Optimizing sustainable basil cultivation with smart-monitoring: a comparative study of biochar and soilless growth media

Abstract

This study evaluated the efficiency of different soilless growth media for sustainable basil cultivation compared to traditional potting mix with continuous monitoring. This paper presents a novel approach of continuous physico-chemical monitoring of basil growth using Internet of Things (IoT) enabled smart growth cabinets. Six growth media combinations—sand, coir, and biochar (unsoaked and nutrient-enriched), sand, coir, and perlite, and potting mix with 10% and 20% biochar—were tested over 30 days under controlled conditions, with potting mix as the control. The pH, electrical conductivity and cation exchange capacity of growth mixes were analyzed before and after, along with key growth metrics such as root length, shoot length, leaf number, fresh and dry plant weight and leaf area index (LAI) were analysed. Results indicated that incorporating 10 to 20% biochar into potting mix optimally enhanced basil growth, with significant improvements in root development and the LAI of the plant. Biochar soaked in nutrient solution demonstrated three times higher plant weight compared to unsoaked biochar, indicating the potential of biochar as a slow-release nutrient matrix. Despite the high exchangeable potassium and sodium of biochar, calcium and magnesium remained dominant in the potting mix, indicating the need for optimising biochar use as a horticultural growth media according to the plant type chosen. Replacement of 10 to 20% of potting mix by biochar supports the circular economy goals by enhancing plant growth and sequestering carbon.

Keywords

Protected cropping / Potting mix / Replacement / Sustainable horticulture / IoT

References

[1] AbrolV, Ben-HurM, VerheijenFGA, KeizerJJ, MartinsMAS, TenawH, TchehanskyL, GraberER. Biochar effects on soil water infiltration and erosion under seal formation conditions: rainfall simulation experiment. J Soils Sediments, 2016, 16(12): 2709-2719

[2] AdhikariS, GascoG, MendezA, SurapaneniA, JegatheesanV, ShahK, Paz-FerreiroJ. Influence of pyrolysis parameters on phosphorus fractions of biosolids derived biochar. Sci Total Environ, 2019, 695 ArticleID: 133846

[3] AdhikariS, TimmsW, MahmudMAP. Optimising water holding capacity and hydrophobicity of biochar for soil amendment—a review. Sci Total Environ, 2022, 851(Pt 1) ArticleID: 158043

[4] AdhikariS, MahmudMAP, NguyenMD, TimmsW. Evaluating fundamental biochar properties in relation to water holding capacity. Chemosphere, 2023, 328 ArticleID: 138620

[5] AdhikariS, MoonE, Paz-FerreiroJ, TimmsW. Comparative analysis of biochar carbon stability methods and implications for carbon credits. Sci Total Environ, 2023

[6] AdhikariS, MoonE, TimmsW. Identifying biochar production variables to maximise exchangeable cations and increase nutrient availability in soils. J Clean Prod, 2024, 446 ArticleID: 141454

[7] AjienA, IdrisJ, Md SofwanN, HusenR, SeliH. Coconut shell and husk biochar: a review of production and activation technology, economic, financial aspect and application. Waste Manag Res, 2023, 41 1): 37-51

[8] Ali MSABM, Nordin MKB, Zaki MHBM, Saaid MFB. Optimizing plant growth in indoor NFT hydroponic systems: design, environmental monitoring, and analysis. In: 2024 IEEE international conference on applied electronics and engineering (ICAEE); 2024.

[9] BanitalebiG, MosaddeghiMR, ShariatmadariH. Evaluation of physico-chemical properties of biochar-based mixtures for soilless growth media. J Mater Cycles Waste Manage, 2021, 23(3): 950-964

[10] BanitalebiG, MosaddeghiMR, ShariatmadariH. Oxygen diffusion in biochar-based mixtures as plant growth media: experimental and modelling. Waste Manage Res, 2024, 42(12): 1195-1207

[11] BeldaRM, LidónA, FornesF. Biochars and hydrochars as substrate constituents for soilless growth of myrtle and mastic. Ind Crops Prod, 2016, 94: 132-142

[12] BhenguNM, MiandaSM, MabokoMM, SivakumarD. The effects of nitrogen application and varietal variation on the product quality and in vitro bioaccessibility of bioactive compounds of baby spinach varieties grown in a soilless growth medium. Foods, 2024, 13(17): 2667

[13] BurdinaI, PrissO. Effect of the substrate composition on yield and quality of basil (Ocimum basilicum L.). J Horticult Res, 2016, 24(2): 109-118

[14] ChopraA, RaoP, PrakashO. Biochar-enhanced soilless farming: a sustainable solution for modern agriculture. Mitig Adapt Strat Glob Change, 2024, 29(7): 72

[15] ChrysargyrisA, PrasadM, TzortzakisN. Wood-based biochar ratio used for partial peat replacement in growing media for Antirrhinum majus pot production. Agriculture, 2024, 14(11): 1860

[16] CoppaE, QuagliataG, VenanziR, BruschiniA, BianchiniL, PicchioR, AstolfiS. Potential use of biochar as a mitigation strategy for salinity-related issues in tomato plants (Solanum lycopersicum L.). Environments, 2024, 11(1): 17

[17] DanishM, PradhanS, McKayG, Al-AnsariT, MansourS, MackeyHR. Effect of biochar, potting mixture and their blends to improve ocimum basilicum growth in sandy soil. J Soil Sci Plant Nutr, 2024, 24(2): 1952-1967

[18] Di LonardoS, BarontiS, VaccariFP, AlbaneseL, BattistaP, MigliettaF, BacciL. Biochar-based nursery substrates: the effect of peat substitution on reduced salinity. Urban for Urban Green, 2017, 23: 27-34

[19] FAO Standard operating procedure for soil electrical conductivity soil/water, 2021 FAO 5 1

[20] FAO Standard operating procedure for soil pH determination, 2021 FAO

[21] GraberER, Meller HarelY, KoltonM, CytrynE, SilberA, Rav DavidD, TsechanskyL, BorenshteinM, EladY. Biochar impact on development and productivity of pepper and tomato grown in fertigated soilless media. Plant Soil, 2010, 337(1): 481-496

[22] HuangL, NiuG, FeagleySE, GuM. Evaluation of a hardwood biochar and two composts mixes as replacements for a peat-based commercial substrate. Ind Crops Prod, 2019, 129: 549-560

[23] Hunter FM, John PC, Tom OO, Robert FP, Kathy PM. Chemical and physical properties of potting media containing varying amounts of composted poultry litter 2011 Louisville, Kentucky, August 7–10, 2011, St. Joseph, MI; 2011. https://elibrary.asabe.org/abstract.asp?aid=38190&t=5

[24] HussainA, IqbalK, AziemS, MahatoP, NegiAK. A review on the science of growing crops without soil (soilless culture)—a novel alternative for growing crops. Int J Agric Crop Sci, 2014, 7: 833

[25] IvanovaN, ObaeedGLO, SulkarnaevF, BuchkinaN, GubinA, YurtaevA. Effect of biochar aging in agricultural soil on its wetting properties and surface structure. Biochar, 2023, 5(1): 75

[26] JabborovaD, MaH, Bellingrath-KimuraSD, WirthS. Impacts of biochar on basil (Ocimum basilicum) growth, root morphological traits, plant biochemical and physiological properties and soil enzymatic activities. Sci Horticult, 2021, 290 ArticleID: 110518

[27] JosephS, CowieAL, Van ZwietenL, BolanN, BudaiA, BussW, CayuelaML, GraberER, IppolitoJA, KuzyakovY, LuoY, OkYS, PalansooriyaKN, ShepherdJ, StephensS, WengZ, LehmannJ. How biochar works, and when it doesn't: A review of mechanisms controlling soil and plant responses to biochar. GCB Bioenergy, 2021

[28] KaushalA, YadavRK, SinghN SinghSV, MandalS, MeenaRS, ChaturvediS, GovindarajuK. Chapter 13—Biochar application in sustainable production of horticultural crops in the new era of soilless cultivation. Biochar production for green economy, 2024 Academic Press 249-267

[29] KhomamiAM, HatamzadehA, Jafari KhaljiriH. Effects of recycled organic waste in soilless growing medium on the growth and flowering of Gerbera (Gerbera jamesonii Bol.) in pot culture. Int J Recycl Org Waste Agric, 2024

[30] KingstonPH, ScagelCF, BrylaDR, StrikBC. Influence of perlite in peat- and coir-based media on vegetative growth and mineral nutrition of highbush blueberry. HortScience Horts, 2020, 55(5): 658-663

[31] KumarTV, VermaR. A comprehensive review on soilless cultivation for sustainable agriculture. J Exp Agric Int, 2024, 46(6): 193-207

[32] KunnenK, AliMM, LatafA, Van HeesM, NautsR, HoremansN, VandammeD, CuypersA. From crop left-overs to nutrient resource: growth-stimulating potential of biochar in nutrient solutions for wheat soilless cultivation systems [Original Research]. Front Plant Sci, 2024

[33] MarouaniR, MahamatC, KhachroumiS, BouadilaS, CherifA. Smart PV hydroponic greenhouse for sustainable agriculture in Tunisia. Eng Technol Appl Sci Res, 2024, 14(3): 14411-14419

[34] MehdizadehL, MoghaddamM, LakzianA. Effect of biochar on growth characteristics and sodium to potassium ratio of summer savory (Satureja hortensis L.) under NaCl stress. Environ Stresses Crop Sci, 2019, 12(2): 595-606

[35] MéndezA, Paz-FerreiroJ, GilE, GascóG. The effect of paper sludge and biochar addition on brown peat and coir based growing media properties. Sci Horticult, 2015, 193: 225-230

[36] Nazari F, Farahmand H, Khosh-Khui M, Salehi H (2011) Effects of different pot mixtures on vegetative, reproductive and physiological characteristics of Iranian Hyacinth (Hyacinthus orientalis L. cv. Sonbole-Irani). Int J Agr Food Sci 1:34–38

[37] NobileC, DenierJ, HoubenD. Linking biochar properties to biomass of basil, lettuce and pansy cultivated in growing media. Sci Hortic, 2020, 261 ArticleID: 109001

[38] NocentiniM, MastrolonardoG, MichelozziM, CencettiG, LenziA, PanettieriM, KnickerH, CertiniG. Effects of biochar and compost addition in potting substrates on growth and volatile compounds profile of basil (Ocimum basilicum L.). J Sci Food Agric, 2024, 104(3): 1609-1620

[39] NorooziA, Rezvani MoghaddamP, HashemianM, KhorramdelS. Effect of biochar amendment and irrigation treatments on biochemical attributes and morphological criteria of basil (Ocimum basilicum L.) using central composite design [Original Research]. J Agric Sci Technol, 2023, 25(3): 535-550

[40] PapadimitriouDM, DaliakopoulosIN, LouloudakisI, SavvidisTI, SabathianakisI, SavvasD, ManiosT. Impact of container geometry and hydraulic properties of coir dust, perlite, and their blends used as growing media, on growth, photosynthesis, and yield of Golden Thistle (S. hispanicus L.). Sci Horticult, 2024, 323 ArticleID: 112425

[41] RathnayakeD, CreberH, Van PouckeR, SohiS, MeersE, MašekO, RonsseF. Biochar from sawmill residues: characterization and evaluation for its potential use in the horticultural growing media. Biochar, 2021, 3(2): 201-212

[42] RozensteinO, CohenY, AlchanatisV, BehrendtK, BonfilDJ, EshelG, HarariA, HarrisWE, KlappI, LaorY, LinkerR, Paz-KaganT, PeetsS, RutterSM, SalzerY, Lowenberg-DeBoerJ. Data-driven agriculture and sustainable farming: friends or foes?. Precision Agric, 2024, 25(1): 520-531

[43] SharmaA, HazarikaM, HeisnamP, PandeyH, DevadasVS, WangsuM. Controlled environment ecosystem: a plant growth system to combat climate change through soilless culture. Crop Design, 2024, 3(1) ArticleID: 100044

[44] SinghB, DolkMM, ShenQ, Camps-ArbestainM. Biochar pH, electrical conductivity and liming potential. Biochar a guide to analytical methods, 2017 Csiro Publishing

[45] SteinerC, HarttungT. Biochar as a growing media additive and peat substitute. Solid Earth, 2014, 5 2): 995-999

[46] TianY, SunX, LiS, WangH, WangL, CaoJ, ZhangL. Biochar made from green waste as peat substitute in growth media for Calathea rotundifola cv. Fasciata. Sci Horticult, 2012, 143: 15-18

[47] VaughnSF, KenarJA, ThompsonAR, PetersonSC. Comparison of biochars derived from wood pellets and pelletized wheat straw as replacements for peat in potting substrates. Ind Crops Prod, 2013, 51: 437-443

[48] YounisA, AhsanM, AkramA, LimKB, ZulfiqarF, TariqU HasanuzzamanM, Hawrylak-NowakB, IslamT, FujitaM. Use of organic substrates in sustainable horticulture. Biostimulants for crop production and sustainable agriculture, 2022 CAB International 122-138

[49] YuP, LiQ, HuangL, NiuG, GuM. Mixed hardwood and sugarcane bagasse biochar as potting mix components for container tomato and basil seedling production. Appl Sci, 2019, 9(21): 4713

[50] ZabaletaR, SánchezE, FabaniP, MazzaG, RodriguezR. Almond shell biochar: characterization and application in soilless cultivation of Eruca sativa. Biomass Convers Bioref, 2024, 14(15): 18183-18200

[51] ZulfiqarF, YounisA, ChenJ. Biochar or biochar-compost amendment to a peat-based substrate improves growth of Syngonium podophyllum. Agronomy, 2019, 9(8): 460

[52] ZulfiqarF, MoosaA, NazirMM, FerranteA, AshrafM, NafeesM, ChenJ, DarrasA, SiddiqueKHM. Biochar: an emerging recipe for designing sustainable horticulture under climate change scenarios [Review]. Front Plant Sci, 2022

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)