Growth and carbon stocks in four mangrove species planted on a former charcoal concession site in Ranong, Thailand

Abstract

The ending of mangrove concessions for charcoal production in 1998 gave new impetus to mangrove conservation and rehabilitation in Thailand, including the designation of the Ranong Biosphere Reserve (RBR) to protect Thailand’s largest single mangrove ecosystem. Four of the dominant tree species in the RBR were planted as seedlings in single species blocks on a former concession site in 1994: Rhizophora apiculata (Ra) and R. mucronata (Rm); and 1995: Bruguiera cylindrica (Bc) and Ceriops tagal (Ct). Tree growth and natural recruitment of seedlings and saplings were recorded in 100 m² sampled quadrats in each species block in 1999, 2008, 2019 and 2023. All four species exceeded 10 m mean height by 2019 (range 12.1 ± 3.8 m to 19.6 ± 2.3 m), while mean DBH was 7.5 ± 3.4 cm to 9.1 ± 6.9 cm. There was evidence of self-thinning mortality by 2023, especially in the Ra and Bc blocks. Some illegal cutting of Bc trees between 2019 and 2023 further impacted the growth performance of this species, which exhibited a compensatory strategy of self-planting many seedlings. The height and DBH of the four planted species in 2023 were still less than in a mature Rhizophora- and Ceriops-dominated conservation forest area (mean tree height 17.4 ± 6.7 m; DBH 15.1 ± 7.3 cm). However, soil organic carbon (SOC) was high and not significantly different between the monoculture species blocks (525 ± 107 Mg C ha^-1 to 743 ± 31 Mg C ha^-1) and the conservation forest (616 ± 91 Mg C ha^-1). SOC accounted for 74%-90% of the total ecosystem C, which was 650 to 829 Mg C ha^-1 in the planted species blocks and 828 Mg C ha^-1 in the conservation forest. The estimates for plant, soil and ecosystem C are compared with those reported from other natural and planted mangrove sites in Southeast Asia, especially along the Andaman Sea coast. The findings confirm the importance of conserving the few remaining areas of near-primary mangrove forest in this region.

Keywords

Mangrove / rehabilitation / tree growth / recruitment / carbon / Thailand / Southeast Asia

References

[1] Richards DR.Rates and drivers of mangrove deforestation in Southeast Asia, 2000-2012.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA2016;113:344-9 PMCID:PMC4720307

[2] Salmo SG. Post-disturbance carbon stocks and rates of sequestration: implications on “blue carbon” estimates in Philippine mangroves. Philipp Sci Lett 2019;12:122-32. Available from: https://scienggj.org/2019/PSL%202019-vol12-no02-p122-132-Salmo%20and%20Gianan.pdf [Last accessed on 27 Jul 2023]

[3] Ashton EC. Threats to mangroves and conservation strategies. In: Das SC, Thammineni P, Ashton EC, editors. Mangroves: Biodiversity, Livelihoods and Conservation. Singapore: Springer Nature; 2022. pp. 217-30.

[4] Abino AC,Lee YJ. Assessment of species diversity, biomass and carbon sequestration potential of a natural mangrove stand in Samar, the Philippines. For Sci Technol 2014;10:2-8. Available from: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/21580103.2013.814593 [Last accessed on 27 Jul 2023]

[5] Alongi DM.Carbon cycling and storage in mangrove forests.Ann Rev Mar Sci2014;6:195-219

[6] Jardine SL.A global predictive model of carbon in mangrove soils.Environ Res Lett2014;9:104013.

[7] Asadi MA,Ricky AB,Andik I.Mangrove ecosystem C-stocks of Lamongan, Indonesia and its correlation with forest age.Res J Chem Environ2017;21:1-9

[8] Aksornkoae S. Mangrove forest in Thailand. Bangkok: The Royal Forest Department of Thailand; 1982. p.38.

[9] Platong J. Status of mangrove forests in Southern Thailand. Wetlands International-Thailand Programme/PSU. Thailand: Prince of Songkla University; 1998. p.128.

[10] Komiyama A,Patanaponpaiboon P,Ogino K.Socio-ecosystem studies on mangrove forests-charcoal industry and primary productivity of secondary stands.Tropics1992;1:233-42

[11] Thappipidh W. Mangrove forest and forestry. Bangkok: The Royal Forest Department of Thailand; 1986. p.42.

[12] Sayaka A. Towards better mangrove management in Southern Thailand. Summary report on two workshops on mangrove forest management in Southern Thailand, 29-30 September and 27 November 1997, Hat Yai, Thailand. PSU/Wetlands International - Thailand Programme. Thailand: Prince of Songkla University; 1998. p.48.

[13] Pumijumnong N.Mangrove forests in Thailand. In: Faridah-Hanum I, Latiff A, Hakeem K, Ozturk M, editors. Mangrove ecosystems of Asia: status, challenges and management strategies. New York: Springer; 2014. pp. 62-79.

[14] Wanthongchai P. Ranong Biosphere Reserve. Bangkok: Department of Marine and Coastal Resources, Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment of Thailand; Undated. p.36.

[15] Macintosh DJ,Havanon S.Mangrove rehabilitation and intertidal biodiversity: a study in the Ranong mangrove ecosystem, Thailand.Estuar Coast Shelf Sci2002;55:331-45

[16] JAM (Japan Association for Mangroves). Final report of the ITTO project on development and dissemination of re-afforestation techniques of mangrove forests [PD 11/92 Rev. 1 (F)]. Tokyo: Japan Association for Mangroves, Tokyo, Japan; 1997. p.104

[17] Aksornkoae S. Sustainable use and conservation of mangrove forest resource with emphasis on policy and management practices in Thailand. In: International workshop Asia-Pacific cooperation on research for conservation of mangroves; 2000 Mar 26-30, Okinawa, Japan. p.9.

[18] Fourqurean JW,Possley J,Lee D.Are mangroves in the tropical Atlantic ripe for invasion? Exotic mangrove trees in the forests of South Florida.Biol Invasions2010;12:2509-22

[19] Meepol W. Carbon sequestration of mangrove forests at Ranong Biosphere Reserve. J For Manag 2010;4:33-47. Available from: https://kukrdb.lib.ku.ac.th/journal/JFM/search_detail/result/35172# [Last accessed on 29 Jul 2023] (In Thai with English abstract).

[20] Komiyama A,Kato S.Common allometric equations for estimating the tree weight of mangroves.J Trop Ecol2005;21:471-7

[21] Howard J,Isensee K,Pidgeon E. Coastal blue carbon: methods for assessing carbon stocks and emissions factors in mangroves, tidal salt marshes, and seagrasses. Conservation International, Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission of UNESCO, International Union for Conservation of Nature. Arlington, Virginia, USA. 2014. Available from: https://www.cifor.org/knowledge/publication/5095 [Last accessed on 27 Jul 2023]

[22] Heiri O,Lemcke G.Loss on ignition as a method for estimating organic and carbonate content in sediments: reproducibility and comparability of results.J Paleolimnol2001;25:101-10

[23] Kauffman JB,Cole TG,Donato DC.Ecosystem carbon stocks of Micronesian mangrove forests.Wetlands2011;31:343-52

[24] Masagca JT.Feeding ecology of tree-climbing mangrove sesarmid crabs from Luzon, Philippines.Biotropia2009;16:1-10

[25] Tamai S. Establishment and growth of mangrove seedling in mangrove forests of Southern Thailand. Ecol Res 1988;3:227-38. Available from: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF02348582 [Last accessed on 29 Jul 2023]

[26] Putz FE. Tree growth, dynamics, and productivity in a mature mangrove forest in Malaysia. For Ecol Manag 1986;17:211-30. Available from: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/0378112786901131 [Last accessed on 29 Jul 2023]

[27] Westoby M.The self-thinning rule. In: MacFadyen A, Ford ED editors. Advances in ecological research. London: Academic Press; 1984. pp. 167-225.

[28] Pranchai A.Regeneration and self-thinning processes in a restored Rhizophora apiculata plantation in southern Thailand.Agric Nat Resour2017;51:390-4

[29] Gong WK.The use of demographic studies in mangrove silviculture.Hydrobiologia1995;295:255-61

[30] Kongkeaw C,Vandergeest P.Explaining success in community based mangrove management: four coastal communities along the Andaman Sea, Thailand.Ocean Coast Manag2019;178:104822

[31] Tamai S,Tabuchi R.Standing biomass of mangrove forests in southern Thailand.J Jpn For Soc1986;68:384-8

[32] Speybroeck D. Regeneration strategy of mangroves along the Kenya coast: a first approach.Hydrobiologia1992;247:243-51

[33] Aluri JSR.Reproductive ecology of Bruguiera cylindrica (L.) Bl. (Rhizophoraceae), a true viviparous mangrove tree species in Coringa mangrove forest, Andhra Pradesh (India).Transylvanian Rev Syst Ecol Res2018;20:31-8

[34] Macintosh DJ,Vannucci M,Clough BF. Final report of the integrated multidisciplinary survey and research programme of the Ranong mangrove ecosystem. Bangkok: Funny Publishing Ltd; 1991. p.183.

[35] Christensen B.Seasonal growth of mangrove trees in Southern Thailand. I. The phenology of Rhizophora apiculata Bl.Aquatic Botany1977;3:281-6

[36] Machin J. Mangrove restoration, a case for an evidence based approach. PhD Thesis, James Cook University. 2015. p.260. Available from: https://researchonline.jcu.edu.au/46580/ [Last accessed on 27 Jul 2023]

[37] Kridiborworn P,Yuttitham M. Carbon sequestration by mangrove forest planted specifically for charcoal production in Yeesarn, Samut Songkram. Int J Sustain Energy 2012;3:87-92. Available from: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Carbon-Sequestration-by-Mangrove-Forest-Planted-for-Kridiborworn-Chidthaisong/2b21de2960c9c896ee6319efa4e997d83967eff5 [Last accessed on 27 Jul 2023]

[38] Alongi DM. Mangrove primary production and above- and below-ground biomass in Sawi Bay, southern Thailand. Phuket mar biol Cent Spec Publ 2000;22:31-8. Available from: https://www.dmcr.go.th/dmcr/fckupload/upload/147/file/SP_paper/2000%20Vol.22%204Alongi.pdf [Last accessed on 29 Jul 2023]

[39] Komiyama A,Aksornkoae S.Root biomass of a mangrove forest in southern Thailand. 1. Estimation by the trench method and the zonal structure of root biomass.J Trop Ecol1987;3:97-108

[40] Win Maung Aye. Ecological studies on locally-managed mangrove forests in Tanintharyi region, Myanmar. PhD Thesis. Japan: Graduate school of Asian and African area studies, Kyoto University; 2020. p.158

[41] Meepol W. Aboveground and underground biomass estimation of mangrove forests in the Ranong Biosphere Reserve. Mangrove Forest Research Center. Forthcoming 2020.

[42] Jachowski NRA,Friess DA,Webb EL.Mangrove biomass estimation in Southwest Thailand using machine learning.Appl Geogr2013;45:311-21.

[43] Ong JE. Mangroves and aquaculture in Malaysia. Ambio 1982;11:252-57. Available from: https://www.jstor.org/stable/4312815 [Last accessed on 29 Jul 2023]

[44] Komiyama A,Srisawatt W.Top/root biomass ratio of a secondary mangrove (Ceriops tagal (Perr.) C.B. Rob.) forest.For Ecol Manag2000;139:127-34

[45] Komiyama A,Poungparn S.Allometry, biomass, and productivity of mangrove forests: a review.Aquatic Botany2008;89:128-37

[46] Purbopuspito J,Warren M, et al.. Mangrove soil properties and their carbon pools among large islands in Indonesia. 2014. Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287347108 [Last accessed on 27 Jul 2023]

[47] Barillé-Boyer AL,Massé H,Héral M.Correction for particulate organic matter as estimated by loss on ignition in estuarine ecosystems.Estuar Coast Shelf Sci2003;58:147-53

[48] Sanderman J,Fiske G.A global map of mangrove forest soil carbon at 30 m spatial resolution.Environ Res Lett2018;13:055002

[49] Tue NT,Nhuan MT.Carbon storage of a tropical mangrove forest in Mui Ca Mau National Park, Vietnam.Catena2014;121:119-26

[50] Nam VN,Murdiyarso D,MacKenzie RA.Carbon stocks in artificially and naturally regenerated mangrove ecosystems in the Mekong Delta. .Wetl Ecol Manag2016;24:231-44

[51] Donato DC,Murdiyarso D,Stidham M.Mangroves among the most carbon-rich forests in the tropics.Nat Geosci2011;4:293-7