Feeling of exposure to fluviomarine risks and adaptation strategies in the Loire estuary

Abstract

Estuaries are low- elevation morphological areas that are highly susceptible to submersion and flooding, and particularly so in view of the rising sea level. As with coastlines, where many adaptation strategies are under consideration (relocation, adaptation of buildings, nature-based solutions, etc.), future adaptation strategies for estuaries involve a number of different ways of converting the area, all of which must be developed on the appropriate spatial and temporal scales and in agreement with the local people. In this regard it is appropriate to examine the views of local residents in an estuarine context. Do they feel vulnerable? What are their perceptions of how planning has evolved in relation to climate change, and what are their preferences in respect of risk management? This article presents the results of an enquiry carried out downstream of the Loire estuary in an area characterized by industry, urban development and natural spaces. The survey involved 633 individuals whose views on the relationships between the local residents and their territory, in terms of fluviomarine risks and adaptation procedures, were collected by completing a questionnaire. The results reveal that few of the people surveyed are worried about fluviomarine risks, although they are aware of the ongoing climate change and that areas close to where they live are under threat. On the other hand, they feel much more threatened by the industrial risk which is characteristic of the Loire estuary. In terms of adaptation strategies the results are highly consensual, although sometimes confused, and could reveal a lack of ‘concern’ about these topics. The results of this research highlight determining factors such as time spent in the community and at home, the elements inherent to estuarine environments, and the memory of local risks. These elements could be useful for stakeholders in large industrialized estuaries wishing to embark on an adaptation strategy or submersion risk management.

Keywords

Feeling of exposure / Risk / Adaptation / Submersion / Estuary / Sea level rise / Flooding / Socio-spatial perception

References

[1] AlmarR, RanasingheR, BergsmaEWJ, DiazH, MeletA, PapaF, et al. . A global analysis of extreme coastal water levels with implications for potential coastal overtopping. Nat Commun, 2021, 1213775.

[2] AltmanI, LowSMPlace attachment, 1992New YorkPlenum336.

[3] Becu N., Rocle N., Rey-Valette H., Almaric M., Balouin Y., Bazart C., et al., 2019, "Les littoraux français face au changement climatique : typologie et variables clés pour des trajectoires d’adaptation à moyen-long terme" https://hal-brgm.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02324658

[4] Berdoulay V., Soubeyran O., 2020, L'aménagement face à la menace climatique. Le défi de l’adaptation. 242 p

[5] Bertrand M., Blot F., Dascon J., Gambino M., Milian J., Molina G., 2006, "Géographie et représentations : De la nécessité des méthodes qualitatives", 316 in: https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01337096

[6] BickerstaffK, SimmonsP. Absencing/presencing risk: Rethinking proximity and the experience of living with major technological hazards. Geoforum, 2009, 405864-872.

[7] Bonaiuto M, Alves S, De Dominicis S, Petruccelli I (2016) Place attachment and natural hazard risk: Research review and agenda. J Environ Psychol 48:33–53. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2016.07.007

[8] BonnetE, AmalricM, ChevéM, TraversM. Hazard and living environment: combining industrial risk and landscape representations. J Risk Res, 2012, 15101281-1298.

[9] BradfordRA, O’SullivanJJ, van der CraatsIM, KrywkowJ, RotkoP, AaltonenJ, et al. . Risk perception – issues for flood management in Europe. Nat Hazard, 2012, 1272299-2309.

[10] BrillyM, PolicM. Public perception of flood risks, flood forecasting and mitigation. Nat Hazard, 2005, 53345-355.

[11] BurninghamK, FieldingJ, ThrushD. ‘It'll never happen to me’: understanding public awareness of local flood risk. Disasters, 2008, 322216-238.

[12] CabanneC. L'estuaire de la Loire, espace vécu, espace perçu. Cahiers Du Centre Nantais De Recherche Pour L'aménagement Régional, 1988, 301119-124.

[13] CarltonSJ, JacobsonSK. Climate change and coastal environmental risk perceptions in Florida. J Environ Manage, 2013, 130: 32-39.

[14] ChadenasC, ChotardM, NavarroO, KerguillecR, RobinM, JuignerM. Coastal erosion risk: Population adaptation to climate change—a case study of the pays De La Loire Coastline. Weather Climate Soc, 2023, 151145-157.

[15] Chadenas C., Struillou J.-F., Menanteau L., Pourinet L., 2009, "Zonage de protection du patrimoine naturel dans l'estuaire de la Loire. Identification et analyse",251–271in: Estuaire de la Loire, un territoire en développement durable ? Espace et Territoires. Presses universitaires de Rennes (1)

[16] ChaumillonE, BertinX, FortunatoAB, BajoM, SchneiderJ-L, DezileauL, et al. . Storm-induced marine flooding: Lessons from a multidisciplinary approach. Earth Sci Rev, 2017, 165: 151-184.

[17] Chevassus-au-Louis B., 2007, L’analyse des risques: l’expert, le décideur et le citoyen. Versailles, Éd. Quae

[18] CoquetM, MercierD, Fleury-BahiG. Individuals’ perceptions of areas exposed to coastal flooding in four French coastal municipalities: the contribution of sketch mapping. Geoenvironment Disasters, 2018, 5115.

[19] Devine-Wright P (2009) Rethinking NIMBYism: The role of place attachment and place identity in explaining place-protective action. J Community Appl Soc Psychol Vol.19, N°6, 426–441

[20] Fattal P., 2002, "L'émergence de la notion d'environnement dans l'estuaire de la Loire", in: Côtes et estuaires: milieux naturels [Proceedings of the 124th National Congress of Historical and Scientific Societies, Nantes, 1999]. Paris, Ed. of the CTHS

[21] Ferret Y., 2016, Reconstruction de la série marégraphique de Saint-Nazaire. SHOM

[22] Flanquart H., 2016, Des risques et des hommes. Presses Universitaires de France, 346 p . http://www.cairn.info/des-risques-et-des-hommes--9782130736295.htm

[23] GeffrayO, MénanteauL. "Géographie de l’inondation des marais de la basse-Loire : l’exemple de la crue de l’hiver 2000–2001", Norois. Environ Aménag Soc, 2004, 192: 11-28

[24] GIP Loire Estuaire., 2018, L'essentiel sur la Moire, de la Maine à la mer

[25] Glatron S., 2009, Représentations cognitives et spatiales des risques et des nuisances pour les citadins. Université de Strasbourg, 200 p . https://theses.hal.science/tel-00565920

[26] GothamKF, Lauve-MoonK, PowersB. Risk and recovery: Understanding flood risk perceptions in a Postdisaster City-the case of New Orleans. Sociol Spectr, 2017, 376335-352.

[27] Guillou E., Meur-Ferec C., 2014, "Représentations des risques côtiers et stratégies d’adaptation: une manière d’appréhender la dimension humaine des risques côtiers.", 339‑352 in: Connaissance et Compréhension des Risques Côtiers: Aléas, Enjeux, Représentations, Gestion. Brest, France, IUEM. https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01102949

[28] HaasnootM, BrownS, ScussoliniP, JimenezJA, VafeidisAT, NichollsRJ. Generic adaptation pathways for coastal archetypes under uncertain sea-level rise. Environ Res Commun, 2019, 17071006.

[29] HaighID, WadeyMP, WahlT, OzsoyO, NichollsRJ, BrownJM, HorsburghK, GouldbyB. Spatial and temporal analysis of extreme sea level and storm surge events around the coastline of the UK. Scientific Data, 2016, 3: 160107.

[30] HellequinA-P, FlanquartH, Meur-FerecC, RulleauB. Perceptions du risque de submersion marine par la population du littoral languedocien : contribution à l’analyse de la vulnérabilité côtière. Nat Sci Soc, 2013, 214385-399.

[31] HermandD, ChauvinB. Contribution du paradigme psychométrique à l'étude de la perception des risques: une revue de littérature de 1978 à 2005. L’année Psychologique, 2008, 1082343-386.

[32] HidalgoMC, HernándezB. Place attachment: Conceptual and empirical questions. J Environ Psychol, 2001, 213273-281.

[33] KellensW, ZaalbergR, NeutensT, VanneuvilleW, De MaeyerP. An analysis of the public perception of flood risk on the Belgian Coast: An analysis of the public perception of flood risk. Risk Anal, 2011, 3171055-1068.

[34] Khojasteh D., Glamore W., Heimhuber V., Felder S., 2021, "Sea level rise impacts on estuarine dynamics: A review", Science of The Total Environment, 780, No.146470. https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0048969721015382

[35] Lammel A. (2015) Changement climatique : De la perception à l’action. Ecologie Politique. https://univparis8.hal.science/hal-02113525

[36] Le Hir P., 2014, Conséquences du Changement Climatique sur l’Ecogéomorphologie des Estuaires

[37] LechowskaE. What determines flood risk perception? A review of factors of flood risk perception and relations between its basic elements. Nat Hazards, 2018, 9431341-1366.

[38] LepeteurM, WegnerA, MooreSA, McCombA. Importance of public information and perception for managing recreational activities in the Peel-Harvey estuary, Western Australia. J Environ Manage, 2008, 873389-395.

[39] LewickaM. Place attachment: How far have we come in the last 40 years?. J Environ Psychol, 2011, 313207-230.

[40] LorenzoniI, Nicholson-ColeS, WhitmarshL. Barriers perceived to engage with climate change among the UK public and their policy implications. Glob Environ Chang, 2007, 173-4445-459.

[41] LudyJ, KondolfGM. Flood risk perception in lands “protected” by 100-year levees. Nat Hazards, 2012, 612829-842.

[42] LujalaP, LeinH, RødJK. Climate change, natural hazards, and risk perception: the role of proximity and personal experience. Local Environ, 2015, 204489-509.

[43] Magnan A., 2014, "Avoiding maladaptation to climate change: towards guiding principles", S.A.P.I.EN.S. Surveys and Perspectives Integrating Environment and Society, No.7.1. https://journals.openedition.org/sapiens/1680

[44] MartinCL, MomtazS, GastonT, MoltschaniwskyjNA. Estuarine cultural ecosystem services valued by local people in New South Wales, Australia, and attributes important for continued supply. Ocean Coast Manag, 2020, 190: 105160.

[45] Menanteau L., 2009, "L'estuaire de la Loire: traits singuliers, limites et artificialisation", 33–51 in: Estuaire de la Loire, un territoire en développement durable ? Espace et Territoires. Presses universitaires de Rennes (1)

[46] Menard AH., 2009, "L’estuaire de la Loire, un territoire mal identifié en quête d’une politique bien identifiée", 99‑113 in: Estuaire de la Loire, un territoire en développement durable ? Espace et Territoires. Presses universitaires de Rennes (1)

[47] Meur-FérecC, DeboudtP, MorelV. Coastal risks in France: an integrated method for evaluating vulnerability. J Coastal Res, 2008, 242B178-189.

[48] Meur-Ferec C., Berre I. L., Cocquempot L., Guillou É., Henaff A., Lami T., et al., 2020, "Une méthode de suivi de la vulnérabilité systémique à l’érosion et la submersion marines", Développement durable et territoires. Économie, géographie, politique, droit, sociologie, 11, no.1. https://journals.openedition.org/sustainabledevelopment/16731

[49] Moatar F., Dupont N., 2016, La Loire fluviale et estuarienne, Un milieu en évolution. 319 p

[50] Navarro O., Michel-Guillou E., 2014, "Analyse des risques et menaces environnementales: Un regard psycho-socio-environnemental", 271–297 In: L'Individu Au Risque de l'Environnement

[51] NavarroO, MambetC, BarbarasC, ChadenasC, RobinM, ChotardM, et al. . Determinant factors of protective behaviors regarding erosion and coastal flooding risk". Int J Disaster Risk Reduct, 2021, 61: 102378.

[52] Navarro O., 2022, Psychologie Environnementale. Enjeux environnementaux, risques et qualité de vie. 192 p

[53] November V., 2002, Les territoires du risque : le risque comme objet de réflexion géographique. Bern, 332 p

[54] O’NeillE, BreretonF, ShahumyanH, ClinchJP. The impact of perceived flood exposure on flood-risk perception: the role of distance: flood-risk perception: the role of distance. Risk Anal, 2016, 36112158-2186.

[55] OppenheimerM, GlavovicB, HinkelJ, van de WalR, MagnanAK, Abd-ElgawadA, et al. . Sea level rise and implications for low lying Islands, coasts and communities. Intergovern Panel Climate Change, 2019, 162163

[56] PaskoffR. Conséquences possibles sur les milieux littoraux de l’élévation du niveau de la mer prévue pour les prochaines décennies. Annales De Géographie, 1998, 107600233-248.

[57] Paulet JP., 2002, Les représentations mentales en géographie. Paris, Anthropos, 152 p

[58] Peretti-Watel P., 2000, Sociologie du risque. 286 p

[59] PhilippenkoX, Goeldner-GianellaL, Le CozannetG, GrancherD, De La TorreY. Perceptions of climate change and adaptation: A subarctic archipelago perspective (Saint-Pierre-and-Miquelon, North America). Ocean Coast Manag, 2021, 215: 105924.

[60] QuinnT, BousquetF, GuerboisC, HeiderL, BrownK. How local water and waterbody meanings shape flood risk perception and risk management preferences. Sustain Sci, 2019, 14: 565-578.

[61] RambonilazaT, JoallandO, BrahicE. Landowner's perception of flood risk and preventive actions in estuarine environment: An empirical investigation. J Environ Manage, 2016, 180: 272-279.

[62] RegnauldH, DubreuilV. L’élévation du niveau marin dans l’Ouest français : signification climatique et conséquences morphologiques. Annales De Géographie, 1998, 107600117-138.

[63] Rey-ValetteH, RulleauB, Meur-FérecC, FlanquartH, HellequinA, SourisseauE. Les plages du littoral languedocien face au risque de submersion : définir des politiques de gestion tenant compte de la perception des usagers. Géograp Écon Soc, 2012, 144369-392.

[64] RochaC, AntunesC, CatitaC. Coastal vulnerability assessment due to sea level rise : The case study of the Atlantic Coast of Mainland Portugal. Water, 2020, 122Article 2.

[65] Rulleau B., Rey-Valette H., Flanquart H., Hellequin A.-P., Meur-Férec C., 2015, "Perception des risques de submersion marine et capacité d’adaptation des populations littorales: « On a eu la guerre, ils auront les inondations! »", VertigO, N°Hors-série 21. http://journals.openedition.org/vertigo/15811

[66] RuzMH, Rufin-SolerC, HéquetteA, RévillonR, HellequinA-P, DeboudtP, et al. . "Climate change and risk perceptions in two French Coastal communities. J Coast Res, 2020, 95SI875-879.

[67] Scannell L, Gifford R (2010) Defining place attachment : A tripartite organizing framework. J Environ Psychol 30(1):1–10. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2009.09.006

[68] SchmidtL, GomesC, GuerreiroS, O’RiordanT. Are we all on the same boat? The challenge of adaptation facing Portuguese coastal communities: Risk perception, trust-building and genuine participation. Land Use Policy, 2014, 38: 355-365.

[69] SebastienL. L'attachement au lieu, vecteur de mobilisation collective ? : Étude de cinq territoires ruraux. Norois, 2016, 238–239: 23-41.

[70] TraversM, BonnetE, ChevéM, AppéréG. Perception des risques industriels dans une zone estuarienne : une analyse hédoniste spatiale. Économie & Prévision, 2009, 1904135-158.

[71] TunstallS. Public perceptions of the environmental changes to the Thames Estuary in London, U.K. J Coastal Res, 2000, 162269-277

[72] UzzellDL. The psycho-spatial dimension of global environmental problems. J Environ Psychol, 2000, 204307-318.

[73] VergerF. Digues et polders littoraux : réflexions après la tempête Xynthia. Physio-Géo, 2011, 5: 95-105.

[74] Verlynde N., 2018, De la perception du risque d’inondation aux propositions d’adaptation en territoire de côtes basses densément peuplées : le cas de la communauté urbaine de Dunkerque. Université du Littoral Côte d'Opale. https://theses.hal.science/tel-02085107

[75] WachingerG, RennO, BeggC, KuhlickeC. The risk perception paradox-implications for governance and communication of natural hazards: the risk perception Paradox. Risk Anal, 2013, 3361049-1065.

[76] Weichselgartner J., Norton J., Chantry G., Brévière E., Pigeon P., Guézo B., 2016, "Culture, connaissance et réduction des risques de catastrophe : liens critiques pour une transformation sociétale durable", VertigO, Vol.16, N°3. http://journals.openedition.org/vertigo/18130

[77] WeinsteinND. Effects of personal experience on self-protective behavior. Psychol Bull, 1989, 105131-50.

[78] WeisscherSAH, BaarAW, van BelzenJ, BoumaTJ, KleinhansMG. Transitional polders along estuaries: Driving land-level rise and reducing flood propagation. Nat Based Solut, 2022, 2: 100022.

[79] Wisner B., 2016. Vulnerability as concept, model, metric, and tool. In: Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Natural Hazard Science. Oxford University Press. http://naturalhazardscience.oxfordre.com/view/https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780199389407.001.0001/acrefore-9780199389407-e-25

[80] Yembi-Yembi L., Costa S., Bonnet E., 2022, "Perceptions et représentations socio-spatiales des risques dans les communes multirisques : le cas de la place du risque d’inondation par la mer chez les habitants de Port-Gentil au Gabon", Cybergeo. http://journals.openedition.org/cybergeo/38919

[81] ZindaJA, WilliamsLB, KayDL, AlexanderSM. Flood risk perception and responses among urban residents in the northeastern United States. Int J Disaster Risk Reduct, 2021, 64: 102528.

Funding

Agence d'urbanisme de la région de saint-Nazaire

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)