Biochar and Bacillus subtilis boost cut chrysanthemum growth via intensified microbial interkingdom interactions

Abstract

Soil continuous monocropping obstacles pose a significant challenge to the sustainable production of cut chrysanthemums. Yet, the effectiveness of integrating biochar and microbial antagonists in alleviating these obstacles in cut chrysanthemum production remains unclear. Here, we collected soils from a 12-year continuous cropping system with a high incidence of disease to establish a pot experiment comprising four treatments: control (CK), biochar (BC), Bacillus subtilis (BM), and their combined addition (BM_BC), investigating the effects of biochar and B. subtilis on the disease incidence, plant growth, pathogenic and antagonistic microbial populations, and the bacterial and fungal communities in diseased soil. The results showed that BM_BC treatment effectively controlled the disease and significantly increased (P < 0.05) the plant biomass and root activity of cut chrysanthemum by 41.3% and 254%, respectively, compared to the CK. Notably, the BM_BC exhibited the lowest population of Fusarium oxysporum and the highest population of B. subtilis, along with the greatest alpha diversity (measured by Chao1 and Shannon indices) of both bacterial and fungal communities among the four treatments. The amendments of BC, BM, and BM_BC significantly altered the structure and composition of bacterial and fungal communities, with BM_BC primarily enriching beneficial bacteria and suppressing pathogen. Microbial co-occurrence network analysis revealed that BM_BC increased the abundance of module 2, co-dominated by bacterial and fungal species, and strengthened the interactions between them. The PLS-PM analysis demonstrated that bacteria-fungi interkingdom interactions played a crucial role in promoting the growth of cut chrysanthemums in diseased soil. Therefore, our findings underscore the synergistic effects of biochar and B. subtilis in suppressing Fusarium wilt disease and enhancing the growth of cut chrysanthemums by strengthening microbial interkingdom interactions.

Graphical Abstract

Keywords

Cut chrysanthemum / Bacillus subtilis / Biochar / Co-occurrence network / Interkingdom cooperation / Biological Sciences / Microbiology / Environmental Sciences / Soil Sciences

References

[1] AnwariG, XiaoxuanH, YimingZ, TianxuY, WenanW, BowenZ, WangX, QingtianL, XiwenS, MoussaAA, MandozaiA, FengJ. Effects of rice-husk biochar and aluminum sulfate addition on rice grain quality in saline-sodic soil of paddy-field. Int J Biosci, 2019, 15: 325-333

[2] AzeemM, HassanTU, TahirMI, AliA, JeyasundarPGSA, HussainQ, BashirS, MehmoodS, ZhangZ. Tea leaves biochar as a carrier of Bacillus cereus improves the soil function and crop productivity. Appl Soil Ecol, 2021, 157: 103732.

[3] BahadurI, MauryaBR, MeenaVS, SahaM, KumarA, AeronA. Mineral release dynamics of tricalcium phosphate and waste muscovite by mineral-solubilizing rhizobacteria isolated from Indo-Gangetic plain of India. Geomicrobiol J, 2017, 345454-466

[4] BharA, JainA, DasS. Soil pathogen, Fusarium oxysporum induced wilt disease in chickpea: a review on its dynamicity and possible control strategies. P Indian Natl Sci Ac, 2021, 872260-274.

[5] BhattacharyaR, MazumderD. Performance evaluation of moving bed bioreactor for simultaneous nitrification denitrification and phosphorus removal from simulated fertilizer industry wastewater. Environ Sci Pollut R, 2023, 30: 49060-49074.

[6] BoerWD, FolmanLB, SummerbellRC, BoddyL. Living in a fungal world: impact of fungi on soil bacterial niche development. FEMS Microbiol Rev, 2005, 294795-811.

[7] CaoX, ZhangN, ZengX, LanQ, MaN, WuC. Effects of biochar and Trichoderma on bacterial community diversity in continuous cropping soil. Hortic Environ Biote, 2022, 6311-12.

[8] ChenW, TengY, LiZ, LiuW, RenW, LuoY, ChristieP. Mechanisms by which organic fertilizer and effective microbes mitigate peanut continuous cropping yield constraints in a red soil of south China. Appl Soil Ecol, 2018, 128: 23-34.

[9] ChenM, LiuH, YuS, WangM, PanL, ChenN, WangT, ChiX, DuB. Long-term continuously monocropped peanut significantly changed the abundance and composition of soil bacterial communities. PeerJ, 2020, 8: e9024.

[10] ChenW, WuZ, LiuC, ZhangZ, LiuX. Biochar combined with Bacillus subtilis SL-44 as an eco-friendly strategy to improve soil fertility, reduce Fusarium wilt, and promote radish growth. Ecotox Environ Safe, 2023, 251: 114509.

[11] ChenL, Dini-AndreoteF, LiuH, WangH, DumbrellA, WangZ, ChenX, ChenF, ChenX, WuL, JiangY. Integrating variation in bacterial-fungal co-occurrence network with soil carbon dynamics. J Appl Ecol, 2024, 61136-50.

[12] ChowdhuryN, MarschnerP, BurnsRG. Soil microbial activity and community composition: impact of changes in matric and osmotic potential. Soil Biol Biochem, 2011, 4361229-1236.

[13] ConteP, BertaniR, SgarbossaP, BambinaP, SchmidtHP, RagaR, PapaGL, MartinoDFC, MeoPL. Recent developments in understanding biochar’s physical–chemistry. Agronomy, 2021, 114615.

[14] CouteaudierY, AlabouvetteC. Quantitative comparison of Fusarium oxysporum competitiveness in relation to carbon utilization. FEMS Microbiol Lett, 1990, 744261-267.

[15] DengZ, WangJ, HeY, TuZ, TianF, LiH, WuZ, AnX. Biochar-based Bacillus subtilis inoculant for enhancing plants disease prevention: microbiota response and root exudates regulation. Biochar, 2023, 5181.

[16] DengZ, WangJ, YanY, WangJ, ShaoW, WuZ. Biochar-based Bacillus subtilis inoculants promote plant growth: regulating microbial community to improve soil properties. J Environ Manage, 2025, 373: 123534.

[17] DeveauA, BonitoG, UehlingJ, PaolettiM, BeckerM, BindschedlerS, HacquardS, HerveV, LabbeJ, LastovetskyOA, MieszkinS, MilletLJ, VajnaB, JunierP, BonfanteP, KromBP, OlssonS, ElsasJDV, WickLY. Bacterial–fungal interactions: ecology, mechanisms and challenges. FEMS Microbiol Rev, 2018, 423335-352.

[18] DingW, LiJ, HuB, ChuG, TaoR. Response of abundance, diversity, and network of rhizosphere fungal community to monoculture of cut chrysanthemum. Appl Microbiol Biot, 2023, 107113673-3685.

[19] DongL, XuJ, ZhangL, ChengR, WeiG, SuH, YangJ, QianJ, XuR, ChenS. Rhizospheric microbial communities are driven by Panax ginseng at different growth stages and biocontrol bacteria alleviates replanting mortality. Acta Pharm Sin B, 2018, 82272-282.

[20] DuránP, ThiergartT, Garrido-OterR, AglerM, KemenE, Schulze-LefertP, HacquardS. Microbial interkingdom interactions in roots promote Arabidopsis survival. Cell, 2018, 1754973-983.

[21] El-TarabilyK. Suppression of Rhizoctonia solani diseases of sugar beet by antagonistic and plant growth-promoting yeasts. J Appl Microbiol, 2004, 96169-75.

[22] EstradaR, CosmeR, PorrasT, ReynosoA, CalderonC, ArbizuCI, AroneGJ. Changes in bulk and rhizosphere soil microbial diversity communities of native quinoa due to the monocropping in the Peruvian central Andes. Microorganisms, 2023, 1181926.

[23] GaoH, XuX, ZengQ, LiP. Optimization of headspace solid-phase microextraction for GC-MS analysis of volatile compounds produced by biocontrol strain Bacillus subtilis CF-3 using response surface methodology. Food Sci Technol Res, 2017, 234583-593.

[24] GuoJ, LingN, ChenZ, XueC, LiL, LiuL, GaoL, WangM, RuanJ, GuoS, VandenkoornhuyseP, ShenQ. Soil fungal assemblage complexity is dependent on soil fertility and dominated by deterministic processes. New Phytol, 2020, 2261232-243.

[25] HanG, LanJ, ChenQ, YuC, BieS. Response of soil microbial community to addition of biochar in cotton soils with different continuous cropping years. Sci Rep, 2017, 711-11

[26] HeM, XiongX, WangL, HouD, BolanNS, OkYS, RinklebeJ, TsangDCW. A critical review on performance indicators for evaluating soil biota and soil health of biochar-amended soils. J Hazard Mater, 2021, 414: 125378.

[27] KaračićS, PalmerB, GeeCT, BierbaumG. Oxygen-dependent biofilm dynamics in leaf decay: an in vitro analysis. Sci Rep, 2024, 1416728.

[28] KimJK, ParkKJ, ChoKS, NamSW, ParkTJ, BajpaiR. Aerobic nitrification–denitrification by heterotrophic Bacillus strains. Bioresource Technol, 2005, 96171897-1906.

[29] LauberCL, HamadyM, KnightR, FiererN. Pyrosequencing-based assessment of soil pH as a predictor of soil bacterial community structure at the continental scale. Appl Environ Microb, 2009, 75155111-5120.

[30] LehmannJ, RilligMC, ThiesJ, MasielloCA, HockadayWC, CrowleyD. Biochar effects on soil biota-a review. Soil Biol Biochem, 2011, 4391812-1836.

[31] LiH, WangJ, LiuQ, ZhouZ, ChenF, XiangD. Effects of consecutive monoculture of sweet potato on soil bacterial community as determined by pyrosequencing. J Basic Microb, 2019, 592181-191.

[32] LiJ, ChengX, ChuG, HuB, TaoR. Continuous cropping of cut chrysanthemum reduces rhizospheric soil bacterial community diversity and co-occurrence network complexity. Appl Soil Ecol, 2023, 185: 104801.

[33] LiX, RenX, IbrahimE, KongH, WangM, XiaJ, WangH, ShouL, ZhouT, LiB, YanJ. Response of Chinese cabbage (Brassica rapa subsp. pekinensis) to bacterial soft rot infection by change of soil microbial community in root zone. Front Microbiol, 2024, 15: 1401896.

[34] LiebalUW, UllmannL, LievenC, KohlP, WibbergD, ZambaniniT, BlankLM. Ustilago maydis metabolic characterization and growth quantification with a genome-scale metabolic model. J Fungi, 2022, 85524.

[35] LievensB, BrouwerM, VanachterAC, LevesqueCA, CammueBP, ThommaBP. Quantitative assessment of phytopathogenic fungi in various substrates using a DNA macroarray. Environ Microbiol, 2005, 7: 1698-1710.

[36] LiuZ, ZhouW, SunY, PengY, NiuJ, TanJ, WeiM. Biochar and its coupling with microbial inoculants for suppressing plant diseases: a review. Appl Soil Ecol, 2023, 190: 105025.

[37] LuJ, WuY, LiuH, GouT, ZhaoS, ChenF, JiangJ, ChenS, FangW, GuanZ. Estimation of plant water content in cut chrysanthemum using leaf-based hyperspectral reflectance. Sci Hortic, 2024, 323: 112517.

[38] LuoS, HeB, SongD, LiT, WuY, YangL. Response of bacterial community structure to different biochar addition dosages in karst yellow soil planted with ryegrass and daylily. Sustainability, 2020, 1252124.

[39] MahapatraS, YadavR, RamakrishnaW. Bacillus subtilis impact on plant growth, soil health and environment: Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. J Appl Microbiol, 2022, 13253543-3562.

[40] MiransariM. Interactions between arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi and soil bacteria. Appl Microbiol Biot, 2011, 89: 917-930.

[41] Morales-CedeñoLR, Orozco-MosquedaMDC, Loeza-LaraPD, Parra-CotaFI, Santos-VillalobosSDL, SantoyoG. Plant growth-promoting bacterial endophytes as biocontrol agents of pre-and post-harvest diseases: fundamentals, methods of addition and future perspectives. Microbiol Res, 2021, 242: 126612.

[42] MoraweM, HoekeH, WissenbachDK, LentenduG, WubetT, KröberE, KolbS. Acidotolerant bacteria and fungi as a sink of methanol-derived carbon in a deciduous forest soil. Front Microbiol, 2017, 8: 1361.

[43] MoriK, IriyeR, HirataM, TakamizawaK. Quantification of Bacillus species in a wastewater treatment system by the molecular analyses. Biotechnol Bioprocess Eng, 2004, 9: 482-489.

[44] PangZ, DongF, LiuQ, LinW, HuC, YuanZ. Soil metagenomics reveals effects of continuous sugarcane cropping on the structure and functional pathway of rhizospheric microbial community. Front Microbiol, 2021, 12: 627569.

[45] PintoC, PinhoD, SousaS, PinheiroM, EgasC, GomesAC. Unravelling the diversity of grapevine microbiome. PLoS ONE, 2014, 91e85622.

[46] RamachandranR, ChalasaniAG, LalR, RoyU. A broad-spectrum antimicrobial activity of Bacillus subtilis RLID 12.1. Sci World J, 2014, 2014: 968487.

[47] ShafikK, UmerM, YouH, AboushedidaH, WangZ, NiD, XuW. Characterization of a novel mitovirus infecting Melanconiella theae isolated from tea plants. Front Microbiol, 2021, 12: 757556.

[48] SunX, AtiyehHK, LiM, ChenY. Biochar facilitated bioprocessing and biorefinery for productions of biofuel and chemicals: a review. Bioresour Technol, 2020, 295: 122252.

[49] TangQ, WangP, LiuH, JinD, ChenX, ZhuL. Effect of chlorantraniliprole on soil bacterial and fungal diversity and community structure. Heliyon, 2023.

[50] TarinMWK, FanL, XieD, TayyabM, RongJ, ChenL, MuneerMA, ZhengY. Response of soil fungal diversity and community composition to varying levels of bamboo biochar in red soils. Microorganisms, 2021, 971385.

[51] TarkkaMT, SarniguetA, Frey-KlettP. Inter-kingdom encounters: recent advances in molecular bacterium–fungus interactions. Curr Genet, 2009, 55: 233-243.

[52] TavakkoliE, RengasamyP, SmithE, McDonaldGK. The effect of cation-anion interactions on soil pH and solubility of organic carbon. Eur J Soil Sci, 2015, 6661054-1062.

[53] TojuH, OkayasuK, NotaguchiM. Leaf-associated microbiomes of grafted tomato plants. Sci Rep, 2019, 911787.

[54] WaiselY, EshelAWaiselY, EshelA, BeeckmanT, KafkafiU. Functional diversity of various constituents of a single root system. Plant roots, 2002Boca RatonCRC Press271-296.

[55] WakelinS, MacdonaldL, RogersS, GreggAL, BolgerTP, BaldockJA. Habitat selective factors influencing the structural composition and functional capacity of microbial communities in agricultural soils. Soil Biol Biochem, 2008, 403803-813.

[56] WangZ, LiY, ZhuangL, YuY, LiuJ, ZhangL, GaoZ, WuY, GaoW, DingG, WangQ. A rhizosphere-derived consortium of Bacillus subtilis and Trichoderma harzianum suppresses common scab of potato and increases yield. Comput Struct Biotec, 2019, 17: 645-653.

[57] WangF, WangX, SongN. Biochar and vermicompost improve the soil properties and the yield and quality of cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.) grown in plastic shed soil continuously cropped for different years. Agr Ecosyst Environ, 2021, 315: 107425.

[58] WangT, YangK, MaQ, JiangX, ZhouY, KongD, WangZ, ParalesRE, LiL, ZhaoX, RuanZ. Rhizosphere microbial community diversity and function analysis of cut chrysanthemum during continuous monocropping. Front Microbiol, 2022, 13: 801546.

[59] WangJ, LiM, ZhouQ, ZhangT. Effects of continuous cropping Jiashi muskmelon on rhizosphere microbial community. Front Microbiol, 2023, 13: 1086334.

[60] WangJ, RiazM, BabarS, XiaH, LiY, XiaX, WangX, JiangC. Iron-modified biochar reduces nitrogen loss and improves nitrogen retention in Luvisols by adsorption and microbial regulation. Sci Total Environ, 2023, 879: 163196.

[61] WasaiS, MinamisawaK. Plant-associated microbes: from rhizobia to plant microbiomes. Microb Environ, 2018, 3311-3.

[62] WorrichA, KönigS, MiltnerA, BanitzT, CentlerF, FrankK, ThullnerM, HarmsH, KästnerM, WickLY. Mycelium-like networks increase bacterial dispersal, growth, and biodegradation in a model ecosystem at various water potentials. Appl Environ Microb, 2016, 82102902-2908.

[63] WuQ, ChenD, ZhouW, ZhangX, AoJ. Long-term fertilization has different impacts on bacterial communities and phosphorus forms in sugarcane rhizosphere and bulk soils under low-P stress. Front Plant Sci, 2022, 13: 1019042.

[64] XiongW, ZhaoQ, ZhaoJ, XunW, LiR, ZhangR, WuH, ShenQ. Different continuous cropping spans significantly affect microbial community membership and structure in a vanilla-grown soil as revealed by deep pyrosequencing. Microb Ecol, 2015, 70: 209-218.

[65] XiongW, ZhaoQ, XueC, XunW, ZhaoJ, WuH, LiR, ShenQ. Comparison of fungal community in black pepper-vanilla and vanilla monoculture systems associated with vanilla Fusarium wilt disease. Front Microbiol, 2016, 7: 117.

[66] XuL, MaL, LuX, WeiR, FengX, MaY, ZhangX, WangW, LiS, MaS, ChenG, YangX. Mulch alleviates the continuous crop barriers of Codonopsis pilosula (Franch.) Nannf. by regulating the soil bacterial community. Ann Appl Biol, 2024, 185111-22.

[67] YouY, ChiY, ChenX, WangJ, WangR, LiR, ChuS, YangX, ZhangD, ZhouP. A sustainable approach for bioremediation of secondary salinized soils: studying remediation efficiency and soil nitrate transformation by bioaugmentation. Chemosphere, 2022, 300: 134580.

[68] ZaidiA, KhanMS, AhemadM, OvesM, WaniPAKhanMS, ZaidiA, MusarratJ. Recent advances in plant growth promotion by phosphate-solubilizing microbes. Microbial strategies for crop improvement, 2009BerlinSpringer23-50.

[69] ZhangH, HuaZW, LiangWZ, NiuQH, WangX. The prevention of bio-organic fertilizer fermented from cow manure compost by Bacillus sp. XG-1 on watermelon continuous cropping barrier. Int J Env Res Pub He, 2020, 17165714.

[70] ZhangQ, LiuY, HarveyPR, StummerBE, YangJ, JiZ. Wheat rhizosphere colonization by Bacillus amyloliquefaciens W10 and Pseudomonas protegens FD6 suppress soil and in planta abundance of the sharp eyespot pathogen Rhizoctonia cerealis. J Appl Microbiol, 2023, 1345lxad101.

[71] ZhaoQ, WangH, ZhuZ, SongY, YuH. Effects of Bacillus cereus F-6 on promoting vanilla (Vanilla planifolia Andrews.) plant growth and controlling stem and root rot disease. Agr Sci China, 2015, 6091068

[72] ZhaoM, LiuR, WangX, ZhangJ, WangJ, CaoB, ZhaoY, XuL, ChenY, ZouG. How do controlled-release fertilizer-coated microplastics dynamically affect Cd availability by regulating Fe species and DOC content in soil?. Sci Total Environ, 2022, 850: 157886.

[73] ZhaoW, GuoQ, LiS, LuX, DongL, WangP, ZhangX, SuZ, MaP. Addition of Bacillus subtilis NCD-2 can suppress cotton verticillium wilt and its effect on abundant and rare microbial communities in the rhizosphere. Biol Control, 2022, 165: 104812.

[74] ZhengX, XuW, DongJ, YangT, ShangguanZ, QuJ, LiX, TanX. The effects of biochar and its additions in the microbial remediation of contaminated soil: a review. J Hazard Mater, 2022, 438: 129557.

[75] ZhouX, WangJ, LiuF, LiangJ, ZhaoP, TsuiCK, CaiL. Cross-kingdom synthetic microbiota supports tomato suppression of Fusarium wilt disease. Nat Commun, 2022, 1317890.

[76] ZhouH, ZhangM, YangJ, WangJ, ChenY, YeX. Returning ryegrass to continuous cropping soil improves soil nutrients and soil microbiome, producing good-quality flue-cured tobacco. Front Microbiol, 2023, 14: 1257924.

[77] ZhuY, LvX, SongJ, LiW, WangH. Addition of cotton straw biochar and compound Bacillus biofertilizer decrease the bioavailability of soil cd through impacting soil bacteria. BMC Microbiol, 2022, 22135.

Funding

National Natural Science Foundation of China(No. 42207367)

Basic Public Welfare Research Program of Zhejiang Province(No. LGN20C150003)

Postdoctoral Research Foundation of China(No. 2022M711655)

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)