568-76

[8] Chowdhury R, Zhang X. Phosphorus use efficiency in agricultural systems: a comprehensive assessment through the review of national scale substance flow analyses.Ecol Indic2021;121:107172

[9] Müller E,Widmer R,Faulstich M.Modeling metal stocks and flows: a review of dynamic material flow analysis methods.Environ Sci Technol2014;48:2102-13

[10] Nasir U,Omrany H.Calculation methods for construction material stocks: a systematic review.Appl Sci2021;11:6612

[11] Rahman S,D’Costa NG,Bhuiyan M.Determining the potential role of the waste sector in decoupling of phosphorus: a comprehensive review of national scale substance flow analyses.Resour Conserv Recycl2019;144:144-57

[12] Ghanimeh S,Tsydenova N,Iossifidou M.Two-level comparison of waste management systems in low-, middle-, and high-income cities.Environ Eng Sci2019;36:1281-95

[13] Betz A,Göbel C.Food waste in the Swiss food service industry - magnitude and potential for reduction.Waste Manag2015;35:218-26

[14] Yang X,Zhang C.Urban mining potential to reduce primary material use and carbon emissions in the Dutch residential building sector.Resour Conserv Recycl2022;180:106215

[15] Alonso-Fernández P.An approximation to the environmental impact of economic growth using the material flow analysis: differences between production and consumption methods, applied to China, United Kingdom and USA (1990-2017).Sustainability2021;13:5489

[16] Schaffartzik A,Gingrich S,Loy C.The global metabolic transition: Regional patterns and trends of global material flows, 1950-2010.Glob Environ Chang2014;26:87-97 PMCID:PMC4375797

[17] Graedel TE.Material flow analysis from origin to evolution.Environ Sci Technol2019;53:12188-96

[18] Wiedenhofer D,Lauk C,Krausmann F.Integrating material stock dynamics into economy-wide material flow accounting: concepts, modelling, and global application for 1900-2050.Ecol Econ2019;156:121-33

[19] Lombardi M,Fellner J.Material flow analysis and sustainability of the Italian plastic packaging management.J Clean Prod2021;287:125573

[20] Amicarelli V.Quantifying textile streams and recycling prospects in Europe by material flow analysis.Environ Impact Assess Rev2022;97:106878

[21] Islam MT.Material flow analysis (MFA) as a strategic tool in E-waste management: applications, trends and future directions.J Environ Manag2019;244:344-61

[22] Guedes GB,Borsato M.Bibliometric and systemic analysis on material flow mapping and industrial ecosystems.J Ind Intg Mgmt2018;03:1850001

[23] Liu L,Maraseni TN.Household CO₂ emissions: current status and future perspectives.Int J Environ Res Public Health2020;17:7077 PMCID:PMC7579624

[24] Xu Y,Chen X.Bibliometric analysis of global NDVI research trends from 1985 to 2021.Remote Sens2022;14:3967

[25] Chen C.CiteSpace II: Detecting and visualizing emerging trends and transient patterns in scientific literature.J Am Soc Inf Sci2006;57:359-77

[26] Krausmann F,Lauk C.Global socioeconomic material stocks rise 23-fold over the 20th century and require half of annual resource use.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA2017;114:1880-5 PMCID:PMC5338421

[27] Liu C,Xu J,Li C.Global trends and characteristics of ecological security research in the early 21st century: a literature review and bibliometric analysis.Ecol Indic2022;137:108734

[28] Hu Z,Cheng Z.Mapping the knowledge development and trend of household energy consumption.Environ Dev Sustain2022;24:6053-71

[29] Haas W,Wiedenhofer D.How circular is the global economy?: An assessment of material flows, waste production, and recycling in the European Union and the world in 2005.J Ind Ecol2015;19:765-77

[30] Fischer-Kowalski M,Giljum S.Methodology and Indicators of economy-wide material flow accounting: state of the art and reliability across sources.J Ind Ecol2011;15:855-76

[31] Ayres RU.Production, consumption, and externalities.Am Econ Rev1969;59:282-97Available from: https://www.jstor.org/stable/1808958 [Last accessed on 2 Aug 2024]

[32] Udo de Haes HA, Huppes G, Guinée JB. Material balances and flow analysis of hazardous substances. Accumulation of substances in economy and environment.Milieu1988;3:51-5Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/316911003_Materials_balances_and_flow_analysis_of_hazardous_substances_Accumulation_of_substances_in_economy_and_environment [Last accessed on 2 Aug 2024]

[33] Wang X,Liu N.An urban material flow analysis framework and measurement method from the perspective of urban metabolism.J Clean Prod2020;257:120564

[34] Organization for Economic Co-Operation and Development. Measuring material flows and resource productivity. 2008. Available from: https://web-archive.oecd.org/2013-12-03/258622-MFA-Accounting-Framework.pdf [Last accessed on 2 Aug 2024]

[35] Zhang Y.Urban metabolism: a review of research methodologies.Environ Pollut2013;178:463-73

[36] Bruuner PH.Handbook of material flow analysis: for environmental resource, and waste engineers. Boca Raton: CRC Press; 2016.

[37] Wang Y.Analysis of uncertainty in material flow analysis.J Clean Prod2018;170:1017-28

[38] Watari T,Nakajima K.Major metals demand, supply, and environmental impacts to 2100: a critical review.Resour Conserv Recycl2021;164:105107

[39] Kiddee P,Wong MH.Electronic waste management approaches: an overview.Waste Manag2013;33:1237-50

[40] Pauliuk S.Critical appraisal of the circular economy standard BS 8001:2017 and a dashboard of quantitative system indicators for its implementation in organizations.Resour Conserv Recycl2018;129:81-92

[41] Chèvre N,Rossi L,Bader HP.Substance flow analysis as a tool for urban water management.Water Sci Technol2011;63:1341-8

[42] Bai L,Li Y,Xie M.Statistical entropy analysis of substance flows in a lead smelting process.Resour Conserv Recycl2015;94:118-28

[43] Ding N,Liu J.Substance flow analysis of aluminum industry in mainland China.J Clean Prod2016;133:1167-80

[44] Seok H.A social network analysis of international creative goods flow.Sustainability2022;14:4463

[45] Kovanda J.Economy-wide material system analysis: mapping material flows through the economy.J Ind Ecol2021;25:1121-35

[46] Kovanda J.Monitoring food-related material flows with the use of economy-wide material system analysis.Ecol Econ2022;195:107392

[47] Ciacci L,Reck BK.Material system analysis: characterization of flows, stocks, and performance indicators of manganese, nickel, and natural graphite in the EU, 2012-2016.J Ind Ecol2022;26:1247-60

[48] Ministry of the Environment Government of Japan. Quality of the environment in Japan 1992. Available from: https://www.env.go.jp/en/wpaper/1992/eae210000000010.html [Last accessed on 2 Aug 2024]

[49] European Communities. Economy-wide material flow accounts and derived indicators: A Methodological guide. 2001. Available from: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/documents/3859598/5855193/KS-34-00-536-EN.PDF.pdf/411cd453-6d11-40a0-b65a-a33805327616?t=1414780409000 [Last accessed on 2 Aug 2024]

[50] Withanage SV.Life cycle assessment and material flow analysis: two under-utilized tools for informing E-waste management.Sustainability2021;13:7939

[51] Huang CL,Yu CP.Triclosan: a review on systematic risk assessment and control from the perspective of substance flow analysis.Sci Total Environ2016;566-7:771-85

[52] Chowdhury RB,Weatherley AJ.A review of recent substance flow analyses of phosphorus to identify priority management areas at different geographical scales.Resour Conserv Recycl2014;83:213-28

[53] Kullmann F,Stolten D.Combining the worlds of energy systems and material flow analysis: a review.Energy Sustain Soc2021;11:289

[54] Li Q,Li T,Chen Y.Embodied carbon emissions of aluminum-containing commodities in international trade: China’s perspective.Clim Chang2021;166:47

[55] Liu L,Gao F.Land use carbon emissions or sink: research characteristics, hotspots and future perspectives.Land2024;13:279

[56] Ohno H,Chapman A.Detailing the economy-wide carbon emission reduction potential of post-consumer recycling.Resour Conserv Recycl2021;166:105263

[57] Zhou X,Bao M.Tracing and evaluating life-cycle carbon emissions of urban multi-energy systems.Energies2022;15:2946

[58] Das D,Velaga NR.Dynamic stock model based assessment of carpooling in passenger transportation carbon emissions: Will avoided trips and material credits help?.Sustain Prod Consump2022;33:372-88

[59] Brunner PH. Practical Handbook of material flow analysis. Boca Raton: CRC Press; 2004. Available from: https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/mono/10.1201/9781315313450/handbook-material-flow-analysis-paul-brunner-helmut-rechberger [Last accessed on 2 Aug 2024]

[60] Tan XP,Song XQ. Constructing a research framework for material flow analysis towards carbon neutrality: a bibliometric perspective. 2023. Available from: https://kns.cnki.net/kcms2/article/abstract?v=dMo7FjsfBlGxSWMb7IstmvMBKtBZ0DaPhFKhKjzF8obXpZuw5AIUl0XWAsjfbwagmqvxZ5_nCo6kJpWHxnXYqw-tebHQPZEN2OWu8QL7-tpfUGOu3jN4-M2POG2lwYQYlmDV1fz2InPaAktbCbukS_jVXsZ13PJ8xhMrZdPGOVxzIG9gHT9ao63sIa7oZoQVoK5i4s3xmYw=&uniplatform=NZKPT&language=CHS [Last accessed on 2 Aug 2024]

[61] Yu S,Zhao G,Zhang Z.Accurate carbon accounting based on industrial metabolism for the lean management of carbon emission.Energy Rep2023;9:3872-80

[62] Yang N,Liu Y.Environmental and economic life-cycle assessments of household food waste management systems: a comparative review of methodology and research progress.Sustainability2022;14:7533

[63] Ke Y,Huang Y.The carbon emissions related to the land-use changes from 2000 to 2015 in Shenzhen, China: implication for exploring low-carbon development in megacities.J Environ Manag2022;319:115660

[64] Xie P,Sun F,Pan X.What factors contribute to the extent of decoupling economic growth and energy carbon emissions in China?.Energy Policy2023;173:113416

[65] Kadam R,Park B,Park J.Realizable wastewater treatment process for carbon neutrality and energy sustainability: a review.J Environ Manag2023;328:116927

[66] Schwab O,Rechberger H.A data characterization framework for material flow analysis.J Ind Ecol2017;21:16-25