Light weighting opportunities and material choice for commercial vehicle frame structures from a design point of view

Abstract

This paper focuses on an estimation of light weighting opportunities for the frame structure of commercial road vehicles. This estimation is based on simplified static load cases which play a predominant role for the dimensioning of a frame structure and therefore these simplifications are not putting the general validity of the conclusions into question. A comparison of different materials under this scenario shows that light metals do not show any weight reduction advantage in comparison to steel while a material-independent topology optimization has more weight reduction potential for the frame structure than a simple change of materials. Considering the constraints of part complexity which is directly linked with production and assembly cost, the ladder frame structure has become the current state of the art design. Thus the paper also puts a spotlight on basic rules of node design and vertical load induction in order to keep the weight of such a design as low as possible. Practical examples from manufacturers show that the weight of a commercial vehicle could be reduced by 10% and main parts of the frame structure could be reduced by 30% using high strength steel in combination with innovative production methods like roll forming.

Keywords

Ladder frame / Light weighting / Commercial vehicle / Node design / High strength steel / Profile section / Vertical bending / Topology optimization

References

[1] Pippert H (1998) Car body technology: commercial vehicle superstructures and chassis frames. Vogel Verlag, Berlin, pp 120–145

[2] Truck MAN, Bus AG (2014) MAN guidelines to fitting bodies truck Series TGS/TGX Edition 2014 V2.0. https://www.manted.de/manted/aufbaurichtlinien/gb_all.html

[3] Mercedes-Benz AG (2012) Body/equipment mounting directives truck. https://www.manted.de/manted/aufbaurichtlinien/d_tgs_tgx.html. Accessed 01 Dec 2012

[4] Wohlecker R, Henn R (2009) Mass reduction potential of steel and aluminum in automotive applications. In: SAE international journal of material and manufacturing, pp 480–484

[5] Gruss M, Nagel M, Höfel P (2012) HD—High-ductility, low-alloy, fine-grain structural steels. In: ThyssenKrupp Techforum, pp 28–31

[6] Klein B (2013) Buckling of plates and tubes. Lightweight design: computation and design fundamentals. Vieweg+Teubner Verlag, Berlin, pp 232–258

[7] Schmitz Cargobull http://www.cargobull.com/de/MODULOS-Fahrzeugrahmen-MODULOS-Chassis_310_689.html. Accessed 8 Jan 2015

[8] Seyfried P, Sudowe U (2007) SLC: the innovative, low-cost lightweight construction solution for passenger car subframes. In: ThyssenKrupp techforum, pp 20–23

[9] SSAB—Swedish steel AB company brochures Domex high strength steel. www.ssab.com

[10] Appel W (2013) Commercial vehicle frames and superstructures. In: Commercial vehicle technology, Vieweg+Teubner Verlag, Berlin, pp 303–373

[11] Spangenberg D (2014) The design of machines and vehicles moving on bumpy roads. Fundamentals of agricultural engineering-edited volume, vol 12