Artificial intelligence-based tools for optimizing surgical research publications

Abstract

To evaluate artificial intelligence (AI)-powered tools for optimizing surgical research workflows and establish an evidence-based framework for appropriate AI technology selection throughout the research pipeline. We conducted a structured, qualitative narrative appraisal of 43 AI-powered tools (October 2024-March 2025), categorizing them across five functional domains: (1) scientific search engines, (2) document interaction systems, (3) literature analysis tools, (4) writing assistants, and (5) graphic design and reference management solutions. Our assessment framework evaluated key functionalities, costs, technical capabilities, and practical limitations through comprehensive documentation analysis, operational testing, and a systematic review of demonstration materials. All assessments reflect tool versions accessed between October 2024 and March 2025, acknowledging the rapidly evolving nature of this ecosystem. AI technologies primarily enhanced efficiency in literature discovery, content synthesis, and manuscript preparation while maintaining methodological rigor. The 43 evaluated tools demonstrated significant capabilities in processing scientific information, with each category offering distinct advantages for specific research tasks. Findings indicate substantial time reduction in literature searches, document analysis, and manuscript preparation when properly integrated into research workflows. AI-powered tools demonstrate transformative potential for optimizing surgical research processes, providing significant efficiencies from initial literature search to final publication. Successful implementation requires maintaining a critical balance between technological innovation and fundamental scientific principles, with essential human oversight to prevent overreliance on automation that could compromise critical thinking and analytical skills.

Keywords

Artificial intelligence and surgery / large language models / surgical research / research tools / scientific writing / research methodology / research efficiency / evidence-based medicine

References

[1] Meng X,Zhang K.The application of large language models in medicine: a scoping review.iScience2024;27:109713 PMCID:PMC11091685

[2] Perlis RH.Evaluating the application of large language models in clinical research contexts.JAMA Netw Open2023;6:e2335924

[3] Kothari AN,Melton GB.Practical guide to the use of AI-enabled analytics in research.JAMA Surg2025;160:590-1

[4] Loftus TJ,Upchurch GR Jr.Practical guide to artificial intelligence, chatbots, and large language models in conducting and reporting research.JAMA Surg2025;160:588-9

[5] Jhajj KS,Kaur K.Use of artificial intelligence tools for research by medical students: a narrative review.Cureus2024;16:e55367 PMCID:PMC10982680

[6] Guo E,Deng J,Paget M.Automated paper screening for clinical reviews using large language models: data analysis study.J Med Internet Res2024;26:e48996 PMCID:PMC10818236

[7] Wang Z,Danek B,Lu Z.Accelerating clinical evidence synthesis with large language models.NPJ Digit Med2025;8:509 PMCID:PMC12331930

[8] Singhal K,Gottweis J.Toward expert-level medical question answering with large language models.Nat Med2025;31:943-50 PMCID:PMC11922739

[9] Fabiano N,Bhambra N.How to optimize the systematic review process using AI tools.JCPP Adv2024;4:e12234 PMCID:PMC11143948

[10] Hashimoto DA,Schwartz TA.Practical guide to machine learning and artificial intelligence in surgical education research.JAMA Surg2024;159:455-6

[11] Nerella S,Zhang J.Transformers and large language models in healthcare: a review.Artif Intell Med2024;154:102900 PMCID:PMC11638972

[12] Pressman SM,Gomez-Cabello CA,Haider CR.Clinical and surgical applications of large language models: a systematic review.J Clin Med2024;13:3041 PMCID:PMC11172607

[13] Bedi S,Orr-Ewing L.Testing and evaluation of health care applications of large language models: a systematic review.JAMA2025;333:319-28 PMCID:PMC11480901

[14] Yang X,Su Q.Application of large language models in disease diagnosis and treatment.Chin Med J2025;138:130-42 PMCID:PMC11745858

[15] Zhang J,Jagadeesh A.The potential and pitfalls of using a large language model such as ChatGPT, GPT-4, or LLaMA as a clinical assistant.J Am Med Inform Assoc2024;31:1884-91 PMCID:PMC11339517

[16] Belmar F,Escalona G.Artificial intelligence in laparoscopic simulation: a promising future for large-scale automated evaluations.Surg Endosc2023;37:4942-6 PMCID:PMC9529161

[17] Bhuyan SS,Mukul N.Generative artificial intelligence use in healthcare: opportunities for clinical excellence and administrative efficiency.J Med Syst2025;49:10 PMCID:PMC11739231

[18] Tu T,Palepu A.Towards conversational diagnostic artificial intelligence.Nature2025;642:442-50 PMCID:PMC12158756

[19] Consensus.app. Available from https://consensus.app/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[20] Elicit.com. Available from https://www.elicit.com [accessed 14 January 2026].

[21] EvidenceHunt. Available from https://evidencehunt.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[22] Manus: the action engine for research. Available from https://manus.im/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[23] OpenRead. Available from https://www.openread.academy/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[24] Perplexity AI. Available from https://www.perplexity.ai/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[25] Scinapse. Finding R&D Trends and Experts Made Simple. Available from https://www.scinapse.io/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[26] Discover, Create, and Publish your research paper. Scispace. Available from https://scispace.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[27] AI for Research. scite.ai. Available from https://scite.ai/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[28] You.com. AI for workplace productivity. Available from https://you.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[29] AskYourPDF. AskYourPDF: The best PDF AI chat app. Available from https://askyourpdf.com/es [accessed 14 January 2026].

[30] Chatea con cualquier PDF. Available from https://www.chatpdf.com/es [accessed 14 January 2026].

[31] Humata. Humata: AI for your files. Available from https://www.humata.ai/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[32] Myreader. Myreader - Let an AI read books, documents, papers for you. Available from https://www.myreader.ai/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[33] Google NotebookLM. Available from https://notebooklm.google/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[34] Scholarcy - Knowledge made simple. Available from https://www.scholarcy.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[35] Anara. anara.com. Available from https://anara.com/?from=unriddle [accessed 14 January 2026].

[36] Connected Papers. Available from https://www.connectedpapers.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[37] Inciteful. Available from https://inciteful.xyz/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[38] Litmaps. Available from https://www.litmaps.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[39] ResearchRabbit. Available from https://www.researchrabbitapp.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[40] Asistente de Escritura AI. Available from https://aithor.com/es-419 [accessed 14 January 2026].

[41] Caktus AI. Available from https://caktus.ai/login?callbackUrl=https%3A%2F%2Fcaktus.ai%2F [accessed 14 January 2026].

[42] ChatGPT. Available from https://chat.openai.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[43] Claude. Available from https://claude.ai/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[44] Cohere. Available from https://dashboard.cohere.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[45] DeepSeek. Available from https://chat.deepseek.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[46] ‎Gemini. Available from https://gemini.google.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[47] Grok. Available from https://x.ai/grok [accessed 14 January 2026].

[48] Jenni AI. Available from https://jenni.ai [accessed 14 January 2026].

[49] Meta AI. Meta AI. Available from https://www.meta.ai/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[50] Mistral AI. Available from https://mistral.ai/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[51] Paperpal. AI Academic Writing Tool - Online English Language Check. Available from https://paperpal.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[52] QuillBot: your complete writing solution. Available from https://quillbot.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[53] Sudowrite - best AI writing partner for fiction. Available from https://sudowrite.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[54] Qwen Chat. Available from https://chat.qwen.ai/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[55] Yomu AI. Available from https://www.yomu.ai/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[56] EndNote. EndNote - the best citation & reference management tool. Available from http://www.endnote.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[57] Map This. Available from https://www.map-this.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[58] Napkin AI. Napkin AI - the visual AI for business storytelling. Available from https://www.napkin.ai/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[59] Paperpile. Available from http://www.paperpile.com/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[60] Zotero. Available from https://www.zotero.org/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[61] Visily. Visily - AI-powered UI design software. Available from https://www.visily.ai/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[62] COPE Council. Authorship and AI tools. Committee on Publication Ethics.2024.

[63] World Association of Medical Editors. Chatbots, generative AI, and scholarly manuscripts. Available from https://wame.org/page3.php?id=106 [accessed 14 January 2026].

[64] International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Recommendations. Available from https://www.icmje.org/recommendations/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[65] Flanagin A,Khera R,Hswen Y.Reporting Use of AI in Research and Scholarly Publication-JAMA Network Guidance.JAMA2024;331:1096-8

[66] Adapting to AI.Nat Geosci2024;17:481

[67] Elsevier. Generative AI policies for journals. Available from: https://www.elsevier.com/about/policies-and-standards/generative-ai-policies-for-journals?utm_source=chatgpt.com [accessed 14 January 2026].

[68] Adam GP,George J. Machine learning tools to (semi-) automate evidence synthesis. Rockville: agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ); 2024. Available from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK614977/ [accessed 14 January 2026].

[69] Dennstädt F,Putora PM,Cihoric N.Implementing large language models in healthcare while balancing control, collaboration, costs and security.NPJ Digit Med2025;8:143 PMCID:PMC11885444

[70] Trad F, Yammine R, Charafeddine J, et al. Streamlining systematic reviews: a novel application of Large Language Models. arXiv 2024;arXiv:2412.15247. Available from https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.15247 [accessed 14 January 2026].

[71] Alaniz L,Pfaff MJ.The utility of artificial intelligence for systematic reviews and boolean query formulation and translation.Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open2023;11:e5339 PMCID:PMC10615538

[72] Alber DA,Alyakin A.Medical large language models are vulnerable to data-poisoning attacks.Nat Med2025;31:618-26 PMCID:PMC11835729

[73] Tam TYC,Kapoor S.A framework for human evaluation of large language models in healthcare derived from literature review.NPJ Digit Med2024;7:258 PMCID:PMC11437138

[74] Feng Y,Zhang Y.Automated medical literature screening using artificial intelligence: a systematic review and meta-analysis.J Am Med Inform Assoc2022;29:1425-32 PMCID:PMC9277646

[75] Yip R,Bassuk AG.Artificial intelligence’s contribution to biomedical literature search: revolutionizing or complicating?.PLOS Digit Health2025;4:e0000849 PMCID:PMC12068611

[76] Esposito C,Di Ianni D.Human vs. ChatGPT. Is it possible obtain comparable results in the analysis of a scientific systematic review?.Recenti Prog Med2024;115:420-5

[77] Tercero-Hidalgo JR,Bueno-Cavanillas A.Artificial intelligence in COVID-19 evidence syntheses was underutilized, but impactful: a methodological study.J Clin Epidemiol2022;148:124-34 PMCID:PMC9059390

[78] Raja H,Mylonas N.Automated category and trend analysis of scientific articles on ophthalmology using large language models: development and usability study.JMIR Form Res2024;8:e52462 PMCID:PMC10998173

[79] Fisher R,Williams J.Can ChatGPT enhance business student creativity?.Stud High Educ2025:1-15

[80] Kosmyna N, Hauptmann E, Yuan YT, et al. Your brain on ChatGPT: accumulation of cognitive debt when using an AI assistant for essay writing task. arXiv 2025;arXiv:2506.08872. Available from https://newsletter.lesderniershommes.com/content/files/2025/06/2025-MIT---Brain-debt-ChatGPT_compressed.pdf [accessed 13 October 2025].

[81] Wang J.The effect of ChatGPT on students’ learning performance, learning perception, and higher-order thinking: insights from a meta-analysis.Humanit Soc Sci Commun2025;12:4787