Separation and recovery of critical metal ions using ionic liquids

Abstract

Separation and purification of critical metal ions such as rare-earth elements (REEs), scandium and niobium from their minerals is difficult and often determines if extraction is economically and environmentally feasible. Solvent extraction is a commonly used metal-ion separation process, usually favored because of its simplicity, speed and wide scope, which is why it is often employed for separating trace metals from their minerals. However, the types of solvents widely used for the recovery of metal ions have adverse environmental impact. Alternatives to solvent extraction have been explored and advances in separation technologies have shown commercial establishment of liquid membranes as an alternative to conventional solvent extraction for the recovery of metals and other valuable materials. Liquid membrane transport incorporates solvent extraction and membrane separation in one continuously operating system. Both methods conventionally use solvents that are harmful to the environment, however, the introduction of ionic liquids (ILs) over the last decade is set to minimize the environmental impact of both solvent extraction and liquid membrane separation processes. ILs are a family of organic molten salts with low or negligible vapour pressure which may be formed below 100 °C. Such liquids are also highly thermally stable and less toxic. Their ionic structure makes them thermodynamically favorable solvents for the extraction of metallic ions. The main aim of this article is to review the current achievements in the separation of REE, scandium, niobium and vanadium from their minerals, using ILs in either solvent extraction or liquid membrane processes. The mechanism of separation using ILs is discussed and the engineering constraints to their application are identified.

Keywords

Critical metals / Ionic liquids (ILs) / Niobium / Tantalum / Rare-earth elements (REEs) / Vanadium / Scandium

References

[1] European Commission (2014) Critical raw materials for the EU. Available from http://ec.europa.eu/enterprise/policies/raw-materials/files/docs/report-b_en.pdf. Accessed 28 Sept 2014

[2] Nuss P, Eckelman M. Life cycle assessment of metals: a scientific synthesis. PLoS One, 2014, 9(7): e101298.

[3] Koltun P, Tharumarajah A. Life cycle impact of rare-earth elements. ISRN Metall, 2014, 2014: 1-10.

[4] Massari S, Ruberti M. Rare-earth elements as critical raw materials: focus on international markets and future strategies. Resour Policy, 2013, 38(1): 36-43.

[5] International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (IUPAC) Nomenclature of inorganic chemistry, 2005, Cambridge: RSC Publishing

[6] Gupta C, Krishnamurthy N. Extractive metallurgy of rare-earths, 2005, Boca Raton: CRC Press

[7] Jordens A, Cheng Y, Waters K. A review of the beneficiation of rare earth element bearing minerals. Miner Eng, 2013, 41: 97-114.

[8] Habashi F. Handbook of extractive metallurgy, 1997, Weinheim: Wiley-VCH

[9] Wang W, Pranolo Y, Cheng C. Metallurgical processes for scandium recovery from various resources: a review. Hydrometallurgy, 2011, 108(1–2): 100-108.

[10] Wagh A, Pinnock W. Occurrence of scandium and rare-earth elements in Jamaican bauxite waste. Econ Geol, 1987, 82(3): 757-761.

[11] Ochsenkühn-Petropulu M, Lyberopulu T, Parissakis G. Direct determination of lanthanides, yttrium and scandium in bauxites and red mud from alumina production. Anal Chim Acta, 1994, 296(3): 305-313.

[12] International Lead and Zinc Study Group, International Nickel Study Group and International Copper Study Group (2013) Study of by-products of copper, lead, zinc and nicke. Available from https://connect.innovateuk.org/documents/2865354/3895467/Study+of+By-Products+of+Copper,%20Lead,%20Nickel+%26+Zinc/2703f24f-14c6-4038-abb4-fb4f215327c6. Accessed 27 Apr 2015

[13] United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) International Resource Panel (2011) Recycling rates of metals: a status report

[14] Binnemans K, Jones P, Blanpain B, et al. Recycling of rare-earths: a critical review. J Clean Prod, 2013, 51: 1-22.

[15] Pohl W. Economic geology, 2011, Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell

[16] Siirama L. The Sokli mine project. Fennoskandian mining and exploration congress, 2009, Rovaniemi: Fennoskandian Mining and Exploration Congress

[17] Zelikman A, Kreĭn O, Samsonov G (1966) Metallurgy of rare metals: metallurgiva redkikh metallov. Jerusalem: Israel program for scientific translations. Available from the U S Dept. of Commerce, Clearinghouse for Federal Scientific and Technical Information, Springfield

[18] British Geological Survey (BGS) Mineral profile: niobium–tantalum, 2011, Nottingham: British Geological Survey

[19] US Geological Survey (USGS) (2014) Mineral commodity summaries 2014: US Geological Survey, p 196

[20] Dewhurst P (2013) Molybdenum and vanadium: key metals in titanium alloys. Roskill consulting group Ltd

[21] US Geological Survey (2013) Mineral commodity summaries 2013: US Geological Survey, 198 p

[22] Rydberg J. Solvent extraction principles and practice, 2004, New York: M. Dekker.

[23] Wellens S (2014) Ionic liquid technology in metal refining: dissolution of metal oxides and separation by solvent extraction. Dissertation, KU Leuven Belgium

[24] Izgorodina E, Bernard U, Dean P, et al. The madelung constant of organic salts. Cryst Growth Des, 2009, 9(11): 4834-4839.

[25] Laus G, Bentivoglio G, Schottenberger H, et al. Ionic liquids: current developments, potential and drawbacks for industrial applications. Lenzinger Berichte, 2005, 84: 71-85.

[26] Tian G, Li J, Hua Y. Application of ionic liquids in hydrometallurgy of nonferrous metals. Trans Nonferr Metals Soc China, 2010, 20(3): 513-520.

[27] Regel-Rosocka M, Wisniewski M (2011) Ionic liquids in separation of metal ions from aqueous solutions. In: Handy S (ed) Applications of ionic liquids in science and technology. InTech, pp 375–398

[28] Pham TPT, Cho CW, Yun YS. Environmental fate and toxicity of ionic liquids: a review. Water Res, 2010, 44(2): 352-372.

[29] Ventura SPM, Marques CS, Rosatella AA, et al. Toxicity assessment of various ionic liquid families towards Vibrio fischeri marine bacteria. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf, 2012, 76(2): 162-168.

[30] Xie F, Zhang TA, Dreisinger D, et al. A critical review on solvent extraction of rare earths from aqueous solutions. Miner Eng, 2014, 56(2): 10-28.

[31] Shimojo K, Kurahashi K, Naganawa H. Extraction behavior of lanthanides using a diglycolamide derivative TODGA in ionic liquids. Dalton Trans, 2008, 252(37): 5083-5088.

[32] Jensen M, Neuefeind J, Beitz J, et al. Mechanisms of metal ion transfer into room-temperature ionic liquids: the role of anion exchange. J Am Chem Soc Jacs, 2003, 125(50): 15466-15473.

[33] Zuo Y, Liu Y, Chen J, et al. The separation of cerium(IV) from nitric acid solutions containing thorium(IV) and lanthanides(III) using pure [C₈mim]PF₆ as extracting phase. Ind Eng Chem Res, 2008, 47(7): 2349-2355.

[34] Belova VV, Voshkin AA, Egorova NS, et al. Extraction of rare earth metals from nitrate solutions with a binary extractant based on Cyanex 272. Russ J Inorg Chem, 2010, 55(4): 629-633.

[35] Rout A, Venkatesan KA, Srinivasan TG, et al. Ionic liquids extractans in molecular diluents: extraction behaviour of europium(III) in quaternary ammonium-based ionic liquids. Sep Purif Technol, 2012, 95(7): 26-31.

[36] Valdés-Vergara M, Lijanova I, Likhanova NV, et al. Recycling and recovery of ammonium-based ionic liquids after extraction of metal cations from aqueous solutions. Sep Purif Technol, 2015, 155: 110-117.

[37] Sun X, Ji Y, Guo L, et al. A novel ammonium ionic liquid based extraction strategy for separating scandium from yttrium and lanthanides. Sep Purif Technol, 2011, 81(1): 25-30.

[38] Castillo J, Coll MT, Fortuny A, et al. Cu(II) extraction using quaternary ammonium and quaternary phosphonium based ionic liquid. Hydrometallurgy, 2014, 141(2): 89-96.

[39] Li D, Wang Z, Song W, et al. Recommended separation processes for ion-absorbed rare earth minerals. Hydrometallurgy, 1994, 94: 627-634.

[40] Preston JS, Cole PM, Craig WM, et al. The recovery of rare earth oxides from a phosphoric acid by-product. Part 1: leaching of rare-earth values and recovery of a mixed rare-earth oxide by solvent extraction. Hydrometallurgy, 1996, 41(1): 1-19.

[41] Preston JS, Cole PM, du Preez AC, et al. The recovery of rare-earth oxides from a phosphoric acid by-product. Part 2: the preparation of high-purity cerium dioxide and recovery of a heavy rare-earth oxide concentrate. Hydrometallurgy, 1996, 41(1): 21-44.

[42] Preston JS, du Preez AC, Cole PM, et al. The recovery of rare-earth oxides from a phosphoric acid by-product. Part 3: the separation of the middle and light rare-earth fractions and the preparation of pure europium oxide. Hydrometallurgy, 1996, 42(2): 131-149.

[43] Reddy MLP, Prasada RT, Damodaran AD. Liquid-liquid extraction processes for the separation and purification of rare earths. Miner Process Extr Metall Rev, 1993, 12(2–4): 91-113.

[44] Sato T. Liquid-liquid extraction of rare-earth elements from aqueous acid solutions by acid organophosphorus compounds. Hydrometallurgy, 1989, 22(1–2): 121-140.

[45] Sun X, Luo H, Dai S. Solvent extraction of rare-earth ions based on functionalized ionic liquids. Talanta, 2012, 90(1): 132-137.

[46] Yang F, Kubota F, Baba Y, et al. Selective extraction and recovery of rare earth metals from phosphor powders in waste fluorescent lamps using an ionic liquid system. J Hazard Mater, 2013, 254–255: 79-88.

[47] Rout A, Binnemans K. Liquid-liquid extraction of europium(III) and other trivalent rare-earth ions using non-fluorinated functionalized ionic liquid. Dalton Trans, 2014, 43(4): 1862-1872.

[48] Sang JY, Lee JG, Tajima H. Extraction of lanthanide ions from aqueous solution by bis(2-ethylhexyl)phosphoric acid with room-temperature ionic liquids. J Ind Eng Chem, 2010, 16(3): 350-354.

[49] Rout A, Kotlarska J, Dehaen W, et al. Liquid–liquid extraction of neodymium(III) by dialkylphosphate ionic liquids from acidic medium: the importance of the ionic liquid cation. Phys Chem Chem Phys, 2013, 15(39): 16533-16541.

[50] Yang F, Kubota F, Kamiya N, et al. Extraction of rare-earth ions with an 8-hydroxyquinoline derivative in an ionic liquid. Solv Extr Res Dev, Jpn, 2013, 20: 123-129.

[51] Zhang P, You S, Zhang L, et al. A solvent extraction process for the preparation of ultrahigh purity scandium oxide. Hydrometallurgy, 1997, 47(1): 47-56.

[52] Li D, Wang C. Solvent extraction of scandium(III) by Cyanex 923 and Cyanex 925. Hydrometallurgy, 1998, 48(3): 301-312.

[53] Wang W, Pranolo Y, Cheng YC. Recovery of scandium from synthetic red mud leach solutions by solvent extraction with D2EHPA. Sep Purif Technol, 2013, 108(16): 96-102.

[54] Dalvi MB, Khopkar SM. Solvent extraction of scandium from malonic acid with high molecular-weight amines. Talanta, 1979, 26(9): 892-894.

[55] Fujinaga K, Yoshimori M, Nakajima Y, et al. Separation of Sc(III) from ZrO(II) by solvent extraction using oxidized Phoslex DT-8. Hydrometallurgy, 2013, 133(2): 33-36.

[56] Zhou HM, Yi DQ, Zhang Y, et al. The dissolution behaviour of Nb₂O₅, Ta₂O₅ and their mixture in highly concentrated KOH solution. Hydrometallurgy, 2005, 80(1–2): 126-131.

[57] Zhou H, Zheng S, Zhang Y. Leaching of a low-grade niobium–tantalum ore by highly concentrated caustic potash solution. Hydrometallurgy, 2005, 80(1–2): 83-89.

[58] Wang XH, Zheng SL, Xu HB, et al. Dissolution behaviours of Ta₂O₅, Nb₂O₅ and their mixture in KOH and H₂O system. Trans Nonferr Metals Soc China, 2010, 20(10): 2006-2011.

[59] Yang XL, Wang XH, Wei C, et al. Decomposition of niobium ore by sodium hydroxide fusion method. Metall Mater Trans B, 2013, 44(1): 45-52.

[60] Packer KJ, Muetterties EL. Nature of viobium(V) fluoride species in solution. J Am Chem Soc, 1963, 85(19): 3035-3036.

[61] Baumann EW. Investigation of the tantalum fluoride system using the fluoride-selective electrode. J Inorg Nucl Chem, 1972, 34(2): 687-695.

[62] Zhu Z, Cheng CY. Solvent extraction technology for the separation and purification of niobium and tantalum: a review. Hydrometallurgy, 2011, 107(1–2): 1-12.

[63] Okada T (2001) Manufacturing of special niobium oxides for optical and ceramic applications. In: International symposium on niobium, pp 175–183

[64] Agulyansky A. The chemistry of tantalum and niobium fluoride compounds, 2004, Amsterdam: Elsevier 339-340.

[65] Nishimura S, Moriyama J, Kushima I. Behaviors of Sn, Ti and Fe in liquid-liquid extraction of Nb and Ta. Trans Jpn Inst Met, 1964, 5(1): 32-38.

[66] Nishimura S, Moriyama J, Kushima I. extraction and separation of tantalum and niobium by liquid-liquid extraction in the HF-H2SO4-TBP system. Trans Jpn Inst Met, 1964, 5(1): 39-42.

[67] Giridhar P, Abedin SZE, Bund A, et al. Electrodeposition of niobium from 1-butyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)amide ionic liquid. Electrochim Acta, 2014, 129(16): 312-317.

[68] Mascia M, Vacca A, Mais L, et al. Electrochemical deposition of Cu and Nb from pyrrolidinium based ionic liquid. Thin Solid Films, 2014, 571: 325-331.

[69] Maho A, Delhalle J, Mekhalif Z. Study of the formation process and the characteristics of tantalum layers electrodeposited on nitinol plates in the 1-butyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide ionic liquid. Electrochim Acta, 2013, 89(1): 346-358.

[70] Babushkina OB, Ekres S. Spectroscopic study of the electrochemical behaviour of tantalum(V) chloride and oxochloride species in 1-butyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium chloride. Electrochim Acta, 2010, 56(2): 867-877.

[71] Alibrahim M, Shlewit H, Alike S. Solvent extraction of Vanadium (IV) with di(2-ethylhexyl) phosphoric acid and tributyl phosphate. Period Polytech Chem Eng, 2008, 52(1): 29-33.

[72] Li X, Deng Z, Wei C, et al. Solvent extraction of vanadium from a stone coal acidic leach solution using D2EHPA/TBP: continuous testing. Hydrometallurgy, 2015, 154: 40-46.

[73] Hu G, Chen D, Wang L, et al. Extraction of vanadium from chloride solution with high concentration of iron by solvent extraction using D2EHPA. Sep Purif Technol, 2014, 125(14): 59-65.

[74] Deng ZG, Wei C, Fan G, et al. Extracting vanadium from stone-coal by oxygen pressure acid leaching and solvent extraction. Trans Nonferr Met Soc China, 2010, 20(S1): s118-s122.

[75] Jayadas S, Reddy ML. Solvent extraction separation of vanadium(V) from multivalent metal chloride solutions using 2-ethylhexyl phosphonic acid mono-2-ethylhexyl ester. J Chem Technol Biotechnol, 2002, 77(10): 1149-1156.

[76] Li X, Wei C, Wu J, et al. Thermodynamics and mechanism of vanadium(IV) extraction from sulphate medium with D2EHPA, EHEHPA and CYANEX 272 in kerosene. Trans Nonferr Met Soc China, 2012, 22(2): 461-466.

[77] Zhao J, Hu Q, Li Y, et al. Efficient separation of vanadium from chromium by a novel ionic liquid-based synergistic extraction strategy. Chem Eng J, 2015, 264: 487-496.

[78] Cui Z, Muralidhara H. Membrane technology, 2010, Oxford: Elsevier/Butterworth-Heinemann

[79] Scott K. Handbook of industrial membranes, 1995, Oxford: Elsevier Advanced Technology

[80] Kocherginsky NM, Yang Q, Seelam L. Recent advances in supported liquid membrane technology. Sep Purif Technol, 2007, 53(2): 171-177.

[81] Lozano LJ, Godínez C, Ríos APDL, et al. Recent advances in supported ionic liquid membrane technology. J Membr Sci, 2011, 376(1–2): 1-14.

[82] Ríos APDl, Hernández-Fernández FJ, Lozano LJ, et al. On the selective separation of metal ions from hydrochloride aqueous solution by pertraction through supported ionic liquid membranes. J Membr Sci, 2013, 444(1): 469-481.

[83] Yang XJ, Gu ZM, Fane AG. Multicomponent separation by a combined extraction/electrostatic pseudo-liquid membrane (II): extraction and group separation of rare earths from simulated rare-earth ore leach solutions. Hydrometallurgy, 1999, 53(1): 19-29.

[84] Yaftian MR, Burgard M, Dieleman CB, et al. Rare-earth metal-ion separation using a supported liquid membrane mediated by a narrow rim phosphorylated calix[4]arene. J Membr Sci, 1998, 144(1–2): 57-64.

[85] Zhu LL, Guo L, Zhang ZJ, et al. The preparation of supported ionic liquids (SILs) and their application in rare metals separation. Sci China Chem, 2012, 55(08): 1479-1487.

[86] Wannachod T, Leepipatpiboon N, Pancharoen U, et al. Separation and mass transport of Nd(III) from mixed rare earths via hollow fiber supported liquid membrane: experiment and modeling. Chem Eng J, 2014, 248: 158-167.

[87] Nakayama C, Uemiya S, Kojima T. Separation of rare earth metals using a supported liquid membrane with DTPA. J Alloy Compd, 1995, 225(1–2): 288-290.

[88] Chitra KR, Gaikwad AG, Surender GD, et al. Studies on ion transport of some rare-earth elements through solvating extractants immobilised on supported liquid membrane. J Membr Sci, 1997, 125(2): 257-268.

[89] Yang F, Kubota F, Baba Y, et al. Selective extraction and recovery of rare earth metals from phosphor powders in waste fluorescent lamps using an ionic liquid system. J Hazard Mater, 2013, 254(12): 79-88.

[90] Kubota F, Shimobori Y, Koyanagi Y, et al. Uphill transport of rare-earth metals through a highly stable supported liquid membrane based on an ionic liquid. Anal Sci Int J Jpn Soc Anal Chem, 2010, 26(3): 289-290.

[91] Baba Y, Kubota F, Kamiya N, et al. Recent advances in extraction and separation of rare-earth metals using ionic liquids. J Chem Eng Jpn, 2011, 44(10): 679-685.

[92] Yang XJ, Gu ZM, Wang DX. Extraction and separation of scandium from rare-earths by electrostatic pseudo liquid membrane. J Membr Sci, 1995, 106(1–2): 131-145.

[93] Campderrós ME, Marchese J. Facilitated transport of niobium(V) and tantalum(V) with supported liquid membrane using TBP as carrier. J Membr Sci, 2010, 164(99): 205-210.

[94] Campderrós ME, Marchese J. Transport of niobium(V) through a TBP–Alamine 336 supported liquid membrane from chloride solutions. Hydrometallurgy, 2001, 61(2): 89-95.

[95] Buachuang D, Ramakul P, Leepipatpiboon N, et al. Mass transfer modeling on the separation of tantalum and niobium from dilute hydrofluoric media through a hollow fiber supported liquid membrane. J Alloy Compd, 2011, 509(39): 9549-9557.

[96] Palet C, Muñoz M, Hidalgo M, et al. Transport of vanadium(V) through a tricaprylylmethylammonium solid supported liquid membrane from aqueous acetic acid/acetate solutions. J Membr Sci, 1995, 98(3): 241-248.

[97] Chaudry MA, Bukhari N, Mazhar M. Vanadium(V) ions transport through tri-n-octyl amine cyclohexane supported liquid membranes. Sep Purif Technol, 2007, 54(2): 227-233.

[98] Yadav SV, Mahajani VV. Liquid emulsion membrane (LEM) process for vanadium (IV) enrichment: process intensification. Sep Sci Technol, 2007, 42(6): 1283-1303.

[99] Nosrati S, Jayakumar NS, Hashim MA, et al. Performance evaluation of vanadium (IV) transport through supported ionic liquid membrane. J Taiwan Inst Chem Eng, 2013, 44(3): 337-342.

[100] Albright L. Albright’s chemical engineering handbook, 2009, Boca Raton: CRC Press 709-715.

[101] Brennecke JF, Maginn EJ. Ionic liquids: innovative fluids for chemical processing. AIChE J, 2001, 47(11): 2384-2389.

[102] Khupse ND, Kumar A. Ionic liquids: new materials with wide applications. Indian J Chem, 2010, 49(5–6): 635-648.

[103] Letcher T. Thermodynamics, solubility and environmental issues, 2007, Amsterdam: Elsevier

[104] Atkins MP, Davey P, Fitzwater G, et al. Ionic liquids: a map for industrial innovation. Report Q001, January 2004, 2004, Belfast: QUILL

[105] Fitzwater G, Geissler W, Moulton R, et al. Ionic liquids: sources of innovation, report Q002, 2005, Belfast: QUILL

[106] Chemical Industry Vision 2020 Technology Partnership (2004) Accelerating ionic liquid commercialization. Research Needs to Advance New Technology, pp 1–40

Funding

Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (GB) http://dx.doi.org/10.13039/501100000266(GR/T19889/01)

Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council http://dx.doi.org/10.13039/501100000266