Shark bite survivors advocate for non-lethal shark mitigation measures in Australia

i

This article has been updated. A Correction to this article was published on .

i

The Original Article was published on

i

The Original Article was published on

i

This article has been updated

i

This article was retracted on

i

This article has been updated

Abstract

As the annual number of shark-related human casualties in Australia increases, there is a need for policymakers to grasp how policy is created in the discourse of shark bite incidences. This is discussed in relation to individuals who have been most affected, i.e., shark bite survivors. The defined argument, being that, victims should feel the most animosity towards sharks, therefore if they show signs of discontent towards culling programs, the government should be compelled to change their strategy. The paper reinforces and challenges assumptions that contribute to the flow of commonly accepted knowledge of shark-human relations by illustrating how shark bite survivors are unlikely marine conservation advocates who support non-lethal shark mitigation methods. Shark bite victims were contacted via two Australian-based organizations and a total of six qualitative semi-structured interviews were conducted. Government shark mitigation practices are perceived as heavy handed and further perception- and conservation-based research is needed.

Keywords

shark-human relations / shark nets / drumlines / conservation / qualitative semi-structured interviews

CHANGE HISTORY

A Correction to this paper has been published:
https://doi.org

The Retraction Note was updated to reflect reception of statements of disagreement from all authors.

This article has been retracted.Please see the Retraction Notice for more detail:
https://doi.org

References

[1] Boissonneault MF, Gladstone W, Scott P, et al. (2005) Grey nurse shark human interactions and portrayals: A study of newspaper portrayals of the grey nurse shark from 1969-2003. Electron Green J 1.

[2] McCagh C, Sneddon J, Blache D (2015) Killing sharks: The media’s role in public and political response to fatal human-shark interactions. Mar Policy 62: 271-278.

[3] Neff C (2015) The Jaws Effect: How movie narratives are used to influence policy responses to shark bites in Western Australia. Aust J Polit Sci 50: 114-127.

[4] Neff C, Yang JYH (2013) Shark bites and public attitudes: Policy implications from the first before and after shark bite survey. Mar Policy 38: 545-547.

[5] Pepin-Neff CL, Wynter T (2018) Reducing fear to influence policy preferences: An experiment with sharks and beach safety policy options. Mar Policy 88: 222-229.

[6] Neff C (2012) Australian Beach Safety and the Politics of Shark Attacks. Coast Manag 40: 88-106.

[7] Friedrich LA, Jefferson R, Glegg G (2014) Public perceptions of sharks: Gathering support for shark conservation. Mar Policy 47: 1-7.

[8] Heithaus MR, Frid A, Wirsing AJ, et al. (2008) Predicting ecological consequences of marine top predator declines. Trends Ecol Evol 23: 202-210.

[9] MacNeil MA, Chapman DD, Heupel M, et al. (2020) Global status and conservation potential of reef sharks. Nature 583: 801-806.

[10] Kraska J, Gaskins L (2015) Can Sharks be Saved? A Global Plan of Action for Shark Conservation in the Regime of the Convention on Migratory Species. Seattle J Environ Law 5.

[11] Dulvy NK, Fowler SL, Musick JA, et al. (2014) Extinction risk and conservation of the world’s sharks and rays. Elife 2014: 590.

[12] Birkmanis CA, Partridge JC, Simmons LW, et al. (2020) Shark conservation hindered by lack of habitat protection. Glob Ecol Conserv 21: e00862.

[13] Muter BA, Gore ML, Gledhill KS, et al. (2013) Australian and U.S. News Media Portrayal of Sharks and Their Conservation. Conserv Biol 27: 187-196.

[14] Kobori H, Dickinson JL, Washitani I, et al. (2016) Citizen science: A new approach to advance ecology, education, and conservation. Ecol Res 31: 1-19.

[15] Ferretti F, Worm B, Britten GL, et al. (2010) Patterns and ecosystem consequences of shark declines in the ocean. Ecol Lett 13: 1055-1071.

[16] Ferretti F, Myers RA, Serena F, et al. (2008) Loss of large predatory sharks from the Mediterranean Sea. Conserv Biol 22: 952-964.

[17] Bargnesi F, Lucrezi S, Ferretti F (2020) Opportunities from citizen science for shark conservation, with a focus on the Mediterranean Sea. Eur Zool J 87: 20-34.

[18] Gallagher AJ, Hammerschlag N (2011) Global shark currency: The distribution frequency and economic value of shark ecotourism. Curr Issues Tour 14: 797-812.

[19] Acuña-Marrero D, Cruz-Modino R de la, Smith ANH, et al. (2018) Understanding human attitudes towards sharks to promote sustainable coexistence. Mar Policy 91: 122-128.

[20] Huveneers C, Meekan MG, Apps K, et al. (2017) The economic value of shark-diving tourism in Australia. Rev Fish Biol Fish 27: 665-680.

[21] Connolly E (2008) The Guardian, Australian snorkeller snatched by shark, 2008. Available from: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2008/dec/28/australia-sharks-attacks.

[22] Government of Western Australia (2019) SharkSmart-Shark Mitigation Strategy, 2019. Available from: https://www.sharksmart.com.au/strategy/.

[23] Pearl H (2017) Reuters, Spate of Australia shark attacks could take a bite out of tourism, 2017. Available from: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-australia-sharkattack-tourism/spate-of-australia-shark-attacks-could-take-a-bite-out-of-tourism-idUSKBN15B0KJ.

[24] Bradshaw CJA, Meagher P, Thiele MJ, et al. (2021) Predicting potential future reduction in shark bites on people. R Soc Open Sci 8.

[25] Gouk C, Pasricha D, Lingathas S (2015) Shark attack: The emergency presentation and management. BMJ Case Rep 2015.

[26] Taylor J, McLean L, Korner A, et al. (2019) Direct and indirect psychological impacts of shark-bite events. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 53: 27-36.

[27] Huveneers C, Apps K, Becerril-García EE, et al. (2018) Future research directions on the ‘elusive’ white shark. Front Mar Sci 5: 455.

[28] NSW Government (2019) Shark Management Strategy-Factsheet, 2019. Available from: moz-extension://02805074-57cf-42f1-ad92-bcd9be2260bf/enhanced-reader.html?openApp&pdf=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.dpi.nsw.gov.au%2F__data%2Fassets%2Fpdf_file%2F0006%2F581694%2Fnsw-shark-management-strategy-factsheet.pdf.

[29] Clua EEG, Linnell JDC (2019) Individual shark profiling: An innovative and environmentally responsible approach for selectively managing human fatalities. Conserv Lett 12: e12612.

[30] Molina JM, Cooke SJ (2012) Trends in shark bycatch research: Current status and research needs. Rev Fish Biol Fish 22: 719-737.

[31] Dudley SFJ (1997) A comparison of the shark control programs of New South Wales and Queensland (Australia) and KwaZulu-Natal (South Africa). Ocean Coast Manag 34: 1-27.

[32] Guyomard D, Perry C, Tournoux PU, et al. (2019) An innovative fishing gear to enhance the release of non-target species in coastal shark-control programs: The SMART (shark management alert in real-time) drumline. Fish Res 216: 6-17.

[33] Oliver S, Braccini M, Newman SJ, et al. (2015) Global patterns in the bycatch of sharks and rays. Mar Policy 54: 86-97.

[34] Gray GME, Gray CA (2017) Human Dimensions of Wildlife An International Journal Beach-User Attitudes to Shark Bite Mitigation Strategies on Coastal Beaches; Sydney, Australia. Hum Dimens Wildl An Int J.

[35] Bornatowski H, Hussey NE, Sampaio CLS, et al. (2019) Geographic bias in the media reporting of aquatic versus terrestrial human predator conflicts and its conservation implications. Perspect Ecol Conserv 17: 32-35.

[36] Marowa I, Matanzima J (2021) Interactions between humans, crocodiles, and hippos at Lake Kariba, Zimbabwe. Human-Wildlife Interact 15: 212-227.

[37] Songhurst A (2017) Measuring human-wildlife conflicts: Comparing insights from different monitoring approaches. Wildl Soc Bull 41: 351-361.

[38] Acharya KP, Paudel PK, Neupane PR, et al. (2016) Human-wildlife conflicts in Nepal: Patterns of human fatalities and injuries caused by large mammals. PLoS One 11.

[39] Saleem S, Jan S, Khan S (2020) Qualitative analysis of the perception of street dog bite victims and implication for the prevention of dog bites at a teaching hospital anti-rabies Clinic. J Fam Med Prim care 9: 4118.

[40] Magaldi D, Berler M (2018) Semi-structured Interviews, Encyclopedia of Personality and Individual Differences , Springer International Publishing, 1-6.

[41] McIntosh MJ, Morse JM (2015) Situating and Constructing Diversity in Semi-Structured Interviews. Glob Qual Nurs Res 2: 2333393615597674.

[42] DeJonckheere M, Vaughn LM (2019) Semistructured interviewing in primary care research: A balance of relationship and rigour. Fam Med Community Heal 7: 57.

[43] Jamshed S (2014) Qualitative research method-interviewing and observation. J Basic Clin Pharm 5: 87.

[44] Alshenqeeti H (2014) Interviewing as a data collection method: A critical review. English Linguist Res 3: 39.

[45] Iacono V Lo, Symonds P, Brown DHK (2016) Skype as a tool for qualitative research interviews. Sociol Res Online 21: 12.

[46] Salazar MK (2016) Interviewer bias: How it affects survey research. Workplace Health Saf 38: 567-572.

[47] Naslund JA, Aschbrenner KA, Marsch LA, et al. (2016) The future of mental health care: Peer-to-peer support and social media. Epidemiol Psychiatr Sci 25: 113-122.

[48] Castleberry A, Nolen A (2018) Thematic analysis of qualitative research data: Is it as easy as it sounds? Curr Pharm Teach Learn 10: 807-815.

[49] Walsh RS, McClean B, Doyle N, et al. (2019) A thematic analysis investigating the impact of positive behavioral support training on the lives of service providers: “It makes you think differently”. Front Psychol 10: 2408.

[50] Xu W, Zammit K (2020) Applying thematic analysis to education: A hybrid approach to interpreting data in practitioner research. Int J Qual Methods 19: 160940692091881.

[51] Attride-Stirling J (2001) Thematic networks: An analytic tool for qualitative research. Qual Res 1: 385-405.

[52] Nowell LS, Norris JM, White DE, et al. (2017) Thematic analysis. Int J Qual Methods 16: 160940691773384.

[53] Kiger ME, Varpio L (2020) Thematic analysis of qualitative data: AMEE guide no. 131. Med Teach 42: 846-854.

[54] Braun V, Clarke V (2006) Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual Res Psychol 3: 77-101.

[55] Vining J (2003) The connection to other animals and caring for nature. Hum Ecol Rev 10: 87-99.

[56] Thomas-Walters L, McNulty C, Veríssimo D (2019) A scoping review into the impact of animal imagery on pro-environmental outcomes. Ambio 49: 1135-1145.

[57] Grajal A, Luebke J, Kelly L, et al. (2017) The complex relationship between personal sense of connection to animals and self-reported proenvironmental behaviors by zoo visitors. Conserv Biol 31: 322-330.

[58] McKinley E, Fletcher S (2010) Individual responsibility for the oceans? An evaluation of marine citizenship by UK marine practitioners. Ocean Coast Manag 53: 379-384.

[59] Schildkraut J, Sokolowski ES, Nicoletti J (2020) The survivor network: the role of shared experiences in mass shootings recovery. Victims & Offenders 16: 20-49.

[60] Ali K, Farrer L, Gulliver A, et al. (2015) Online peer-to-peer support for young people with mental health problems: A systematic review. JMIR Ment Heal 2.

[61] Smith-Frigerio S (2020) ‘You are not alone’: Linking peer support to information and resources for mental health concerns in advocacy groups’ social media messaging. Health Commun 1: 1-10.

[62] Hayes JP, VanElzakker MB, Shin LM (2012) Emotion and cognition interactions in PTSD: A review of neurocognitive and neuroimaging studies. Front Integr Neurosci 0: 89.

[63] Gibbs L, Fetterplace L, Rees M, et al. (2020) Effects and effectiveness of lethal shark hazard management: The Shark Meshing (Bather Protection) Program, NSW, Australia. People Nat 2: 189-203.

[64] Gibbs LM (2016) More shark nets for NSW: Why haven’t we learned from WA’s cull?, Wollongong, University of Wollongong.

[65] Brazier W, Nel R, Cliff G, et al. (2012) Impact of protective shark nets on sea turtles in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa, 1981-2008. African J Mar Sci 34: 249-257.

[66] Cosandey-Godin A, Morgan A (2011) Fisheries bycatch of sharks: Options for mitigation, Washington, D.C., Pew Research.

[67] Sumpton WD, Taylor SM, Gribble NA, et al. (2011) Gear selectivity of large-mesh nets and drumlines used to catch sharks in the Queensland Shark Control Program. African J Mar Sci 33: 37-43.

[68] Guyomard D, Lee KA, Perry C, et al. (2020) SMART drumlines at Réunion Island do not attract bull sharks Carcharhinus leucas into nearshore waters: Evidence from acoustic monitoring. Fish Res 225: 105480.

[69] Tate RD, Cullis BR, Smith SDA, et al. (2019) The acute physiological status of white sharks (Carcharodon carcharias) exhibits minimal variation after capture on SMART drumlines. Conserv Physiol 7.

[70] Pepin-Neff C, Wynter T (2018) Save the sharks: Reevaluating and (re)valuing feared predators. Hum Dimens Wildl 24: 87-94.

[71] Sergio F, Blas J, Forero M, et al. (2005) Preservation of wide-ranging top predators by site-protection: Black and red kites in Doñana National Park. Biol Conserv 125: 11-21.

[72] Villafaña JA, Hernandez S, Alvarado A, et al. (2020) First evidence of a palaeo-nursery area of the great white shark. Sci Rep 10: 1-8.