Wave dissipation effect of a new combined breakwater and its protective performance for coastal box girder bridges

Abstract

Breakwaters play an important role in in mitigating wave-induced damage to marine structures. However, conventional submerged breakwaters often exhibit limited wave dissipation capabilities, while floating breakwaters may lack adequate safety performance. Therefore, this study introduces a novel combined breakwater design aimed at addressing the shortcomings of both traditional types. The proposed breakwater integrates a floating structure with a trapezoidal submerged breakwater via an anchor chain connection. To evaluate its efficacy, numerical simulations of wave interactions with structures were conducted using the OpenFOAM computational fluid dynamics (CFD) software in a two-dimensional (2D) numerical flume. Dynamic mesh technology was employed to simulate the motion of the floating body, and the resulting wave loads on a box girder bridge deck positioned behind the breakwater were analyzed to assess the combined breakwater’s protective capabilities and influencing factors. Analysis of wave heights and loads on the bridge deck revealed that the combined breakwater outperformed traditional submerged breakwaters in terms of wave dissipation. Furthermore, it was observed that the protective efficacy of the combined breakwater was more sensitive to variations in the size of the floating body compared to the submerged structure, and more responsive to changes in wave period than wave height. Leveraging the ability of the floating body to attenuate waves near the surface and the enhanced impact resistance provided by the combined floating and submerged structures, the proposed breakwater offers a promising approach to improving wave attenuation performance and enhancing safety for coastal infrastructure.

Keywords

Numerical method / Floating structure / Combined breakwater / Structural performance

References

[1] Akhtar A, Pareek V, Tadé M (2007) CFD simulations for continuous flow of bubbles through gas-liquid columns: application of VOF method. Chem Prod Process Model 2(1):1–19

[2] Chen H, Hall M. CFD simulation of floating body motion with mooring dynamics: coupling MoorDyn with OpenFOAM. Appl Ocean Res, 2022, 124,

[3] Dai J, Wang C, Utsunomiya T, Duan W. Review of recent research and developments on floating breakwaters. Ocean Eng, 2018, 158: 132-151,

[4] Deng X (2019) Design and performance analysis of cost-effective floating Breakwaters. Master's thesis. Jiangsu University of Science and Technology, Zhenjiang

[5] Deng L (2019a) Research on wave force calculation method of bearing platform-group pile foundation for cross-sea bridge. Doctoral Dissertation. Southwest Jiaotong University, Chengdu

[6] Domínguez JM, Crespo AJ, Hall M, Altomare C, Wu M, Stratigaki V, et al.. SPH simulation of floating structures with moorings. Coast Eng, 2019, 153: 103560,

[7] Gao Z, Ruan H, Qin S, Ma R, Mei D. Research on the Development Status, challenges and countermeasures of China’s marine bridge engineering technology. Chin Eng Sci, 2019, 21(3): 1-4,

[8] Hall M, Goupee A. Validation of a lumped-mass mooring line model with deep wind semisubmersible model test data. Ocean Eng, 2015, 104: 590-603,

[9] He J (2009) Research on wave dissipation and wave pressure characteristics of special plate breakwater. Master's thesis. Changsha Institute of Science & Technology, Changsha

[10] He C, Wang D, Feng E. Study on wave dissipation performance of rectangular square box floating breakwater. Port Waterway Eng, 2014, 1: 14-18

[11] Higuera P, Lara JL, Losada IJ. Realistic wave generation and active wave absorption for Navier–Stokes models. Coast Eng, 2013, 71: 102-118,

[12] Hirt CW, Nichols BD. Volume of fluid (VOF) method for the dynamics of free boundaries. J Comput Phys, 1981, 39(1): 201-225,

[13] Huang B, Yang Z, Zhu B, Zhang J, Kang A, Pan L. Vulnerability assessment of coastal bridge superstructure with box girder under solitary wave forces through experimental study. Ocean Eng, 2019, 189,

[14] Iemura H, Pradono M, Takahashi Y. Report on the tsunami damage of bridges in Banda Aceh and some possible countermeasures. Environ Syst Res, 2005, 28: 214-214

[15] Ji C, Chen X, Cui J, Yuan Z, Incecik A. Experimental study of a new type of floating breakwater. Ocean Eng, 2015, 105: 295-303,

[16] Jiang X, Li Y. Joint utility theory and risk quantification for decision modeling of breakwaters. Mar Notification, 2009, 28(1): 65-74

[17] Jiang X, Ma Q, Li S, Li Y. Analysis of wave force fluctuations along the embankment taking into account the wrap-around effect. J Water Resour Water Transp Eng, 2012, 5: 1-7

[18] Jin F, Qian HYM. Numerical simulation of wave dissipation performance of factory shaped plate breakwater. Port & Waterway Eng, 2023, 4: 16-21

[19] Kirca VÖ, Kabdaşli MS. Reduction of non-breaking wave loads on caisson type breakwaters using a modified perforated configuration. Ocean Eng, 2009, 36(17–18): 1316-1331,

[20] Li Z (2020) Hydrodynamic characterization of combined plate floating Breakwater. Master's thesis. Jiangsu University of Science and Technology, Zhenjiang

[21] Luan Y. Progress of floating Breakwater Research. Port & Waterway Eng, 2021, 3: 65-69

[22] Mimura N, Yasuhara K, Kawagoe S, Yokoki H, Kazama S. Damage from the Great East Japan Earthquake and Tsunami-a quick report. Mitig Adapt Strat Glob Change, 2011, 16: 803-818,

[23] Mulbah C, Kang C, Mao N, Zhang W, Shaikh AR, Teng S. A review of VOF methods for simulating bubble dynamics. Prog Nucl Energy, 2022, 154,

[24] Niu E, Ma D, Sun S. New comb type breakwater. J Civil Eng, 2003, 36(10): 51-55

[25] Qiu W, Wang Z, Jiang M, Lin L. Prediction approach for wave forces on large-scale offshore structures under linear wave action. Ocean Eng, 2022, 257,

[26] Schäffer HA, Klopman G. Review of multidirectional active wave absorption methods. J Waterw Port Coast Ocean Eng, 2000, 126(2): 88-97,

[27] Shen Y, Zhou Y, Pan J, Wang X. Progress of floating breakwater research. J Water Resour Water Transp Eng, 2016, 5: 124-132

[28] Shih R-S. Investigation of random wave impact on highly pervious pipe breakwaters. Appl Ocean Res, 2016, 58: 146-163,

[29] Sun J, Ma Z, Wang D, Dong S, Zhou T. Numerical study of the run-up of a solitary wave after propagation over a saw-tooth-shaped submerged breakwater. Int J Naval Archit Ocean Eng, 2020, 12: 283-296,

[30] Syed SA, Mani J. . Performance of Multiple Pontoons Floating Breakwater-A Numerical Approach. In Civil Engineering in the Oceans, 2006 342-355

[31] Tang Z, Wu W, Zhao S, Du MUQ, Zou B. Research on wave dissipation characteristics of an inverted π-type floating breakwater[J]. Chin J Hydrodynamics, 2023, 38(1): 53-58

[32] Ti Z, Zhang M, Li Y, Wei K. Numerical study on the stochastic response of a long-span sea-crossing bridge subjected to extreme nonlinear wave loads. Eng Struct, 2019, 196,

[33] Wan X, Li X, Xie T, Sun J, Xie X, Cheng Z. Comparison of hydrodynamic characteristics of caisson and comb breakwater based on OpenFOAM. Port & Waterway Eng, 2022, 6: 1-8

[34] Wang M (1985) Damage and prevention of sloping embankments (in Chinese), vol 3. Harbor Technology Newsletter.

[35] Wang J, He G, You R, Liu P. Numerical study on interaction of a solitary wave with the submerged obstacle. Ocean Eng, 2018, 158: 1-14,

[36] Williams A, Abul-Azm A. Dual pontoon floating breakwater. Ocean Eng, 1997, 24(5): 465-478,

[37] Williams A, Lee H, Huang Z. Floating pontoon breakwaters. Ocean Eng, 2000, 27(3): 221-240,

[38] Windt C, Davidson J, Chandar DD, Faedo N, Ringwood JV. Evaluation of the overset grid method for control studies of wave energy converters in OpenFOAM numerical wave tanks. J Ocean Eng Mar Energy, 2020, 6(1): 55-70,

[39] Wu Y (2018) Numerical study on wave dissipation performance of single-layer arc-plate breakwater structure. Master"s thesis. Ludong University, Yantai

[40] Wu M, Stratigaki V, Troch P, Altomare C, Verbrugghe T, Crespo A, et al.. Experimental study of a moored floating oscillating water column wave-energy converter and of a moored cubic box. Energies, 2019, 12(10),

[41] Xie S (1982) Breach of the breakwater in Tripoli harbor and analysis of its causes. Harbor Technology Newsletter, 15–20

[42] Xu T, Wang X, Guo W, Dong G, Hou H. Numerical simulation of combined effect of pneumatic breakwater and submerged breakwater on wave damping. Ships Offshore Struct, 2022, 17(2): 242-256,

[43] Xue S, Xu Y, Xu G, Wang J, Chen Q. A novel tri-semicircle shaped submerged breakwater for mitigating wave loads on coastal bridges part I: efficacy. Ocean Eng, 2022, 245,

[44] Yi Z (2020) Numerical simulation study on the protection mechanism of coastal columnar structures by floating breakwater. Mater's thesis. Changsha University of Science and Technology, Changsha

[45] Yin X, Wei K, Zhou C (2021) Numerical simulation of wave action at a cylindrical bridge pier considering the effect of a floating breakwater. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the 30th National Structural Engineering Conference (Volume II)

[46] Zang Z, Fang Z, Zhang N. Flow mechanism of impulsive wave forces and improvement on hydrodynamic performance of a comb-type breakwater. Coast Eng, 2018, 133: 142-158,

[47] Zhan J, Chen X, Gong Y, Hu W. Numerical investigation of the interaction between an inverse T-type fixed/floating breakwater and regular/irregular waves. Ocean Eng, 2017, 137: 110-119,

[48] Zhang R. Research on construction technology and equipment development of ocean bridge engineering. Chin Eng Sci, 2019, 21(3): 5-11,

[49] Zhao X, Cheng D, Zhang Y, Li M. Experimental and numerical study on the hydrodynamic characteristics of solitary waves passing over a submerged breakwater. China Ocean Eng, 2019, 33(3): 253-267,

[50] Zou S. Breakwater damage in Sines, Portugal. Dock Harbour Authority, 1980, 3: 342-343

Funding

National Natural Science Foundation of China(52378200)