Mentorship and early career mentorship

Abstract

Mentorship is important for the personal and professional development of a surgeon. Surgical mentoring includes technical and non-technical skills necessary for clinical activities, career improvement, leadership acquisition and research development. Mentors are important in different phases of surgical career, conferring various forms of support. The most delicate period for a surgeon is the transition between the role of trainee and physician, and the first few years are crucial to the trajectory of future career. While in the past, the main limitation for mentorship opportunities was the lack of available mentors at a single institution, more recently, long-distance mentorship opportunities have overcome this barrier. This is of particular importance for women and underrepresented minorities in surgery, who benefit the most from same gender and same ethnicity role model. Furthermore, having the opportunity to establish productive relationships with mentors from other institutions and/or countries will prevent the possibility of leading to dependence between mentee and mentor within a single institution. This review aims to investigate different forms of mentorships, with a specific interest in early career support, long-distance mentorship and opportunities for underrepresented minorities in surgery.

Keywords

Mentorship / early career mentorship / telementoring / long-distance mentoring

References

[1] Gough I.Mentoring: historical origins and contemporary value.ANZ J Surg2008;78:831

[2] Clutterbuck D.Everyone needs a mentor, 4th ed. London: Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development; 2004.

[3] Patel VM,Ahmed K.How can we build mentorship in surgeons of the future?.ANZ J Surg2011;81:418-24

[4] Kibbe MR,Townsend CM Jr,Patti MG.Characterization of mentorship programs in departments of surgery in the united states.JAMA Surg2016;151:900-6

[5] DeCastro R,Ubel PA,Jagsi R.Mentoring and the career satisfaction of male and female academic medical faculty.Acad Med2014;89:301-11 PMCID:PMC4341994

[6] Straus SE,Marquez C.Characteristics of successful and failed mentoring relationships: a qualitative study across two academic health centers.Acad Med2013;88:82-9 PMCID:PMC3665769

[7] Stephens EH.On becoming a master surgeon: role models, mentorship, coaching, and apprenticeship.Ann Thorac Surg2021;111:1746-53

[8] Odell DD,Fuller S,Antonoff MB.Society of Thoracic Surgeons Workforce on Career DevelopmentThe art and science of mentorship in cardiothoracic surgery: a systematic review of the literature.Ann Thorac Surg2022;113:1093-100

[9] Moreno NA,Newman EA.Mentorship strategies to foster inclusivity in surgery during a virtual era.Am J Surg2020;220:1536-8 PMCID:PMC7358155

[10] Myers SP,Hill KA.Perceptions regarding mentorship among general surgery trainees with academic career intentions.J Surg Educ2019;76:916-23

[11] Myers PL,Ramanadham SR.Mentorship in plastic surgery: a critical appraisal of where we stand and what we can do better.Plast Reconstr Surg2021;148:667-77

[12] Nassour I,Boland GM.Committee on Academic Advancement of the Association for Academic SurgerySuccessful mentor-mentee relationship.J Surg Res2020;247:332-4

[13] Sachdeva AK.Preceptoring, proctoring, mentoring, and coaching in surgery.J Surg Oncol2021;124:711-21

[14] Corsini EM,Antonoff MB.Women in thoracic surgery: social media and the value of mentorship.J Thorac Dis2021;13:464-72 PMCID:PMC7867810

[15] Corsini EM,Hughes KA.Global impact of social media on women in surgery.Am Surg2020;86:152-7

[16] Georgi M,Patel S.The impact of same gender speed-mentoring on women’s perceptions of a career in surgery - a prospective cohort study.J Surg Educ2022;79:1166-76

[17] Chopra V,Saint S.Will you be my mentor?.JAMA Intern Med2018;178:175-6

[18] Chopra V.Mindful mentorship.Healthc (Amst)2020;8:100390

[19] Bettis J,Slotcavage RL,Petersen E.What makes them different?.Am J Surg2019;218:767-71

[20] Patel VM,Humphris P.What does leadership in surgery entail?.ANZ J Surg2010;80:876-83

[21] Ramanan RA,Davis RB.Mentoring matters. Mentoring and career preparation in internal medicine residency training.J Gen Intern Med2006;21:340-5 PMCID:PMC1484727

[22] Abernethy AD.A mentoring program for underrepresented-minority students at the University of Rochester School of Medicine.Acad Med1999;74:356-9

[23] Haggins A,Ross PT.Value of near-peer mentorship from protégé and mentor perspectives: a strategy to increase physician workforce diversity.J Natl Med Assoc2018;110:399-406

[24] Mahendran GN,Bennett M.Qualitative study of mentorship for women and minorities in surgery.J Am Coll Surg2022;234:253-61

[25] Neumayer L,Anderson K.Perceptions of women medical students and their influence on career choice.Am J Surg2002;183:146-50

[26] Faucett EA,Milinic T,Roward SG.The role of same-sex mentorship and organizational support in encouraging women to pursue surgery.Am J Surg2017;214:640-4

[27] Bratescu RA,Jones JM.Which subspecialties do female orthopaedic surgeons choose and why?.J Am Acad Orthop Surg Glob Res Rev2020;4:e19 PMCID:PMC7028786

[28] Stephens EH,Fiedler AG.Appraisal of mentorship in cardiothoracic surgery training.J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2018;156:2216-23

[29] Rudnicki PA,Prince NH,May JW Jr.What made them successful: an introspective survey of AAPS members.Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open2015;3:e327 PMCID:PMC4387149

[30] Yorozuya K,Akashi-Tanaka S,Nomura S.Mentorship as experienced by women surgeons in Japan.World J Surg2016;40:38-44

[31] Ehrlich H,Sutherland M.Gender distribution among surgical journals’ editorial boards: empowering women surgeon scientists.Surgery2021;169:1346-51

[32] Picciariello A,Gallo G.Gender distribution in the editorial boards of surgical journals: a snapshot from Western Europe.Surgery2021;170:1292

[33] Luc JGY,Antonoff MB.Social media as a means of networking and mentorship: role for women in cardiothoracic surgery.Semin Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2018;30:487-95

[34] Luc JGY,Antonoff MB.Social media in the mentorship and networking of physicians: important role for women in surgical specialties.Am J Surg2018;215:752-60

[35] Raborn LN.Overcoming the impact of COVID-19 on surgical mentorship: a scoping review of long-distance mentorship in surgery.J Surg Educ2021;78:1948-64 PMCID:PMC8894132

[36] Bilgic E,Watanabe Y.Effectiveness of telementoring in surgery compared with on-site mentoring: a systematic review.Surg Innov2017;24:379-85

[37] Erridge S,Patel HRH.Telementoring of surgeons: a systematic review.Surg Innov2019;26:95-111

[38] Challacombe B.Telementoring and telerobotics in urological surgery.Curr Urol Rep2010;11:22-8

[39] Budrionis A,Hartvigsen G.Assessing the impact of telestration on surgical telementoring: a randomized controlled trial.J Telemed Telecare2016;22:12-7

[40] Rojas-Muñoz E,Lin C.The system for telementoring with augmented reality (STAR): a head-mounted display to improve surgical coaching and confidence in remote areas.Surgery2020;167:724-31

[41] Rojas-Muñoz E,Lin C.Telementoring in leg fasciotomies via mixed-reality: clinical evaluation of the STAR platform.Mil Med2020;185:513-20

[42] Zhang F,Gao J.Coaxial projective imaging system for surgical navigation and telementoring.J Biomed Opt2019;24:1-9 PMCID:PMC7000882

[43] Ladd BM,Gupte A.Feasibility of telementoring for microneurosurgical procedures using a microscope: a proof-of-concept study.World Neurosurg2017;99:680-6

[44] Ereso AQ,Tseng E.Live transference of surgical subspecialty skills using telerobotic proctoring to remote general surgeons.J Am Coll Surg2010;211:400-11

[45] Okrainec A,Azzie G.Telesimulation: an effective method for teaching the fundamentals of laparoscopic surgery in resource-restricted countries.Surg Endosc2010;24:417-22

[46] Kauta NJ,Arnolds D.Whatsapp mobile health platform to support fracture management by non-specialists in South Africa.J Am Coll Surg2020;230:37-42

[47] Bruns NE,Rothenberg SS,Kotobi H.Trans-Atlantic telementoring with pediatric surgeons: technical considerations and lessons learned.J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A2016;26:75-8

[48] Talbot M,Berry GK.Compartment release in austere locations (CORAL) collaboratorsA pilot study of surgical telementoring for leg fasciotomy.J R Army Med Corps2018;164:83-6

[49] Ullrich LA,Bannon J,Oxenberg J.The mentor match: a new approach to implementing formal mentorship in general surgery residency.Am J Surg2020;220:589-92

[50] Available from: https://www.acpgbi.org.uk/about/committees/3/early_years_consultant_network_committee/public [Last accessed on 26 Sep 2022]

[51] Available from: www.mentoring-unipd.it [Last accessed on 26 Sep 2022]