A comprehensive review of extrusion-based additive manufacturing processes for rapid production of metallic and ceramic parts

Abstract

The extrusion-based additive manufacturing (EAM) technique is recently being employed for rapid production of metals and ceramic components. This technique involves extruding the metal or ceramic material in solid powder form mixed with a binder (i.e., an expendable viscous fluid), which is removed from the part after 3D printing. These technologies rely on the large design freedom allowed and the cost efficiency advantage over alternative metal additive manufacturing processes that are based on high energy beams, such as laser or electron beams. The EAM of metals and ceramics is not yet widespread, but published scientific and technical literature on it is rapidly growing. However, this literature is still less extensive than that on the fused deposition modeling (FDM) of plastics or the selective laser melting (SLM) of metals. This paper aims at filling this gap. FDM and powder injection molding are identified as preceding or enabling technologies for EAM. This paper systematically reviews all aspects of the feedstock EAM processes used for production of complex-shaped parts. The unique characteristics and advantages of these processes are also discussed with respect to materials and process steps. In addition, the key process parameters are explained to illustrate the suitability of the EAM process for diverse application domains.

Keywords

Feedstock extrusion / Rapid production / Complex-shaped metallic / Ceramic parts

References

[1] ISO/ASTM 52900:2015(E) Standard terminology for additive manufacturing. ASTM 2015

[2] Deckers J, Vleugels J, Kruth JP. Additive manufacturing of ceramics: a review. J Ceram Sci Tech, 2014, 5(4): 245-260.

[3] Frazier WE. Metal additive manufacturing: a review. J Mater Eng Perform, 2014, 23(6): 1917-1928.

[4] Turner BN, Gold SA. A review of melt extrusion additive manufacturing processes: II. materials, dimensional accuracy, and surface roughness. Rapid Prototyp J, 2015, 21(3): 250-261.

[5] Turner N, Strong B, Gold S. A review of melt extrusion additive manufacturing processes: I. Process design and modeling. Rapid Prototyp J, 2014, 20(3): 192-204.

[6] Karunakaran KP, Alain Bernard, Suryakumar S, et al. Rapid manufacturing of metallic objects. Rapid Prototyp J, 2012, 18(4): 264-280.

[7] Lewis JA, Smay JE, Stuecker J, et al. Direct ink writing of three-dimensional ceramic structures. J Am Ceram Soc, 2006, 89(12): 3599-3609.

[8] Gonzalez-Gutierrez J, Cano S, Schuschnigg S, et al. Additive manufacturing of metallic and ceramic components by the material extrusion of highly-filled polymers: a review and future perspectives. Materials, 2018, 11(5): 840.

[9] Bikas H, Stavropoulos P, Chryssolouris G. Additive manufacturing methods and modeling approaches: a critical review. Int J Adv Manuf Technol, 2016, 83(1–4): 389-405.

[10] Carneiro OS, Silva AF, Gomes R. Fused deposition modeling with polypropylene. Mater Des, 2015, 83(15): 768-776.

[11] Tymrak BM, Kreiger M, Pearce JM. Mechanical properties of components fabricated with open-source 3D printers under realistic environmental conditions. Mater Des, 2014, 58: 242-246.

[12] Bottini A, Boschetto L. Accuracy prediction in fused deposition modeling. Int J Adv Manuf Technol, 2014, 73(5–8): 913-928.

[13] Ning F, Cong W, Qiu J, et al. Additive manufacturing of carbon fiber reinforced thermoplastic composites using fused deposition modeling. Compos B Eng, 2015, 80: 369-378.

[14] Brünler R, Aibibu D, Wöltje M, et al. In silico modeling of structural and porosity properties of additive manufactured implants for regenerative medicine. Mater Sci Eng C, 2017, 76: 810-817.

[15] xjet3d.com, XJet’s system. Accessed on 06 Sept 2017

[16] Miyanaji H, Zhang S, Lassell A, et al. Process development of porcelain ceramic material with binder jetting process for dental applications. JOM, 2016, 68(3): 831-841.

[17] King WE, Anderson AT, Ferencz RM, et al. Laser powder bed fusion additive manufacturing of metals; physics, computational, and materials challenges. Appl Phys Rev, 2015, 2(4): 41304.

[18] Khoshnevis B, Zhang J (2015) Selective separation sintering (SSS) A new layer based additive manufacturing approach for metals and ceramics. In: AIAA SPACE conference and exposition

[19] Gallo D, Biamino S, Fino P, et al. An overview of additive manufacturing of titanium components by directed energy deposition: microstructure and mechanical properties. Appl Sci, 2017, 7(9): 883.

[20] Rane K, Cataldo S, Parenti P, et al. Rapid production of hollow SS316 profiles by extrusion based additive manufacturing. AIP Conf Proc, 2018, 1960(1): 140014.

[21] Stavropoulos P, Foteinopoulos P. Modelling of additive manufacturing processes: a review and classification. Manuf Rev, 2018, 5(2): 1-26.

[22] Atzeni E, Salmi A. Economics of additive manufacturing for end-usable metal parts. Int J Adv Manuf Technol, 2012, 62(9–12): 1147-1155.

[23] German RM. PIM breaks the $1 bn barrier. Metal Powder Rep, 2008, 63(3): 8-10.

[24] Gonçalves A. Metallic powder injection molding using low pressure. J Mater Process Technol, 2001, 118(1–3): 193-198.

[25] German RM, Bose A. Injection molding of metals and ceramics, 1997, Metals Powder Industries Federation: Princeton

[26] Jabbari A, Abrinia K. Developing thixo-extrusion process for additive manufacturing of metals in semi-solid state. J Manuf Process, 2018, 35: 664-671.

[27] Tseng JW, Hsu CK. Cracking defect and porosity evolution during thermal debinding in ceramic injection molding. Ceram Int, 1999, 25(5): 461-466.

[28] Finke S, Feenstra FK. Solid freeform fabrication by extrusion and deposition of semi-solid alloys. J Mater Sci, 2002, 37(15): 3101-3106.

[29] Luo J, Qi LH, Zhong SY, et al. Printing solder droplets for micro devices packages using pneumatic drop-on-demand (DoD) technique. J Mater Process Technol, 2012, 212(10): 2066-2073.

[30] Zhong SY, Qi LH, Luo J, et al. Effect of process parameters on copper droplet ejecting by pneumatic drop-on-demand technology. J Mater Process Technol, 2014, 214(12): 3089-3097.

[31] Zhang D, Qi L, Luo J, et al. Direct fabrication of unsupported inclined aluminum pillars based on uniform micro droplets deposition. Int J Mach Tools Manuf, 2017, 116: 18-24.

[32] Cesarano J (1998) A review of robocasting technology. In: MRS Proceedings 542:133. https://doi.org/10.1557/PROC-542-133

[33] Slots C, Jensen MB, Ditzel N, et al. Simple additive manufacturing of an osteoconductive ceramic using suspension melt extrusion. Dental Mater, 2017, 43(9): 198-208.

[34] Travitzky N, Bonet A, Dermeik B, et al. Additive manufacturing of ceramic-based materials. Adv Eng Mater, 2014, 16: 729-754.

[35] Houmard M, Fu Q, Genet M, et al. On the structural, mechanical, and biodegradation properties of HA/β-TCP robocast scaffolds. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater, 2013, 101: 1233-1242.

[36] Thomas A, Kolan KC, Leu MC, et al. Freeform extrusion fabrication of titanium fiber reinforced 13–93 bioactive glass scaffolds. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater, 2017, 69: 153-162.

[37] Wang J, Shaw LL, Cameron TB. Solid freeform fabrication of permanent dental restorations via slurry micro-extrusion. J Am Ceram Soc, 2006, 89(1): 346-349.

[38] I. 3. Bioprinter, Accessed on 25 Sept 2017

[39] Li JP, De Wijn JR, Van Blitterswijk CA, et al. Porous Ti6Al4V scaffold directly fabricating by rapid prototyping: preparation and in vitro experiment. Biomaterials, 2006, 27(8): 1223-1235.

[40] Sercombe TB, Schaffer GB, Lucia. Freeform fabrication of functional aluminium prototypes using powder metallurgy. J Mater Sci, 1999, 34(17): 4245-4251.

[41] Grida I, Evans JRG. Extrusion freeforming of ceramics through fine nozzles. J Eur Ceram Soc, 2003, 23(5): 629-635.

[42] Bellini A, Shor L, Guceri SI. New developments in fused deposition modeling of ceramics. Rapid Prototyp J, 2005, 11(4): 214-220.

[43] Lu X, Lee Y, Yang S, et al. Fabrication of electromagnetic crystals by extrusion freeforming. Metamaterials, 2008, 2(1): 36-44.

[44] Lu X, Lee Y, Yang S, et al. Fine lattice structures fabricated by extrusion freeforming: process variables. J Mater Process Technol, 2009, 209(10): 4654-4661.

[45] Lu X, Lee Y, Yang S, et al. Solvent-based paste extrusion solid freeforming. J Eur Ceram Soc, 2010, 30(1): 1-10.

[46] Jafari MA, Han W, Mohammadi F, et al. A novel system for fused deposition of advanced multiple ceramics. Rapid Prototyp J, 2000, 6(3): 161-175.

[47] Wu G, Langrana NA, Sadanji R, et al. Solid freeform fabrication of metal components using fused deposition of metals. Mater Des, 2002, 23(1): 97-105.

[48] Vaidyanathan R, Walish J, Lombardi JL, et al. The extrusion freeforming of functional ceramic prototypes. JOM, 2000, 52(12): 34-37.

[49] Kalita SJ, Bose S, Hosick HL, et al. Development of controlled porosity polymer-ceramic composite scaffolds via fused deposition modeling. Mater Sci Eng C, 2003, 23(5): 611-620.

[50] 3devo.com, 3devo.com/next-filament-extruder/. Accessed on 13 Oct 2017

[51] The Virtual Foundry. www.thevirtualfoundry.com/showcase/m0mau80bklzxkr50voo7gkvrdqzs38. Accessed on 12 Oct 2017

[52] Li JB, Xie ZG, Zhang XH, et al. Study of metal powder extrusion and accumulating rapid prototyping. Key Eng Mater, 2010, 443: 81-86.

[53] Holshouser C, Newell C, Palas S, et al. Out of bounds additive manufacturing. Adv Mater Process, 2013, 171(3): 15-27.

[54] Annoni M, Giberti H, Strano M. Feasibility study of an extrusion-based direct metal additive manufacturing technique. Proc Manuf, 2016, 5: 916-927.

[55] Ren LQ, Zhou XL, Song ZY, et al. Process parameter optimization of extrusion-based 3D metal printing utilizing PW-LDPE-SA binder system. Materials, 2017, 10(3): 305.

[56] Gaub (2016) www.arburg.com/us/us/products-and-services/additive-manufacturing/freeformer-system. (Online). Accessed 04 June 2017

[57] D Rotman (2017) Director. www.technologyreview.com/s/604088/the-3-d-printer-that-could-finally-change-manufacturing/. (Film)

[58] Tay BY, Loh NH, Tor SB, et al. Characterisation of micro gears produced by micro powder injection moulding. Powder Technol, 2009, 188(3): 179-182.

[59] Rane KK, Date PP. Rheological investigation of MIM feedstocks for reducing frictional effects during injection moulding. Adv Mater Res, 2014, 966–967: 196-205.

[60] A. F3049-14 (2014) Standard guide for characterizing properties of metal powders used for additive manufacturing processes. ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA

[61] Thomas-Vielma P, Cervera A, Levenfeld B, et al. Production of alumina parts by powder injection molding with a binder system based on high density polyethylene. J Eur Ceram Soc, 2008, 28(4): 763-771.

[62] Kiyota Y (1989) Patent US4867943

[63] Kang H, Kitsomboonloha R, Jang J, et al. High-performance printed transistors realized using femtoliter gravure-printed sub-10 μm metallic nanoparticle patterns and highly uniform polymer dielectric and semiconductor layers. Adv Mater, 2012, 24(22): 3065-3069.

[64] Maleksaeedi S, Eng H, Wiria FE, et al. Property enhancement of 3D-printed alumina ceramics using vacuum infiltration. J Mater Process Technol, 2014, 214(7): 1301-1306.

[65] Asadi-Eydivand M, Solati-Hashjin M, Farzad A, et al. Effect of technical parameters on porous structure and strength of 3D printed calcium sulfate prototypes. Robot Comput Integr Manuf, 2016, 37: 57-67.

[66] Gaytan SM, Cadena MA, Karim H, et al. Fabrication of barium titanate by binder jetting additive manufacturing technology. Ceram Int, 2015, 41(5): 6610-6619.

[67] Farzadi A, Waran V, Solati-Hashjin M, et al. Effect of layer printing delay on mechanical properties and dimensional accuracy of 3D printed porous prototypes in bone tissue engineering. Ceram Int, 2015, 41(7): 8320-8330.

[68] Vitorino N, Freitas C, Ribeiro MJ, et al. Extrusion of ceramic emulsions: plastic behavior. Appl Clay Sci, 2014, 101: 315-319.

[69] Kono T, Horata A, Kondo T. Development of titanium and titanium alloy by metal injection molding process. J Jpn Soc Powder Metall, 1997, 44: 985-992.

[70] Wen G, Cao P, Gabbitas B, et al. Development and design of binder systems for titanium metal injection molding: an overview. Metall Mater Trans A, 2013, 44(3): 1530-1547.

[71] Ahn S, Park SJ, Lee S, et al. Effect of powders and binders on material properties and molding parameters in iron and stainless steel powder injection molding process. Powder Technol, 2009, 193(2): 162-169.

[72] Levenfeld B, Varez A, Torralba JM. Effect of residual carbon on the sintering process of M2 high speed steel parts obtained by a modified metal injection molding process. Metall Mater Trans A, 2002, 33(6): 1843-1851.

[73] Moballegh L, Morshedian J, Esfandeh M. Copper injection molding using a thermoplastic binder based on paraffin wax. Mater Lett, 2005, 59(22): 2832-2837.

[74] Suri P, Atre SV, German RM, et al. Effect of mixing on the rheology and particle characteristics of tungsten-based powder injection molding feedstock. Mater Sci Eng A, 2003, 356(1): 337-344.

[75] Bose A, Schuh CA, Tobia JC, et al. Traditional and additive manufacturing of a new tungsten heavy alloy alternative. Int J Refract Metals Hard Mater, 2018, 73: 22-28.

[76] Merz L, Rath S, Piotter V, et al. Feedstock development for micro powder injection molding. Microsyst Technol, 2002, 8(2–3): 129-132.

[77] Samuel I, Lin E. Near-net-shape forming of zirconia optical sleeves by ceramics injection molding. Ceram Int, 2001, 27(2): 205-214.

[78] Yang WW, Yang KY, Hon MH. Effects of PEG molecular weights on rheological behavior of alumina injection molding feedstocks. Mater Chem Phys, 2003, 78(2): 416-424.

[79] Ani S, Muchtar SM, Muhamad A, et al. Binder removal via a two-stage debinding process for ceramic injection molding parts. Ceram Int, 2014, 40(2): 2819-2824.

[80] Burkhardt C, Freigassner P, Weber O et al (2016) Fused filament fabrication (FFF) of 316L green parts for the MIM process. In: Proceedings of the world PM2016 congress and exhibition, Hamburg, Germany, 9–13 Oct 2016

[81] www.mixer.co.uk/en/product/zx-sigma-mixer-extruder. U. Winkworth Mixer Co. Accessed 04 May 2017

[82] Hausnerová B. Powder injection moulding—an alternative processing method for automotive items. Trends Dev Autom Syst Eng, 2011, 2011: 129-145.

[83] Peng F, Vogt BD, Cakmak M. Complex flow and temperature history during melt extrusion in material extrusion additive manufacturing. Addit Manuf, 2018, 22: 197-206.

[84] Northcutt LA, Orski SV, Migler KB, et al. Effect of processing conditions on crystallization kinetics during materials extrusion additive manufacturing. Polymer, 2018, 154: 182-187.

[85] Valkenaers H, Vogeler F, Voet A et al (2013) Screw extrusion based 3D printing, a novel additive manufacturing technology. In: International conference on competitive manufacturing (COMA)

[86] Tseng JW, Liu CY, Yen YK, et al. Screw extrusion-based additive manufacturing of PEEK. Mater Des, 2018, 140: 209-221.

[87] Pachauri P, Hamiuddin M. Optimization of injection moulding process parameters in MIM for impact toughness of sintered parts. Int J Adv Mater Metall Eng, 2015, 1: 1-11.

[88] Giberti H, Sbaglia L, Silvestri M. Mechatronic design for an extrusion-based additive manufacturing machine. Machines, 2017, 5(4): 29.

[89] Rishi O (2013) Feed rate effects in freeform filament extrusion. Dissertation, Rochester Institute of Technology

[90] Fiore E, Giberti H, Sbaglia L (2015) Dimensional synthesis of a 5-DoF parallel kinematic manipulator for a 3D printer. In: 16th international conference on research and education in mechatronics (REM), Bochun Germany, 18–20 Nov 2015

[91] Giberti H, Fiore E, Sbaglia L (2016) Kinematic synthesis of a new 3D printing solution. In: MATEC Web of conferences

[92] Anzalone GC, Zhang CL, Wijnen B, et al. A low-cost open-source metal 3-D printer. IEEE Access, 2013, 1: 803-810.

[93] Giberti H, Sbaglia L, Urgo M. A path planning algorithm for industrial processes under velocity constraints with an application to additive manufacturing. J Manuf Syst, 2017, 43: 160-167.

[94] Monzón MD, Gibson I, Benítez AN, et al. Process and material behavior modeling for a new design of micro-additive fused deposition. Int J Adv Manuf Technol, 2013, 67(9–12): 2717-2726.

[95] Oliveira RVB, Soldi V, Fredel MC, et al. Ceramic injection molding: influence of specimen dimensions and temperature on solven debinding kinetics. J Mater Process Technol, 2005, 160(2): 213-220.

[96] Royer A, Barrière T, Gelin JC. Development and characterization of a metal injection molding bio sourced Inconel 718 feedstock based on polyhydroxyalkanoates. Metals, 2016, 6(4): 89.

[97] Tandon R. Metal injection moulding in Encyclopedia of materials science and technology, 2008, Amsterdam: Elsevier 5439-5442.

[98] Boljanovic V. Powder metallurgy, in metal shaping processes: casting and molding, particulate processing, deformation processes, metal removal, 2010, New York: Industrial Press Inc 75-106.

[99] Parenti P, Kuriakose S, Mussi V et al (2017) Green-state micromilling of AISI316L feedstock. In: World congress on micro and nano manufacturing, 27–30 Mar 2017

[100] Parenti P, Cataldo S, Annoni M. Shape deposition manufacturing of 316L parts via feedstock extrusion and green-state milling. Manuf Lett, 2018, 18: 6-11.

[101] A. F3091/F3091M-14 (2014) Standard specification for powder bed fusion of plastic materials, ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA

[102] A. F3122-14 (2014) Standard guide for evaluating mechanical properties of metal materials made via additive manufacturing processes, ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA

[103] Komineas G, Foteinopoulos P, Papacharalampopoulos A, et al. Build time estimation models in thermal extrusion additive manufacturing processes. Proc Manuf, 2018, 21: 647-654.

[104] Ghazanfari A, Li WB, Leu MC et al (2016) A novel extrusion-based additive manufacturing process for ceramic parts. In: 26th annual international solid freeform fabrication symposium

[105] Brenken B, Barocio E, Favaloro A, et al. Development and validation of extrusion deposition additive manufacturing process simulations. Addit Manuf, 2019, 25: 218-226.

[106] Singh S, Ramakrishna S, Singh R. Material issues in additive manufacturing: a review. J Manuf Process, 2017, 25: 185-200.

[107] Faes M, Valkenaers H, Vogeler F, et al. Extrusion-based 3D printing of ceramic components. Proc CIRP, 2015, 28: 76-81.

[108] Bletzinger KU, Ramm E. Structural optimization and form finding of light weight structures. Comput Struct, 2001, 79(22–25): 2053-2062.

[109] Gonzalez-Gutierrez J, Godec D, Guran R, et al. 3D printing conditions determination for feedstock used in fused filament fabrication (FFF) of 17-4PH stainless steel parts. Metalurgija, 2018, 57: 117-120.

[110] Moritz T, Partsch U, Ziesche S, et al. Additive manufacturing of ceramic components. Mater Process Annu Rep, 2014, 15: 28-31.

[111] Ghazanfari A, Li W, Leu M, et al. Mechanical characterization of parts produced by ceramic on-demand extrusion process. Int J Appl Ceram Technol, 2017, 14(3): 486-494.

[112] Li W, Ghazanfari A, McMillen D, et al. Fabricating ceramic components with water dissolvable support structures by the ceramic on-demand extrusion process. CIRP Ann Manuf Technol, 2017, 66: 225-228.

[113] Lieberwirth C, Harder A, Seitz H. Extrusion based additive manufacturing of metals parts. J Mech Eng Autom, 2017, 7: 79-83.