Biochar to improve the thermal performance of living wall systems: laboratory assessment of three planting substrates

Abstract

Living wall systems (LWSs) help to alleviate the climate and biodiversity harms associated with buildings and bring benefits to building occupants. Their performance can be variable and existing research points to the planting substrate as a key design factor. This study provides quantitative evidence on the physical, thermal and moisture performance of three planting substrates that vary according to the proportion of biochar added to green waste compost (GWC). Thermal conductivity (Wm⁻¹ K⁻¹), thermal resistivity (mK W⁻¹), volumetric moisture content (%) and mass (g) are measured for each fraction, replicated six times. Controlled drying procedures were employed, measuring these properties at a range of moisture levels. Data analysis finds that volumetric moisture content and biochar fraction have a statistically significant (p ≤ 0.05) effect on thermal conductivity. Added biochar is associated with non-linear reductions in thermal conductivity at low moisture levels. This suggests increasing the biochar fraction while reducing moisture in the substrate of a LWS will reduce its thermal conductivity, with a 100 mm planting substrate with 30% biochar and 30%vol moisture content providing 0.82 m² KW⁻¹ of thermal resistance, compared to 0.46 m² KW⁻¹ without added biochar. The methods build on previous work to assess the properties of different planting substrates for LWSs, providing a practical, lab-based assessment of biochar. The data produced are useful for researchers and professionals seeking to understand how biochar additions impact irrigation and thermal performance when specifying and designing LWSs and underline the potential value of biochar for improving the thermal performance of green infrastructure more widely.

Keywords

Living wall systems / Nature-based solutions / Building energy performance / Moisture / Thermal conductivity / Green infrastructure

References

[1] Abdeen N, Rafaat T. Assessing vertical green walls for indoor corridors in educational buildings and its impact outdoor: a field study at the universities of Canada in Egypt. Results Eng, 2024

[2] Acharya BS, et al.. Biochar impacts on soil water dynamics: knowns, unknowns, and research directions. Biochar, 2024, 6(1): 34

[3] Adhikari S, Timms W, Mahmud MAP. Optimising water holding capacity and hydrophobicity of biochar for soil amendment—a review. Sci Total Environ, 2022, 851 158043

[4] Aicher A, Boermel M, Londong J, Beier S. Vertical green system for gray water treatment: analysis of the VertiKKA-module in a field test. Front Environ Sci, 2022

[5] Ali L, Xiukang W, Naveed M, Ashraf S, Nadeem SM, Haider FU, Mustafa A. Impact of biochar application on germination behavior and early growth of maize seedlings: insights from a growth room experiment. Appl Sci, 2021

[6] Alvarado-Alvarado AA, Smets W, Irga P, Denys S. Engineering green wall botanical biofiltration to abate indoor volatile organic compounds: a review on mechanisms, phyllosphere bioaugmentation, and modeling. J Hazard Mater, 2024

[7] Anangadan SM, Pradhan S, Saththasivam J, McKay G, Mackey HR. A kinetic evaluation of nutrient and organic matter removal in greywater for green walls: assessing the performance of mineral-based, organic, and waste-derived plant support media. Sep Purif Technol, 2024

[8] Anderson B, Kosmina L (2019) BR443 Conventions for U-value calculations. Building Research Establishment, Watford, United Kingdom. https://bregroup.com/store/bookshop/conventions-for-u-value-calculations-br443-2019

[9] Bakhshoodeh R, Ocampo C, Oldham C. Thermal performance of green façades: review and analysis of published data. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 2022, 155 111744

[10] Bakhtyari V, Fattahi K, Movahed K, Franz A. Investigating the effect of living walls on cooling energy consumption in various urban microclimates, building heights, and greenery coverage areas. Sustainability, 2024

[11] Bao S, Zou S, Li B, Chen Q, Zhao M. Summer thermal comparative experimental study of double plant-skin façades and double skin façades. J Build Eng, 2023, 72 106641

[12] Bolan S, Hou D, Wang L, et al.. The potential of biochar as a microbial carrier for agricultural and environmental applications. Sci Total Environ, 2023, 886: 163968

[13] Bustami RA, Belusko M, Ward J, Beecham S. Vertical greenery systems: a systematic review of research trends. Build Environ, 2018, 146: 226-237

[14] Cameron RWF, Taylor JE, Emmett MR. What's ‘cool’ in the world of green façades? How plant choice influences the cooling properties of green walls. Build Environ, 2014, 73: 198-207

[15] Chen W, Meng J, Han X, Lan Y, Zhang W. Past, present, and future of biochar. Biochar, 2019, 1(175-87

[16] CIOB. Guide to sustainability in the built environment, 2023, London, The Chartered Institute of Building

[17] Cortês A, Almeida J, Santos MI, Tadeu A, de Brito J, Silva CM. Environmental performance of a cork-based modular living wall from a life-cycle perspective. Build Environ, 2021

[18] Cortês A, Almeida J, Tadeu A, Ramezani B, Fino MR, de Brito J, Silva CM. The effect of cork-based living walls on the energy performance of buildings and local microclimate. Build Environ, 2022

[19] Daemei AB, Shafiee E, Chitgar AA, Asadi S. Investigating the thermal performance of green wall: experimental analysis, deep learning model, and simulation studies in a humid climate. Build Environ, 2021

[20] Dayoub EB, Tóth Z, Anda A. Biochar and its effects on soil properties and evapotranspiration: a sustainable solution for plant growth. Cog Food Agric, 2023

[21] Decagon Devices Inc (2016) KD2 Pro thermal properties analyzer operator’s manual. Decagon Devices Inc, Pullman, United States of America. https://www.manualslib.com/manual/1247577/Decagon-Devices-Kd2-Pro.html

[22] Dede OH, Mercan N, Ozer H, Dede G, Pekarchuk O, Mercan B. Thermal insulation characteristics of green wall systems using different growing media. Energy Build, 2021

[23] Delta-T Devices Ltd (2017) User manual for the ML3 thetaprobe. Kingdom, U, Cambridge. https://delta-t.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/ML3-user-manual-version-2.1.pdf

[24] Dominici L, Fleck R, Gill RL, Pettit TJ, Irga PJ, Comino E, Torpy FR. Analysis of lighting conditions of indoor living walls: effects on CO² removal. J Build Eng, 2021, 44 102961

[25] Duang HN, Nguyen NP. Impact of biochar on the water holding capacity and moisture of basalt and grey soil. Univ J Sci–Eng Technol, 2017, 7: 36

[26] Exeter Charcoal (2024) The carbon compost company exeter retort exeter charcoal. https://www.exetercharcoal.co.uk/. Accessed 12 Nov 2024].

[27] Falzone C, Jupsin H, El Jarroudi M, Romain AC. Advancing methodologies for investigating PM2.5 removal using green wall system. Plants, 2024

[28] Fox M, Morewood J, Murphy T, Lunt P, Goodhew S. Living wall systems for improved thermal performance of existing buildings. Build Environ, 2022

[29] Gale NV, Thomas SC. Dose-dependence of growth and ecophysiological responses of plants to biochar. Sci Total Environ, 2019, 658: 1344-1354

[30] Gascó G, Cely P, Paz-Ferreiro J, Plaza C, Méndez A. Relation between biochar properties and effects on seed germination and plant development. Biol Agric Hortic, 2016, 32(4): 237-247

[31] Global Alliance for Buildings and Construction (2024) Global status report for buildings and construction: beyond foundations: mainstreaming sustainable solutions to cut emissions from the buildings sector. United Nations Environment Programme, Nairobi. https://www.unep.org/resources/publication/2022-global-status-report-buildings-and-construction

[32] Hellebaut A, Boisson S, Mahy G. Do plant traits help to design green walls for urban air pollution control? A short review of scientific evidences and knowledge gaps. Environ Sci Pollut Res Int, 2022, 29(54): 81210-81221

[33] HM Government (2024) The merged approved documents. UK Government, London, United Kingdom. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/building-regulations-and-approved-documents-index

[34] Jimenez MS, Cortesão J, Lenzholzer S, Walker R. Plant pixel: an optimized bio-inspired living wall system. Dev Built Environ, 2024

[35] Kaltsidi MP, Fernández-Cañero R, Franco-Salas A, Pérez-Urrestarazu L. Improving the performance of felt-based living wall systems in terms of irrigation management. Urban for Urban Green, 2020, 54 126782

[36] Karimi K, Farrokhzad M, Roshan G, Aghdasi M. Evaluation of effects of a green wall as a sustainable approach on reducing energy use in temperate and humid areas. Energy Build, 2022, 262 112014

[37] Koch K, Wuyts K, Denys S, Samson R. The influence of plant species, leaf morphology, height and season on PM capture efficiency in living wall systems. Sci Total Environ, 2023, 905 167808

[38] Kolton M, Graber ER, Tsehansky L, Elad Y, Cytryn E. Biochar-stimulated plant performance is strongly linked to microbial diversity and metabolic potential in the rhizosphere. New Phytol, 2017, 213(3): 1393-1404

[39] Kraus M, Žáková K, Žák J. Biochar for vertical greenery systems. Energies, 2020, 13: 6320

[40] Liao W, Sifton MA, Thomas SC. Biochar granulation reduces substrate erosion on green roofs. Biochar, 2022, 4(1): 61

[41] Libessart L, Kenai MA. Measuring thermal conductivity of green-walls components in controlled conditions. J Build Eng, 2018, 19: 258-265

[42] Lunt PH, Fuller K, Fox M, Goodhew S, Murphy TR. Comparing the thermal conductivity of three artificial soils under differing moisture and density conditions for use in green infrastructure. Soil Use Manage, 2023, 39(1260-269

[43] Manso M, Castro-Gomes J. Green wall systems: a review of their characteristics. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 2015, 41: 863-871

[44] Manso M, Teotónio I, Silva CM, Cruz CO. Green roof and green wall benefits and costs: a review of the quantitative evidence. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 2021

[45] Medl A, Stangl R, Florineth F. Vertical greening systems—a review on recent technologies and research advancement. Build Environ, 2017, 125: 227-239

[46] Mobarhan M, Yeganeh M, Motie MB, Ahmadi S. Assessing the efficacy of green walls versus street green lanes in mitigating air pollution: a critical evaluation. Environ Sustain Indic, 2024

[47] Mohammadi P, et al.. Can biomass-derived chars serve as a viable alternative to commercial inorganic fertilizers?. Biofuel Res J, 2025, 12(1): 2350-2372

[48] Murphy TR, Hanley ME, Ellis JS, Lunt PH. Soil saturation limits early oak establishment in upland pastures for restoration of Atlantic oak woodlands. For Ecol Manag, 2024, 561 121895

[49] Nan X, Yan H, Wu R, Shi Y, Bao Z. Assessing the thermal performance of living wall systems in wet and cold climates during the winter. Energy Build, 2020, 208 109680

[50] Ng S-C, Low K-S. Thermal conductivity of newspaper sandwiched aerated lightweight concrete panel. Energy Build, 2010, 42(12): 2452-2456

[51] Oquendo-Di Cosola V, Olivieri F, Ruiz-García L. A systematic review of the impact of green walls on urban comfort: temperature reduction and noise attenuation. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 2022, 162 112463

[52] Petreje M, et al.. Quantifying the benefits of incorporating biochar in green roof substrates: field study on the highrise rooftop in temperate climate setting. Biochar, 2025, 7(1): 7

[53] Plitsiri I, Taemthong W, et al.. Ksibi M, et al.. Reduction of PM 25 and improvement of thermal comfort in naturally ventilated area of a building by using an active green wall system. Advances in science, technology & innovation, 2024, Cham, Springer

[54] Pradhan S, Al-Ghamdi SG, Mackey HR. Greywater recycling in buildings using living walls and green roofs: a review of the applicability and challenges. Sci Total Environ, 2019, 652: 330-344

[55] Qian X, Zhang X, Weerasuriya AU, Zhai J. Designing green walls to mitigate fine particulate pollution in an idealized urban environment. Sustain Cities Soc, 2024

[56] RICS (2023) Whole life carbon assessment for the built environment. London

[57] Ripple WJ, et al.. The 2024 state of the climate report: perilous times on planet Earth. Bioscience, 2024

[58] Rowe T, Poppe J, Buyle M, Belmans B, Audenaert A. Is the sustainability potential of vertical greening systems deeply rooted? Establishing uniform outlines for environmental impact assessment of VGS. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 2022, 162 112414

[59] Ruiz-Valero L, Faxas-Guzmán J, Arranz B, Flores-Sasso V, Céspedes L. Living wall system for improved thermal performance of facades located in tropical climate. Case study in Dominican Republic. Build Environ, 2022, 222 109419

[60] Sami M, Hedstrom A, Kvarnstrom E, McCarthy DT, Herrmann I. Greywater treatment in a green wall using different filtermaterials and hydraulic loading rates. J Environ Manag, 2023, 340: 117998

[61] Sanei H, et al.. Assessing biochar's permanence: an inertinite benchmark. Int J Coal Geol, 2024, 281 104409

[62] Shafiee E, Faizi M, Yazdanfar S-A, Khanmohammadi M-A. Assessment of the effect of living wall systems on the improvement of the urban heat island phenomenon. Build Environ, 2020, 181 106923

[63] Shao Y, Li J, Zhou Z, Zhang F, Cui Y. The impact of indoor living wall system on air quality: a comparative monitoring test in building corridors. Sustainability, 2021

[64] Spokas KA. Review of the stability of biochar in soils: predictability of O:C molar ratios. Carbon Manag, 2010, 1(2289-303

[65] Trimplants (2024) Trimplants Home. https://www.trimplants.co.uk/ Accessed 12 Nov 2024

[66] Tudiwer D, Korjenic A. The effect of living wall systems on the thermal resistance of the façade. Energy Build, 2017, 135: 10-19

[67] UK Green Building Council (2022) The value of urban nature-based solutions. UK Green Building Council, London, United Kingdom. https://ukgbc.org/resources/the-value-of-urban-nature-based-solutions/

[68] Usowicz B, Lipiec J, Łukowski M, Marczewski W, Usowicz J. The effect of biochar application on thermal properties and albedo of loess soil under grassland and fallow. Soil Tillage Res, 2016, 164: 45-51

[69] Vijayalaxmi J, Gandham K. Steady-state assessment of vertical greenery systems on the thermal resistance of the wall and its correlation with thermal insulation. Lecture Notes Civil Eng, 2023, 316: 53-69

[70] Wang L, Deng J, Yang X, Hou R, Hou D. Role of biochar toward carbon neutrality. Carbon Res, 2023, 2(12

[71] Wu P, Fu Y, Vancov T, Wang H, Wang Y, Chen W. Analyzing the trends and hotspots of biochar’s applications in agriculture, environment, and energy: a bibliometrics study for 2022 and 2023. Biochar, 2024, 6(178

[72] WWF (2022) Living Planet Report 2022–Building a nature-positive society. WWF International, Gland, Switzerland. https://www.wwf.org.uk/our-reports/living-planet-report-2022

[73] Xiang Y, Deng Q, Duan H, Guo Y. Effects of biochar application on root traits: a meta-analysis. GCB Bioenergy, 2017, 9(101563-1572

[74] Xu L, Wu K-C, Deng Z-N, Huang C-M, Verma KK, Pang T, Huang H-R. Biochar and its impact on soil profile and plant development. J Plant Interact, 2024, 19(12401356

[75] Yuan J. Impact of insulation type and thickness on the dynamic thermal characteristics of an external wall structure. Sustainability, 2018

[76] Zhu D, Ciais P, Krinner G, Maignan F, Jornet Puig A, Hugelius G. Controls of soil organic matter on soil thermal dynamics in the northern high latitudes. Nat Commun, 2019, 10(13172

Funding

Good Growth Entrepreneurial Futures

UK Research and Innovation(RR206058)

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)