Efficacy and safety of a dual-scan protocol for carbon dioxide laser in the treatment of split-thickness skin graft contraction in a red Duroc pig model

Abstract

Background: Fractional CO₂ laser plays an important role in scar management post split-thickness skin graft by loosening the graft contracture and restoring the smoothness of the surface. However, the optimal treatment protocol remains unknown. This study applied a dual-scan protocol to achieve both releasing and ablation of contracted skin graft. We comprehensively describe this treatment method and compare the efficacy and safety between this dual-scan method and the conventional mono-scan mode. Methods: A hypercontracted scar model after split-thickness skin grafting in red Duroc pigs was established. All scars meeting the inclusion criteria were randomly divided into four groups: high fluence–low density (HF–LD), low fluence–high density (LF–HD), combined group and control group. The energy per unit area was similar in the HF–LD and LF–HD groups. Two laser interventions were performed at a 6-week interval. The efficacy of the treatment was evaluated by objective measures of scar area, release rate, elasticity, thickness and flatness, while the safety was evaluated based on adverse reactions and melanin index. Collagen structure was observed histologically. The animals were followed up for a maximum of 126 days after modeling. Results: A total of 28 contracted scars were included, 7 in each group. At 18 weeks postoperatively, the HF–LD and the combined groups showed significantly increased scar release rate (p = 0.000) and elasticity (p = 0.036) and decreased type I/III collagen ratio (p = 0.002) compared with the control and LF–HD groups. In terms of flatness, the combined group was significantly better than the HF–LD group for elevations <1 mm (p = 0.019). No significant skin side effects, pigmentation or scar thickness changes were observed at 18 weeks. Conclusions: Dual-scan protocol could achieve superficial ablation and deep release of contracted split-thickness skin graft in a single treatment, with similar contraction release and texture improvement compared to a single deep scan. Its main advantage is to restore a smoother scar appearance. Adequate laser penetration was necessary for the release of contracted scars.

Keywords

Skin graft contraction / Scar / Laser treatment / Fractional carbon dioxide laser

References

[1] McDonald WS, Deitch EA.Hypertrophic skin grafts in burned patients: a prospective analysis of variables. J Trauma. 1987; 27: 147-50.

[2] Schneider JC, Holavanahalli R, Helm P, Goldstein R, Kowalske K. Contractures in burn injury: defining the problem. Journal of burn care & research: official publication of the American Burn Association. 2006; 27: 508-14.

[3] Harrison CA, MacNeil S. The mechanism of skin graft contraction: an update on current research and potential future therapies. Burns. 2008; 34: 153-63.

[4] Schouten HJ, Nieuwenhuis MK, van Zuijlen PP. A review on static splinting therapy to prevent burn scar contracture: do clinical and experimental data warrant its clinical application? Burns. 2012; 38: 19-25.

[5] Wiseman J, Ware RS, Simons M, McPhail S, Kimble R, Dotta A, et al. Effectiveness of topical silicone gel and pressure garment therapy for burn scar prevention and management in children: a randomized controlled trial. Clin Rehabil. 2020; 34: 120-31.

[6] DeBruler DM, Zbinden JC, Baumann ME, Blackstone BN, Malara MM, Bailey JK, et al. Early cessation of pressure garment therapy results in scar contraction and thickening. PLoS One. 2018; 13: e0197558. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0197558.

[7] Shumaker PR, Kwan JM, Landers JT, Uebelhoer NS. Functional improvements in traumatic scars and scar contractures using an ablative fractional laser protocol. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2012; 73: S116-21.

[8] Lv K, Liu H, Xu H, Wang C, Zhu S, Lou X, et al. Ablative fractional CO (2) laser surgery improving sleep quality, pain and pruritus in adult hypertrophic scar patients: a prospective cohort study. Burns & trauma. 2021; 9: tkab023.

[9] Dai Z, Lou X, Shen T, Sun Y, Xiao Y, Zheng X, et al. Combination of ablative fractional carbon dioxide laser and platelet-rich plasma treatment to improve hypertrophic scars: a retrospective clinical observational study. Burns Trauma. 2021; 9: tkab016. doi: 10.1093/burnst/tkab016.

[10] Kroonen L, Shumaker PR, Kwan JM, Uebelhoer N, Hofmeister E. Treatment of split-thickness skin graft-related forearm scar contractures with a carbon dioxide laser protocol: 3 case reports. J Hand Surg Am. 2013; 38: 2164-8.

[11] Krakowski AC, Goldenberg A, Eichenfield LF, Murray JP, Shumaker PR. Ablative fractional laser resurfacing helps treat restrictive pediatric scar contractures. Pediatrics. 2014; 134: e1700-5.

[12] Zuccaro J, Ziolkowski N, Fish J. A systematic review of the effectiveness of laser therapy for hypertrophic burn scars. Clin Plast Surg. 2017; 44: 767-79.

[13] Kucukkaya D, Irkoren S, Ozkan S, Sivrioglu N. The effects of botulinum toxin a on the wound and skin graft contraction. J Craniofac Surg. 2014; 25: 1908-11.

[14] Kwak M, Son D, Kim J, Han K. Static Langer’s line and wound contraction rates according to anatomical regions in a porcine model. Wound Repair Regen. 2014; 22: 678-82.

[15] DeBruler DM, Blackstone BN, Baumann ME, McFarland KL, Wulff BC, Wilgus TA, et al. Inflammatory responses, matrix remodeling, and re-epithelialization after fractional CO2 laser treatment of scars. Lasers Surg Med. 2017; 49: 675-85.

[16] Kanapathy M, Mosahebi A. Comparative study on the donor site aesthetic outcome between epidermal graft and split-thickness skin graft. Int Wound J. 2019; 16: 354-9.

[17] Klifto KM, Asif M, Hultman CS. Laser management of hypertrophic burn scars: a comprehensive review. Burns Trauma. 2020; 8: tkz002. doi: 10.1093/burnst/tkz002.

[18] Baumann ME, Blackstone BN, Malara MM, Clairmonte IA, Supp DM, Bailey JK, et al. Fractional CO2 laser ablation of porcine burn scars after grafting: is deeper better? Burns. 2020; 46: 937-48.

[19] Anderson RR, Donelan MB, Hivnor C, Greeson E, Ross EV, Shumaker PR, et al. Laser treatment of traumatic scars with an emphasis on ablative fractional laser resurfacing: consensus report. JAMA Dermatol. 2014; 150: 187-93.

[20] Yuan XH, Zhong SX, Li SS.Comparison study of fractional carbon dioxide laser resurfacing using different fluences and densities for acne scars in Asians: a randomized split-face trial. Dermatol Surg. 2014; 40: 545-52.

[21] Tierney EP. Treatment of acne scarring using a dual-spot-size ablative fractionated carbon dioxide laser: review of the literature. Dermatol Surg. 2011; 37: 945-61.

[22] Poetschke J, Dornseifer U, Clementoni MT, Reinholz M, Schwaiger H, Steckmeier S, et al. Ultrapulsed fractional ablative carbon dioxide laser treatment of hypertrophic burn scars: evaluation of an in-patient controlled, standardized treatment approach. Lasers Med Sci. 2017; 32: 1031-40.

[23] Kotlus BS. Dual-depth fractional carbon dioxide laser resurfacing for periocular rhytidosis. Dermatol Surg. 2010; 36: 623-8.

[24] Hultman CS, Friedstat JS, Edkins RE, Cairns BA, Meyer AA.Laser resurfacing and remodeling of hypertrophic burn scars: the results of a large, prospective, before-after cohort study, with long-term follow-up. Ann Surg. 2014; 260: 519-29 discussion 529- 532.

[25] Issler-Fisher AC, Fisher OM, Haertsch P, Li Z, Maitz PKM. Ablative fractional resurfacing with laser-facilitated steroid delivery for burn scar management: does the depth of laser penetration matter? Lasers Surg Med. 2020; 52: 149-58.

[26] Lee SJ, Suh DH, Lee JM, Song KY, Ryu HJ. Dermal Remodeling of burn scar by fractional CO2 laser. Aesthetic Plast Surg. 2016; 40: 761-8.

[27] Xie CH, Gao XX, Meng XL, Chen KX, Zhang XH, Zhou X, et al. Effect analysis of sequential laser application in treating the hypertrophic scars of burn children at early stage. Chin J Burns. 2021; 37: 327-32.

[28] Ozog DM, Liu A, Chaffins ML, Ormsby AH, Fincher EF, Chipps LK, et al. Evaluation of clinical results, histological architecture, and collagen expression following treatment of mature burn scars with a fractional carbon dioxide laser. JAMA Dermatol. 2013; 149: 50-7.

[29] Cho SB, Lee SJ, Kang JM, Kim YK, Kim TY, Kim DH. The treatment of burn scar-induced contracture with the pinhole method and collagen induction therapy: a case report. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2008; 22: 513-4.

[30] Tierney EP, Hanke CW, Watkins L. Treatment of lower eyelid rhytids and laxity with ablative fractionated carbon-dioxide laser resurfacing: case series and review of the literature. J Am Acad Dermatol. 2011; 64: 730-40.

[31] Datz E, Schonberger C, Zeman F, Koller M, Berneburg M, Landthaler M, et al. Fractional carbon dioxide laser resurfacing of skin grafts: long-term results of a prospective, randomized, split-scar, evaluator-blinded study. Lasers Surg Med. 2018; 50: 1010-6.

[32] Avram MM, Tope WD, Yu T, Szachowicz E, Nelson JS. Hypertrophic scarring of the neck following ablative fractional carbon dioxide laser resurfacing. Lasers Surg Med. 2009; 41: 185-8.

[33] Karmisholt KE, Taudorf EH, Wulff CB, Wenande E, Philipsen PA, Haedersdal M. Fractional CO(2) laser treatment of caesarean section scars-a randomized controlled split-scar trial with long term follow-up assessment. Lasers Surg Med. 2017; 49: 189-97.

[34] Cho SB, Lee SJ, Cho S, Oh SH, Chung WS, Kang JM, et al. Non-ablative 1550-nm erbium-glass and ablative 10 600-nm carbon dioxide fractional lasers for acne scars: a randomized split-face study with blinded response evaluation. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2010; 24: 921-5.

[35] Huang L. A new modality for fractional CO2 laser resurfacing for acne scars in Asians. Lasers Med Sci. 2013; 28: 627-32.

[36] Cameli N, Mariano M, Serio M, Ardigò M. Preliminary comparison of fractional laser with fractional laser plus radiofrequency for the treatment of acne scars and photoaging. Dermatol Surg. 2014; 40: 553-61.

[37] Fitzpatrick RE, Smith SR, Sriprachya-anunt S.Depth of vaporization and the effect of pulse stacking with a high-energy, pulsed carbon dioxide laser. J Am Acad Dermatol. 1999; 40: 615-22.

[38] Blackstone BN, Kim JY, McFarland KL, Sen CK, Supp DM, Bailey JK, et al. Scar formation following excisional and burn injuries in a red Duroc pig model. Wound Repair Regen. 2017; 25: 618-31.

[39] Gallant CL, Olson ME, Hart DA. Molecular, histologic, and gross phenotype of skin wound healing in red Duroc pigs reveals an abnormal healing phenotype of hypercontracted, hyperpigmented scarring. Wound Repair Regen. 2004; 12: 305-19.

[40] Zhu KQ, Carrougher GJ, Gibran NS, Isik FF, Engrav LH. Review of the female Duroc/Yorkshire pig model of human fibroproliferative scarring. Wound Repair Regen. 2007;15 Suppl 1: S32-9.

[41] DeBruler DM, Blackstone BN, McFarland KL, Baumann ME, Supp DM, Bailey JK, et al. Effect of skin graft thickness on scar development in a porcine burn model. Burns. 2018; 44: 917-30.