Detection of fragments of an obstacle and a projectile in a gunshot injury

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Law enforcement agencies look for the presence of an obstacle between the human body and the muzzle of a firearm at the time of the shot when assigning forensic medical examination of a firearm injury. Imported particles removed from the corpse, a skin flap, or damaged clothing could be sent for a laboratory examination.

CASE PRESENTATION: Here, we present a case from expert practice which demonstrates the possibility of establishing the presence of barrier particles on surrounding objects in the case of a gunshot injury caused to a person. In the given case, detecting the fragments of an obstacle (triplex ― the windshield of a car) played a leading role in proving the suspect’s involvement in the incident under investigation. Described are the violations of an expert method of particle removal (in one case only, the material obtained from the clothing was placed on a special carbonic adhesive tape during a targeted search of micro overlays) and evaluation of the obtained data which contributed to incorrect findings in the expert’s conclusion.

Experts of the Federal State-Owned Institution “111 Main State Center for Medical and Forensic Examinations” conducted a re-examination of the above-stated objects, as well as experimental target shooting with similar weapons through a similar barrier. Presented are the possibilities of modern scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersion analysis, which allow not only to establish the presence of barrier particles on surrounding objects but also to identify the signs of gunshot damage inflicted upon a human body and clothing, identify the destroyed projectile particles, and establish the elemental composition of all the detected microparticles.

CONCLUSION: This study demonstrated the methodological gaps in establishing the existence of a passage of a firearm projectile through an obstacle in the case of a gunshot injury. The methods for identifying the fragments of a firearm projectile and particles of an obstacle, which we are currently developing, are aimed at solving this problem by improving the corresponding research methods in forensic medicine and science.

Keywords

fragments of an obstacle / triplex glass / destruction of a firearm projectile / scanning electron microscopy / energy dispersion analysis

References

[1] Fedorenko VA, Pereverzev MM. Features of establishing the place of the shotwhen the projectile penetrates some transparent materials. Expert-criminalist. 2007;(3):10–14.

[2] Федоренко В.А., Переверзев М.М. Особенности установления места выстрела при пробивании снарядом некоторых прозрачных материалов // Эксперт-криминалист. 2007. № 3. С. 10–14.

[3] Leonov SV, Pinchuk PV, Sukhareva MA, Shakiryanova YuP. Characteristics of shell fragments after hitting triplex car glass with shots from a hunting "Saiga" carbine under the 5.45×39 cartridge. Russian Journal of Forensic Medicine. 2021;7(3):139–145. (In Russ). doi: 10.17816/fm381

[4] Леонов С.В., Пинчук П.В., Сухарева М.А., Шакирьянова Ю.П. Характеристика фрагментов снарядов после повреждения триплексного стекла автомобиля выстрелами из охотничьего карабина «Сайга» под патрон 5,45х39 // Судебная медицина. 2021. Т. 7, №3. С. 139–145. doi: 10.17816/fm381

[5] Leonov SV, Pinchuk PV, Suhareva MA, Shakiryanova JP. Features of the trajectory of particles of car triplex glass damaged by "Saiga" carbine shots with the cartridge 5.45×39 mm. Forensic Medical Expertise. 2021;64(6):18–20. (In Russ). doi: 10.17116/sudmed20216406118

[6] Леонов С.В., Пинчук П.В., Сухарева М.А., Шакирьянова Ю.П. Особенности траектории выброса частиц триплексного стекла автомобиля, поврежденного выстрелами из карабина «Сайга» под патрон 5,45х39 // Судебно-медицинская экспертиза. 2021. Т. 64, № 6. С. 18–20. doi: 10.17116/sudmed20216406118

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Leonov S.V., Pinchuk P.V., Suhareva M.A., Shakiryanova J.P.