South Asian dairy smallholders: A scoping review of practices and zoonoses

Abstract

Objective: To identify and discuss on-farm management practices linked to bacterial zoonosis risk in smallholder dairy farmers in South Asia. Methods: This scoping review was conducted as per the PRISMA-ScR guidelines. Five hundred and two publications were retrieved from five online databases using a comprehensive search strategy. Studies were selected if they discussed a farm management practice which impacted human health within a South Asian country. Results: Twenty-two studies were included. Seven management practices relevant to farmers, livestock and their shared environment were identified including raw milk consumption, farm hygiene management, personal protective equipment uses, animal vaccination, cleaning udders, hand washing and disposal of afterbirth materials. Preventive practices were found to be utilized at lower frequencies compared to risk increasing practices. Awareness of bacterial zoonoses is particularly low within the region. Conclusions: Based on the results of this review, it was determined that improving farmer awareness of bacterial zoonotic diseases may favor several of the presented leverage points within the South Asian smallholder dairy system. Relying on formal school education to improve this awareness may not solve this problem, instead, more focus on accessible and affordable zoonoses education and farming programs is required.

Keywords

Management practices / Zoonoses / Dairy / Smallholder system

References

[1] Moran J. Smallholder dairy farming in Asia. In: Business management for tropical dairy farmers. Victoria: CSIRO Publishing; 2009, p. 25-42.

[2] Siddiky M. Dairying in South Asian region: Opportunities, challenges and way forward. SAARC J Agri 2017; 15(1):173-187.

[3] Morgan N. Developing an Asian regional strategy for sustainable smallholder dairy development. 2008. [Online]. Available from:https://www.fao.org/3/i0281e/I0281E02.htm. [Accessed on 2 June 2022].

[4] Grace D, Mutua FK, Ochungo P, Kruska RL, Jones K, Brierley L, et al. Mapping of poverty and likely zoonoses hotspots Project 4. Nairobi, Kenya: International Livestock Research Institute; 2012. [Online]. Available from:https://cgspace.cgiar.org/handle/10568/21161. [Accessed on 5 June 2022].

[5] Harvey CA, Rakotobe ZL, Rao NS, Dave R, Razafimahatratra H, Rabarijohn RH, et al. Extreme vulnerability of smallholder farmers to agricultural risks and climate change in Madagascar. Phil Trans R Soc B Biol Sci 2014; 369(1639):20130089.

[6] McDaniel CJ, Cardwell DM, Moeller RB, Gray GC. Humans and cattle: A review of bovine zoonoses. Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis 2014; 14(1):1-19.

[7] Dadar M, Shahali Y, Whatmore AM. Human brucellosis caused by raw dairy products: A review on the occurrence, major risk factors and prevention. Int J Food Microbiol 2019; 292:39-47.

[8] Lucey JA. Raw milk consumption: Risks and benefits. Nutr Today 2015; 50(4):189-193.

[9] Tricco AC, Lillie E, Zarin W, O’Brien KK, Colquhoun H, Levac D, et al. PRISMA extension for scoping reviews (PRISMA-ScR): Checklist and explanation. Ann Intern Med 2018; 169(7):467-473.

[10] Veritas Health Innovation. Covidence. 2022. [Online]. Available from:https://www.covidence.org/. [Accessed on 29 March 2022].

[11] Joanna Briggs Institute. Checklist for analytical cross sectional studies. 2017. [Online]. Available from:https://jbi.global/critical-appraisal-tools. [Accessed on 3 April 2022].

[12] Meadows D. Leverage points: Places to intervene in a system. The Academy for Systems Change. 1999. [Online]. Available from:https://donellameadows.org/archives/leverage-points-places-to-intervene-in-a-system/. [Accessed on 23 August 2023].

[13] Akbarian Z, Ziay G, Schauwers W, Noormal B, Saeed I, Qanee AH, et al. Brucellosis and Coxiella burnetii infection in householders and their animals in secure villages in Herat province, Afghanistan: A cross-sectional study. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2015; 9(10):e0004112.

[14] Ali S, Ali Q, Neubauer H, Melzer F, Elschner M, Khan I, et al. Seroprevalence and risk factors associated with brucellosis as a professional hazard in Pakistan. Foodborne Pathog Dis 2013; 10(6):500-505.

[15] Deka RP, Magnusson U, Grace D, Shome R, Lindahl JF. Knowledge and practices of dairy farmers relating to brucellosis in urban, peri-urban and rural areas of Assam and Bihar, India. Infect Ecol Epidemiol 2020; 10(1):1769531.

[16] Holt HR, Bedi JS, Kaur P, Mangtani P, Sharma NS, Gill JPS, et al. Epidemiology of brucellosis in cattle and dairy farmers of rural Ludhiana, Punjab. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2021; 15(3):e0009102.

[17] Hussain S, Hussain A, Zia UuR, Naqvi SMR, Zahoor MY, Bilal M, et al. Knowledge, attitude, and practices associated with brucellosis among livestock owners and its public health impact in Punjab, Pakistan. Biologia 2021; 76(10):2921-2929.

[18] Mangtani P, Berry I, Beauvais W, Holt HR, Kulashri A, Bharti S, et al. The prevalence and risk factors for human Brucella species infection in a cross-sectional survey of a rural population in Punjab, India. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 2020; 114(4):255-263.

[19] Nawaz Z, Shafique M, Zahoor MA, Siddique AB, Ali S, Arshad R, et al. Sero-epidemiology and risk factor analysis of human brucellosis in Punjab, Pakistan: A cross sectional study. Trop Biomed 2021; 38(3):413-419.

[20] Rahman AKMA, Dirk B, Fretin D, Saegerman C, Ahmed MU, Muhammad N, et al. Seroprevalence and risk factors for brucellosis in a high-risk group of individuals in Bangladesh. Foodborne Pathog Dis 2012; 9(3):190-197.

[21] Rajput MB, Sheikh AS, Parmar DV. Knowledge of zoonotic diseases among dairy farmers of Banaskantha district. Rumin Sci 2015; 4(1):75-80.

[22] Saidu AS, Mahajan NK, Musallam II, Holt HR, Guitian J. Epidemiology of bovine brucellosis in Hisar, India: Identification of risk factors and assessment of knowledge, attitudes, and practices among livestock owners. Trop Anim Health Prod 2021; 53(5):450.

[23] Sikder S, Rahman AKMA, Faruque R, Alim MA, Das S, Gupta A, et al. Pakistan veterinary journal bovine brucellosis: An epidemiological study at Chittagong, Bangladesh. Pak Vet J 2012; 32(4):2074-7764.

[24] Singh BB, Kaur R, Gill GS, Gill JPS, Soni RK, Aulakh RS. Knowledge, attitude and practices relating to zoonotic diseases among livestock farmers in Punjab, India. Acta Trop 2019; 189:15-21.

[25] Yadav N, Aggarwal D. Potential risk factors of brucellosis in dairy farmers of peri-urban areas of South West Delhi. Indian J Community Med 2020; 45(Suppl 1):S12-S15.

[26] Gompo TR, Shrestha A, Ranjit E, Gautam B, Ale K, Shrestha S, et al. Risk factors of tuberculosis in human and its association with cattle TB in Nepal: A one health approach. One Health 2020; 10:100156.

[27] Islam SS, Rumi TB, Kabir SML, Rahman AKMA, Faisal MMH, Islam R, et al. Zoonotic tuberculosis knowledge and practices among cattle handlers in selected districts of Bangladesh. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2021; 15(4):e0009394.

[28] Lakra SB, Aggarwal D. Practices that are potential risks to an increase in zoonotic tuberculosis: A cross-sectional study among cattle holders in peri-urban area of Sonipat. Indian J Community Med 2020; 45(Suppl 1):S35-S37.

[29] Jadav S, Patel J. Consciousness of dairy farmers about leptospirosis disease as a zoonosis. Indian J Dairy Sci 2021; 74(4):356-361.

[30] Ahuja R, Gautam S, Sangwan S, Rajesh. Knowledge level of dairy farmers about prevention of zoonotic diseases. Haryana Vet 2019; 58(2):301-303.

[31] Chinchwadkar P, Panda P. An assessment of knowledge regarding the risk of zoonoses and hygiene practices among females with livestock in South-West Delhi, India: A cross-sectional study. Indian J Community Med 2020; 45(Suppl 1):S38-S42.

[32] Patel K, Saxena D. Self-reported selected zoonotic diseases among animal handlers in Urban Ahmedabad, India. Vet World 2019; 12(1):176-182.

[33] Singh S, Kar S, Mishra A, Pattnaik D. Hygiene practices and awareness regarding milk borne diseases (MBD) among dairy workers in unorganized urban settings of Bhubaneswar, Odisha, India. Indian J Community Health 2021; 33(3):466-474.

[34] Singh A, Ramachandran A. Assessment of hygienic milking practices and prevalence of bovine mastitis in small dairy farms of peri-urban area of Jaipur. Indian J Community Med 2020; 45(Suppl 1):S21-S25.

[35] Brooks-Pollock E, de Jong MCM, Keeling MJ, Klinkenberg D, Wood JLN. Eight challenges in modelling infectious livestock diseases. Epidemics 2015; 10:1-5.

[36] Tomley FM, Shirley MW. Livestock infectious diseases and zoonoses. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 2009; 364(1530):2637-2642.

[37] Musallam II, Abo-Shehada MN, Guitian J. Knowledge, attitudes, and practices associated with brucellosis in livestock owners in Jordan. Am J Trop Med Hyg 2015; 93(6):1148-1155.

[38] Campbell Z, Coleman P, Guest A, Kushwaha P, Ramuthivheli T, Osebe T, et al. Prioritizing smallholder animal health needs in East Africa, West Africa, and South Asia using three approaches: Literature review, expert workshops, and practitioner surveys. Prev Vet Med 2021; 189:105279.

[39] Montgomery H, Haughey SA, Elliott CT. Recent food safety and fraud issues within the dairy supply chain (2015-2019). Glob Food Sec 2020; 26:100447.

[40] Groot MJ, van’t Hooft KE. The hidden effects of dairy farming on public and environmental health in the Netherlands, India, Ethiopia, and Uganda, considering the use of antibiotics and other agro-chemicals. Front Public Health 2016; 4. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2016.00012.

[41] Amenu K, Wieland B, Szonyi B, Grace D. Milk handling practices and consumption behavior among Borana pastoralists in southern Ethiopia. J Health Popul Nutr 2019; 38(1):6.

[42] Kebede T, Tsige TZ. Perception of the public on the common zoonotic diseases and attitude to One Health approach in Shalla District, Oromia, Ethiopia. World J Agri Sci 2020; 16(3):143-155.

[43] Mhlanga A. Assessing the impact of optimal health education programs on the control of zoonotic diseases. Comput Math Methods Med 2020; 2020:6584323.

[44] Asaaga FA, Young JC, Oommen MA, Chandarana R, August J, Joshi J, et al. Operationalising the “One Health” approach in India: Facilitators of and barriers to effective cross-sector convergence for zoonoses prevention and control. BMC Public Health 2021; 21(1):1517.

[45] Sharma A, Schuetze C, Phillips CJC. Public attitudes towards cow welfare and cow shelters (Gaushalas) in India. Animal 2019; 9(11):972.

[46] Dean AS, Forcella S, Olea-Popelka F, Idrissi AE, Glaziou P, Benyahia A, et al. A roadmap for zoonotic tuberculosis: A One Health approach to ending tuberculosis. Lancet Infect Dis 2018; 18(2):137-138.

[47] One Health High Level Expert Panel (OHHLEP). One Health theory of change. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2022.

[48] Adisasmito WB, Almuhairi S, Behravesh CB, Bilivogui P, Bukachi SA, Casas N, et al. One Health: A new definition for a sustainable and healthy future. PLoS Pathog 2022; 18(6):e1010537.

[49] World Health Organization. One Health Joint Plan of Action, 2022-2026: Working together for the health of humans, animals, plants and the environment. Geneva: World Health Organization ; 2022.

[50] McKenzie JS, Dahal R, Kakkar M, Debnath N, Rahman M, Dorjee S, et al. One Health research and training and government support for One Health in South Asia. Infect Ecol Epidemiol 2016; 6(1):33842.

[51] Pal SK, Siddiky MNA. Veterinary public health and zoonotic disease control in SAARC countries. Dhaka: SAARC Agriculture Centre; 2011, p. 249.

[52] Villanueva-Cabezas JP, Winkel KD, Campbell PT, Wiethoelter A, Pfeiffer C. One Health education should be early, inclusive, and holistic. Lancet Planet Health 2022; 6(3):e188-e189.

[53] Hák T, Janoušková S, Moldan B. Sustainable development goals: A need for relevant indicators. Ecol Indic 2016; 60:565-573.

[54] Food and Agriculture Organization. World livestock: Transforming the livestock sector through the Sustainable Development Goals. 2018. [Online]. Available from:http://www.fao.org/documents/card/en/c/ca1201en. [Accessed on 2 January 2023].