Analytical study on the exposedness of potential positions for external human-machine interfaces

Abstract

As we move towards a future of autonomous vehicles, questions regarding their method of communication have arisen. One of the common concerns is the placement of the signaling used to communicate with pedestrians and road users, but few works have been fully dedicated to the matter. This paper uses a simulation made in the Unity game engine to record the fifteen different vehicles under fifty-seven different scenarios each for the first time, in order to find how often their forward-facing exterior surfaces can be seen by a pedestrian on the sidewalk. Variables include the vehicle type, position, number of vehicles on the road, camera position and direction, as well as its minimum and maximum distance from the recorded points. It was concluded that the areas of the vehicle most often seen by pedestrians on the sidewalk attempting to cross the road were the wheels, front fenders, and headlights. Based on these results, a suggestion is made to implement displays on at least two of the following regions: windshield, front fenders, side mirrors. These findings are valuable in the future design of signaling for autonomous vehicles in order to ensure pedestrians are able to see them on approaching vehicles. The software used provides a platform for similar work in the future to be conducted.

Keywords

Autonomous vehicles / eHMI / Road safety / Pedestrian safety

References

[1] Winter J., Dodou D.. External human–machine interfaces: gimmick or necessity?. Transp. Res. Interdiscip. Perspect., 2022, 15 100643Accessed 2024-03-16

[2] Clercq K., Dietrich A., Núñez Velasco J.P., Winter J., Happee R.. External human-machine interfaces on automated vehicles: effects on pedestrian crossing decisions. Hum. Factors, 2019, 61(81353-1370 Accessed 2024-03-16

[3] Rodríguez Palmeiro A., Kint S., Vissers L., Farah H., Winter J.C.F., Hagenzieker M.. Interaction between pedestrians and automated vehicles: a wizard of oz experiment. Transp. Res., Part F Traffic Psychol. Behav., 2018, 58: 1005-1020 Accessed 2024-03-16

[4] Alhawiti A., Kwigizile V., Oh J.-S., Asher Z.D., Hakimi O., Aljohani S., Ayantayo S.. The effectiveness of eHMI displays on pedestrian–autonomous vehicle interaction in mixed-traffic environments. Sensors, 2024, 24(15): 5018 Accessed 2024-10-08

[5] Guo F., Lyu W., Ren Z., Li M., Liu Z.. A video-based, eye-tracking study to investigate the effect of eHMI modalities and locations on pedestrian–automated vehicle interaction. Sustainability, 2022, 14(9): 5633 Accessed 2024-03-16

[6] Dey D., Walker F., Martens M., Terken J.. Gaze patterns in pedestrian interaction with vehicles: towards effective design of external human-machine interfaces for automated vehicles. Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Automotive User Interfaces and Interactive Vehicular Applications. AutomotiveUI ’19, 2019, New York, Association for Computing Machinery, 369-378 https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3342197.3344523. Accessed 2026-01-16

[7] Troel-Madec M., Boissieux L., Borkoswki S., Vaufreydaz D., Alaimo J., Chatagnon S., Spalanzani A.. eHMI positioning for autonomous vehicle/pedestrians interaction. Adjunct Proceedings of the 31st Conference on L’Interaction Homme-Machine. IHM ’19 Adjunct, 2019, Grenoble, Association for Computing Machinery, 1-8 https://hal.science/hal-02388847. Accessed 2024-03-16

[8] Definition of EXPOSED (2026). https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/exposed. Accessed 2026-02-12

[9] Winter J., Bazilinskyy P., Wesdorp D., Vlam V., Hopmans B., Visscher J., Dodou D.. How do pedestrians distribute their visual attention when walking through a parking garage? An eye-tracking study. Ergonomics, 2020, 64(6): 793-805

[10] Aversa D.. Unity Artificial Intelligence Programming: Add Powerful, Believable, and Fun AI Entities in Your Game with the Power of Unity, 2022, 5, Birminham Packt Publishing

[11] Federal Highway Administration: Office of Highway Policy Information - Policy | Federal Highway Administration. https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/policyinformation/tmguide/tmg_2013/vehicle-types.cfm. Accessed 2024-05-24

[12] [@Alex.Ka.]: Honda Shadow RS 2010 (2022). https://sketchfab.com/models/2e7cf7bc195044f4a0f60c04581e2691/embed?autostart=1. Accessed 2024-10-16

[13] [@beztao01]: Smart by Material (2021). https://sketchfab.com/models/27a7f393d3134e90b30d03bc6805cfb1/. Accessed 2024-10-16

[14] [@maxdragon]: area 9 golf cart (2021). https://sketchfab.com/models/5fd13a5303af4f3bbbba993dad35f788/. Accessed 2024-10-16

[15] Daniel Zhabotinsky [@DanielZhabotinsky]: Generic sedan 2010 (2020). https://sketchfab.com/models/7fd6e15785fa4aa9bfd6e31eb7c97ba6/. Accessed 2024-10-16

[16] [@fishermans]: Ford Edge 2006 lowpoly for 3D-printing (2024). https://sketchfab.com/models/dec7fe5f75874a9cb913e8e54dcd4954/. Accessed 2024-10-16

[17] [@danzzzeg]: D3S MB Vito Panel Van (W447) ’15 (2017). https://sketchfab.com/models/98d85b403ba0426f84636b575319e4f7/. Accessed 2024-10-16

[18] [Brian N.]: Chrysler Sebring Convertible (2007). https://sketchfab.com/3d-models/chrysler-sebring-convertible-dac8529f24754bbd936173cbe8da92b1. Accessed 2024-10-16

[19] Daniel Zhabotinsky [@DanielZhabotinsky]: American 80s Station Wagon - Low poly model (2020). https://sketchfab.com/models/680e4ad1090f4e738bbd46e618f3a01f/. Accessed 2024-10-16

[20] Daniel Zhabotinsky [@DanielZhabotinsky]: Light Box Truck - Low poly model (2020). https://sketchfab.com/models/cbc508a5ad424d79b2f2c8a3de7e1cd3/. Accessed 2024-10-16

[21] [@boitaloran]: Peugeot J5 Minibus (2022). https://sketchfab.com/models/55d72c5dd507464ca2fe26f782f8c04e/. Accessed 2024-10-16

[22] David Holiday [@David_Holiday]: 2015 Ford F150 King Ranch Edition (2021). https://sketchfab.com/models/79ebd5caaf414ab08debc36157dbc878/. Accessed 2024-10-16

[23] Daniel Zhabotinsky [@DanielZhabotinsky]: ’90 Light Commercial Truck - Low poly model (2021). https://sketchfab.com/models/663a0953c038434a918cb85725c88ffa/. Accessed 2024-10-16

[24] Lion Sharp [@lionsharp]: FREE GMC Motorhome reimagined low poly (2013). https://sketchfab.com/models/6hiH0iyDqXqtdD9wbqSbyLLhKmz/. Accessed 2024-10-16

[25] [@businessyuen]: Bus (2020). https://sketchfab.com/models/cc159e95590b49999c6e08793eb0a76a/. Accessed 2024-10-16

[26] [@own.guest]: Generic Town Bus (2021). https://sketchfab.com/models/14fe03d792914d51b6c6250b393c44fd/. Accessed 2024-10-16

[27] National Center for Health Statistics: Growth Charts - Clinical Growth Charts (2024). https://www.cdc.gov/growthcharts/data/set1clinical/cj41c021.pdf. Accessed 2026-01-16

[28] W3Counter: Global Web Stats - August 2024 (2024). https://www.w3counter.com/globalstats.php?year=2024&month=8. Accessed 2026-01-16

Rights & permissions

The Author(s)