How to conduct an acupuncture dose-effect relationship study? A discussion based on study methodology

Abstract

Acupuncture therapy is widely used in the clinic, and its therapeutic effects have been proven by numerous studies. The dose-effect relationship of acupuncture is a fundamental aspect of the acupuncture research system. Recent studies found that different acupuncture dosages altered study results directly, indicating the importance of screening the optimal stimulation dosage. However, the system for studying the acupuncture dose-effect relationship is still in its infancy, and the methodology of the system needs to be improved. This review aimed to define the factors impacting acupuncture “dosage” and “effect,” and to improve the methodological system for research on the dose-effect relationship of acupuncture. By summarizing the current findings of acupuncture dose-effect studies, we discussed the vital acupuncture parameters and methodological problems that influence the relationship between acupuncture dosage and its effects. These factors consist of specific influencing factors (acupoint selection, acupuncture manipulation parameters, de qi response) and nonspecific influencing factors (comparison selection, blinding procedure, patient expectancy). Our perspectives offer suggestions for the design of acupuncture dosage-effect trials. Further studies need to be conducted to establish the methodological system and provide systematic evidence of the acupuncture dose-effect relationship.

Keywords

Acupuncture / Dose-effect relationship / Methodology / Review

References

[[1]] Lu L, Zhang Y, Tang X, et al.Evidence on acupuncture therapies is underused in clinical practice and health policy. BMJ. 2022;376:e067475.

[[2]] Ifrim CF, Antochi AD, Barbilian AG.Acupuncture and the retrospect of its modern research. Rom [J] Morphol Embryol. 2019;60(2):411-418.

[[3]] Fei Y, Cao H, Xia R, et al.Methodological challenges in design and conduct of randomised controlled trials in acupuncture. BMJ. 2022;376:e064345.

[[4]] Shi XM.Study of the relationship between acupuncture dose and effect. Acupuncture Herbal Med. 2021;1(1):3-9.

[[5]] Schulz KF, Altman DG, Moher D, et al.CONSORT 2010 changes and testing blindness in RCTs. Lancet. 2010;375(9721):1144-1146.

[[6]] MacPherson H, Altman DG, Hammerschlag R, et al. Revised STandards for Reporting Interventions in Clinical Trials of Acupuncture (STRICTA): extending the CONSORT statement. PLoS Med. 2010;7(6):e1000261.

[[7]] Jing J, Meng X, Zhao XQ, et al.Dual antiplatelet therapy in transient ischemic attack and minor stroke with different infarction patterns: subgroup analysis of the CHANCE randomized clinical trial. JAMA Neurol. 2018;75(6):711-719.

[[8]] Ma SX.Establishing an adequate dose of acupuncture is essential for clinical trial studies. Clin Res Trials. 2020;6(2):1-3.

[[9]] Sun N, Tu JF, Lin LL, et al.Correlation between acupuncture dose and effectiveness in the treatment of knee osteoarthritis: a systematic review. Acupunct Med. 2019;37(5):261-267.

[[10]] Wen Y, Zhang C, Zhao XF, et al.Safety of different acupuncture manipulations for posterior circulation ischemia with vertigo. Neural Regen Res. 2016;11(8):1267-1273.

[[11]] Zheng XY, Yu SY, Liu LY, et al.The dose-related efficacy of acupuncture on endometrial receptivity in infertile women: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Front Public Health. 2022;10:858587.

[[12]] Cui X, Liu K, Gao XY, et al.Advancing the understanding of acupoint sensitization and plasticity through cutaneous C-nociceptors. Front Neurosci. 2022;16:822436.

[[13]] Du F, Liu S.Electroacupuncture with high frequency at acupoint ST-36 induces regeneration of lost enteric neurons in diabetic rats via GDNF and PI3K/AKT signal pathway. American Journal of Physiology-Regulatory. Integrative Comparative Physiology. 2015;309(2):R109-R118.

[[14]] Li NC, Guo Y, Gong YN, et al.The anti-inflammatory actions and mechanisms of acupuncture from acupoint to target organs via neuro-immune regulation. [J] Inflammation. Research. 2021;14:7191-7224.

[[15]] Li X, He F, Tuo X, et al.Electroacupuncture ameliorates peptic ulcer disease in association with gastroduodenal microbiota modulation in mice. Front Cell Infect Mi. 2022;12:935681.

[[16]] Zhang YQ, Jiao RM, Witt CM, et al.How to design high quality acupuncture trials—a consensus informed by evidence. BMJ. 2022;376:e067476.

[[17]] Zhao L, Li DH, Zheng H, et al.Acupuncture as adjunctive therapy for chronic stable angina: a randomized clinical trial. JAMA Intern Med. 2019;179(10):1388-1397.

[[18]] Wang Y, Hou YQ, Yang JW, et al.Acupuncture of different treatment frequency in postprandial distress syndrome: A pilot randomized clinical trial. Neurogastroenterol Motil. 2020;32(6):e13812.

[[19]] Liu ZS, Liu Y, Xu HF, et al.Effect of electroacupuncture on urinary leakage among women with stress urinary incontinence: a randomized clinical trial. JAMA. 2017;317(24):2493-2501.

[[20]] Song SM, Xu Y, Liu J, et al.Strong twirling-rotating manual acupuncture with 4 r/s is superior to 2 r/s in relieving pain by activating C-Fibers in rat models of CFA-induced pain. Evid-Based Compl Alt. 2021;2021:1-10.

[[21]] Hinman RS, McCrory P, Pirotta M, et al. Acupuncture for chronic knee pain. JAMA. 2014;312(13):1313.

[[22]] Tu JF, Yang JW, Shi GX, et al.Efficacy of intensive acupuncture versus sham acupuncture in knee osteoarthritis: A randomized controlled trial. Arthritis Rheumatol. 2020;73(3):448-458.

[[23]] Lai F, Ren Y, Lai C, et al. Acupuncture at Zusanli (ST36) for experimental sepsis: a systematic review. Evid-Based Compl Alt. 2020;2020:3620741.

[[24]] Sun XQ, Zhou HF.Investigation of relevance between partial anatomy of lianquan & panglianquan and treatment of dysphagia. [J] Liaoning Univ TCM. 2016;18(8):147-149.

[[25]] Meng YC, Wang C, Shang SQ, et al. Effects of different acupuncture depths of Lianquan (CV 23) for dysphagia after stroke: a randomized controlled trial. Zhongguo Zhen Jiu. 2015;35(10):990-994.

[[26]] Ma Y, Wei L, Wang L.Different needling depth for neck pain of cervical spondylosi: a clinical study. [J] External Therapy TCM. 2022;31(02):102-104.

[[27]] Liu CT, Shang NX, Feng ZG.On the practical significance of “superficial and deep acupuncture” from the difference of efficacy of superficial and deep acupuncture in zusanli. New Chinese Medicine. 2022;54(11):202-205.

[[28]] Sun L, Kou RZ, Liu LQ, et al.Acupuncture direction and analgesia. Zhongguo Zhen Jiu. 2017;37(3):279-283.

[[29]] Tian G, Men ZH. Dose-effect study on acupuncture at Hegu (LI4) in treating central facial palsy. Shanghai J Acu-mox. 2015;34(2):95-98.

[[30]] Li MH. About retaining needle time with acupuncture depth in Inner Canon of Huangdi classic theory and research. Guangzhou: Guangdong University of TCM2017.

[[31]] Wang T. Observation of different retention time in knee osteoarthritis. Beijing: Beijing University of TCM2016.

[[32]] Zhang LL, Chen HJ, Jiang XM, et al. Effects of acupuncture at Yanglingquan (GB 34) with different needle-retaining time on chronic inflammatory hypertonic gallbladder motility. CJTCMP. 2021;36(10):6242-6244.

[[33]] Zhang PX, Zhao ZL, Zhao XY, et al. Comparison and analysis of acupuncture treatment of shoulder pain in different courses. Inner Mongolia Med J. 2019;51(4):408-410.

[[34]] Zhang LL, Lai H, Li L, et al.Effects of acupuncture with needle manipulation at different frequencies for patients with hypertension: Result of a 24- week clinical observation. Complement Ther Med. 2019;45:142-148.

[[35]] Zhang JQ, Han K, Mu J, et al. Study on the Optimal Stimulating Parameters for Intervention on MCAo Rats by Stimulating PC 6 (Neiguan) Acupoint. J Liaoning Univ TCM. 2013;40(2):329-331.

[[36]] Wang TH, Wang MH, Shih C, et al. Comparison of physical electrical conductivity and acupuncture de-qi sensation between stainless steel needling and supercritical fluid-treated needling. Biomed J. 2021;44(6):S267-S274.

[[37]] Guo X, Liu JL, Wang SY.Deqi and qizhi in acupuncture treatment. Guiding [J] Traditional Chinese Med Pharmacy. 2018;24(16):85-86.

[[38]] Chen T, Zhang WW, Chu Y, et al.Acupuncture for pain management: molecular mechanisms of action. Am [J] Chin Med. 2020;48(4):793-811.

[[39]] Kwon OS, Kim J, Choi K, et al.Trends in deqi research: a text mining and network analysis. Integrative Med Res. 2018;7(3):231-237.

[[40]] Chang S, Kwon OS, Bang SK, et al.Peripheral sensory nerve tissue but not connective tissue is involved in the action of acupuncture. Front Neurosci. 2019;13:110.

[[41]] Nierhaus T, Chang YH, Liu B, et al.Somatosensory stimulation With XNKQ acupuncture modulates functional connectivity of motor areas. Front Neurosci. 2019;13:147.

[[42]] He R, Zhao BX.Progress of researches on mechanisms of needling and moxibustion sensations and their related sensation transmission. Acupuncture Res. 2019;44(4):307-311.

[[43]] Gong YN, Li NC, Lyu Z, et al.Theneuro-immune microenvironment of acupoints—initiation of acupuncture effectiveness. [J] Leukoc Biol. 2020;108:189-198.

[[44]] Hao XY, Ly L, Duan DX, et al.Research progress and application overview on evaluating tools of arrival of qi in acupuncture. CJTCMP. 2018;33(12):5514-5517.

[[45]] Chen HY, Ning ZP, Lam WL, et al.Types of control in acupuncture clinical trials might affect the conclusion of the trials: a review of acupuncture on pain management. [J] Acupuncture Meridian Studies. 2016;9(5):227-233.

[[46]] Chen YJ, Shimizu Bassi G, Yang YQ. Classic Chinese acupuncture versus different types of control groups for the treatment of chronic pain: review of randomized controlled trials (2000-2018). Evid-Based Compl Alt. 2019;2019:1-15.

[[47]] Kaptchuk TJ.Placebo effects in acupuncture. Med Acupuncture. 2020;32(6):352-356.

[[48]] Zhong YM, Luo XC, Chen Y, et al. Acupuncture versus sham acupuncture for simple obesity: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Postgrad Med J. 2020;96(1134):221-227.

[[49]] Vickers AJ, Vertosick EA, Lewith G, et al.Acupuncture for chronic pain: update of an individual patient data meta-analysis. [J] Pain. 2018;19(5):455-474.

[[50]] Streitberger K, Kleinhenz J.Introducing a placebo needle into acupuncture research. Lancet. 1998;352(9125):364-365.

[[51]] Park J, White A, Stevinson C, et al.Validating a new non-penetrating sham acupuncture device: two randomised controlled trials. Acupunct Med. 2002;20(4):168-174.

[[52]] Lam WC, Au KY, Qin Z, et al. Superficial needling acupuncture vs sham acupuncture for knee osteoarthritis: a randomized controlled trial. Am J Med. 2021;134(10):1286-1294.e2.

[[53]] Tu JF, Yang JW, Lin LL, et al.Efficacy of electro-acupuncture and manual acupuncture versus sham acupuncture for knee osteoarthritis: study protocol for a randomised controlled trial. Trials. 2019;20:204.

[[54]] Linde K, Niemann K, Schneider A, et al.How large are the nonspecific effects of acupuncture? A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. BMC Med. 2010;8(1):75.

[[55]] Jones SMW, Lange J, Turner J, et al.Development and validation of the EXPECT questionnaire: assessing patient expectations of outcomes of complementary and alternative medicine treatments for chronic pain. [J] Alternative Complement Med. 2016;22(11):936-946.

[[56]] Constantino MJ, Ametrano RM, Greenberg RP.Clinician interventions and participant characteristics that foster adaptive patient expectations for psychotherapy and psychotherapeutic change. Psychotherapy. 2012;49(4):557-569.

[[57]] Norcross JC. Psychotherapy Relationships That Work: Evidence-Based Responsiveness. Oxford University Press2011.

[[58]] Norberg MM, Wetterneck CT, Sass DA, et al.Development and psychometric evaluation of the Milwaukee Psychotherapy Expectations Questionnaire. [J] Clin Psychol. 2011;67(6):574-590.

[[59]] Shi GX, Yang XM, Liu CZ, et al.Factors contributing to therapeutic effects evaluated in acupuncture clinical trials. Trials. 2012;13:42.

[[60]] Prady SL, Burch J, Vanderbloemen L, et al.Measuring expectations of benefit from treatment in acupuncture trials: a systematic review. Complement Ther Med. 2015;23(2):185-199.

[[61]] Zhang JL, Zhai X, Wang X, et al.The effect of thunder-fire moxibustion on lumbar disc herniation: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial. Front Public Health. 2022;10:930830.

[[62]] Tu JF, Wang LQ, Liu JH, et al.Home-based transcutaneous electrical acupoint stimulation for hypertension: a randomized controlled pilot trial. Hypertens Res. 2021;44:1300-1306.

[[63]] Schwehr NA, Shippee ND, Johnson PJ. Acupuncture “dose” (Number of Treatments) and Insurance Benefits in the USA. Acupunct Med. 2018;36(2):88-95.

[[64]] Liou KT, Hung TKW, Meghani SH, et al.What if acupuncture were covered by insurance for pain management? a cross-sectional study of cancer patients at one academic center and 11 community hospitals. Pain Med. 2019;20(10):2060-2068.

[[65]] Candon M, Nielsen A, Dusek JA.Trends in insurance coverage for acupuncture, 2010-2019. JAMA Network Open. 2022;5(1):e2142509.

[[66]] Bleck R, Marquez E, Gold MA, et al.A scoping review of acupuncture insurance coverage in the United States. Acupunct Med. 2021;39(5):461-470.

[[67]] Lyu W, Kang LJ, Chen XF, et al. Start and transduction of acupuncture physical signals in Acupoint. Shanghai J Acu-mox. 2022;41(7):737-741.

[[68]] Ali U, Apryani E, Wu H, et al. Low frequency electroacupuncture alleviates neuropathic pain by activation of spinal microglial IL-10/β-endorphin pathway. Biomed Pharmacother. 2020;125:109898.

[[69]] Chang S, Ryu Y, Gwak YS, et al. Spinal pathways involved in somatosensory inhibition of the psychomotor actions of cocaine. Sci Rep. 2017;7(1):5359.

[[70]] Fox JR, Gray W, Koptiuch C, et al.Anisotropic tissue motion induced by acupuncture needling along intermuscular connective tissue planes. [J] Alternative Complement Med. 2014;20:290-294.

[[71]] Langevin HM.Acupuncture, connective tissue, and peripheral sensory modulation. Crit Rev Eukaryot Gene Expr. 2014;24(3):249-253.

[[72]] Wu ML, Xu DS, Bai WZ, et al. Local cutaneous nerve terminal and mast cell responses to manual acupuncture in acupoint LI4 area of the rats. [J] Chem Neuroanat. 2015;6814:21.

[[73]] Ma QF. Somatotopic organization of autonomic reflexes by acupuncture. Curr Opin Neurobiol. 2022;76:102602.

[[74]] Li H, Sang L, Xia X, et al.Therapeutic duration and extent affect the effect of moxibustion on depression-like behaviour in rats via regulating the brain tryptophan transport and metabolism. Evid-Based Compl Alt. 2019;2019:1-10.