Geomorphology-Driven variations in mangrove carbon stocks and economic valuation across fringing, estuarine, and riverine ecosystems

Abstract

Mangrove ecosystems play a vital role in climate change mitigation by capturing and storing carbon, particularly in their soils. As essential coastal wetlands, they contribute significantly to blue carbon sequestration, helping to offset greenhouse gas emissions and mitigate global change. This study evaluates vegetation and soil carbon stocks, along with their economic valuation, across three distinct geomorphological settings: bordering mangroves in Nusa Lembongan, estuarine mangroves in Benoa Bay, and riverine mangroves in Estuary Perancak. Soil samples were analyzed for organic carbon, bulk density, and various physical and chemical properties, and carbon economic value was estimated using the World Bank’s proposed carbon tax rates. The results revealed significant differences (ρ < 0.05) in soil carbon stocks across the sites, with Estuary Perancak showing the highest values due to its riverine characteristics, while Nusa Lembongan had the lowest values, attributed to sandy soils and limited organic input. Vegetation carbon stocks did not differ significantly among the locations. The economic assessment highlighted a range of values, from 27,622 to 87,925 USD tonCO₂⁻¹ ha⁻¹, demonstrating the financial benefits of mangrove conservation and restoration. Strong positive correlations were observed between soil carbon storage and parameters such as canopy coverage, water content, and clay content, whereas bulk density and salinity were negatively correlated. These findings underscore the critical influence of geomorphology on carbon sequestration in both vegetation and soil, while highlighting the ecological and economic value of mangroves. The study provides valuable insights to support sustainable management and conservation strategies, contributing to global climate mitigation efforts and advancing Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) 13, 14, and 15.

Keywords

Coastal wetlands / Blue carbon / Global change / Greenhouse gases / Carbon sequestration / SDGs / Environmental Sciences / Environmental Science and Management / Soil Sciences / Biological Sciences / Ecology

References

[1] Abdul-HamidH, Mohamad-IsmailFN, MohamedJ, SamdinZ, AbiriR, Tuan-IbrahimTM, MohammadLS, JalilAM, NajiHR. Allometric equation for aboveground biomass estimation of mixed mature mangrove forest. Forests, 2022, 132325.

[2] AdameMF, LovelockCE. Carbon and nutrient exchange of mangrove forests with the coastal ocean. Hydrobiologia, 2011, 663: 23-50.

[3] AlhassanAB, AljahdaliMO. Nutrient and physicochemical properties as potential causes of stress in mangroves of the central Red Sea. PLoS ONE, 2021, 1612. e0261620

[4] AlongiDM. Carbon cycling and storage in mangrove forests. Ann Rev Mar Sci, 2014, 6: 195-219.

[5] AlongiDM. Carbon balance in salt marsh and mangrove ecosystems: A global synthesis. Journal of Marine Science and Engineering, 2020, 810767.

[6] Alsumaiti, T., and Shahid, S (2018) A comprehensive analysis of mangrove soil in Eastern Lagoon National Park of Abu Dhabi Emirate. Int J Business Appl Soc Sci 4(5).

[7] AmorimHC, AraujoMA, LalR, ZinnYL. What C: N ratios in soil particle-size fractions really say: N is preferentially sorbed by clays over organic C. CATENA, 2023, 230. 107230

[8] Asdourian, E., and Wessel, D. (2023). What is the social cost of carbon? Retrieved from https://www.brookings.edu/articles/what-is-the-social-cost-of-carbon/

[9] AshworthJ, KeyesD, KirkR, LessardR. Standard procedure in the hydrometer method for particle size analysis. Commun Soil Sci Plant Anal, 2001, 325–6633-642.

[10] As-syakurAR, SetiawatiMD, NovandaIGA, RachmanHA, WirayudaIKAK, AryunishaPEP, SaifullohM, PratamaRT. Spatio-Temporal Variation Trends of Mangrove Canopy Cover in Urban Areas Using Landsat 8 Imagery and Implications of Management Policies: A Case Study of the Benoa Bay Mangrove Area, Bali. Indonesia Wild, 2025, 218.

[11] As-syakur AR, Wijaya IMS, Andiani AAE, Dewi IGAIP, Sugiana IP, Faiqoh E, Wiyanto DB, and Rachman HA (2023) Pedoman Identifikasi Mangrove di Bali. PenerbitAVI, Badung-Indonesia.

[12] BaiJ, MengY, GouR, LyuJ, DaiZ, DiaoX, ZhangH, LuoY, ZhuX, LinG. Mangrove diversity enhances plant biomass production and carbon storage in Hainan Island. China Functional Ecology, 2021, 353774-786.

[13] BuntingP, RosenqvistA, LucasRM, RebeloLM, HilaridesL, ThomasN, HardyA, ItohT, ShimadaM, FinlaysonCM. The global mangrove watch—a new 2010 global baseline of mangrove extent. Remote Sensing, 2018, 10101669.

[14] ChaveJ, AndaloC, BrownS, et al. . Tree allometry and improved estimation of carbon density and balance in tropical forests. Oecologia, 2005, 145: 87-99.

[15] ChenGC, UlumuddinYI, PramudjiS, ChenSY, ChenB, YeY, OuDY, MaZY, HuangH, WangJK. Rich soil carbon and nitrogen but low atmospheric greenhouse gas fluxes from North Sulawesi mangrove swamps in Indonesia. Sci Total Environ, 2014, 487: 91-96.

[16] ChenG, ChenB, YuD, TamNF, YeY, ChenS. Soil greenhouse gas emissions reduce the contribution of mangrove plants to the atmospheric cooling effect. Environ Res Lett, 2016, 1112. 124019

[17] ChenD, KeZ, TanY. Distribution of C/N/P stoichiometry in suspended particulate matter and surface sediment in a bay under serious anthropogenic influence: Daya Bay, China. Environ Sci Pollut Res, 2021, 28: 29177-29187.

[18] CraftCB, SenecaED, BroomeSW. Loss on ignition and Kjeldahl digestion for estimating organic carbon and total nitrogen in estuarine marsh soils: calibration with dry combustion. Estuaries, 1991, 14: 175-179.

[19] DangremondEM, FellerIC, SousaWP. Environmental tolerances of rare and common mangroves along light and salinity gradients. Oecologia, 2015, 179: 1187-1198.

[20] DhaouD, GrosR, BaldyV, AdotéviA, GaboriauM, EstevezY, LecareuxC, DupouyetS, FernandezC, Bousquet-MélouA. Comparison of leaf litter decomposition and microbial decomposer communities in fringe and riverine mangroves in French Guiana. Reg Environ Change, 2022, 223102.

[21] Dharmawan, I.W.E., and Ulumuddin, Y.I (2021) Mangrove Community Structure Data Analysis, A Guidebook for Mangrove Health Index (MHI) Training. Nas Media Pustaka, Makassar.

[22] Dharmawan, I.W.E (2020) Hemispherical Photography: Analisis Tutupan Kanopi Komunitas Mangrove. Nas Media Pustaka, Makassar.

[23] Dharmayasa, I.G.P.N., Ngurah, I.G., Sugiana, I.P., Prapaspongsa, T. (2025). Soil organic matter in natural and rehabilitated mangroves: Implications for environmental restoration and climate resilience. Journal of Ecological Engineering, 26;(1):153–162. https://doi.org/10.12911/22998993/195515

[24] Dharmayasa IGPN, Sugiana IP, Putri PYA, Boonyasana K (2024) Assessment of soil fraction, carbon storage capacity, and rate of carbon uptake from three coastal ecosystems: Mangroves, seagrass, and mudflats in Benoa Bay, Indonesia. Biodiversitas 25(6):2541-2549. https://doi.org/10.13057/biodiv/d250623

[25] DonatoDC, KauffmanJB, MurdiyarsoD, KurniantoS, StidhamM, KanninenM. Mangroves among the most carbon-rich forests in the tropics. Nat Geosci, 2011, 45293-297.

[26] DookieS, JaikishunS, AnsariAA. Soil and water relations in mangrove ecosystems in Guyana. Geology, Ecology, and Landscapes, 2024, 83445-469.

[27] EmrinelsonT, WarningsihT. Estimations of carbon storage and economic value of mangrove forest on the North Coast of Cawan Island, Indragiri Hilir. Asian Journal of Aquatic Sciences, 2024, 7161-73.

[28] Ernawati NM, Astarini IA, Suarna IW, As-Syakur A, Perwira IY, Krisna Dewi AP, Sugiana IP (2024) Comparison of soil carbon-nitrogen ratio at two different mangrove ecosystems in Bali, Indonesia. Ecol Eng Environ Technol. 25(7), 343–354. https://doi.org/10.12912/27197050/188738

[29] EwelK, BourgeoisJ, ColeT, ZhengS. Variation in environmental characteristics and vegetation in high-rainfall mangrove forests, Kosrae. Micronesia Global Ecology and Biogeography Letters, 1998, 7149-56.

[30] Farahisah, H., Yulianda, F., Effendi, H. (2021). Struktur komunitas, cadangan karbon, dan estimasi nilai ekonomi mangrove di Muara Sungai Musi. Jurnal Ilmu Pertanian Indonesia, 26;(2):228–234. https://doi.org/10.18343/jipi.26.2.228

[31] Fuchs M, Stroebel J, Terstegge J (2024) Carbon vix: Carbon price uncertainty and decarbonization investments. NBER Working Paper 32937. National Bureau of Economic Research. Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States.

[32] GaoY, ZhouJ, WangL, GuoJ, FengJ, WuH. Distribution patterns and controlling factors for the soil organic carbon in four mangrove forests of China. Global Ecology and Conservation, 2019, 17. e00575

[33] HallSJ, McDowellWH, SilverWL. When wet gets wetter: Decoupling of moisture, redox biogeochemistry, and greenhouse gas fluxes in a humid tropical forest soil. Ecosystems, 2013, 16: 576-589.

[34] HarishmaKM, SandeepS, SreekumarVB. Biomass and carbon stocks in mangrove ecosystems of Kerala, southwest coast of India. Ecol Process, 2020, 9: 1-9.

[35] Hong LC, Hemati Z, Zakaria R (2017) Carbon stock evaluation of selected mangrove forests in Peninsular Malaysia and its potential market value. J Environ Sci Manage. 20(2). https://doi.org/10.47125/jesam/2017_2/09

[36] Huluka, G., and Miller, R. (2014). Particle size determination by hydrometer method. Southern Cooperative Series Bulletin, 419, 180–184. https://aesl.ces.uga.edu/sera6/PUB/MethodsManualFinalSERA6.pdf#page=188

[37] Husna VN (2019) Estimasi cadangan karbon biomassa di atas permukaan pada tegakan mangrove menggunakan pengindraan jauh di Tongke-Tongke, Sulawesi Selatan. Jurnal Pengelolaan Sumberdaya Alam dan Lingkungan, 9(2), 456–466. https://doi.org/10.29244/jpsl.9.2.456-466

[38] JakovacCC, LatawiecAE, LacerdaE, LucasIL, KorysKA, IribarremA, MalagutiGA, TurnerRK, LuisettiT, StrassburgBBN. Costs and carbon benefits of mangrove conservation and restoration: A global analysis. Ecol Econ, 2020, 176. 106758

[39] JerathM, BhatM, Rivera-MonroyVH, Castañeda-MoyaE, SimardM, TwilleyRR. The role of economic, policy, and ecological factors in estimating the value of carbon stocks in Everglades mangrove forests, South Florida, USA. Environ Sci Policy, 2016, 66: 160-169.

[40] Juanico DE, and Salmo III S (2014) Simulated effects of site salinity and inundation on long-term growth trajectory and carbon sequestration in monospecific Rhizophora mucronata plantation in the Philippines. arXiv:1405.6944. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1405.6944

[41] KarpowiczDA, MohanM, WattMS, MontenegroJF, KingSA, SelvamPP, NithyanandanM, RobynB, AliT, AbdullahMG, DoaemoW, EwaneEB. Mangrove-based carbon market projects: 15 considerations for engaging and supporting local communities. Diversity, 2024, 169574.

[42] KauffmanJB, BhomiaRK. Ecosystem carbon stocks of mangroves across broad environmental gradients in West-Central Africa: Global and regional comparisons. PLoS ONE, 2017, 1211. e0187749

[43] KauffmanJB, AdameMF, ArifantiVB, et al. . Total ecosystem carbon stocks of mangroves across broad global environmental and physical gradients. Ecol Monogr, 2020, 902. e01405

[44] Kauffman JB, and Donato DC (2012) Protocols for the measurement, monitoring, and reporting of structure, biomass, and carbon stocks in mangrove forests (Vol. 86). CIFOR, Bogor. https://www.cifor-icraf.org/publications/pdf_files/WPapers/WP86CIFOR.pdf

[45] Kauffman BJ, Donato DC, Adame MF (2014) Protocols for the measurement, monitoring and reporting of structure, biomass and carbon stocks in mangrove forests (Protocolo para la medición, monitoreo y reporte de la estructura, biomasa y reservas de carbono de los manglares). Working paper 117, Center for International Forestry Research, Bogor, Indonesia, 37 pp. https://www.cifor-icraf.org/publications/pdf_files/WPapers/WP117Kauffman.pdf

[46] Kida M, Fujitake N (2020) Organic carbon stabilization mechanisms in mangrove soils: a review. Forests 11(9):981. https://doi.org/10.3390/f11090981

[47] KristensenE, BouillonS, DittmarT, MarchandC. Organic carbon dynamics in mangrove ecosystems: a review. Aquat Bot, 2008, 892201-219.

[48] LeeSY, PrimaveraJH, Dahdouh-GuebasF, McKeeK, BosireJO, CannicciS, DieleK, FromardF, KoedamN, MarchandC, MendelssohnI. Ecological role and services of tropical mangrove ecosystems: A reassessment. Glob Ecol Biogeogr, 2014, 237726-743.

[49] LiB, XiaY, ChenX, WangJ, LiuW, WangZ, SuW, RenH. Enhanced sediment microbial diversity in mangrove forests: Indicators of nutrient status in coastal ecosystems. Mar Pollut Bull, 2025, 211. 117421

[50] LinCW, KaoYC, ChouMC, WuHH, HoCW, LinHJ. Methane emissions from subtropical and tropical mangrove ecosystems in Taiwan. Forests, 2020, 114470.

[51] LiuH, RenH, HuiD, WangW, LiaoB, CaoQ. Carbon stocks and potential carbon storage in the mangrove forests of China. J Environ Manage, 2014, 133: 86-93.

[52] LovelockCE, FellerIC, BallMC, EngelbrechtBM, EweML. Differences in plant function in phosphorus- and nitrogen-limited mangrove ecosystems. New Phytol, 2006, 1723514-522.

[53] Mahasani IGAI, Karang IWGA, Hendrawan IG (2016) Karbon organik di bawah permukaan tanah pada kawasan rehabilitasi hutan mangrove, Taman Hutan Raya Ngurah Rai, Bali. Proceedings of the National Marine Seminar, Universitas Trunojoyo Madura 33–42. [Indonesian]. https://ilmukelautan.trunojoyo.ac.id/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/6_Prosiding_semnaskel_2016

[54] MatusFJ. Fine silt and clay content is the main factor defining maximal C and N accumulations in soils: A meta-analysis. Sci Rep, 2021, 1116438.

[55] Maulidah FZ, Iskandar J, Gunawan B (2023) The tangible and intangible benefits of mangrove forests as a factor affecting community participation in mangrove management. J Trop Ethnobiol. 6(2):112–125. https://doi.org/10.46359/jte.v6i2.174

[56] Murdiyarso D, Purbopuspito J, Kauffman JB, Warren MW, Sasmito SD, Donato DC, Manuri S, Krisnawati H, Taberima S, Kurnianto S (2015) The potential of Indonesian mangrove forests for global climate change mitigation. Nat Clim Change 5(12):1089–1092. https://doi.org/10.1038/nclimate2734

[57] NaidooG. The mangroves of South Africa: An ecophysiological review. S Afr J Bot, 2016, 107: 101-113.

[58] NguyenTMH, LeTPQ, HoangVV, VuCT. Biodegradable and seasonal variation of organic carbon affected by anthropogenic activity: A case in Xuan Thuy Mangrove Forest. North Vietnam Water, 2022, 145773.

[59] PerieC, OuimetR. Organic carbon, organic matter, and bulk density relationships in boreal forest soils. Can J Soil Sci, 2008, 883315-325.

[60] Prameswari AASR, Hariyanto T, Sidik F (2015) Analisis indeks vegetasi mangrove menggunakan citra satelit ALOS AVNIR-2 (Studi kasus: Estuari Perancak, Bali). Geoid 11(1):40–45. https://doi.org/10.12962/j24423998.v11i1.1094

[61] Priscillia CC, Herdiansyah H, Patria MP (2021) Environmental conditions to support blue carbon storage in mangrove forest: A case study in the mangrove forest, Nusa Lembongan, Bali, Indonesia. Biodiversitas, 22(6):3304–3314. https://doi.org/10.13057/biodiv/d220636

[62] PurahongW, SadubsarnD, TanunchaiB, WahdanSFM, SansupaC, NollM, WuY-T, BuscotF. First insights into the microbiome of a mangrove tree reveal significant differences in taxonomic and functional composition among plant and soil compartments. Microorganisms, 2019, 712585.

[63] QueirozHM, ArturAG, TaniguchiCA, da SilveiraMR, et al. . Hidden contribution of shrimp farming effluents to greenhouse gas emissions from mangrove soils. Estuar Coast Shelf Sci, 2019, 221: 8-14.

[64] ReefR, FellerIC, LovelockCE. Nutrition of mangroves. Tree Physiol, 2010, 3091148-1160.

[65] RichardsDR, FriessDA. Rates and drivers of mangrove deforestation in Southeast Asia, 2000–2012. Proc Natl Acad Sci, 2016, 1132344-349.

[66] RovaiAS, Coelho-JrC, de AlmeidaR, Cunha-LignonM, MenghiniRP, TwilleyRR, Cintrón-MoleroG, Schaeffer-NovelliY. Ecosystem-level carbon stocks and sequestration rates in mangroves in the Cananéia-Iguape lagoon estuarine system, southeastern Brazil. For Ecol Manage, 2021, 479. 118553

[67] SasmitoSD, SillanpääM, HayesMA, BachriS, Saragi-SasmitoMF, SidikF, MurdiyarsoD. Mangrove blue carbon stocks and dynamics are controlled by hydrogeomorphic settings and land-use change. Glob Change Biol, 2020, 2653028-3039.

[68] SastrosuwondoP, DharmawanIWE. Mangrove community structure in Papuan Small Islands, case study in Biak Regency. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 2020, 5501. 012002

[69] SidikF, AdameFM, LovelockCE. Carbon sequestration and fluxes of restored mangroves in abandoned aquaculture ponds. Journal of the Indian Ocean Region, 2019, 152177-192.

[70] SiikamäkiJ, SanchiricoJN, JardineSL. Global economic potential for reducing carbon dioxide emissions from mangrove loss. Proc Natl Acad Sci, 2012, 1093614369-14374.

[71] SitoeAA, Comissario-MandlateLJ, GuedesBS. Biomass and carbon stocks of Sofala Bay mangrove forests. Forests, 2014, 581967-1981.

[72] Sofawi AB, Nazri MN, Rozainah MZ (2017) Nutrient variability in mangrove soil: anthropogenic, seasonal and depth variation factors. Applied Ecology & Environmental Research 15(4):1983–1998. https://doi.org/10.15666/aeer/1504_19831998

[73] SrikanthS, LumSKY, ChenZ. Mangrove root: Adaptations and ecological importance. Trees, 2016, 30: 451-465.

[74] SugianaIP, FaiqohE, AdameMF, IndrawanGS, AndianiAAE, DewiIGAIP, DharmawanIWE. Soil greenhouse gas fluxes to the atmosphere during the wet season across mangrove zones in Benoa Bay. Indonesia Asian Journal of Atmospheric Environment, 2023, 17113.

[75] Sugiana IP, Faiqoh E, Indrawan GS, Dharmawan IWE (2021) Methane concentration on three mangrove zones in Ngurah Rai Forest Park, Bali. Jurnal Ilmu Lingkungan 19(2):422–431. https://doi.org/10.14710/jil.19.2.422-431

[76] Sugiana IP, Andiani AAE, Dewi IGAIP, Karang IWGA, As-Syakur AR, Dharmawan IWE (2022) Spatial distribution of mangrove health index on three genera dominated zones in Benoa Bay, Bali, Indonesia. Biodiversitas, 23(7):3407–3418. https://doi.org/10.13057/biodiv/d230713

[77] Sugiana IP, Prartono T, Rastina R, Koropitan AF (2024). Warming effect from soil greenhouse gas emission of each mangrove zone during the dry season in Ngurah Rai Forest Park, Bali, Indonesia. Environ Nat Resources J 22(5):449–463. https://doi.org/10.32526/ennrj/22/20240029

[78] TreatCC, NataliSM, ErnakovichJ, et al. . A pan-Arctic synthesis of CH₄ and CO₂ production from anoxic soil incubations. Glob Change Biol, 2015, 2172787-2803.

[79] Twilley RR, Castañeda-Moya E, Rivera-Monroy VH, Rovai A (2017) Productivity and carbon dynamics in mangrove wetlands. In: Rivera-Monroy VH, Kristensen (eds) Mangrove Ecosystems: A Global Biogeographic Perspective. Springer, Switzerland. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-62206-4_5

[80] World Bank Group. (2017). New global pathway on carbon pricing can shift finance to sustainable investments: World Bank. Retrieved from https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2017/05/29/new-global-pathway-on-carbon-pricing-can-shift-finance-to-sustainable-investments-world-bank

[81] WuT, GuoJ, LiG, JinY, ZhaoW, LinG, LuoF, ZhuY, JiaY, WenL. Soil organic carbon contents and their major influencing factors in mangrove tidal flats: a comparison between estuarine and non-estuarine areas. Ecol Process, 2025, 14115.

[82] XiongY, LiuX, GuanW, et al. . Fine root functional group-based estimates of fine root production and turnover rate in natural mangrove forests. Plant Soil, 2017, 413: 83-95.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)