Effects of nourished beach morphology on storm response

Abstract

Field observations on storm induced beach changes are important to improve our effort on beach management. This study compared storm induced beach changes caused by hurricane Hermine in 2016 (4 years after a beach nourishment) and Tropical Storm Eta in 2020 (2 years after a beach renourishment) along the barrier-island coast of west-central Florida. Pre-Eta beach were 1 to 2 times wider than that of pre-Hermine. Since Hurricane Hermine and TS Eta generated a similar hydrodynamic condition for the study site, comparing beach changes induced by these two storms provides a unique opportunity to investigate the response of different antecedent beach conditions to energetic events. The shore protection effect of beach nourishment is apparently evidenced by the fact that post-Eta shoreline was located seaward of those post-Hermine at half of the beach-profile locations in the study area. The shore protection effect in the subaerial portion of the beach, however, is not obvious for the other half of beach profiles where shoreline positions were retreated to similar locations after these two storms. Instead, their shore protection effect occurred in the sub-aqueous portion of the beach and was indicated by higher sandbar crests located closer to the shoreline, which can dissipate and reduce incoming wave energy. The shoreline elevation needs to be properly defined (Mean High Water vs Mean Low Water line) as it is used as a proxy to represent beach volume loss. For Hermine induced beach change, no significant correlation exists between MHW line change and beach volume loss. While a significant correlation exists between MHW line change and beach volume loss induced by TS Eta. This correlation pattern switched if the shoreline here is defined as mean low water line. For efficient beach/shoreline management, multiple proxies (e.g., sandbar height and location of its crest and trough) in addition to shoreline change should be used to assess the performance of beach nourishment project.

References

[1] Antworth RL, Pike DA, Stiner JC. Nesting ecology, current status, and conservation of sea turtles on an uninhabited beach in Florida, USA. Biol Cons, 2006, 130: 10-15.

[2] Bacopoulo P. Extreme low and high waters due to a large and powerful tropical cyclone: Hurricane Irma 2017. Nat Hazards, 2018,

[3] Barone DA, Mckenna KM, Farrell SC. Hurricane sandy: beach-dune performance at New Jersey beach profile network sites. Shore Beach, 2014, 82(4): 13-23

[4] Beck T, Wang P. Morphodyanmics of barrier-inlet systems in the context of reginal sediment management, with case studies from west-central Florida, USA. Ocean Coast Manag, 2019, 177: 31-51.

[5] Boak EH, Turner IL. Shoreline definition and detection: a review. J Coastal Res, 2005, 214: 688-703.

[6] Brenner OT, Lentz EE, Hapke CJ, Henderson RE, Wilson KE, Nelson TR (2018) Characterizing storm response and recovery using the beach change envelope: Fire Island, New York. Marine Geology 300(1):189–202

[7] Cheng J, Wang P. Dynamic equilibrium of sandbar position and height along a low wave energy micro-tidal coast. Cont Shelf Res, 2018, 165: 120-136.

[8] Cheng J, Wang P. Unusual beach changes induced by hurricane Irma with a negative storm surge and poststorm recovery. J Coastal Res, 2019, 35(6): 1185-1199.

[9] Cheng J, Wang P. Factors controlling storm-induced morphology changes at an erosional hot spot on a nourished beach, Sand Key Barrier Island, west-central Florida. J Coastal Res, 2022, 38(4): 750-765.

[10] Cheng J, Wang P, Guo QD. Measuring beach profiles along a low-wave energy microtidal coast, west-central Florida, USA. Geosciences, 2016, 6(4): 44.

[11] Davis RA, Barnard P. Morphodynamics of the barrier-inlet system, west-central Florida. Mar Geol, 2003, 200: 77-101.

[12] Farris AS, List JH. Shoreline change as a proxy for subaerial beach volume change. J Coastal Res, 2007, 233: 740-748.

[13] Houston JR. Beach nourishment provides resilient protection for critical coastal infrastructure. Shore Beach, 2022, 90(2): 19-32.

[14] Kolodin J, Lorenzo-Trueba J, Hoagland P, Jin D, Ashton A. Engineered coastal berm-dune renourishment in New Jersey: can coastal communities continue to hold the line?. Anthropocene Coasts, 2021, 4: 193-209.

[15] Lemke L, Miller JK. Evaluation of storm through the lens of erosion potential along the New Jersey. USA Coast. Costal Eng, 2020, 158: 103699.

[16] Liu G, Cai F, Qi H, Liu J, Lei G, Zhu J, Cao H, Zheng J, Zhao S, Yu F. A summary of beach nourishment in China: the past decade of practices. Shore Beach, 2020, 88(3): 65-73.

[17] Liu S, Cai F, Qi H, Liu J, Yang W, Liu G. Economic contribution of beach resources and their sustainable development in China. Ocean Coast Manag, 2023, 239(15

[18] Mieras R, Toburen C, Holsclaw A (2023) Continuous beach morphology observations under active storm forcing using compact 3D LiDAR scanners. Coastal Sediment 2023 conference proceeding. p. 2585–2598. https://doi.org/10.1142/9789811275135_0236

[19] Pagan JI, Banon L, Lopez I, Banon C, Aragones L. Monitoring the dune-beach system of Guardamar del Segura (Spain) using UAV, SfM and GIS techniques. Sci Total Environ, 2019, 687(15): 1034-1045.

[20] Papin PP. The 2023 Atlantic hurricane season: Hurricane Idalia makes headlines. Weatherwise, 2024, 77(4): 14-20.

[21] Pearre NS, Puleo JA. Quantifying seasonal shoreline variability at Rehoboth Beach, Delaware, using automated imaging techniques. J Coastal Res, 2009, 25(4): 900-914.

[22] Roberts TM, Wang P. Four-year performance and associated controlling factors of several beach nourishment projects along three adjacent barrier islands, west-central Florida, USA. Coast Eng, 2012, 70: 21-39.

[23] Royer E, Wang P, Cheng J. Determining depth of closure based on time-series beach profiles and empirical formulas: a case study along the Florida coast. Shore Beach, 2023, 91: 3-22.

[24] Saengsupavanich C, Ratnayake AS, Yun LS, Ariffin EH. Current challenges in coastal erosion management for southern Asian regions: examples form Thailand, Malaysia, and Sri Lanka. Anthropocene Coasts, 2023, 6: 15.

[25] Sallenger AH, Krabill W, Brock J, Swift R, Manizade S, Stockdon H (2002) Sea-cliff erosion as a function of beach changes and extreme wave runup during the 1997-1998 El Nino, Marine Geology 3–4:279–297

[26] Sims SA, Seavey JR, Curtin CG. Room to move? Threatened shorebird habitat in the path of sea level rise – dynamic beaches, multiple users, and mixed ownership: a case study from Rhode Island, USA. J Coast Conserv, 2013, 17: 339-350.

[27] Van Alphen R, Rodgers M, Malservisi R, Wang P, Cheng J, Valleé M. Application of UAV structure-from-motion photogrammetry to a nourished beach for assessment of storm surge impacts Pinellas County, Florida. IEEE Trans Geosci Remote Sensing, 2024, 62(1–12): 4409812

[28] Vos K, Splinter K, Harley M, Simmons J, Turner I. CoastSat: a google earth engine-enabled python toolkit to extract shorelines from publicly available satellite imagery. Environ Model Softw, 2019, 122,

[29] Wang P, Beck TM Beach-Inlet Interaction and Sediment Management, 2022 Cambridge University Press 364.

[30] Wang P, Davis RA. Depth of closure and the equilibrium beach profile - a case study from sand key, west-central Florida. Shore Beach, 1999, 67: 33-42

[31] Wang P, Davis RA Jr, Kraus NC. Cross-shore distribution of sediment textures under breaking waves. J Sediment Res, 1998, 68: 497-506.

[32] Wang P, Adam JD, Cheng J, Vallée M. Morphological and sedimentological impacts of Hurricane Michael along the Northwest Florida Coast. J Coastal Res, 2020, 36: 932-950.

[33] Wang Z, Boyer T, Reagan J, Hogan P. Upper-ceanic warming in the Gulf of Mexico between 1950 and 2020. J Clim, 2023, 36(8): 2721-2734.

[34] Wang P, Royer EL, Jackson K, Gutierrez S. Impacts of Hurricane Ian along the low-lying southwest Florida coast (USA) in 2022: lesson learned. J Coastal Res, 2024,