Anaerobic digestion of process water from hydrothermal treatment processes: a review of inhibitors and detoxification approaches

Abstract

Integrating hydrothermal treatment processes and anaerobic digestion (AD) is promising for maximizing resource recovery from biomass and organic waste. The process water generated during hydrothermal treatment contains high concentrations of organic matter, which can be converted into biogas using AD. However, process water also contains various compounds that inhibit the AD process. Fingerprinting these inhibitors and identifying suitable mitigation strategies and detoxification methods is necessary to optimize the integration of these two technologies. By examining the existing literature, we were able to: (1) compare the methane yields and organics removal efficiency during AD of various hydrothermal treatment process water; (2) catalog the main AD inhibitors found in hydrothermal treatment process water; (3) identify recalcitrant components limiting AD performance; and (4) evaluate approaches to detoxify specific inhibitors and degrade recalcitrant components. Common inhibitors in process water are organic acids (at high concentrations), total ammonia nitrogen (TAN), oxygenated organics, and N-heterocyclic compounds. Feedstock composition is the primary determinant of organic acid and TAN formation (carbohydrates-rich and protein-rich feedstocks, respectively). In contrast, processing conditions (e.g., temperature, pressure, reaction duration) influence the formation extent of oxygenated organics and N-heterocyclic compounds. Struvite precipitation and zeolite adsorption are the most widely used approaches to eliminate TAN inhibition. In contrast, powdered and granular activated carbon and ozonation are the preferred methods to remove toxic substances before AD treatment. Currently, ozonation is the most effective approach to reduce the toxicity and recalcitrance of N and O-heterocyclic compounds during AD. Microaeration methods, which disrupt the AD microbiome less than ozone, might be more practical for nitrifying TAN and degrading recalcitrant compounds, but further research in this area is necessary.

Keywords

Hydrothermal treatment / Process water / Anaerobic digestion / Biogas / Inhibition / Detoxification

References

[1] Adams P, Bridgwater T, Lea-Langton A, Ross A, Watson I (2018) Chapter 8 - Biomass conversion technologies. In: Thornley P, Adams P (eds) Greenhouse gas balances of bioenergy systems. Academic Press

[2] Adedeji OM, Bauer SK, Jahan K. Anaerobic digestion of aqueous product of co-hydrothermal liquefaction of beverage waste and sewage sludge: reduction of toxicity and energy assessment. Energy Convers Manag, 2023, 290: 117228.

[3] Ahmad F, Silva EL, Varesche MBA. Hydrothermal processing of biomass for anaerobic digestion—a review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 2018, 98: 108-124.

[4] Ahmed M, Sartori F, Merzari F, Fiori L, Elagroudy S, Negm MS, Andreottola G. Anaerobic degradation of digestate based hydrothermal carbonization products in a continuous hybrid fixed bed anaerobic filter. Bioresour Technol, 2021, 330.

[5] Akarsu K, Duman G, Yilmazer A, Keskin T, Azbar N, Yanik J. Sustainable valorization of food wastes into solid fuel by hydrothermal carbonization. Biores Technol, 2019, 292.

[6] Angenent LT, Karim K, Al-Dahhan MH, Wrenn BA, Domíguez-Espinosa R. Production of bioenergy and biochemicals from industrial and agricultural wastewater. Trends Biotechnol, 2004, 22(9): 477-485.

[7] Angenent LT, Usack JG, Sun T, Fink C, Molitor B, Labatut R, Posmanik R, Hörl M, Hafenbradl D (2022) Upgrading anaerobic digestion within the energy economy—the methane platform. In: Pikaar I, Guest J, Ganigué R, Jensen P, Rabaey K, Seviour T, Trimmer J, van der Kolk O, Vaneeckhaute C, Verstraete W (eds) Resource Recovery from Water: Principles and Application. IWA Publishing

[8] Basar IA, Liu H, Eskicioglu C. Incorporating hydrothermal liquefaction into wastewater treatment—Part III: Aqueous phase characterization and evaluation of on-site treatment. Chem Eng J, 2023, 467: 143422.

[9] Bayat H, Dehghanizadeh M, Jarvis JM, Brewer CE, Jena U (2021) Hydrothermal liquefaction of food waste: effect of process parameters on product yields and chemistry. Front Sustain Food Syst 5

[10] Becker R, Dorgerloh U, Paulke E, Mumme J, Nehls I. Hydrothermal carbonization of biomass: major organic components of the aqueous phase. Chem Eng Technol, 2014, 37(3): 511-518.

[11] Biller P, Ross AB. Potential yields and properties of oil from the hydrothermal liquefaction of microalgae with different biochemical content. Biores Technol, 2011, 102(1): 215-225.

[12] Boll M, Fuchs G, Heider J. Anaerobic oxidation of aromatic compounds and hydrocarbons. Curr Opin Chem Biol, 2002, 6(5): 604-611.

[13] Brown AE, Adams JMM, Grasham OR, Camargo-Valero MA, Ross AB. An assessment of different integration strategies of hydrothermal carbonisation and anaerobic digestion of water hyacinth. Energies, 2020, 13(22): 5983.

[14] Brown AE, Finnerty GL, Camargo-Valero MA, Ross AB. Valorisation of macroalgae via the integration of hydrothermal carbonisation and anaerobic digestion. Bioresour Technol, 2020, 312.

[15] Cabrera DV, Labatut RA. Outlook and challenges for recovering energy and water from complex organic waste using hydrothermal liquefaction. Sustainable Energy Fuels, 2021, 5(8): 2201-2227.

[16] Cabrera DV, Barria DA, Camu E, Celis C, Tester JW, Labatut RA. Enhancing energy recovery of wastewater treatment plants through hydrothermal liquefaction. Environ Sci Water Res Technol, 2023, 9(2): 474-488.

[17] Chen Y, Cheng JJ, Creamer KS. Inhibition of anaerobic digestion process: a review. Bioresour Technol, 2008, 99(10): 4044-4064.

[18] Chen W-T, Zhang Y, Zhang J, Yu G, Schideman LC, Zhang P, Minarick M. Hydrothermal liquefaction of mixed-culture algal biomass from wastewater treatment system into bio-crude oil. Bioresour Technol, 2014, 152: 130-139.

[19] Chen H, Wan J, Chen K, Luo G, Fan J, Clark J, Zhang S. Biogas production from hydrothermal liquefaction wastewater (HTLWW): Focusing on the microbial communities as revealed by high-throughput sequencing of full-length 16S rRNA genes. Water Res, 2016, 106: 98-107.

[20] Chen H, Zhang C, Rao Y, Jing Y, Luo G, Zhang S. Methane potentials of wastewater generated from hydrothermal liquefaction of rice straw: focusing on the wastewater characteristics and microbial community compositions. Biotechnol Biofuels, 2017, 10(1): 140.

[21] Chen H, Rao Y, Cao L, Shi Y, Hao S, Luo G, Zhang S. Hydrothermal conversion of sewage sludge: Focusing on the characterization of liquid products and their methane yields. Chem Eng J, 2019, 357: 367-375.

[22] Cheng F, Tompsett GA, Murphy CM, Maag AR, Carabillo N, Bailey M, Hemingway JJ, Romo CI, Paulsen AD, Yelvington PE, Timko MT. Synergistic effects of inexpensive mixed metal oxides for catalytic hydrothermal liquefaction of food wastes. ACS Sustain Chem Eng, 2020, 8(17): 6877-6886.

[23] Cioabla AE, Ionel I, Dumitrel G-A, Popescu F. Comparative study on factors affecting anaerobic digestion of agricultural vegetal residues. Biotechnol Biofuels, 2012, 5(1): 39.

[24] De la Rubia MA, Villamil JA, Rodriguez JJ, Borja R, Mohedano AF. Mesophilic anaerobic co-digestion of the organic fraction of municipal solid waste with the liquid fraction from hydrothermal carbonization of sewage sludge. Waste Manag, 2018, 76: 315-322.

[25] de Mora A, Diaz de Tuesta JL, Pariente MI, Segura Y, Puyol D, Castillo E, Lissitsyna K, Melero JA, Martínez F. Chemically activated hydrochars as catalysts for the treatment of HTC liquor by catalytic wet air oxidation. Catal Today, 2024, 429.

[26] de Souza SMdAGU, Bonilla KAS, de Souza AAU. Removal of COD and color from hydrolyzed textile azo dye by combined ozonation and biological treatment. J Hazard Mater, 2010, 179(1): 35-42.

[27] Dias ME, Oliveira GHD, Couto PT, Dussán KJ, Zaiat M, Ribeiro R, Stablein MJ, Watson JT, Zhang Y, Tommaso G. Anaerobic digestion of hydrothermal liquefaction wastewater from spent coffee grounds. Biomass Bioenergy, 2021, 148.

[28] do Nascimento JGD, Silva EVA, dos Santos AB, da Silva MER, Firmino PIM (2021) Microaeration improves the removal/biotransformation of organic micropollutants in anaerobic wastewater treatment systems. Environ Res 198

[29] Elliott DC, Biller P, Ross AB, Schmidt AJ, Jones SB. Hydrothermal liquefaction of biomass: Developments from batch to continuous process. Bioresour Technol, 2015, 178: 147-156.

[30] Erdogan E, Atila B, Mumme J, Reza MT, Toptas A, Elibol M, Yanik J. Characterization of products from hydrothermal carbonization of orange pomace including anaerobic digestibility of process liquor. Bioresour Technol, 2015, 196: 35-42.

[31] Fettig J, Austermann-Haun U, Meier J-F, Busch A, Gilbert E. Options for removing refractory organic substances in pre-treated process water from hydrothermal carbonization. Water (switzerland), 2019, 11: 730.

[32] Filer J, Ding HH, Chang S. Biochemical methane potential (BMP) assay method for anaerobic digestion research. Water, 2019, 11(5): 921.

[33] Gai C, Li Y, Peng N, Fan A, Liu Z. Co-liquefaction of microalgae and lignocellulosic biomass in subcritical water. Biores Technol, 2015, 185: 240-245.

[34] Gaur RZ, Khoury O, Zohar M, Poverenov E, Darzi R, Laor Y, Posmanik R. Hydrothermal carbonization of sewage sludge coupled with anaerobic digestion: integrated approach for sludge management and energy recycling. Energy Convers Manag, 2020, 224.

[35] Gavazza S, Guzman JJ, Angenent LT. Electrolysis within anaerobic bioreactors stimulates breakdown of toxic products from azo dye treatment. Biodegradation, 2015, 26(2): 151-160.

[36] Gupta D, Mahajani SM, Garg A. Investigation on hydrochar and macromolecules recovery opportunities from food waste after hydrothermal carbonization. Sci Total Environ, 2020, 749.

[37] Hao S, Ren S, Zhou N, Chen H, Usman M, He C, Shi Q, Luo G, Zhang S. Molecular composition of hydrothermal liquefaction wastewater from sewage sludge and its transformation during anaerobic digestion. J Hazard Mater, 2020, 383.

[38] Hübner T, Mumme J. Integration of pyrolysis and anaerobic digestion–use of aqueous liquor from digestate pyrolysis for biogas production. Bioresour Technol, 2015, 183: 86-92.

[39] Ipiales RP, de la Rubia MA, Diaz E, Mohedano AF, Rodriguez JJ. Integration of hydrothermal carbonization and anaerobic digestion for energy recovery of biomass waste: an overview. Energy Fuels, 2021, 35(21): 17032-17050.

[40] Jenicek P, Celis CA, Krayzelova L, Anferova N, Pokorna D. Improving products of anaerobic sludge digestion by microaeration. Water Sci Technol, 2014, 69(4): 803-809.

[41] Jiang X, Shen J, Xu K, Chen D, Mu Y, Sun X, Han W, Li J, Wang L. Substantial enhancement of anaerobic pyridine bio-mineralization by electrical stimulation. Water Res, 2018, 130: 291-299.

[42] Kambo HS, Minaret J, Dutta A. Process water from the hydrothermal carbonization of biomass: a waste or a valuable product?. Waste and Biomass Valorization, 2018, 9(7): 1181-1189.

[43] Kayembe K, Basosila L, Mpiana PT, Sikulisimwa PC, Mbuyu K. Inhibitory effects of phenolic monomers on methanogenesis in anaerobic digestion. Br Microbiol Res J, 2013, 3: 32-41.

[44] Kilgore UJ, Subramaniam S, Fox SP, Cronin DJ, Guo MF, Schmidt AJ, Ramasamy KK, Thorson MR. Wet air oxidation of HTL aqueous waste. Biomass Bioenergy, 2023, 176.

[45] Kim BJ, Chu I, Jusuf S, Kuo T, TerAvest MA, Angenent LT, Wu M. Oxygen tension and riboflavin gradients cooperatively regulate the migration of Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 revealed by a hydrogel-based microfluidic device. Front Microbiol, 2016, 7: 1438.

[46] Kim S, Chen J, Cheng T, Gindulyte A, He J, He S, Li Q, Shoemaker BA, Thiessen PA, Yu B, Zaslavsky L, Zhang J, Bolton EE. PubChem 2023 update. Nucleic Acids Res, 2023, 51(D1): D1373-D1380.

[47] Knapp JS, Bromley-Challoner KCA (2003) 34—Recalcitrant organic compounds. In: Mara D, Horan N (eds) Handbook of Water and Wastewater Microbiology. Academic Press, London

[48] Leng L, Zhou W. Chemical compositions and wastewater properties of aqueous phase (wastewater) produced from the hydrothermal treatment of wet biomass: a review. Energy Sourc Part A, 2018, 40(22): 2648-2659.

[49] Leng L, Zhang W, Leng S, Chen J, Yang L, Li H, Jiang S, Huang H. Bioenergy recovery from wastewater produced by hydrothermal processing biomass: progress, challenges, and opportunities. Sci Total Environ, 2020, 748.

[50] Li C-s, Cai R-r. Preparation of solid organic fertilizer by co-hydrothermal carbonization of peanut residue and corn cob: a study on nutrient conversion. Sci Total Environ, 2022, 838.

[51] Li D, Zhou Y, Tan Y, Pathak S, MbA M, Ng WJ. Alkali-solubilized organic matter from sludge and its degradability in the anaerobic process. Bioresour Technol, 2016, 200: 579-586.

[52] Li R, Liu D, Zhang Y, Zhou J, Tsang YF, Liu Z, Duan N, Zhang Y. Improved methane production and energy recovery of post-hydrothermal liquefaction waste water via integration of zeolite adsorption and anaerobic digestion. Sci Total Environ, 2019, 651: 61-69.

[53] Li Y, Kontos GA, Cabrera DV, Avila NM, Parkinson TW, Viswanathan MB, Singh V, Altpeter F, Labatut RA, Guest JS. Design of a high-rate wastewater treatment process for energy and water recovery at biorefineries. ACS Sustain Chem Eng, 2023, 11(9): 3861-3872.

[54] Li Y, Xu H, Zhao Y, Yi X, Chen L, Jin F, Hua D. The integrated production of hydrochar and methane from lignocellulosic fermentative residue coupling hydrothermal carbonization with anaerobic digestion. Chemosphere, 2023, 340.

[55] Liu Z, Zhang Y, Liu Z. Comparative production of biochars from corn stalk and cow manure. Biores Technol, 2019, 291.

[56] Liu Q, Zhang G, Liu M, Kong G, Xu R, Han L, Zhang X. Fast hydrothermal liquefaction coupled with homogeneous catalysts to valorize livestock manure for enhanced biocrude oil and hydrochar production. Renewable Energy, 2022, 198: 521-533.

[57] Liu H, Basar IA, Eskicioglu C. Hydrothermal liquefaction for sludge-to-energy conversion: an evaluation of biocrude production and management of waste streams. Energy, 2023, 281.

[58] Lu J, Li H, Zhang Y, Liu Z. Nitrogen migration and transformation during hydrothermal liquefaction of livestock manures. ACS Sustain Chem Eng, 2018, 6(10): 13570-13578.

[59] Ma Z, Wang R, Song G, Zhang K, Zhao Z, Wang J. Interpretable ensemble prediction for anaerobic digestion performance of hydrothermal carbonization wastewater. Sci Total Environ, 2024, 908.

[60] Magdalena JA, Angenent LT, Usack JG. The measurement, application, and effect of oxygen in microbial fermentations: focusing on methane and carboxylate production. Fermentation, 2022, 8(4): 138.

[61] Mannarino G, Sarrion A, Diaz E, Gori R, De la Rubia MA, Mohedano AF. Improved energy recovery from food waste through hydrothermal carbonization and anaerobic digestion. Waste Manag, 2022, 142: 9-18.

[62] Marin-Batista JD, Villamil JA, Qaramaleki SV, Coronella CJ, Mohedano AF. Energy valorization of cow manure by hydrothermal carbonization and anaerobic digestion. Renew Energy, 2020, 160: 623-632.

[63] Mills TY, Sandoval NR, Gill RT. Cellulosic hydrolysate toxicity and tolerance mechanisms in Escherichia coli. Biotechnol Biofuels, 2009, 2(1): 1-11.

[64] Motavaf B, Savage PE. Effect of process variables on food waste valorization via hydrothermal liquefaction. ACS ESandT Eng, 2021, 1(3): 363-374.

[65] Nguyen TAH, Bui TH, Guo WS, Ngo HH. Valorization of the aqueous phase from hydrothermal carbonization of different feedstocks: challenges and perspectives. Chem Eng J, 2023, 472.

[66] Ortiz-Ardila AE, Diez B, Celis C, Jenicek P, Labatut R. Microaerobic conditions in anaerobic sludge promote changes in bacterial composition favouring biodegradation of polymeric siloxanes. Environ Sci Process Impacts, 2021, 23(8): 1182-1197.

[67] Parmar KR, Ross AB. Integration of hydrothermal carbonisation with anaerobic digestion; Opportunities for valorisation of digestate. Energies, 2019, 12(9): 1586.

[68] Pecchi M, Baratieri M. Coupling anaerobic digestion with gasification, pyrolysis or hydrothermal carbonization: a review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 2019, 105: 462-475.

[69] Periyavaram SR, Uppala L, Reddy PHP. Hydrothermal carbonization of food waste: process parameters optimization and biomethane potential evaluation of process water. J Environ Manage, 2023, 347: 119132.

[70] Pham M, Schideman L, Scott J, Rajagopalan N, Plewa MJ. Chemical and biological characterization of wastewater generated from hydrothermal liquefaction of Spirulina. Environ Sci Technol, 2013, 47(4): 2131-2138.

[71] Posmanik R, Labatut RA, Kim AH, Usack JG, Tester JW, Angenent LT. Coupling hydrothermal liquefaction and anaerobic digestion for energy valorization from model biomass feedstocks. Bioresour Technol, 2017, 233: 134-143.

[72] Ried A, Mielcke J, Wieland A, Schaefer S, Sievers M. An overview of the integration of ozone systems in biological treatment steps. Water Sci Technol, 2007, 55(12): 253-258.

[73] Romero P, Huang R, Jiménez E, Palma-Hidalgo JM, Ungerfeld EM, Popova M, Morgavi DP, Belanche A, Yáñez-Ruiz DR. Evaluating the effect of phenolic compounds as hydrogen acceptors when ruminal methanogenesis is inhibited in vitro—Part 2. Dairy Goats Animal, 2023, 17(5

[74] Ruirui L, Xia R, Na D, Zhang Y, Zhidan L, Haifeng L. Application of zeolite adsorption and biological anaerobic digestion technology on hydrothermal liquefaction wastewater. Int J Agric Biol Eng, 2017, 10(1): 163-168.

[75] Ruiz HA, Rodríguez-Jasso RM, Fernandes BD, Vicente AA, Teixeira JA. Hydrothermal processing, as an alternative for upgrading agriculture residues and marine biomass according to the biorefinery concept: a review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 2013, 21: 35-51.

[76] Seyedsadr S, Al Afif R, Pfeifer C. Hydrothermal carbonization of agricultural residues: A case study of the farm residues -based biogas plants. Carbon Resour Convers, 2018, 1(1): 81-85.

[77] Shanmugam SR, Adhikari S, Shakya R. Nutrient removal and energy production from aqueous phase of bio-oil generated via hydrothermal liquefaction of algae. Bioresour Technol, 2017, 230: 43-48.

[78] Shao M, Zhang C, Cui G, Bai X, Wang N, Wang X, Chen Q, Xu Q. Inhibition insights of hydrothermal liquid digestate in anaerobic digestion: Impact on organics conversion and inhibitor degradation. J Hazard Mater, 2023, 459.

[79] Shen J, Chen Y, Wu S, Wu H, Liu X, Sun X, Li J, Wang L. Enhanced pyridine biodegradation under anoxic condition: the key role of nitrate as the electron acceptor. Chem Eng J, 2015, 277: 140-149.

[80] Si B, Li J, Zhu Z, Shen M, Lu J, Duan N, Zhang Y, Liao Q, Huang Y, Liu Z. Inhibitors degradation and microbial response during continuous anaerobic conversion of hydrothermal liquefaction wastewater. Sci Total Environ, 2018, 630: 1124-1132.

[81] Si B, Yang L, Zhou X, Watson J, Tommaso G, Chen W-T, Liao Q, Duan N, Liu Z, Zhang Y. Anaerobic conversion of the hydrothermal liquefaction aqueous phase: fate of organics and intensification with granule activated carbon/ozone pretreatment. Green Chem, 2019, 21(6): 1305-1318.

[82] Siegert I, Banks C. The effect of volatile fatty acid additions on the anaerobic digestion of cellulose and glucose in batch reactors. Process Biochem, 2005, 40(11): 3412-3418.

[83] Silva Thomsen LB, Anastasakis K, Biller P. Wet oxidation of aqueous phase from hydrothermal liquefaction of sewage sludge. Water Res, 2022, 209.

[84] Sung S, Liu T. Ammonia inhibition on thermophilic anaerobic digestion. Chemosphere, 2003, 53(1): 43-52.

[85] Tekin K, Karagoz S, Bektas S. A review of hydrothermal biomass processing. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 2014, 40: 673-687.

[86] Tian Y, Wang F, Djandja JO, Zhang S-L, Xu Y-P, Duan P-G. Hydrothermal liquefaction of crop straws: effect of feedstock composition. Fuel, 2020, 265.

[87] Tommaso G, Chen WT, Li P, Schideman L, Zhang Y. Chemical characterization and anaerobic biodegradability of hydrothermal liquefaction aqueous products from mixed-culture wastewater algae. Bioresour Technol, 2015, 178: 139-146.

[88] Usack JG, Angenent LT. Comparing the inhibitory thresholds of dairy manure co-digesters after prolonged acclimation periods: part 1–performance and operating limits. Water Res, 2015, 87: 446-457.

[89] Usack JG, Spirito CM, Angenent LT. Continuously-stirred anaerobic digester to convert organic wastes into biogas: system setup and basic operation. J vis Exp, 2012, 65

[90] Usman M, Hao S, Chen H, Ren S, Tsang D, . Molecular and microbial insights towards understanding the anaerobic digestion of the wastewater from hydrothermal liquefaction of sewage sludge facilitated by granular activated carbon (GAC). Environ Int, 2019, 133: 12.

[91] Usman M, Shi Z, Ren S, Ngo HH, Luo G, Zhang S. Hydrochar promoted anaerobic digestion of hydrothermal liquefaction wastewater: Focusing on the organic degradation and microbial community. Chem Eng J, 2020, 399.

[92] Usman M, Shi Z, Dutta N, Ashraf MA, Ishfaq B, El-Din MG. Current challenges of hydrothermal treated wastewater (HTWW) for environmental applications and their perspectives: a review. Environ Res, 2022, 212.

[93] Villamil JA, Mohedano AF, Rodriguez JJ, de la Rubia MA. Valorisation of the liquid fraction from hydrothermal carbonisation of sewage sludge by anaerobic digestion. J Chem Technol Biotechnol, 2018, 93(2): 450-456.

[94] Wang Y, Zhang Y, Wang J, Meng L. Effects of volatile fatty acid concentrations on methane yield and methanogenic bacteria. Biomass Bioenergy, 2009, 33: 848-853.

[95] Wang X, Sheng L, Yang X. Pyrolysis characteristics and pathways of protein, lipid and carbohydrate isolated from microalgae Nannochloropsis sp. Biores Technol, 2017, 229: 119-125.

[96] Wang T, Zhai Y, Zhu Y, Peng C, Xu B, Wang T, Li C, Zeng G. Influence of temperature on nitrogen fate during hydrothermal carbonization of food waste. Bioresour Technol, 2018, 247: 182-189.

[97] Wang F, Yi W, Zhang D, Liu Y, Shen X, Li Y. Anaerobic co-digestion of corn stover and wastewater from hydrothermal carbonation. Bioresour Technol, 2020, 315.

[98] Wang P, Sakhno Y, Adhikari S, Peng H, Jaisi D, Soneye T, Higgins B, Wang Q. Effect of ammonia removal and biochar detoxification on anaerobic digestion of aqueous phase from municipal sludge hydrothermal liquefaction. Bioresour Technol, 2021, 326.

[99] Watson J, Wang T, Si B, Chen W-T, Aierzhati A, Zhang Y. Valorization of hydrothermal liquefaction aqueous phase: pathways towards commercial viability. Prog Energy Combust Sci, 2020, 77.

[100] Wen C, Moreira CM, Rehmann L, Berruti F. Feasibility of anaerobic digestion as a treatment for the aqueous pyrolysis condensate (APC) of birch bark. Bioresour Technol, 2020, 307.

[101] Wilson CA, Novak JT. Hydrolysis of macromolecular components of primary and secondary wastewater sludge by thermal hydrolytic pretreatment. Water Res, 2009, 43(18): 4489-4498.

[102] Wirth B, Mumme J. Anaerobic digestion of waste water from hydrothermal carbonization of corn silage. Appl Bioenergy, 2013, 1(1): 1-10.

[103] Wirth B, Reza T, Mumme J. Influence of digestion temperature and organic loading rate on the continuous anaerobic treatment of process liquor from hydrothermal carbonization of sewage sludge. Bioresour Technol, 2015, 198: 215-222.

[104] Xiang C, Tian D, Hu J, Huang M, Shen F, Zhang Y, Yang G, Zeng Y, Deng S. Why can hydrothermally pretreating lignocellulose in low severities improve anaerobic digestion performances?. Sci Total Environ, 2021, 752.

[105] Yang L, Huang Y, Zhao M, Huang Z, Miao H, Xu Z, Ruan W. Enhancing biogas generation performance from food wastes by high-solids thermophilic anaerobic digestion: effect of pH adjustment. Int Biodeterior Biodegrad, 2015, 105: 153-159.

[106] Yang L, Si B, Martins MA, Watson J, Chu H, Zhang Y, Tan X, Zhou X, Zhang Y. Improve the biodegradability of post-hydrothermal liquefaction wastewater with ozone: conversion of phenols and N-heterocyclic compounds. Water Sci Technol, 2017, 1: 248-255.

[107] Yang L, Si B, Tan X, Chu H, Zhou X, Zhang Y, Zhang Y, Zhao F. Integrated anaerobic digestion and algae cultivation for energy recovery and nutrient supply from post-hydrothermal liquefaction wastewater. Bioresour Technol, 2018, 266: 349-356.

[108] Yang H, Si B, Huang S, Wu H, Liu Z. Efficient anaerobic digestion of hydrothermal carbonization wastewater via an innovative multistage anaerobic hythane reactor (MAHR): organic conversion and microbial evolution. J Environ Chem Eng, 2023, 11(3): 110179.

[109] Yu G, Zhang Y, Schideman L, Funk T, Wang Z. Distributions of carbon and nitrogen in the products from hydrothermal liquefaction of low-lipid microalgae. Energy Environ Sci, 2011, 4(11): 4587-4595.

[110] Yu X, Zhang C, Qiu L, Yao Y, Sun G, Guo X. Anaerobic digestion of swine manure using aqueous pyrolysis liquid as an additive. Renewable Energy, 2020, 147: 2484-2493.

[111] Yuan Z, He C, Shi Q, Xu C, Li Z, Wang C, Zhao H, Ni J. Molecular insights into the transformation of dissolved organic matter in landfill leachate concentrate during biodegradation and coagulation processes using ESI FT-ICR MS. Environ Sci Technol, 2017, 51(14): 8110-8118.

[112] Zheng M, Schideman LC, Tommaso G, Chen W-T, Zhou Y, Nair K, Qian W, Zhang Y, Wang K. Anaerobic digestion of wastewater generated from the hydrothermal liquefaction of Spirulina: Toxicity assessment and minimization. Energy Convers Manage, 2017, 141: 420-428.

[113] Zhou Y, Schideman L, Zheng M, Martin-Ryals A, Li P, Tommaso G, Zhang Y. Anaerobic digestion of post-hydrothermal liquefaction wastewater for improved energy efficiency of hydrothermal bioenergy processes. Water Sci Technol, 2015, 72(12): 2139-2147.

[114] Zhu K, Liu Q, Dang C, Li A, Zhang L. Valorization of hydrothermal carbonization products by anaerobic digestion: Inhibitor identification, biomethanization potential and process intensification. Bioresour Technol, 2021, 341.

Funding

German-Israeli Foundation for Scientific Research and Development(I-1547-500.15/2021)

Alexander von Humboldt Professorship

China Scholarship Council(202006310033)

University of Georgia - Agricultural Experiment Station