Optimizing the conditions of biowastes hydrothermal treatment and predicting phosphorus fate in the hydrochar and liquid phase using machine learning

Abstract

Applications of artificial intelligence (AI)- and machine learning (ML)-based methodologies for predicting optimal conditions in sustainable and effective management of biowastes and natural resources are of great concern. However, the AI-applications for optimizing the hydrothermal treatment (HT) of organic solid biowastes and prediction of nutrients fate during the HT process have not yet been investigated. Therefore, this study explores the application of different ML models (e.g., XGBoost, Decision Tree, and Random Forest) for optimizing HT of swine manure, focusing on the role of calcium (Ca) and iron (Fe) ions in phosphorus (P) distribution in the produced liquid and solid phases (hydrochar). Specifically, we investigated the fate of total P (TPS) in the hydrochar and inorganic P (IPL) in the liquid phase during HT. Experimental validation was conducted alongside the ML predictions, with XGBoost outperforming the other models, showing strong predictive accuracy for TPS (R² = 0.77) and IPL (R² = 1.0). Key factors influencing model accuracy included feedstock composition, reaction temperature, duration, solid–liquid ratio, and Ca and Fe concentrations. We found that the impact of time on TPS and IPL was minimal when the reaction time was less than 200 min, while pH showed a positive correlation with TPS and IPL. NMR and XRD analyses indicated that as the reaction severity increased, the organic P content in the hydrochar became more uniform. These findings highlight the potential of AI-based methodologies for optimizing HT processes, contributing to more sustainable and effective solutions for safe recycling, management, and development of bioresources.

Keywords

Livestock biowastes / Hydrothermal technology / Hydrochar / Nutrients resources / Artificial intelligence-based methodology

References

[1] BansalM, GoyalA, ChoudharyA. A comparative analysis of K-nearest neighbour, genetic, support vector machine, decision tree, and long short term memory algorithms in machine learning. Decis Anal J, 2022, 3. 100071

[2] ChenC, WangZ, GeY, LiangR, HouD, TaoJ, YanB, ZhengW, VelichkovaR, ChenGY. Characteristics prediction of hydrothermal biochar using data enhanced interpretable machine learning. Biores Technol, 2023, 377. 128893

[3] ChenGY, WangJ, YuF, WangX, XiaoH, YanB, CuiX. A review on the production of P-enriched hydro/bio-char from solid waste: transformation of P and applications of hydro/bio-char. Chemosphere, 2022, 301. 134646

[4] ChojnackaK, MikulaK, SkrzypczakD, IzydorczykG, GorazdaK, KulczyckaJ, KominkoH, MoustakasK, Witek-KrowiakA. Practical aspects of biowastes conversion to fertilizers. Biomass Convers Biorefin, 2024, 14: 1515-1533.

[5] DaerD, LuoL, ShangY, WangJ, WuC, LiuZG. Co-hydrothermal carbonization of waste biomass and phosphate rock: promoted carbon sequestration and enhanced phosphorus bioavailability. Biochar, 2024, 670.

[6] DengYX, ZhangT, ClarkJ, AminabhaviT, KruseA, TsangDCW, SharmaBK, ZhangF, RenHQ. Mechanisms and modelling of phosphorus solid-liquid transformation during the hydrothermal processing of swine manure. Green Chem, 2020, 22: 5628-5638.

[7] DjandjaOS, SalamiAA, WangZ, DuoJ, YinL, DuanP. Random forest-based modeling for insights on phosphorus content in hydrochar produced from hydrothermal carbonization of sewage sludge. Energy, 2022, 245. 123295

[8] FanW, SrisupanM, BryantL, TremblyJP. Utilization of fly ash as pH adjustment for efficient immobilization and reutilization of nutrients from swine manure using hydrothermal treatment. Waste Manage, 2018, 79: 709-716.

[9] GoldfarbJL, HubbleAH, MaQ, VolpeM, SeveriniG, AndreottolaG, FioriL. Valorization of cow manure via hydrothermal carbonization for phosphorus recovery and adsorbents for water treatment. J Environ Manage, 2022, 308. 114561

[10] HeilmannSM, MoldeJS, TimlerJG, WoodBM, MikulaAL, VozhdayevGV, ColoskyEC, SpokasKA, ValentasKJ. Phosphorus reclamation through hydrothermal carbonization of animal manures. Environ Sci Technol, 2014, 48: 10323-10329.

[11] HuangR, TangY. Evolution of phosphorus complexation and mineralogy during (hydro)thermal treatments of activated and anaerobically digested sludge: Insights from sequential extraction and P K-edge XANES. Water Res, 2016, 100: 439-447.

[12] HuangRX, FangC, ZhangB, TangYZ. Transformations of phosphorus speciation during (hydro)thermal treatments of animal manures. Environ Sci Technol, 2018.

[13] JeonPR, MoonJ, OgunsolaNO, LeeSH, LingJLJ, YouSM, ParkYK. Recent advances and future prospects of thermochemical biofuel conversion processes with machine learning. Chem Eng J, 2023, 471. 144503

[14] JiangR, YuG, YuL, WangY, LiC, XingZ, XueX, WangY, YuC. Migration of phosphorus in pig manure during pyrolysis process and slow-release mechanism of biochar in hydroponic application. Sci Total Environ, 2024, 915. 170116

[15] JinS, ZhangB, WuB, HanD, HuY, RenC, ZhangC, WeiX, WuY, MolAPJ, ReisS, GuBJ, ChenJ. Decoupling livestock and crop production at the household level in China. Nat Sustain, 2021, 4: 48-55.

[16] KumarA, BhattacharyaT, ShaikhWA, RoyA, ChakrabortyS, VithanageM, BiswasJK. Multifaceted applications of biochar in environmental management: a bibliometric profile. Biochar, 2023, 511.

[17] LangQ, ZhangB, LiuZ, JiaoW, XiaY, ChenZ, LiD, MaJ, GaiC. Properties of hydrochars derived from swine manure by CaO assisted hydrothermal carbonization. J Environ Manage, 2019, 233: 440-446.

[18] LengL, ZhouJ, ZhangW, ChenJ, WuZ, XuD, ZhanH, YuanX, XuZ, PengH, YangZ, LiH. Machine-learning-aided hydrochar production through hydrothermal carbonization of biomass by engineering operating parameters and/or biomass mixture recipes. Energy, 2024, 288. 129854

[19] LengL, ZhangW, LiuT, ZhanH, LiJ, YangL, LiJ, PengH, LiH. Machine learning predicting wastewater properties of the aqueous phase derived from hydrothermal treatment of biomass. Biores Technol, 2022, 358. 127348

[20] LiJ, PanL, LiZ, WangY. Unveiling the migration of Cr and Cd to biochar from pyrolysis of manure and sludge using machine learning. Sci Total Environ, 2023, 885. 163895

[21] LiJ, ZhangW, LiuT, YangL, LiH, PengH, JiangS, WangX, LengL. Machine learning aided bio-oil production with high energy recovery and low nitrogen content from hydrothermal liquefaction of biomass with experiment verification. Chem Eng J, 2021, 425. 130649

[22] LiL, FloraJRV, BergeND. Predictions of energy recovery from hydrochar generated from the hydrothermal carbonization of organic wastes. Renew Energy, 2020, 145: 1883-1889.

[23] LiS, ZengW, JiaZ, WuG, XuH, PengY. Phosphorus species transformation and recovery without apatite in FeCl3- assisted sewage sludge hydrothermal treatment. Chem Eng J, 2020, 399. 125735

[24] LiuQ, ZhangG, YuJ, KongG, CaoT, JiG, ZhangX, HanLJ. Machine learning-aided hydrothermal carbonization of biomass for coal-like hydrochar production: Parameters optimization and experimental verification. Biores Technol, 2024, 393. 130073

[25] NguyenH, VuT, VoTP, ThaiH. Efficient machine learning models for prediction of concrete strengths. Constr Build Mater, 2021, 266. 120950

[26] QianL, NiJ, LuoM, LuY, WangS, YuanC, ZhuK, ZhangB, GuH. Machine learning models for fast and isothermal hydrothermal liquefaction of biomass: Comprehensive experiment and prediction of various product fraction yields. Energy Convers Manage, 2023, 292. 117430

[27] RavindiranG, RajamanickamS, JanardhanG, HayderG, AlagumalaiA, MahianO, LamSS, SonneC. Production and modifications of biochar to engineered materials and its application for environmental sustainability: a review. Biochar, 2024, 662.

[28] RezaMT, RottlerE, HerklotzL, WirthB. Hydrothermal carbonization (HTC) of wheat straw: Influence of feedwater pH prepared by acetic acid and potassium hydroxide. Biores Technol, 2015, 182: 336-344.

[29] ShafizadehA, ShahbeigH, NadianMH, MobliH, DowlatiM, GuptaVK, PengW, LamSS, TabatabaeiM, AghbashloM. Machine learning predicts and optimizes hydrothermal liquefaction of biomass. Chem Eng J, 2022, 445. 136579

[30] ShiY, LuoG, RaoY, ChenH, ZhangS. Hydrothermal conversion of dewatered sewage sludge: Focusing on the transformation mechanism and recovery of phosphorus. Chemosphere, 2019, 228: 619-628.

[31] StobernackN, MalekC. Hydrothermal carbonization combined with thermochemical treatment of sewage sludge: effects of MgCl₂ on the migration of phosphorus and heavy metal. Waste Manage, 2023, 165: 150-158.

[32] SunZ, LiJ, WangX, XiaS, ZhaoJ. Enhanced heavy metal stabilization and phosphorus retention during the hydrothermal carbonization of swine manure by in-situ formation of MgFe₂O₄. Waste Manage, 2024, 174: 96-105.

[33] SuvarnaM, AraújoTP, Pérez-RamírezJ. A generalized machine learning framework to predict the space-time yield of methanol from thermocatalytic CO₂ hydrogenation. Appl Catal B, 2022, 315. 121530

[34] XieSY, ZhangT, YouSM, MukherjeeS, PuMJ, ChenQ, WangYS, AliEF, AbdelrahmanH, RinklebeJ, LeeSS, ShaheenSM. Applied machine learning for predicting the properties and carbon and phosphorus fate of pristine and engineered hydrochar. Biochar, 2025, 719.

[35] XuY, QiF, YanY, SunW, BaiT, LuN, LuoH, LiuC, YuanB, ShengZ, LiuT. The interaction of different chlorine-based additives with swine manure during pyrolysis: effects on biochar properties and heavy metal volatilization. Waste Manage, 2023, 169: 52-61.

[36] XuY, YangF, ZhangL, WangX, SunY, LiuQ, QianG. Migration and transformation of phosphorus in municipal sludge by the hydrothermal treatment and its directional adjustment. Waste Manage, 2018, 81: 196-201.

[37] YeW, LinX, ZhongX, LanQ, YangG, HuangJ, WuY, ZhaoZ, HeQ, WuY, XuX, YangJ. Unraveling the effects of sodium carbonate on hydrothermal liquefaction through individual biomass model component and machine learning-enabled prediction. Fuel, 2024, 358. 130330

[38] YuF, WangJ, WangX, WangY, GuoQ, WangZ, GuiXQ, HuY, YanB, ChenGY. Phosphorus-enriched biochar from biogas residue of Eichhornia crassipes: transformation and release of phosphorus. Biochar, 2023, 582.

[39] ZhangW, ChenQ, ChenJ, XuD, ZhanH, PengH, PanJ, VlaskinM, LengL, LiH. Machine learning for hydrothermal treatment of biomass: a review. Biores Technol, 2023, 370. 128547

[40] ZhengXY, YeYT, JiangZW, YingZ, JiS, ChenW, WangB, DouB. Enhanced transformation of phosphorus (P) in sewage sludge to hydroxyapatite via hydrothermal carbonization and calcium-based additive. Sci Total Environ, 2020, 738. 139786

Funding

the National Key Research and Development Program of China(2023YFE0104700)

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)