On using artificial intelligence in procedural decision-making in forensic medical examination

Abstract

The article explores the application of artificial intelligence (AI) in forensic medical examination, assessing its current state and future prospects in procedural decision-making. While the integration of AI in forensic medical examination introduces new opportunities, it is equally important to consider potential risks.

The reviews research conducted by experts from various countries on the implementation of AI in forensic medical examination, with a particular focus on its role in procedural decision-making. A literature analysis reveals that forensic psychiatry leads the way in AI adoption within forensic medicine.

Based on a synthesis of scientific literature and an analysis of domestic and international experience, the authors identify key areas where AI can be applied in forensic medical examination and highlight specific aspects that require careful attention.

The introduction of AI into forensic medical examination marks a revolutionary development, offering enhanced efficiency in data analysis and interpretation. However, despite AI’s vast potential, human expertise remains irreplaceable in making critical decisions. AI is not intended to replace human judgment but rather to serve as a valuable assistant. At the current stage of technological development, human involvement is essential for interpreting context and making well-founded decisions.

The article also includes a SWOT analysis of AI applications in procedural decision-making within forensic medical examination. The findings outline the strengths and weaknesses of AI implementation.

Keywords

artificial intelligence / principle of legality / forensic medical examination / digitalization

References

[1] 1. Barinov E. H., Tihomirov A. V. Meditsinskaıa kspertiza na pravovom pole //Meditsinskaıa kspertiza i pravo. – 2012. – №. 1. – S. 3-4.

[2] Баринов Е.Х., Тихомиров А.В. Медицинская экспертиза на правовом поле // Медицинская экспертиза и право. 2012. № 1. С. 3–4. EDN: OXWLZJ

[3] Barinov EKh, Tikhomirov AV. Medical expertise on the legal field. Meditsinskaya ekspertiza i pravo. 2012;(1):3–4. (In Russ.) EDN: OXWLZJ

[4] 2. Ugolovno-protsessualnyi kodeks Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 18.12.2001 N 174-FZ

[5] Kuppala J., Srinivas Kandala K., Anudeep P., et al. Benefits of artificial intelligence in the legal system and law enforcement // Conference: 2022 International Mobile and Embedded Technology Conference (MECON). IEEE, 2022. doi: 10.1109/MECON53876.2022.9752352

[6] Kuppala J, Srinivas Kandala K, Anudeep P, et al. Benefits of artificial intelligence in the legal system and law enforcement. In: Conference: 2022 International Mobile and Embedded Technology Conference (MECON). IEEE; 2022. doi: 10.1109/MECON53876.2022.9752352

[7] 3. Ugolovno-protsessualnyi kodeks Respubliki Kazahstan ot 4 iiylıa 2014 goda № 231-V ZRK.

[8] Alowais S.A., Alghamdi S.S., Alsuhebany N., et al. Revolutionizing healthcare: The role of artificial intelligence in clinical practice // BMC Med Educ. 2023. Vol. 23, N 1. P. 689. doi: 10.1186/s12909-023-04698-z

[9] Alowais SA, Alghamdi SS, Alsuhebany N, et al. Revolutionizing healthcare: The role of artificial intelligence in clinical practice. BMC Med Educ. 2023;23(1):689. doi: 10.1186/s12909-023-04698-z

[10] 4. Kuppala J. et al. Benefits of Artificial Intelligence in the Legal System and Law Enforcement //2022 International Mobile and Embedded Technology Conference (MECON). – IEEE, 2022. – S. 221-225

[11] Баринов Е.Х., Михеева Н.А., Калинин Р.Э., Тарасова Н.В. Внутренний контроль качества судебно-медицинских экспертиз по фактам неоказания медицинской помощи // Судебная медицина. 2020. Т. 6, № 1. С. 46–50. EDN: VPSFMQ doi: 10.19048/2411-8729-2020-6-1-46-50

[12] Barinov EKh, Mikheeva NA, Kalinin RE, Tarasova NV. Internal quality control of forensic medical examinations in cases involving failure to provide medical care. Russ J For Med. 2020;6(1):46–50. EDN: VPSFMQ doi: 10.19048/2411-8729-2020-6-1-46-50

[13] 5. Alowais S. A. et al. Revolutionizing healthcare: the role of artificial intelligence in clinical practice //BMC medical education. – 2023. – T. 23. – №. 1. – S. 689.

[14] Гаврилова Ю.А. Концепция интеграции искусственного интеллекта в правовую систему // Вестник Российского университета дружбы народов. Серия: Юридические науки. 2021. Т. 25, № 3. C. 673–692. EDN: PXTNWU doi: 10.22363/2313-2337-2021-25-3-673-692

[15] Gavrilova YuA. The concept of integrating artificial intelligence into the legal system. RUDN J Law. 2021;25(3):673–692. EDN: PXTNWU doi: 10.22363/2313-2337-2021-25-3-673-692

[16] 6. Barinov E. H., Miheeva N. A., Kalinin R. ., Tarasova N. V. Vnutrennii kontrol kachestva sudebno-meditsinskih kspertiz po faktam neokazaniıa meditsinskoi pomoşi // Sudebnaıa meditsina. 2020;6(1):46–50. https://doi.org/10.19048/2411-8729-2020-6-1-46-50.

[17] Хмыз А.И. Использование возможностей искусственного интеллекта в судебной экспертизе // Вестник экономической безопасности. 2022. № 5. С. 224–227. EDN: XTVDHS doi: 10.24412/2414-3995-2022-5-224-227

[18] Hmyz AI. Using the power of artificial intelligence in judicial expertise. Vestnik economicheskoi bezopasnosti = Bulletin of economic security. 2022;(5):224–227. EDN: XTVDHS doi: 10.24412/2414-3995-2022-5-224-227

[19] 7. Gavrilova IY.A. Kontseptsiıa integratsii iskusstvennogo intellekta v pravovuiy sistemu // Vestnik Rossiiskogo universiteta drujby narodov. Seriıa: IYridicheskie nauki. - 2021. - T.25. - №3. - C. 673-692. doi: 10.22363/2313-2337-2021-25-3-673-692

[20] Vodanović M., Subašić M., Milošević D.P., et al. Artificial intelligence in forensic medicine and forensic dentistry // J Forensic Odontostomatol. 2023. Vol. 41, N 2. P. 30–41.

[21] Vodanović M, Subašić M, Milošević DP, et al. Artificial intelligence in forensic medicine and forensic dentistry. J Forensic Odontostomatol. 2023;41(2):30–41.

[22] 8. Hmyz A. I. Ispolzovanie vozmojnostei iskusstvennogo intellekta v sudebnoi kspertize // Vestnik konomicheskoi bezopasnosti. 2022. № 5. S. 224–227. https://doi.org/10.24412/2414-3995-2022-5-224-227.

[23] Attia Z.I., Friedman P.A., Noseworthy P.A., et al. Age and sex estimation using artificial intelligence from standard 12-lead ECGs // Circ Arrhythm Electrophysiol. 2019. Vol. 12, N 9. P. e007284. doi: 10.1161/CIRCEP.119.007284

[24] Attia ZI, Friedman PA, Noseworthy PA, et al. Age and sex estimation using artificial intelligence from standard 12-lead ECGs. Circ Arrhythm Electrophysiol. 2019;12(9):e007284. doi: 10.1161/CIRCEP.119.007284

[25] 9. Wankhade TD, Ingale SW, Mohite PM, Bankar NJ. Artificial Intelligence in Forensic Medicine and Toxicology: The Future of Forensic Medicine // Cureus. 2022. August;14(8):e28376. 10.7759/cureus.28376.

[26] Ghildiyal A., Sharma S., Verma I., et al. Age and gender predictions using artificial intelligence algorithm // Conference: 2020 3rd International Conference on Intelligent Sustainable Systems (ICISS). IEEE, 2020. doi: 10.1109/ICISS49785.2020.9316053

[27] Ghildiyal A, Sharma S, Verma I, et al. Age and gender predictions using artificial intelligence algorithm. In: Conference: 2020 3rd International Conference on Intelligent Sustainable Systems (ICISS). IEEE; 2020. doi: 10.1109/ICISS49785.2020.9316053

[28] 10. Vodanović M, Subašić M, Milošević DP, Galić I, Brkić H. Artificial intelligence in forensic medicine and forensic dentistry // J Forensic Odontostomatol. 2023 Aug 27;41(2):30-41. PMID: 37634174; PMCID: PMC10473456.

[29] Yang C.Y., Pan Y.J., Chou Y., et al. Using deep neural networks for predicting age and sex in healthy adult chest radiographs // J Clin Med. 2021. Vol. 10, N 19. P. 4431. doi: 10.3390/jcm10194431

[30] Yang CY, Pan YJ, Chou Y, et al. Using deep neural networks for predicting age and sex in healthy adult chest radiographs. J Clin Med. 2021;10(19):4431. doi: 10.3390/jcm10194431

[31] 11. Sadykov M.B., Begaliev E.N., Bahteev D.V., Kazieva A.N., Husainov O.B. Primenenie iskusstvennogo intellekta i chipirovaniıa cheloveka v sudebno-meditsinskoi kspertize: nauchnyi obzor // Sudebnaıa meditsina. 2024. T. 10, № 1. S. 000–000. DOI: https://doi.org/10.17816/fm16093.

[32] Niazi M.K., Parwani A.V., Gurcan M.N. Digital pathology and artificial intelligence // Lancet Oncol. 2019. Vol. 20, N 5. P. e253–e261. doi: 10.1016/S1470-2045(19)30154-8

[33] Niazi MK, Parwani AV, Gurcan MN. Digital pathology and artificial intelligence. Lancet Oncol. 2019;20(5):e253–e261. doi: 10.1016/S1470-2045(19)30154-8

[34] 12. Orakbaev A.B., Kurmangali J.K., Begaliev E.N., Syrbu A.V., Begaliev B.A. K voprosu ob ispolzovanii rezultatov virtualnoi autopsii (virtopsii) v hode rassledovaniıa prestuplenii: nauchnyi obzor // Sudebnaıa meditsina. 2023. T.9. №2. C. 183-192. doi: 10.17816/fm774.

[35] Lefèvre T., Tournois L. Artificial intelligence and diagnostics in medicine and forensic science // Diagnostics (Basel). 2023. Vol. 13, N 23. P. 3554. doi: 10.3390/diagnostics13233554

[36] Lefèvre T, Tournois L. Artificial intelligence and diagnostics in medicine and forensic science. Diagnostics (Basel). 2023;13(23):3554. doi: 10.3390/diagnostics13233554

[37] 13. Maltsev V. A., Murjina A. S. Ispolzovanie vozmojnostei iskusstvennogo intellekta v sudebno-kspertnoi deıatelnosti. – 2023.

[38] Försch S., Klauschen F., Hufnagl P., Roth W. Artificial intelligence in pathology // Dtsch Arztebl Int. 2021. Vol. 118, N 12. P. 194–204. doi: 10.3238/arztebl.m2021.0011

[39] Försch S, Klauschen F, Hufnagl P, Roth W. Artificial intelligence in pathology. Dtsch Arztebl Int. 2021;118(12):194–204. doi: 10.3238/arztebl.m2021.0011

[40] 14. Lefèvre, T.; Tournois, L. Artificial Intelligence and Diagnostics in Medicine and Forensic Science // Diagnostics 2023, 13, 3554. https://doi.org/10.3390/diagnostics13233554.

[41] Wankhade T.D., Ingale S.W., Mohite P.M., Bankar N.J. Artificial intelligence in forensic medicine and toxicology: The future of forensic medicine // Cureus. 2022. Vol. 14, N 8. P. e28376. doi: 10.7759/cureus.28376

[42] Wankhade TD, Ingale SW, Mohite PM, Bankar NJ. Artificial intelligence in forensic medicine and toxicology: The future of forensic medicine. Cureus. 2022;14(8):e28376. doi: 10.7759/cureus.28376

[43] 15. Bahteev D. V. Iskusstvennyi intellekt: tiko-pravovye osnovy. Monografiıa. – " Izdatelstvo"" Prospekt""", 2021.

[44] Bahado-Singh R., Vlachos K.T., Aydas B., et al. Precision oncology: Artificial intelligence and DNA methylation analysis of circulating cell-free DNA for lung cancer detection // Front Oncol. 2022. Vol. 12. P. 790645. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2022.790645

[45] Bahado-Singh R, Vlachos KT, Aydas B, et al. Precision oncology: Artificial intelligence and DNA methylation analysis of circulating cell-free DNA for lung cancer detection. Front Oncol. 2022;12:790645. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2022.790645

[46] 16. Tumanova L. V. Osobennosti dokazyvaniıa po delam, svıazannym s okazaniem meditsinskih uslug //Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriıa" Pravo". – 2022. – №. 2. – S. 124.

[47] Raponi S., Oligeri G., Ali I.M. Sound of guns: Digital forensics of gun audio samples meets artificial intelligence // Multimedia Tools Applications. 2022. Vol. 81, N 2. P. 30387–30412. doi: 10.1007/s11042-022-12612-w

[48] Raponi S, Oligeri G, Ali IM. Sound of guns: Digital forensics of gun audio samples meets artificial intelligence. Multimedia Tools Applications. 2022;81(2):30387–30412. doi: 10.1007/s11042-022-12612-w

[49] 17. Voevodkin D.V., Rustemova G.R., Begaliev E.N., Igembaev K.A., Aiypova Z.N. K voprosu vyıavleniıa poddelnyh zakliychenii sudebno-meditsinskih kspertiz posredstvom primeneniıa tehnologii iskusstvennogo intellekta po opytu Respubliki Kazahstan: nauchnyi obzor // Sudebnaıa meditsina. 2023 T. 9, № 3 S. 287–298. DOI: https://doi.org/10.17816/fm8270

[50] Kudonu M., Al-Shamsi M.A., Philip S., et al. Artificial intelligence: Future of firearm examination // Conference: 2022 Advances in Science and Engineering Technology International Conferences (ASET). IEEE, 2022. doi: 10.1109/ASET53988.2022.9735105

[51] Kudonu M, Al-Shamsi MA, Philip S, et al. Artificial intelligence: Future of firearm examination. In: Conference: 2022 Advances in Science and Engineering Technology International Conferences (ASET). IEEE; 2022. doi: 10.1109/ASET53988.2022.9735105

[52] 18. Wood, M. (2019). Customary International Law and the General Principles of Law Recognized by Civilized Nations // International Community Law Review, 21(3-4), 307-324.

[53] Egiazarov A., Mavroeidis V., Zennaro F.M., Vishi K. Firearm detection and segmentation using an ensemble of semantic neural networks // Conference: 2019 European Intelligence and Security Informatics Conference (EISIC). IEEE, 2019. doi: 10.1109/EISIC49498.2019.9108871

[54] Egiazarov A, Mavroeidis V, Zennaro FM, Vishi K. Firearm detection and segmentation using an ensemble of semantic neural networks. In: Conference: 2019 European Intelligence and Security Informatics Conference (EISIC). IEEE; 2019. doi: 10.1109/EISIC49498.2019.9108871

[55] 19. Horder, J. (2016). Ashworth's principles of criminal law. Oxford University Press.

[56] Costantini S., De Gasperis G., Olivieri R. Digital forensics and investigations meet artificial intelligence // Ann Mathematics Artificial Intelligence. 2019. Vol. 86, N 12. P. 193–229. doi: 10.1007/s10472-019-09632-y

[57] Costantini S, De Gasperis G, Olivieri R. Digital forensics and investigations meet artificial intelligence. Anne Mathematics Artificial Intelligence. 2019;86(12):193–229. doi: 10.1007/s10472-019-09632-y

[58] 20. Peno, M. (2019). The Character of the Principles of Criminal Law and Criminal Responsibility: Between the Philosophy of Law and Semiotic // Liverpool Law Review, 40(2), 79-93.

[59] Jarrett A., Choo K.K. The impact of automation and artificial intelligence on digital forensics // Wiley Interdisciplinary Rev Forensic Sci. 2021. Vol. 3, N 4. doi: 10.1002/wfs2.1418

[60] Jarrett A, Choo KK. The impact of automation and artificial intelligence on digital forensics. Wiley Interdisciplinary Rev Forensic Sci. 2021;3(4). doi: 10.1002/wfs2.1418

[61] 21. Werle, G., & Jessberger, F. (2020). Principles of international criminal law. Oxford University Press.

[62] Dong X.Y., Niu X.Q., Zhang Z.Y., et al. Red fluorescent carbon dot powder for accurate latent fingerprint identification using an artificial intelligence program // ACS Appl Mater Interfaces. 2020. Vol. 12, N 26. P. 29549–29555. doi: 10.1021/acsami.0c01972

[63] Dong XY, Niu XQ, Zhang ZY, et al. Red fluorescent carbon dot powder for accurate latent fingerprint identification using an artificial intelligence program. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces. 2020;12(26):29549–29555. doi: 10.1021/acsami.0c01972

[64] 22. Stoian, A., & Drăghici, T. (2015). The principle of legality, principle of public law // International Conference knowledge-based organization.

[65] Singh A., Aseri V., Nagar V., et al. Artificial intelligence in fingerprint identification // Artificial Intelligence in Forensic Science. 1st edition. CRC Press, 2024. 13 р.

[66] Singh A, Aseri V, Nagar V, et al. Artificial intelligence in fingerprint identification. In book: Artificial Intelligence in Forensic Science. 1st edition. CRC Press; 2024. 13 р.

[67] 23. Gurl E. SWOT analysis: A theoretical review. – 2017.

[68] Zhao X. Image technology investigation based on fingerprint devices and artificial intelligence // Int J Adv Computer Sci Applications (IJACSA). 2024. Vol. 15, N 6. P. 387–395.

[69] Zhao X. Image technology investigation based on fingerprint devices and artificial intelligence. Int J Adv Computer Sci Applications (IJACSA). 2024;15(6):387–395.

[70] Nawaz N. Artificial intelligence applications for face recognition in recruitment process // J Management Inform Decision Sci. 2020. Vol. 23, N S1. P. 499–509.

[71] Nawaz N. Artificial intelligence applications for face recognition in recruitment process. J Management Inform Decision Sci. 2020;23(S1):499–509.

[72] Le T.H. Applying artificial neural networks for face recognition // Adv Artificial Neural Systems. 2011. Vol. 2011, N 3. P. 673016. doi: 10.1155/2011/673016

[73] Le TH. Applying artificial neural networks for face recognition. Adv Artificial Neural Systems. 2011;2011(3):673016. doi: 10.1155/2011/673016

[74] Chary M.A., Manini A.F., Boyer E.W., Burns M. The role and promise of artificial intelligence in medical toxicology // J Med Toxicol. 2020. Vol. 16, N 4. P. 458–464. doi: 10.1007/s13181-020-00769-5

[75] Chary MA, Manini AF, Boyer EW, Burns M. The role and promise of artificial intelligence in medical toxicology. J Med Toxicol. 2020;16(4):458–464. doi: 10.1007/s13181-020-00769-5

[76] Nasnodkar S., Cinar B., Ness S. Artificial intelligence in toxicology and pharmacology // J Engineering Res Rep. 2023. Vol. 25, N 7. P. 192–206. EDN: VXIRSI doi: 10.9734/jerr/2023/v25i7952

[77] Nasnodkar S, Cinar B, Ness S. Artificial intelligence in toxicology and pharmacology. J Engineering Res Rep. 2023;25(7):192–206. EDN: VXIRSI doi: 10.9734/jerr/2023/v25i7952

[78] Садыков М.Б., Бегалиев Е.Н., Бахтеев Д.В., и др. Применение искусственного интеллекта и чипирования человека в судебно-медицинской экспертизе: научный обзор // Судебная медицина. 2024. Т. 10, № 1. С. 88–98. EDN: LXZIJZ doi: 10.17816/fm16093

[79] Sadykov MB, Begaliyev YN, Bakhteev DV, et al. Use of artificial intelligence and human chipping in forensic medicine: A review. Russ J For Med. 2024;10(1):88–98. EDN: LXZIJZ doi: 10.17816/fm16093

[80] Оракбаев А.Б., Курмангали Ж.К., Бегалиев Е.Н., и др. К вопросу об использовании результатов виртуальной аутопсии (виртопсии) в ходе расследования преступлений: научный обзор // Судебная медицина. 2023. Т. 9, № 2. C. 183–192. EDN: OEERGD doi: 10.17816/fm774

[81] Orakbayev AB, Kurmangali ZhK, Begaliyev YeN, et al. On the issue of using the results of a virtual autopsy in criminal investigation: A review. Russ J For Med. 2023;9(2):183–192. EDN: OEERGD doi: 10.17816/fm774

[82] Мальцев В.А., Муржина А.С., Сучкова Т.Е. Использование возможностей искусственного интеллекта в судебно-экспертной деятельности // Вопросы современной науки и практики. 2023. № 2. С. 21–26. EDN: IQNRDF

[83] Maltsev VA, Murzhina AS, Suchkova TE. Use of artificial intelligence capabilities in forensic activity. Voprosy sovremennoi nauki i praktiki. 2023;(2):21–26. EDN: IQNRDF

[84] Бахтеев Д.В. Искусственный интеллект: этико-правовые основы. Монография. Москва: Проспект, 2021. 176 с. EDN: TZMPRL doi: 10.31085/9785392334131-2021-176

[85] Bakhteev DV. Artificial intelligence: Ethical and legal foundations. Monograph. Moscow: Prospekt; 2021. 176 р. (In Russ.) EDN: TZMPRL doi: 10.31085/9785392334131-2021-176

[86] Туманова Л.В. Особенности доказывания по делам, связанным с оказанием медицинских услуг // Вестник Тверского государственного университета. Серия: Право. 2022. № 2. С. 123–130. EDN: ERYYMH doi: 10.26456/vtpravo/2022.2.123

[87] Tumanova LV. Features of evidence in cases related to provision of medical services. Vestnik Tver State University. Series: Law. 2022;(2):123–130. EDN: ERYYMH doi: 10.26456/vtpravo/2022.2.123

[88] Воеводкин Д.В., Рустемова Г.Р., Бегалиев Е.Н., и др. К вопросу выявления поддельных заключений судебно-медицинских экспертиз посредством применения технологии искусственного интеллекта по опыту Республики Казахстан: научный обзор // Судебная медицина. 2023 Т. 9, № 3 С. 287–298. EDN: EFNJIE doi: 10.17816/fm8270

[89] Voyevodkin DV, Rustemova GR, Begaliyev YeN, et al. Identifying fake conclusions of forensic medical examinations using an artificial intelligence technology based on the experience in the Republic of Kazakhstan: A review. Russ J For Med. 2023;9(3):287–298. EDN: EFNJIE doi: 10.17816/fm8270

[90] Gurel E., Tat M. SWOT analysis: A theoretical review // J Int Social Res. 2017. Vol. 10, N 51. P. 994–1006. doi: 10.17719/jisr.2017.1832

[91] Gurel E, Tat M. SWOT analysis: A theoretical review. J Int Social Res. 2017;10(51):994–1006. doi: 10.17719/jisr.2017.1832

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Eco-Vector