Life cycle climate performance of urban plant factory versus rural greenhouse under China’s power-grid decarbonization: considering short-lived methane and nitrous oxide emissions

Abstract

Plant factories can potentially enhance the climate resilience of urban vegetable production by reducing the losses from climate hazards but generate high climate burdens - due to consuming carbon-intensive power generated by coal combustion with upstream methane emissions - unlike rural traditional sunlight greenhouses with nitrous oxide emissions. Here, we compared the life cycle Global Warming Potential (GWP) and Technical Warming Potential (TWP) metrics of lettuce production by plant factory and greenhouse, and explored the effect of power grid decarbonization on the climate performance of the cultivations. Results show that in the baseline scenario using the southern Chinese grid, the 100-year GWP of plant factory cultivation (14.9 kgCO₂e kg^-1) is over 50 times higher than that of the greenhouse (0.27 kgCO₂e kg^-1). The nitrous oxide emissions contribute 14% to the GWP of greenhouse, while methane contributes 16% to that of plant factories, which can be reduced to ~4% under a high grid decarbonization scenario in 2050. Electricity consumption (fertilizer and polyethylene film applications) shares 43%-99% (80%-89%) of the GWP of plant factory (greenhouse) cultivations. Grid decarbonization decreases the TWP metrics over time, meaning a rising climate advantage for plant factories. However, plant factories still fail to compete with greenhouses in mitigating climate change (with TWP ranging from 5-66), except if hydropower were fully deployed. Our findings add knowledge about climate-friendly and resilient vegetable supplies under China’s grid decarbonization efforts.

Keywords

Climate resilience / plant factory / crystallinity of COF / sunlight greenhouse / global warming potential / methane / nitrous oxide

References

[1] van Delden SH,Butturini M.Current status and future challenges in implementing and upscaling vertical farming systems.Nat Food2021;2:944-56

[2] Weidner T,Forster F.Regional conditions shape the food-energy-land nexus of low-carbon indoor farming.Nat Food2022;3:206-16

[3] Wang X,Shi X.Innovative management programme reduces environmental impacts in Chinese vegetable production.Nat Food2021;2:47-53

[4] Gruda N,Tanny J.Impacts of protected vegetable cultivation on climate change and adaptation strategies for cleaner production - a review.J Clean Prod2019;225:324-39

[5] Miller SM,Detmers RG,Bruhwiler LMP.China’s coal mine methane regulations have not curbed growing emissions.Nat Commun2019;10:303 PMCID:PMC6351523

[6] IEA global methane tracker. Avaialble from: https://www.iea.org/reports/global-methane-tracker-2022/overview [Last accessed on 29 May 2024]

[7] Masson-Delmotte V,Pirani S. IPCC, 2021: summary for policymakers. In: Climate change 2021: the physical science basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Available from: http://hdl.handle.net/10204/12710 [Last accessed on 29 May 2024]

[8] Rosselot KS,Ku AY.Comparing greenhouse gas impacts from domestic coal and imported natural gas electricity generation in China.ACS Sustain Chem Eng2021;9:8759-69

[9] Pérez-Domínguez I,Mittenzwei K.Short- and long-term warming effects of methane may affect the cost-effectiveness of mitigation policies and benefits of low-meat diets.Nat Food2021;2:970-80 PMCID:PMC7612339

[10] National Development and Reform Commission of China. Action plan for carbon dioxide peaking before 2030. 2021. Available from: https://en.ndrc.gov.cn/policies/202110/t20211027_1301020.html [Last accessed on 29 May 2024]

[11] Bartzas G,Komnitsas K.Life cycle assessment of open field and greenhouse cultivation of lettuce and barley.Inf Process Agric2015;2:191-207

[12] Rothwell A,Page G.Environmental performance of local food: trade-offs and implications for climate resilience in a developed city.J Clean Prod2016;114:420-30

[13] Pennisi G,Orsini F.Modelling environmental burdens of indoor-grown vegetables and herbs as affected by red and blue LED lighting.Sustainability2019;11:4063

[14] Alvarez RA,Winebrake JJ,Hamburg SP.Greater focus needed on methane leakage from natural gas infrastructure.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA2012;109:6435-40 PMCID:PMC3340093

[15] ISO14040. Environmental management - life cycle assessment - principles and framework. 2006. Available from: http://www.iso.org/iso/home/store/catalogue_tc/catalogue_detail.htm?csnumber=37456 [Last accessed on 29 May 2024]

[16] Wolf M,Brandao M. International reference life cycle data system (ILCD) handbook - general guide for life cycle assessment - detailed guidance. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union; 2010. Available from: https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/handle/JRC48157 [Last accessed on 29 May 2024]

[17] Ekvall T,Finnveden G,Weidema BP.Attributional and consequential LCA in the ILCD handbook.Int J Life Cycle Assess2016;21:293-6

[18] Durlinger B,Broekema R,Scholten J. Agri-footprint 4.0-Part 2: description of data. Gouda, the Netherlands, 2017. Available from: https://simapro.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/Agri-Footprint-4.0-Part-2-Description-of-data.pdf [Last accessed on 29 May 2024]

[19] Niemistö J,Judl J.Benefits and challenges of streamlined life-cycle assessment for SMEs - findings from case studies on climate change impacts.Int J Sustain Dev World Ecol2019;26:625-34

[20] Hergoualc’h K,Bernoux M. N₂O emissions from managed soils, and CO₂ emissions from lime and urea application. In: Refinement to the 2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories 2019. Available from: https://www.ipcc-nggip.iges.or.jp/public/2019rf/pdf/4_Volume4/19R_V4_Ch11_Soils_N2O_CO2.pdf [Last accessed on 29 May 2024]

[21] Wang X,Gao X.Nitrous oxide emissions in Chinese vegetable systems: a meta-analysis.Environ Pollut2018;239:375-83

[22] Yue Q,Sun J.Deriving emission factors and estimating direct nitrous oxide emissions for crop cultivation in China.Environ Sci Technol2019;53:10246-57

[23] Pannier M,Peuportier B.Comprehensive assessment of sensitivity analysis methods for the identification of influential factors in building life cycle assessment.J Clean Prod2018;199:466-80

[24] IPCC. Chapter 3: uncertainties in guidelines for national greenhouse gas inventories. 2006. Available from: https://www.ipcc-nggip.iges.or.jp/public/2006gl/pdf/1_Volume1/V1_3_Ch3_Uncertainties.pdf [Last accessed on 29 May 2024]

[25] Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Anthropogenic and Natural Radiative Forcing. In: Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, editor. Climate Change 2013 - the physical science basis. Cambridge University Press; 2014. pp. 659-740.

[26] Joos F,Fuglestvedt JS.Carbon dioxide and climate impulse response functions for the computation of greenhouse gas metrics: a multi-model analysis.Atmos Chem Phys2013;13:2793-825

[27] Cossu M,Cossu A,Pala T.Increasing the agricultural sustainability of closed agrivoltaic systems with the integration of vertical farming: a case study on baby-leaf lettuce.Appl Energy2023;344:121278

[28] Souza NRDD,Bruno KMB.Unraveling the potential of sugarcane electricity for climate change mitigation in Brazil.Resour Conserv Recy2021;175:105878

[29] Chen H,Lei J.Life cycle assessment of carbon capture by an intelligent vertical plant factory within an industrial park.Sustainability2024;16:697

[30] Zhou Y,Lei J.A cross-scale modelling and decarbonisation quantification approach for navigating carbon neutrality pathways in China.Energy Convers Manage2023;297:117733

[31] Oh S.Vertical farming - smart urban agriculture for enhancing resilience and sustainability in food security.J Hortic Sci Biotech2023;98:133-40