Chinese herbal medicine and COVID-19: quality evaluation of clinical guidelines and expert consensus and analysis of key recommendations

Abstract

Objective:To systematically review the clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) for the treatment of patients with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) using Chinese herbal medicine (CHM), assess the methodological quality as well as clinical credibility and implementability of specific recommendations, and summarize key recommendations.

Methods:As of April 2022, we conducted a comprehensive search on major electronic databases, guideline websites, academic society websites, and government websites to assess the methodological quality and clinical applicability of the included CPGs using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE) II tool and Evaluation-Recommendations EXcellence (AGREE-REX) instructions, respectively.

Results:The search yielded 61 CPGs, which were mostly published in 2020; moreover, 98.4% of the CPGs were published in China. Only five CPGs achieved a high-quality AGREE II rating; further, six CPGs could be directly recommended, with most of the CPGs still showing much room for improvement. CPGs had a low overall score in the AGREE-REX evaluation, with the domains of clinical applicability, values and preferences, and implementability being standardized in 21.80%β±β12.56%, 16.00%β±β11.81%, and 31.33%β±β14.55% of the CPGs, respectively. Five high-quality CPGs mentioned 56 Chinese herbal formulas. Half of the recommendations had moderate or strong evidence level in the GRADE evaluation. The most frequently recommended herbal medicines were Lianhua Qingwen granule/capsule and Jinhua Qinggan granule; however, the strength of recommendation for each prescription varied across CPGs and populations.

Conclusions:The overall quality of current CPGs for COVID-19 for CHM still needs to be improved; moreover, the strength of the evidence remains to be standardized across CPGs.

Keywords

AGREE II / AGREE-REX / Chinese herbal formulations / COVID-19 / Guideline / Quality evaluation

References

[[1]] Li YX, Li J, Zhang Y, et al. Clinical practice guidelines and experts’ consensuses for treatment of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) patients with Chinese herbal medicine: a systematic review. Chin J Integr Med. 2020;26(10):786-793.

[[2]] Munster VJ, Koopmans M, van Doremalen N, et al. A novel coronavirus emerging in China - key questions for impact assessment. N Engl J Med. 2020;382(8):692-694.

[[3]] Ghosh N, Nandi S, Saha I.A review on evolution of emerging SARS-CoV-2 variants based on spike glycoprotein. Int Immunopharmacol. 2022;105:108565.

[[4]] World Health Organization. Numbers at a glance. Available from: https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019.

[[5]] Guan WJ, Ni ZY, Hu Y, et al. Clinical characteristics of coronavirus disease 2019 in China. N Engl J Med. 2020;382(18):1708-1720.

[[6]] Zhong LLD, Lam WC, Yang W, et al. Potential targets for treatment of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19): a review of Qing-Fei-Pai-Du-Tang and its major herbs. Am J Chin Med. 2020;48(5):1051-1071.

[[7]] Fan SJ, Liao JK, Wei L, et al.Treatment efficacy of Lianhua Qingwen capsules for early-stage COVID-19. Am J Transl Res. 2022;14(2):1332-1338.

[[8]] Xia QD, Xun Y, Lu JL, et al.Network pharmacology and molecular docking analyses on Lianhua Qingwen capsule indicate Akt1 is a potential target to treat and prevent COVID-19. Cell Prolif. 2020;53(12):e12949.

[[9]] Zhuang W, Fan Z, Chu Y, et al. Chinese patent medicines in the treatment of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) in China. Front Pharmacol. 2020;11:1066.

[[10]] Niu WH, Wu F, Cao WY, et al. Network pharmacology for the identification of phytochemicals in traditional Chinese medicine for COVID-19 that may regulate interleukin-6. Biosci Rep. 2021;41(1):BSR20202583.

[[11]] National Health Commission, National Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Diagnosis and treatment plan for pneumonia caused by novel coronavirus infection (trial version 3). Tianjin J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;37(1):1-3.

[[12]] Hu YQ, Lu JQ, Tang N. Expert consensus on TCM prevention and treatment of COVID-19 in Guangxi Zhuang autonomous region (first edition). Guangxi J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;43(2):1-4.

[[13]] Zhang W, Shen N, Tian M, et al.Expert consensus on treatment of recovery period of COVID-19 by traditional Chinese medicine in Shandong Province. Shandong J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;39(5):438-440.

[[14]] Lin L, Chen YL, Tan XY, et al. TCM treatment plan for COVID-19 in Guangdong Province (Trial version 2). J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;61(14):1197-1199.

[[15]] WHO. WHO Expert Meeting on Evaluation of Traditional Chinese Medicine in the Treatment of COVID-19. Available from: https://www.who.int/publications/m/item/who-expert-meeting-on-evaluation-of-traditional-chinese-medicine-in-the-treatment-of-covid-19.

[[16]] Santero M, Meade AG, Acosta-Dighero R, et al.European clinical practice guidelines on the use of chemotherapy for advanced oesophageal and gastric cancers: a critical review using the AGREE II and the AGREE-REX instruments. Clin Transl Oncol. 2022;24(8):1588-1604.

[[17]] Middleton JC, Kalogeropoulos C, Middleton JA, et al.Assessing the methodological quality of the Canadian Psychiatric Association’s anxiety and depression clinical practice guidelines. J Eval Clin Pract. 2019;25(4):613-621.

[[18]] Wan KR, Zeng GQ, Li Y, et al. Quality changes of clinical practice guidelines for respiratory diseases in China: a systematic review. Clin Respir J. 2021;15(9):983-991.

[[19]] Dans AL, Dans LF. Appraising a tool for guideline appraisal (the AGREE II instrument). J Clin Epidemiol. 2010;63(12):1281-1282.

[[20]] AGREE-REX Research Team. The appraisal of guidelines research & Evaluation- Recommendation EXcellence (AGREE-REX). Available from: https://www.agreetrust.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/AGREE-REX-2019.pdf.

[[21]] Institute of Medicine (US) Committee on Standards for Developing Trustworthy Clinical Practice Guidelines. Clinical Practice Guidelines We Can Trust. Washington (DC): National Academies Press (US), 2011:188-201.

[[22]] Brouwers MC, Kho ME, Browman GP, et al. AGREE II: advancing guideline development, reporting and evaluation in health care. CMAJ. 2010;182(18):E839-E842.

[[23]] Sun W, An LY, Bao XD, et al. Consensus and controversy among severe pancreatitis surgery guidelines: a guideline evaluation based on the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II (AGREE II) tool. Gland Surg. 2020;9(5):1551-1563.

[[24]] Shrout PE, Fleiss JL. Intraclass correlations: uses in assessing rater reliability. Psychol Bull. 1979;86(2):420-428.

[[25]] Lee BJ, Lee JA, Kim KI, et al. A consensus guideline of herbal medicine for coronavirus disease 2019. Integr Med Res. 2020;9(3):100470.

[[26]] Wuhan University Central South Hospital Novel Coronavirus Pneumonia Prevention and Control Group. Expert consensus on rational use of Chinese herbal medicine for COVID-19(First Edition). Beijing J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;7(2):51-64.

[[27]] Chinese Association of Integrative Medicine. Experts consensus on prevention and treatment of coronavirus disease 2019 by integrative medicine. Acta Chin Med. 2020;35(4):681-688.

[[28]] Li ZY, Xie ZJ, Li HC, et al.Guidelines on the treatment with integrated traditional Chinese medicine and Western medicine for severe coronavirus disease 2019. Pharmacol Res. 2021;174:105955.

[[29]] Ge L, Zhu H, Wang Q, et al. Integrating Chinese and Western medicine for COVID-19: a living evidence-based guideline (version 1). J Evid Based Med. 2021;14(4):313-332.

[[30]] Ji YH, Zhan QY, Peng ZY, et al. Chemoprophylaxis, diagnosis, treatments, and discharge management of COVID-19: an evidence-based clinical practice guideline (updated version). Med J Chin PLA. 2020;45(10):1003-1031.

[[31]] Guangdong Association of Chinese Integrative Medicine. Expert consensus on preventing and treating novel coronavirus disease 2019 in Guangdong with integrated traditional Chinese and western medicine (trial version 1). World Chin Med. 2020;15(5):805-812.

[[32]] China Association of Chinese Medicine. Chinese Association of Rehabilitation Medicine. Guidelines for rehabilitation of novel coronavirus pneumonia during the recovery phase of Chinese and Western medicine (version 1). Tianjin J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;37(5):484-489.

[[33]] Chinese Association of Integrative Medicine. Experts consensus on prevention and treatment of coronavirus disease 2019 by integrative medicine. Chin J Integr Tradit West Med. 2020;40(12):1413-1423.

[[34]] Ma ZP, Yin ZM, Wei GS, et al. Chinese medicine treatment protocol for novel coronavirus pneumonia in Shaanxi Province (trial version 2). Shaanxi J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;41(3):275-277.

[[35]] Jin R, Kong LW, Yan D, et al. Consensus on the safe and rational use of early intervention Chinese patent medicines in the corona-virus disease 2019 (COVID 19)(Beijing). Chin J Hosp Pharm. 2020;40(8):837-846.

[[36]] Li Q, Chen ZB. Expert consensus on the prevention and treatment of COVID-19 with traditional Chinese medicine in Fujian Province (fifth edition). Fujian J Tradit Chin Med. 2022;53(3):1-3.

[[37]] Miao Q, Shi LQ, Feng JH, et al.Expert consensus on prevention and treatment of COVID-19 with proprietary Chinese medicines. Chin J Integr Tradit West Med. 2022;42(3):294-297.

[[38]] Feng CL, Cui HS, Yu HY, et al. Expert guidance on a comprehensive Chinese medicine intervention program for recovery from novel coronavirus pneumonia (draft). Beijing J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;39(2):102-104.

[[39]] Yang L, Xu J, Li J. Expert consensus on rational use of Chinese herbal medicine for COVID-19 (first edition). Beijing J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;39(7):657-664.

[[40]] Nian JY, Gao C, Yang Y, et al.Expert consensus on clinical management strategy of integrated traditional Chinese and Western medicine for cancer patients during COVID-19 epidemic. Beijing J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;39(7):665-668.

[[41]] Shenzhen Critical Care Medical Expert Group for COVID-19 Treatment. The Shenzhen 2020 guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of severe (severe/critical) corona virus disease 2019. Chin J Integr Tradit West Med Intensive Crit Care. 2020;27(1):6-9.

[[42]] Hubei TCM Society of Geriatric Professional Committee. Expert consensus on novel coronavirus pneumonia prevention and treatment in elderly (first edition). Hubei J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;42(2):3-6.

[[43]] Xiong XL, Yan SQ, Tang JQ, et al. Expert consensus on diagnosis and treatment of children’s 2019 novel coronavirus infection with integrated traditional Chinese and Western medicine. Chin J Integr Tradit West Med Intensive Crit Care. 2020;27(2):129-133.

[[44]] Hu ZW, Wang B, Xiao L, et al. Expert consensus on combination of Chinese and western medicine for prevention, treatment and rehabilitation during the novel coronavirus pneumonia outbreak in tumor patients in Hubei region (first edition). Her Med. 2020;39(5):591-593.

[[45]] Shen KL, Yang YH, Jiang RM, et al. Updated diagnosis, treatment and prevention of COVID-19 in children: experts’ consensus statement (condensed version of the second edition). World J Pediatr. 2020;16(3):232-239.

[[46]] Beijing University of Chinese Medicine. Diagnosis and treatment protocol for COVID-19 (trial version 7) traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) treatment. World J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;6(2):121-123.

[[47]] Jiang RM, Xie ZD, Jiang Y, et al. Diagnosis, treatment and prevention of 2019 novel coronavirus infection in children: experts′ consensus statement (third edition). Chin J Appl Clin Pediatr. 2021;36(10):721-732.

[[48]] General Office of National Health Commission of the People’s Republic of China, Office of National Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine of the People’s Republic of China. Corona virus disease-19 prevention and control consensus diagnosis and treatment of corona virus disease-19(9th trial edition). Chin Med. 2022;17(4):481-487.

[[49]] Zhao M, Qin EQ, Zhang DW, et al.Expert consensus on clinical prevention and treatment of COVID-19. Med J Chin PLA. 2020;45(11):1109-1116.

[[50]] Jiangsu Commission of Health. Jiangsu provincial scheme of TCM differentiation and treatment to COVID-19 the 3rd trial edition. Jiangsu J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;52(4):7-8.

[[51]] Military Medical Expert Group on the Front-line. Diagnosis and treatment protocol for COVID-19 from military medical team supporting Wuhan (trial version 2). Chin J Tuberc Respir Dis. 2020;43(5):414-420.

[[52]] Nanjing Health Commission Nanjing Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Nanjing scheme of traditional Chinese medicine prevention and treatment to COVID-19 (trial). Jiangsu J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;52(4):9-10.

[[53]] Zou BL, Li M, Fan TB, et al.Experience summary and suggestion on diagnosis and treatment program of traditional Chinese medicine treating severe type coronavirus disease 2019. J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;61(15):1289-1293.

[[54]] Mao JY, Bi YF, Sun HY, et al.Traditional Chinese medicine treatment plan for the patients with novel coronavirus pneumonia in Tianjin area. Tianjin J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;37(4):361-362.

[[55]] Ba YM, Li XD, Min XJ, et al. Novel coronavirus pneumonia in Hubei provincial hospital of TCM: a Chinese medicine prevention and treatment plan (Third edition). Hubei J Tradit Chin Med. 2020;42(2):7-8.

[[56]] Chen G, Liu YJ. Chinese medicine treatment and prevention of novel coronavirus pneumonia (Tongji Hospital, Huazhong University of Science and Technology). Her Med. 2020;39(3):308-309.

[[57]] The Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region Health and Health Committee. Prevention and treatment protocols for COVID-19 in Mongolian medicine. Available from: http://wjw.nmg.gov.cn/zfxxgk/fdzzgknr/wjzt/202106/t20210615_1620948.html. Accessed April 10, 2022.

[[58]] Anhui Association of China Medicine. Recommended Chinese medicine intervention program for COVID-19 infection in Anhui Province. Available from: http://wjw.ah.gov.cn/ztzl/zyygljzt/zyyztsy/zhxw/56171911.html. Accessed April 10, 2022.

[[59]] Sichuan Province Pharmaceutical Administration. Chinese medicine for pneumonia with COVID-19 infection in Sichuan Province. Available from: https://www.sc.gov.cn/10462/12771/2020/1/25/0d37953ca2534d5382ba744e81725469.shtml.

[[60]] Health Commission of Shandong Province. Chinese medicine prevention and treatment programme for COVID-19 in Shandong Province. Available from: http://wsjkw.shandong.gov.cn/zwgk/fdzdgknr/tzwj/202005/t20200512_3444768.html.

[[61]] Shuguang Hospital, Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Shanghai expert consensus on the treatment of COVID-19 infections in Chinese medicine (2022 spring edition). Available from: https://zynj.shutcm.edu.cn/2022/0329/c4359a140758/page.htm.

[[62]] Health Commission of Hebei Province. Chinese medicine prevention and treatment programme for COVID-19 in Hebei Province (trial version 6). Available from: http://wsjkw.hebei.gov.cn/zcfg2/387099.jhtml.

[[63]] Tianjin Municipal Health and Health Committee. Chinese medicine prevention and treatment program for COVID-19 in Tianjin (trial version V). Available from: http://wsjk.tj.gov.cn/ZWGK3158/ZCFG6243_1/GZWJ625/202112/t20211227_5762295.html.

[[64]] Health Commission of Liaoning Province. Chinese medicine treatment protocol for pneumonia with COVID-19 infection in Liaoning Province (trial version 2). Available from: http://wsjk.ln.gov.cn/gsga/202002/t20200203_3733243.html.

[[65]] Hunan Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine. TCM diagnosis and treatment protocol for COVID-19 in Hunan Province (trial version 3). Available from: http://tcm.hunan.gov.cn/tcm/xxgk/tzgg/202002/t20200203_11168981.html.

[[66]] Health Commission of Taiyuan. Guidelines on prevention of traditional Chinese medicine for COVID-19 in Taiyuan. Available from: http://wjw.taiyuan.gov.cn//doc/2020/02/01/954877.shtml.

[[67]] Health Commission of Henan Province. TCM prevention and treatment of COVID-19 in Henan Province. Available from: http://wsjkw.henan.gov.cn/2022/01-12/2381435.html.

[[68]] Health Commission of Yunan Province. Prevention and treatment in COVID-19 infection with traditional Chinese medicine in Yunnan Province (trial version 2). Available from: http://ynswsjkw.yn.gov.cn/wjwWebsite/web/doc/UU158140615448559052.

[[69]] Health Commission of Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region. Prevention and treatment of COVID-19 with traditional Chinese medicine in Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region. Available from: http://wjw.xinjiang.gov.cn/hfpc/zyyfw/202001/d99c1db0128f4ce5ac1edd09b130a81e.shtml.

[[70]] Tibetan Medicine Administration of Tibet Autonomous Region. Tibetan medicine prevention and treatment plan for COVID-19 in Tibet Autonomous Region. Available from: http://ex.chinadaily.com.cn/exchange/partners/82/rss/channel/cn/columns/j3u3t6/stories/WS5e2f9dfca3107bb6b579bed2.html.

[[71]] Health Commission of Qinghai Province. Prevention and treatment of COVID-19 with traditional Chinese medicine in Qinghai Province (trial version 2). Available from: http://wsjkw.qinghai.gov.cn/zwgk/xxgkml/zcyy/2020/02/25/1582597802814.html.

[[72]] Guizhou Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine. TCM prevention and treatment plan for COVID-19 in Guizhou Province (fourth edition). Available from: http://atcm.guizhou.gov.cn/zwgk/xxgkml/jcxxgk/zcwj_5130534/bmwj/202201/t20220127_72429283.html.

[[73]] Hainan Epidemic Prevention and Control Headquarters. Prevention and treatment of COVID-19 with traditional Chinese medicine in Hainan Province (public trial version 2). Available from: http://www.hainan.gov.cn/hainan/yycy/202002/533b405bce224f2fbf9071e74631430c.shtml.

[[74]] Hubei Provincial Hospital of TCM. Hubei Provincial Hospital of TCM developed 8 protocols for the prevention and treatment of Chinese medicine. Available from: http://www.zyzf.gov.cn/xwzx/gjj/202001/t20200125_2017327.shtml.

[[75]] Heilongjiang Provincial Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Prevention and treatment of COVID-19 with TCM in Heilongjiang Province (second edition). Available from: http://wsjkw.hlj.gov.cn/pages/5ee9973b6df5eb2e2420739e.

[[76]] Jiangxi Provincial Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Prevention and treatment of COVID-19 by TCM in Jiangxi Province (Trial version 3). Available from: http://hc.jiangxi.gov.cn/art/2020/3/27/art_38264_2417746.html. Accessed April 10, 2022.

[[77]] Health Commission of Shizuishan. Prevention and treatment of COVID-19 with TCM in Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region (trial). Available from: http://wjw.shizuishan.gov.cn/xwzx/yzyg/202003/t20200310_1985554.html. Accessed April 10, 2022.

[[78]] Tianjin municipal health and Health Committee. Prevention and treatment of COVID-19 with traditional Chinese medicine in Tianjin (Trial version VI). Available from: http://wsjk.tj.gov.cn/ZWGK3158/ZCFG6243_1/GZWJ625/202201/t20220124_5788132.html.

[[79]] Beijing Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Prevention and treatment of COVID-19 by traditional Chinese medicine in Beijing (Trial Version 6). Available from: http://zyj.beijing.gov.cn/sy/tzgg/202205/t20220506_2702478.html.

[[80]] Health Commission of Gansu Province. Prevention and treatment of COVID-19 with traditional Chinese medicine in Gansu Province. Available from: http://wsjk.gansu.gov.cn/wsjk/c112819/202001/1273197.shtml. Accessed April 10, 2022.

[[81]] Health Commission of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region. TCM treatment of COVID-19 in Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region. Available from: http://wsjkw.gxzf.gov.cn/ztbd_49627/sszt/xxgzbdfyyqfk/zcwj_49666/t5709539.shtml.

[[82]] Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine of Jilin Province. TCM prevention and treatment plan for COVID-19 in Jilin Province. Available from: http://jltcm.jl.gov.cn/tzgg/xgdt/202101/t20210120_7918314.html.