Scaling-up production of plant endophytes in bioreactors: concepts, challenges and perspectives

Abstract

The benefit of microorganisms to humans, animals, insects and plants is increasingly recognized, with intensified microbial endophytes research indicative of this realization. In the agriculture industry, the benefits are tremendous to move towards sustainable crop production and minimize or circumvent the use of chemical fertilizers and pesticides. The research leading to the identification of potential plant endophytes is long and arduous and for many researchers the challenge is ultimately in scale-up production. While many of the larger agriculture and food industries have their own scale-up and manufacturing facilities, for many in academia and start-up companies the next steps towards production have been a stumbling block due to lack of information and understanding of the processes involved in scale-up fermentation. This review provides an overview of the fermentation process from shake flask cultures to scale-up and the manufacturing steps involved such as process development optimization (PDO), process hazard analysis (PHA), pre-, in- and post-production (PIP) challenges and finally the preparation of a technology transfer package (TTP) to transition the PDO to manufacturing. The focus is on submerged liquid fermentation (SLF) and plant endophytes production by providing original examples of fungal and bacterial endophytes, plant growth promoting Penicillium sp. and Streptomyces sp. bioinoculants, respectively. We also discuss the concepts, challenges and future perspectives of the scale-up microbial endophyte process technology based on the industrial and biosafety research platform for advancing a massive production of next-generation biologicals in bioreactors.

Keywords

Plant endophytes / Scale-up fermentation / Bioreactors / Process development optimization

References

[1] Abhilash PC, Dubey RK, Tripathi V, Gupta VK, Singh HB. Plant growth-promoting microorganisms for environmental sustainability. Trends Biotechnol, 2016, 34(11): 847-850.

[2] Atlas RM, Dando M. The dual-use dilemma for the life sciences: perspectives, conundrums, and global solutions. Biosecur Bioterror, 2006, 4(3): 276-286.

[3] Bashan Y, de-Bashan LE, Prabhu SR, Hernandez J-P. Advances in plant growth-promoting bacterial inoculant technology: formulations and practical perspectives (1998–2013). Plant Soil, 2014, 378(1): 1-33.

[4] Behera BK, Varma A. Microbial biomass process technologies and management, 2017, Cham: Springer

[5] Berg G, Rybakova D, Grube M, Köberl M. The plant microbiome explored: implications for experimental botany. J Exp Bot, 2015, 67(4): 995-1002.

[6] Berg G, Rybakova D, Fischer D, . Microbiome definition re-visited: old concepts and new challenges. Microbiome, 2020, 8: 103.

[7] Burke F (2008) Practical fermentation technology. In: McNeil B, Harvey LM (eds) Wiley, West Sussex, pp 231–269

[8] Cameron I, Mannan S, Nemeth E, Park S, Pasman H, Rogers W, Seligmann B. Process hazard analysis, hazard identification and scenario definition: are the conventional tools sufficient, or should and can we do much better?. Process Saf Environ Prot, 2017, 110: 53-70.

[9] Cao Y, Fanning S, Proos S, Jordan K, Srikumar S. A review on the applications of next generation sequencing technologies as applied to food-related microbiome studies. Front Microbiol, 2017, 8: 1829.

[10] Chartrain M, Chu L. Development and production of commercial therapeutic monoclonal antibodies in mammalian cell expression systems: an overview of the current upstream technologies. Curr Pharm Biotechnol, 2008, 9(6): 447-467.

[11] Chastain JW, Delanoy P, Devlin C, Mueller T Study K. Beyond HAZOP and LOPA: four different company approaches. Process Saf Prog, 2017, 36(1): 38-53.

[12] Chitnis VR, Suryanarayanan TS, Nataraja KN, Prasad SR, Oelmüller R, Shaanker RU. Fungal endophyte-mediated crop improvement: the way ahead. Front Plant Sci, 2020, 11: 561007.

[13] Crater JS, Lievense JC. Scale-up of industrial microbial processes. FEMS Microbiol Lett, 2018, 365(13): fny138.

[14] Elsallamet MEA, EL-Moslamy SH, El-Al AA, Zahran HF. Scaling-up production of cost-effective and eco-friendly bio-fertilizer and its application on Barley green fodder via IoT hydroponic system. J Genet Eng Biotechnol, 2021, 19: 97.

[15] Fadiji AE, Babalola OO. Elucidating mechanisms of endophytes used in plant protection and other bioactivities with multifunctional prospects. Front Bioeng Biotechnol, 2020, 8: 467.

[16] FAO. The state of the world’s land and water resources for food and agriculture—managing systems at risk, 2011, Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.

[17] FAO. The future of food and agriculture—trends and challenges, 2017, Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.

[18] FAO. World Food Agriculture—statistical pocketbook 2018, 2018, Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.

[19] Gerson DF, Himes V, Hopfer R, Khandke L, Kohn F, Komotar A, Krumm P, Machulski J, Weisser A, Sciotto-Brown S. Transfer of processes from development to manufacturing. Drug Inf J, 1998, 32(1): 19-26.

[20] González-Menéndez V, Crespo G, Toro C, Martín J, de Pedro N, Tormo JR, Genilloud O. Extending the metabolite diversity of the endophyte Dimorphosporicola tragani. Metabolites, 2019, 9(10): 197.

[21] Harvey LM, McNeil B (2008) Practical fermentation technology. In: McNeil B, Harvey LM (eds) Wiley, West Sussex, pp 97–123

[22] Hayward A (2008) Practical fermentation technology. In: McNeil B, Harvey LM (eds) Wiley, West Sussex, pp 271–288

[23] Johnston-Monje D, Raizada MN. Comprehensive biotechnology, 2011, Burlington: Academic, 713-727.

[24] Jones KA, Burges HD (1998) Formulation of microbial biopesticides: beneficial microorganisms, nematodes and seed treatments. In: Burges HD (ed) Springer, Netherlands, pp 7–30

[25] Junker BH. Scale-up methodologies for Escherichia coli and yeast fermentation processes. J Biosci Bioeng, 2004, 97(6): 347-364.

[26] Kakes E (2008) Practical fermentation technology. In: McNeil B, Harvey LM (eds) Wiley, West Sussex, pp 289–322

[27] Kennedy M, Krouse D. Strategies for improving fermentation medium performance: a review. J Ind Microbiol Biotechnol, 1999, 23(6): 456-475.

[28] Keswani C, Prakash O, Bharti N, Vílchez JI, Sansinenea E, Lally RD, Borriss R, Singh SP, Gupta VK, Fraceto LF, de Lima R, Singh HB. Re-addressing the biosafety issues of plant growth promoting rhizobacteria. Sci Total Environ, 2019, 690: 841-852.

[29] Kotsanopoulos KV, Arvanitoyannis IS. The role of auditing, food safety, and food quality standards in the food industry: a review. Compr Rev Food Sci Food Saf, 2017, 16(5): 760-775.

[30] Kumar V, Sahai V, Bisaria VS. High-density spore production of Piriformosporaindica, a plant growth-promoting endophyte, by optimization of nutritional and cultural parameters. Bioresour Technol, 2011, 102(3): 3169-3175.

[31] Kumari V, Germida J, Vujanovic V. Legume endosymbionts: drought stress tolerance in second-generation chickpea (Cicerarietinum) seeds. J Agron Crop Sci, 2018, 204(6): 529-540.

[32] Li G-X, Wu X-Q, Ye J-R. Biosafety and colonization of Burkholderia multivorans WS-FJ9 and its growth-promoting effects on poplars. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 2013, 97(24): 10489-10498.

[33] Mandenius C-F, Brundin A. Bioprocess optimization using design-of-experiments methodology. Biotechnol Prog, 2008, 24(6): 1191-1203.

[34] Matthews G (2008) Practical fermentation technology. In: McNeil B, Harvey LM (eds) Wiley, West Sussex, pp 3–36

[35] Mitter EK, Tosi M, Obregón D, Dunfield KE, Germida JJ. Rethinking crop nutrition in times of modern microbiology: innovative biofertilizer technologies. Front Sustain Food Syst, 2021, 5: 606815.

[36] Monteiro SM, Clemente JJ, Henriques AO, Gomes RJ, Carrondo MJ, Cunha AE. A procedure for high-yield spore production by Bacillus subtilis. Biotechnol Prog, 2005, 21(4): 1026-1031.

[37] Murphy BR, Doohan F, Hodkinson T. A seed dressing combining fungal endophyte spores and fungicides improves seedling survival and early growth in barley and oat. Symbiosis, 2016, 71: 69-76.

[38] Murphy BR, Hodkinson TR, Doohan FM. A fungal endophyte consortium counterbalances the negative effects of reduced nitrogen input on the yield of field-grown spring barley. J Agric Sci, 2017, 155(8): 1324-1331.

[39] Murphy BR, Doohan FM, Hodkinson TR. From concept to commerce: developing a successful fungal endophyte inoculant for agricultural crops. J Fungi, 2018, 4(1): 24.

[40] Nicolaidou V, Nicolaou P, Nicolaou SA. Transforming a cookbook undergraduate microbiology laboratory to inquiry based using a semester-long PBL case study. Adv Physiol Educ, 2019, 43(1): 82-92.

[41] Nolan DP. Application of HAZOP and what-if safety reviews to the petroleum, petrochemical and chemical industries, 1994, New Jersey: Noyes Publications.

[42] NSABB. Proposed framework for the oversight of dual use life sciences research: strategies for minimizing the potential misuse of research information, 2007, New York: National Science Advisory Board for Biosecurity, 62.

[43] O’Callaghan M. Microbial inoculation of seed for improved crop performance: issues and opportunities. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 2016, 100(13): 5729-5746.

[44] Orozco-Mosqueda MdC, Santoyo G. Plant-microbial endophytes interactions: scrutinizing their beneficial mechanisms from genomic explorations. Curr Plant Biol, 2021, 25: 100189.

[45] Panghal A, Chhikara N, Sindhu N, Jaglan S. Role of Food Safety Management Systems in safe food production: a review. J Food Saf, 2018, 38(4): e12464.

[46] Parnell JJ, Berka R, Young HA, Sturino JM, Kang Y, Barnhart DM, DiLeo MV. From the lab to the farm: an industrial perspective of plant beneficial microorganisms. Front Plant Sci, 2016, 7: 1110.

[47] Pham JV, Yilma MA, Feliz A, Majid MT, Maffetone N, Walker JR, Kim E, Cho HJ, Reynolds JM, Song MC, Park SR, Yoon YJ. A review of the microbial production of bioactive natural products and biologics. Front Microbiol, 2019, 10: 1404.

[48] Pylak M, Oszust K, Frąc M. Review report on the role of bioproducts, biopreparations, biostimulants and microbial inoculants in organic production of fruit. Rev Environ Sci Biotechnol, 2019, 18(3): 597-616.

[49] Rana KL, Kour D, Kaur T, Devi R, Yadav AY, Yadav Y, Dwaliwal SH, Saxena AK. Endophytic microbes: biodiversity, plant growth-promoting mechanisms and potential applications for agricultural sustainability. Antonie Van Leeuwenhoek, 2020, 113: 1075-1107.

[50] Reinhold-Hurek B, Hurek T. Living inside plants: bacterial endophytes. Curr Opin Plant Biol, 2011, 14(4): 435-443.

[51] Reisman H. Economic analysis of fermentation processes, 1988, Boca Raton: CRC Press.

[52] Resnik DB (2010) Can scientists regulate the publication of dual use research?

[53] Robl D, da Silva Delabona P, Mergel CM, Rojas JD, . The capability of endophytic fungi for production of hemicellulases and related enzymes. BMC Biotechnol, 2020, 13: 94.

[54] Rogers EM. The nature of technology transfer. Sci Commun, 2002, 23(3): 323-341.

[55] Rouphael Y, Colla G. Toward a sustainable agriculture through plant biostimulants: from experimental data to practical applications. Agronomy, 2020, 10(10): 1461.

[56] Running JA, Bansal K. Oxygen transfer rates in shaken culture vessels from Fernbach flasks to microtiter plates. Biotechnol Bioeng, 2016, 113(8): 1729-1735.

[57] Santos MS, Nogueira MA, Hungria M. Microbial inoculants: reviewing the past, discussing the present and previewing an outstanding future for the use of beneficial bacteria in agriculture. AMB Expr, 2019, 9: 205.

[58] Shen HD, Lin WL, Tam MF, Wang SR, Tzean SS, Huang MH, Han SH. Characterization of allergens from Penicillium oxalicum and P. notatum by immunoblotting and N-terminal amino acid sequence analysis. Clin Exp Allergy, 1999, 29(5): 642-651.

[59] Shen H-D, Tam MF, Tang R-B, Chou H. Aspergillus and Penicillium allergens: focus on proteases. Curr Allergy Asthma Rep, 2007, 7(5): 351-356.

[60] Singh V, Haque S, Niwas R, Srivastava A, Pasupuleti M, Tripathi CKM. Strategies for fermentation medium optimization: an in-depth review. Front Microbiol, 2017, 7: 2087.

[61] Singh P, Garg A, Pandit S, Mokkapati VRSS, Mijakovic I. Antimicrobial effects of biogenic nanoparticles. Nanomaterials (basel, Switzerland), 2018, 8(12): 1009.

[62] Soccol CR, Costa ESFd, Letti LAJ, Karp SG, Woiciechowski AL, Vandenberghe LPdS. Recent developments and innovations in solid state fermentation. Biotechnol Res Innov, 2017, 1(1): 52-71.

[63] Stanbury PF, Whitaker A, Hall SJ (1995) Principles of fermentation technology (2nd edn). In: Stanbury PF, Whitaker A, Hall SJ (eds) Pergamon, Amsterdam, pp 35–91

[64] Strobel G. The emergence of endophytic microbes and their biological promise. J Fungi (basel), 2018, 4(2): 57.

[65] Takahashi M, Aoyagi H. Practices of shake-flask culture and advances in monitoring CO2 and O2. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 2018, 102(10): 4279-4289.

[66] Tatsumura K, Yamasaki M, Goto H. Scaling out Ising machines using a multi-chip architecture for simulated bifurcation. Nat Electron, 2021, 4(3): 208-217.

[67] Turner TR, James EK, Poole PS. The plant microbiome. Genome Biol, 2013, 14(6): 209.

[68] Ude C, Hentrop T, Lindner P, Lücking TH, Scheper T, Beutel S. New perspectives in shake flask pH control using a 3D-printed control unit based on pH online measurement. Sens Actuators B Chem, 2015, 221: 1035-1043.

[69] Venugopalan A, Potunuru UR, Dixit M, Srivastava S. Effect of fermentation parameters, elicitors and precursors on camptothecin production from the endophyte Fusariumsolani. Bioresour Technol, 2016, 206: 104-111.

[70] Vílchez JI, Navas A, González-López J, Arcos SC, Manzanera M. Biosafety test for plant growth-promoting bacteria: proposed environmental and human safety index (EHSI) protocol. Front Microbiol, 2016, 6: 1514-1514.

[71] Vujanovic V, Germida JJ (2014) Endophytic microbial symbionts in plant prenatal care. In: Organization, W.I.P. (ed) Canada, p 154

[72] Vujanovic V, Germida JJ. Seed endosymbiosis: a vital relationship in providing prenatal care to plants. Can J Plant Sci, 2017, 97(6): 972-981.

[73] Vujanovic V, Kim SH, Lahlali R, Karunakaran C. Spectroscopy and SEM imaging reveal endosymbiont-dependent components changes in germinating kernel through direct and indirect coleorhiza-fungus interactions under stress. Sci Rep, 2019, 9(1): 1665.

[74] Weuster-Botz D, Altenbach-Rehm J, Arnold M. Parallel substrate feeding and pH-control in shaking-flasks. Biochem Eng J, 2001, 7(2): 163-170.

[75] WHO. Laboratory biosafety manual, 2004, Geneva: World Health Organization, 186.

[76] Willaert RG. Yeast biotechnology 4.0. Fermentation, 2021, 7: 69.

[77] Zhang J, Greasham R. Chemically defined media for commercial fermentations. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 1999, 51(4): 407-421.

Funding

Canadian Network for Research and Innovation in Machining Technology, Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada(RGPIN-2017-05286)